Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Creator / HansChristianAndersen

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The princess in "Blockhead Hans" declares that she'll marry the man whom she judges best in conversation. This turns out to be harder than it sounds; for many suitors, just being at the palace and in her presence is so overwhelming that their speech fails them.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added: 999

Changed: 350

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* UnluckyChildhoodFriend: Knud in "Under the Willow Tree" falls in love with the girl next door, Johanna, only after she moves away. He eventually asks her to marry him, but they've chosen incompatible career paths. The story ends with [[spoiler:Johanna becoming engaged to someone else and Knud freezing to death as he tries to make his way home across Europe alone]].

to:

* UnluckyChildhoodFriend: Several of his stories feature boys who fall in love with female friends who move away, usually ending with the boy never marrying:
**
Knud in "Under the Willow Tree" falls in love with the girl next door, Johanna, only after she moves away. Tree." He eventually asks her his old friend Johanna to marry him, but they've chosen incompatible career paths. The story ends with [[spoiler:Johanna becoming engaged to someone else and Knud freezing to death as he tries to make his way home across Europe alone]].alone]].
** Ib from "Ib and Little Christina." Again, Christina moves away and falls in love with someone else. Ib accepts this, though he's privately depressed. He actually winds up the luckier of the two, [[spoiler:and raises Christina's orphaned daughter]].
** Anton in "The Pepperman's Nightcap." When they meet again as adults, Molly simply tells him that she's not in love with him, but wants to remain friends. He's quite bitter about it at first, but his feelings mellow after he suffers real hardships and realizes she would've shared in them if she'd married him. He becomes a pepperman (local seller employed by a spice merchant) because he's single and always will be, which is literally a job requirement.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* RodentCellmates: One of the mice who takes up the challenge in "How to Cook Soup Upon a Sausage Pin" befriends a human prisoner in the course of her quest, and stays with him so long that she forgets about the quest until he's taken away.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Andersen was attracted to both men and women (admitting this in his writings). It's believed that his works about romantic incompatibility, such as "The Little Mermaid" and "Thumbelina", reflect his own short end in life. It's also noted that Andersen himself, his eccentric behavior and arrogance usually led to him getting kicked out by the various nobles who housed him.

to:

Andersen was attracted to both men and women (admitting this in his writings).writings), and had at least one same-sex relationship with the German Grand Duke of Saxe-Weimar Eisenach, Carl Alexander, but this may not have been sexual (he asserted his celibacy too in early life). It's believed that his works about romantic incompatibility, such as "The Little Mermaid" and "Thumbelina", reflect his own short end in life. It's also noted that Andersen himself, his eccentric behavior and arrogance usually led to him getting kicked out by the various nobles who housed him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Anderson was attracted to both men and women (admitting this in his writings). It's believed that his works about romantic incompatibility, such as "The Little Mermaid" and "Thumbelina", reflect his own short end in life. It's also noted that Andersen himself, his eccentric behavior and arrogance usually led to him getting kicked out by the various nobles who housed him.

to:

Anderson Andersen was attracted to both men and women (admitting this in his writings). It's believed that his works about romantic incompatibility, such as "The Little Mermaid" and "Thumbelina", reflect his own short end in life. It's also noted that Andersen himself, his eccentric behavior and arrogance usually led to him getting kicked out by the various nobles who housed him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


It is believed that he was gay or bisexual and that his works about romantic incompatibility, such as "The Little Mermaid" and "Thumbelina", reflect his own short end in life. It's also noted that Andersen himself, his eccentric behavior and arrogance usually led to him getting kicked out by the various nobles who housed him.

to:

It is Anderson was attracted to both men and women (admitting this in his writings). It's believed that he was gay or bisexual and that his works about romantic incompatibility, such as "The Little Mermaid" and "Thumbelina", reflect his own short end in life. It's also noted that Andersen himself, his eccentric behavior and arrogance usually led to him getting kicked out by the various nobles who housed him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The 1952 film ''Hans Christian Andersen'', starring Creator/DannyKaye, which describes itself as "a fairy tale about the great spinner of fairy tales" (a colorful way of saying it's almost entirely made up).

to:

* The 1952 film ''Hans ''[[Film/HansChristianAndersen1952 Hans Christian Andersen'', Andersen]]'', starring Creator/DannyKaye, which describes itself as "a fairy tale about the great spinner of fairy tales" (a colorful way of saying it's almost entirely made up).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* UnluckyChildhoodFriend: Knud in "Under the Willow Tree" falls in love with the girl next door, Johanna, only after she moves away. He eventually asks her to marry him, but they've chosen incompatible career paths. The story ends with [[spoiler:Johanna becoming engaged to someone else and Knud freezing to death as he tries to make his way home across Europe alone]].

Added: 45

Removed: 26

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* "Literature/TheSixSwans"


Added DiffLines:

* "[[Literature/TheSixSwans The Wild Swans]]"

Added: 26

Changed: 1157

Removed: 926

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None of this is about Andersen.


