Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Film / Burning2018

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* LoveTriangle: The relationship that developers between Jong-su, Hae-mi and Ben.

to:

* LoveTriangle: The relationship that developers between Jong-su, Hae-mi and Ben. Jong-su comes off as Hae-mi's RomanticRunnerUp as he cannot [[RichSuitorPoorSuitor financially compete]] with Ben.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* {{Sleepyhead}}: Hae-mi is prone to fall asleep at unbefitting times.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
according to Jong-su, the sister stayed with him and their dad


* AbusiveParents: Jong-su's father has a severe anger disorder that causes him to have violent outbursts. It caused Jong-su's mother to leave the family and take his sister with her, and eventually leads to his own arrest when he violently assaults a government worker. Jong-su mentions an incident soon after his mother left, where his father forced him to take all of his mother's clothes out of the house and burn them on a huge bonfire, traumatizing him for life.

to:

* AbusiveParents: Jong-su's father has a severe anger disorder that causes him to have violent outbursts. It caused Jong-su's mother to leave the family and take his sister with her, family, and eventually leads to his own arrest when he violently assaults a government worker. Jong-su mentions an incident soon after his mother left, where his father forced him to take all of his mother's clothes out of the house and burn them on a huge bonfire, traumatizing him for life.

Added: 996

Changed: 515

Removed: 226

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Spelling/grammar fix(es), Added example(s)








* AmbiguousEnding: We see Jong-su writing in a computer in Hae-mi's apartment right before it cuts to a scene in Ben's perspective (throughout the whole movie the focus is mostly in Jong-su) and then the last scene, in which [[spoiler: Jong-su stabs Ben]], leaving the implication that it could be just Jong-su fantasizing of [[spoiler: avenging Hae-mi supposed murder]].

to:

* AmbiguousEnding: We see Jong-su writing in on a computer in Hae-mi's apartment right before it cuts to a scene in Ben's perspective (throughout the whole movie the focus is mostly in Jong-su) and then the last scene, in which [[spoiler: Jong-su stabs Ben]], leaving the implication that it could be just Jong-su fantasizing of [[spoiler: avenging Hae-mi supposed murder]].



*** Does Boil exist? Jong-su never sees the cat after weeks of feeding him in spite of Hae-mi's apartment being tiny. We conspicuously never see Boil's food or litter bowl after the first time Jong-su checks them, so the viewer cannot compare whether the levels are changing between his visits. Hae-mi's neighbor insists that pets aren't allowed in the apartment, but Hae-mi could be breaking the rules. The fact that Ben's stray seems to answer to the name Boil might suggest that it's him, but it might have just been a coincidence. Hardly any real housecats answer to their name.
*** Did Hae-mi fall down a well? Jong-su doesn't remember finding her like she claims. Her family says that no well was near their house, and if it had happened, they'd have known about it, but it's possible that it was kept from them or they were ignoring her. They don't seem fond of her. Another neighbor also doesn't remember a well being in the area. Jong-su's mother, however, remembers a dry well being near her house, which might explain why no one else knew about or remembered it.

to:

*** Does Boil exist? Jong-su never sees the cat after weeks of feeding him in spite of Hae-mi's apartment being tiny. We conspicuously never see Boil's food or litter bowl after the first time Jong-su checks them, so the viewer cannot compare whether the levels are changing change between his visits. Hae-mi's neighbor insists that pets aren't allowed in the apartment, but Hae-mi could be breaking the rules. The fact that Ben's stray seems to answer to the name Boil might suggest that it's him, but it might have just been a coincidence. Hardly any real housecats answer to their name.
*** Did Hae-mi fall down a well? Jong-su doesn't remember finding her like as she claims. Her family says that no well was near their house, and if it had happened, they'd have known about it, but it's possible that it was kept from them or they were ignoring her. They don't seem fond of her. Another neighbor also doesn't remember a well being in the area. Jong-su's mother, however, remembers a dry well being near her house, which might explain why no one else knew about or remembered it.