Remember that bedtime story about the ugly duckling who became a swan? The image of a princess sleeping on a ton of mattresses...and a pea? The FairyTale about a mermaid who sold her voice to a sorceress to try to win the love of a human prince? Meet the Danish author of all the saddest and sweetest of the fairy tales we all grew up with, tales seen referenced in pop culture so frequently that many people have no idea they were written by the same author.

Born on April 2, 1805 (which is now "National Children's Book Day"), Hans Christian Andersen (abbreviated H. C. Andersen in Denmark) grew up to become to fairy tales what Creator/{{Shakespeare}} became to drama. His works range from the simple to the epic, are full of complex but meaningful symbolism, and span the SlidingScaleOfIdealismVersusCynicism.

The most familiar version of "The Little Mermaid" in the Western world is probably Disney's, which deviates strongly from the original: Hans Christian's protagonist has NoNameGiven, no bikini top made from seashells, and no {{Non Human Sidekick}}s, but does have a grandmother, and wants to marry the prince for "an immortal soul" (yes, in the Christian sense) as much as for romantic love. Not to mention the minor fact that said prince marries another girl, meaning she'll die unless she stabs him, which she doesn't. And then there's a bit of disconnected DeusExMachina {{Aesoptinum}} MoodWhiplash, but [[FanonDiscontinuity we don't talk about that.]]

Interestingly, Creator/OscarWilde still thought the story too upbeat and penned an even darker version, "The Fisherman and His Soul" as a reaction. In this charming tale, a human must [[DealWithTheDevil sell his immortal soul]] in order to marry a mermaid.

Other works have come through the adaptation process about as reasonably intact as can be expected. "The Snow Queen", basically an epic {{Gender Flip}}ped RescueRomance heavy on the symbolism, has been turned into a science-fiction novel, an animated movie, and an anime by NHK, ''Manga/CardcaptorSakura's'' network. The Disney film ''WesternAnimation/Frozen2013'' was originally meant to be an adaptation of "The Snow Queen", and even had it as its WorkingTitle (and it's still titled that in some countries), but ended up developing into its own original story with very, very loose inspiration from the fairy tale (basically just the ice palace).

It is believed that he was also bisexual, so that's fun too. It's also noted that Andersen himself, his eccentric behavior and arrogance usually led to him getting kicked out by the various nobles who housed him.

He passed away in August 1875, and never married or had children.

to:

Remember that bedtime story about the ugly duckling who became a swan? The image of a princess sleeping on a ton of mattresses... and a pea? The FairyTale about a mermaid who sold her voice to a sorceress to try to win the love of a human prince? Meet the Danish author of all the saddest and sweetest of the fairy tales we all grew up with, tales seen referenced in pop culture so frequently that many people have no idea they were written by the same author.

Born on April 2, 1805 (which is now "National Children's Book Day"), Hans Christian Andersen (abbreviated H. C. Andersen in Denmark) grew up to become to fairy tales what Creator/{{Shakespeare}} became to drama. His works range from the simple to the epic, are full of complex but meaningful symbolism, and span the SlidingScaleOfIdealismVersusCynicism.

The most familiar version of
SlidingScaleOfIdealismVersusCynicism. They also are overtly Christian and these bits usually get taken out in adaptations.

It is believed that he was gay or bisexual and that his works about romantic incompatibility, such as
"The Little Mermaid" in the Western world is probably Disney's, which deviates strongly from the original: Hans Christian's protagonist has NoNameGiven, no bikini top made from seashells, and no {{Non Human Sidekick}}s, but does have a grandmother, and wants to marry the prince for "an immortal soul" (yes, in the Christian sense) as much as for romantic love. Not to mention the minor fact that said prince marries another girl, meaning she'll die unless she stabs him, which she doesn't. And then there's a bit of disconnected DeusExMachina {{Aesoptinum}} MoodWhiplash, but [[FanonDiscontinuity we don't talk about that.]]

Interestingly, Creator/OscarWilde still thought the story too upbeat and penned an even darker version, "The Fisherman and His Soul" as a reaction. In this charming tale, a human must [[DealWithTheDevil sell
"Thumbelina", reflect his immortal soul]] in order to marry a mermaid.

Other works have come through the adaptation process about as reasonably intact as can be expected. "The Snow Queen", basically an epic {{Gender Flip}}ped RescueRomance heavy on the symbolism, has been turned into a science-fiction novel, an animated movie, and an anime by NHK, ''Manga/CardcaptorSakura's'' network. The Disney film ''WesternAnimation/Frozen2013'' was originally meant to be an adaptation of "The Snow Queen", and even had it as its WorkingTitle (and it's still titled that in some countries), but ended up developing into its
own original story with very, very loose inspiration from the fairy tale (basically just the ice palace).

It is believed that he was also bisexual, so that's fun too.
short end in life. It's also noted that Andersen himself, his eccentric behavior and arrogance usually led to him getting kicked out by the various nobles who housed him.