*** Hae-mi vanishes inexplicably. She leaves all her possessions behind, including her suitcase, so it's unlikely that she took a trip. Her cat is gone, but it might never have existed. Her apartment has been thoroughly cleaned, which Jong-su says is unlike her, given that she made no effort to do so before going to Africa. It's possible that she was murdered, and Ben straightened her bedroom to remove all trace of him and stole her cat as a trophy. It's also possible she skipped town, given that she had debts and no friends except Ben and Jong-su, but you would think that she'd take more possessions with her. Ben says that she thought Jong-su was the only person on her side, and the last thing he said to her was hurtful, so she might even have committed suicide given her mental health issues, which might explain her out-of-character cleanliness.

to:

*** Hae-mi vanishes inexplicably. She leaves all her possessions behind, including her suitcase, so it's unlikely that she took a trip. Her cat is gone, but it might never have existed. Her apartment has been thoroughly cleaned, which Jong-su says is unlike her, given that she made no effort to do so before going to Africa. It's possible that she was murdered, and Ben straightened her bedroom to remove all trace traces of him and stole her cat as a trophy. It's also possible she skipped town, given that she had debts and no friends except Ben and Jong-su, but you would think that she'd take more possessions with her. Ben says that she thought Jong-su was the only person on her side, and the last thing he said to her was hurtful, so she might even have committed suicide given her mental health issues, which might explain her out-of-character cleanliness.



* BreakUpBonfire: Discussed. Jong-su tells Ben that after his mother left, his father built a fire in the yard and told him to burn all her clothes.



** The pink watch. [[spoiler: Jong-su gives it to Hae-mi at the beginning of the film, and finds it in the possession of Ben well after she's disappeared. This is one of several clues that convince Jong-su that Ben killed her]].



** The pink watch. [[spoiler: Jong-su gives it to Hae-mi at the beginning of the film, and finds it in the possession of Ben well after she's disappeared. This one of several clues that convince Jong-su that Ben killed her]].



* CommieLand: The farm is very close to the DPRK border. Loud propaganda can often be heard at night.

to:

* CommieLand: The farm is very close to the DPRK border. [[CannedOrdersOverLoudspeaker Loud propaganda propaganda]] can often be heard at night.



* CreepySouvenir: [[spoiler: Ben keeps small items such as bracelets, watches, and earrings in a secret box in his bathroom, which are implied to be from the women he's murdered. When Jong-su visits after Hae-mi's disappearance, he finds the pink watch he gave to her in there, convincing him that Ben killed her. Ben also apparently adopts her cat]].

to:

* CreepySouvenir: [[spoiler: Ben keeps small items such as bracelets, watches, and earrings in a secret box in his bathroom, which are implied to be from the women he's murdered. When Jong-su visits after Hae-mi's disappearance, he finds the pink watch in there that he gave to her in there, early on, convincing him that Ben killed her. Ben also apparently adopts her cat]].
* CuttingBackToReality: When Jong-su has his EroticDream of Hae-mi giving him a handjob, the scene eventually cuts back to the real scene of Jong-su lying alone on her bed with his pants down.



* {{Foreshadowing}}: Ben tells metaphor to Hae-mi early in the movie, which she doesn't understand, and then asks Jong-su to explain her, but he ignores their whole conversation. Later up in the movie Ben tells Jong-su about his hobby of burning abandoned greenhouses which he understands literally. [[spoiler: In reality it seems to be a metaphor for killing lonely women.]]

to:

* {{Foreshadowing}}: Ben tells a metaphor to Hae-mi early in the movie, which she doesn't understand, and then asks Jong-su to explain her, but he ignores their whole conversation. Later up in the movie Ben tells Jong-su about his hobby of burning abandoned greenhouses which he understands literally. [[spoiler: In reality it seems to be a metaphor for killing lonely women.]]



* LoveTriangle: The relationship that developers between Jong-su, Hae-mi and Ben.



* TheOner: Hae-mi's NudeNatureDance is filmed in one continuous take.
* PartingWordsRegret: Jong-su berates Hae-mi for taking her clothes off so easily around other men, which hurts her feelings. She disappears soon after.
* PoliceAreUseless: Ben claims that it's easy to burn down greenhouses in Korea because of this.

to:

* TheOner: TheOner:
**
Hae-mi's NudeNatureDance is filmed in one continuous 4-minute take.
** The final scene of [[spoiler:Jong-su killing Ben]] is a single take running for over 7 minutes.
* PartingWordsRegret: Implied but never openly addressed. Jong-su berates Hae-mi for [[SlutShaming taking her clothes off so easily around other men, men]], which hurts her feelings. She disappears soon after.
* PoliceAreUseless: Ben claims that it's easy to burn down greenhouses in Korea because of this.the police don't care about minor crimes in this area.



* SerialKiller: [[spoiler:Although it is never confirmed beyond a doubt, the film strongly hints that Ben might be one. Evidence for this include his LackOfEmpathy, the fact he seems to date a very specific type of women (young and naïve individuals from the lower classes with no social and familial ties and whose disappearance is unlikely to be noticed or reported to the authorities), a drawer in his bathroom containing numerous, clearly feminine trinkets (implied to be trophies taken from previous victims), and his strange monologue about burning greenhouses, in which he admits that he has a fixed routine (he only does it once every two months) and describes the act of "burning" (i.e, killing) as the only thing that truly makes him feel alive]].

to:

* SerialKiller: [[spoiler:Although it is never confirmed beyond a doubt, the film strongly hints that Ben might be one. Evidence for this include includes his LackOfEmpathy, the fact he seems to date a very specific type of women (young and naïve individuals from the lower classes with no social and familial ties and whose disappearance is unlikely to be noticed or reported to the authorities), a drawer in his bathroom containing numerous, clearly feminine trinkets (implied to be trophies taken from previous victims), and his strange monologue about burning greenhouses, in which he admits that he has a fixed routine (he only does it once every two months) and describes the act of "burning" (i.e, killing) as the only thing that truly makes him feel alive]].



* UnexplainedAccent: Ben's Korean sounds completely different than the other characters'. This is because Steven Yeun is not a native Korean speaker, having left Korea when he was five and growing up in the United States. Given that Ben has a western name, he might share Yeun's background, but we get no furthers clues about his background.

to:

* UnexplainedAccent: Ben's Korean sounds completely different than the other characters'. This is because Steven Yeun is not a native Korean speaker, having left Korea when he was five and growing up in the United States. Given that Ben has a western Western name, he might share Yeun's background, but we get no furthers further clues about his background.



* VomitIndiscretionShot: Jong-su vomits after [[spoiler: stabbing Ben to death at the end of the film]].

to:

* VomitIndiscretionShot: StressVomit: Jong-su vomits after [[spoiler: stabbing Ben to death at the end of the film]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
redundant pothole. this is already an entry under Ambiguous Situation


*** Hae-mi vanishes inexplicably. She leaves all her possessions behind, including her suitcase, so it's unlikely that she took a trip. Her cat is gone, but it [[AmbiguousSituation might never have existed]]. Her apartment has been thoroughly cleaned, which Jong-su says is unlike her, given that she made no effort to do so before going to Africa. It's possible that she was murdered, and Ben straightened her bedroom to remove all trace of him and stole her cat as a trophy. It's also possible she skipped town, given that she had debts and no friends except Ben and Jong-su, but you would think that she'd take more possessions with her. Ben says that she thought Jong-su was the only person on her side, and the last thing he said to her was hurtful, so she might even have committed suicide given her mental health issues, which might explain her out-of-character cleanliness.

to:

*** Hae-mi vanishes inexplicably. She leaves all her possessions behind, including her suitcase, so it's unlikely that she took a trip. Her cat is gone, but it [[AmbiguousSituation might never have existed]].existed. Her apartment has been thoroughly cleaned, which Jong-su says is unlike her, given that she made no effort to do so before going to Africa. It's possible that she was murdered, and Ben straightened her bedroom to remove all trace of him and stole her cat as a trophy. It's also possible she skipped town, given that she had debts and no friends except Ben and Jong-su, but you would think that she'd take more possessions with her. Ben says that she thought Jong-su was the only person on her side, and the last thing he said to her was hurtful, so she might even have committed suicide given her mental health issues, which might explain her out-of-character cleanliness.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
misuse. this trope is for serial works


* WhatNowEnding: [[spoiler: Jong-su stabs Ben to death, and burns him inside his Porsche along with his bloodstained clothes. We see a naked Jong-su climb into his truck and start driving away, and the movie just sort of... ends]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
that's not the type of situations the trope is about


* SoMuchForStealth: Lee Jong-su stalks Ben, who lives in a wealthy neighbourhood, driving an ugly truck. Ben spots him once, but most of the time he doesn't seem to notice.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
the alias is misleading. Forgotten Friend New Foe is about childhood friend who are now opponents


* ForgottenChildhoodFriend: Jong-su allegedly helped rescue Hae-mi from a well when they were children, only to forget about her when they both grew up. He also forgot that he ever called her ugly, if he did.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
that's in the eye of the beholder. the sex scene and the stripping at the farm are done tastefully. the only creepy scenes are the masturbations which cant be regarded as fan service in the first place.


* FanDisservice: None of the sex and nudity in the film is particularly enticing.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added bit of trivia.

Added DiffLines:

* ForeignLanguageTitle: The film's original title is ''버닝'', a transliteration of the English word "Burning".

Added: 348

Removed: 348

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AdaptationalKarma: [[spoiler:In ''Literature/BarnBurning'', the Ben character faces no consequences and likely continues to murder women with impunity for years. Even the narrator doesn't admit to himself what really happened. Here, Jong-su kills Ben after becoming convinced he killed Hae-mi, though it's never explicitly confirmed if he did.]]



* AdaptationalKarma: [[spoiler:In ''Literature/BarnBurning'', the Ben character faces no consequences and likely continues to murder women with impunity for years. Even the narrator doesn't admit to himself what really happened. Here, Jong-su kills Ben after becoming convinced he killed Hae-mi, though it's never explicitly confirmed if he did.]]

Added: 139

Removed: 124

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
A Date With Rosie Palms is no longer a trope


* ADateWithRosiePalms: Lee Jong-su masturbates several times in Shin Hae-mi's place while she's in Africa, as he misses her.


Added DiffLines:

* MasturbationMeansSexualFrustration: Lee Jong-su masturbates several times in Shin Hae-mi's place while she's in Africa, as he misses her.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Ambiguous Disorder is now Diagnosed By The Audience, an audience reaction and an YMMV item; misused here


*** Hae-mi vanishes inexplicably. She leaves all her possessions behind, including her suitcase, so it's unlikely that she took a trip. Her cat is gone, but it [[AmbiguousSituation might never have existed]]. Her apartment has been thoroughly cleaned, which Jong-su says is unlike her, given that she made no effort to do so before going to Africa. It's possible that she was murdered, and Ben straightened her bedroom to remove all trace of him and stole her cat as a trophy. It's also possible she skipped town, given that she had debts and no friends except Ben and Jong-su, but you would think that she'd take more possessions with her. Ben says that she thought Jong-su was the only person on her side, and the last thing he said to her was hurtful, so she might even have committed suicide given her AmbiguousDisorder, which might explain her out-of-character cleanliness.

to:

*** Hae-mi vanishes inexplicably. She leaves all her possessions behind, including her suitcase, so it's unlikely that she took a trip. Her cat is gone, but it [[AmbiguousSituation might never have existed]]. Her apartment has been thoroughly cleaned, which Jong-su says is unlike her, given that she made no effort to do so before going to Africa. It's possible that she was murdered, and Ben straightened her bedroom to remove all trace of him and stole her cat as a trophy. It's also possible she skipped town, given that she had debts and no friends except Ben and Jong-su, but you would think that she'd take more possessions with her. Ben says that she thought Jong-su was the only person on her side, and the last thing he said to her was hurtful, so she might even have committed suicide given her AmbiguousDisorder, mental health issues, which might explain her out-of-character cleanliness.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TheFlameOfLife: Implied by the use of fire as an ArcSymbol. Jong-su remembers being forced to burn his mother's clothes in a fire after she left. Ben says that he burns down greenhouses, [[spoiler:though it's heavily implied that he's talking about killing women.]] At the end, [[spoiler:Jong-su burns Ben's body after killing him.]]

Top