He passed away in August 1875, and having never married or had children.children.


Added DiffLines:

* "Literature/TheSixSwans"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

[[index]]





to:

\n[[/index]]

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Wiki/TheOtherWiki says he was also bisexual, so that's fun too. It's also noted that Andersen himself, his eccentric behavior and arrogance usually led to him getting kicked out by the various nobles who housed him.

to:

Wiki/TheOtherWiki says It is believed that he was also bisexual, so that's fun too. It's also noted that Andersen himself, his eccentric behavior and arrogance usually led to him getting kicked out by the various nobles who housed him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In "How to Cook Soup Upon a Sausage Pin," the mouse king declares that he'll marry whichever mouse can find [[LiteralMinded the recipe for making soup on a sausage pin]].

to:

** In "How to Cook Soup Upon a Sausage Pin," the mouse king declares that he'll marry whichever mouse can find [[LiteralMinded the best recipe for making soup on a sausage pin]].

Added: 399

Changed: 224

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* EngagementChallenge: The princess in "The Traveling Companion" requires all her suitors to answer three impossible questions (the protagonist gets "What am I thinking about right now?"). The penalty for getting even one question wrong is death.

to:

* EngagementChallenge: EngagementChallenge:
**
The princess in "The Traveling Companion" requires all her suitors to answer three impossible questions (the protagonist gets "What am I thinking about right now?"). The penalty for getting even one question wrong is death.death.
** In "How to Cook Soup Upon a Sausage Pin," the mouse king declares that he'll marry whichever mouse can find [[LiteralMinded the recipe for making soup on a sausage pin]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SlidingScaleOfIdealismVsCynicism: As the writer of so many beloved fairy tales, his works fall right off the idealistic end of the scale. A couple of his stories, however (Such as "Literature/TheShadow") turn out to be surprisingly cynical.

to:

* SlidingScaleOfIdealismVsCynicism: As the writer of so many beloved fairy tales, his works fall right off the idealistic end of the scale. A couple of his stories, however (Such as "Literature/TheShadow") "Literature/{{The Shadow|Fairy Tale}}") turn out to be surprisingly cynical.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Disambiguating "The Shadow", the fairy tale, from the various editions of the photo-superhero character. The Literature namespace for "The Shadow" will eventually be used for the pulp fiction and magazine stories.


* "Literature/TheShadow"

to:

* "Literature/TheShadow""Literature/{{The Shadow|Fairy Tale}}"

Changed: 34

Removed: 556

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


%%* RageAgainstTheHeavens: "The Wicked Prince".
* RainbowLens: A lot of his stories are interpreted as subtext for his own same-sex romantic attractions and his frustrations at being unable to materialise them. The most well known case is ''Literature/TheLittleMermaid'', widely accept to have been written in response to a male crush and essentially reading as a tragic gay story with the "gay" (or, in more modern readings, the "trans") element being instead a mermaid, but other stories like ''Literature/TheNightingale'' ad even ''Literature/TheUglyDuckling'' have also had similar if rarer readings.

to:

%%* * RageAgainstTheHeavens: "The Wicked Prince".
* RainbowLens: A lot of his stories are interpreted as subtext for his own same-sex romantic attractions and his frustrations at being unable to materialise them. The most well known case is ''Literature/TheLittleMermaid'', widely accept to have been written in response to a male crush and essentially reading as a tragic gay story with the "gay" (or, in more modern readings, the "trans") element being instead a mermaid, but other stories like ''Literature/TheNightingale'' ad even ''Literature/TheUglyDuckling'' have also had similar if rarer readings.
Prince", who ful on declares war on God.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* RainbowLens: A lot of his stories are interpreted as subtext for his own same-sex romantic attractions and his frustrations at being unable to materialise them. The most well known case is ''Literature/TheLittleMermaid'', widely accept to have been written in response to a male crush and essentially reading as a tragic gay story with the "gay" (or, in more modern readings, the "trans") element being instead a mermaid, but other stories like ''Literature/TheNightingale'' ad even ''Literature/TheUglyDuckling'' have also had similar if rarer readings.

Added: 449

Changed: 6

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DiabolusExMachina: The protagonist of "The Flying Trunk" uses the titular magical luggage to [[GodGuise pretend to be God]] and get himself engaged to a Turkish princess. [[spoiler:In the last paragraph, the trunk is burned to ashes by the celebratory fireworks, so he never gets back into the castle, [[DownerEnding the princess waits hopelessly for his return for the rest of her life, and he spends the rest of his as a vagrant storyteller]]]].



** ''WesternAnimation/Frozen2013'' went even further, it outright ignored what Anderson wrote.

to:

** ''WesternAnimation/Frozen2013'' went even further, further; it outright ignored what Anderson wrote.



** "The Storks". A young boy leads several other boys into singing a song that taunts a family of storks. As revenge, [[spoiler: the storks refuse to bring any of the boys baby brothers or sisters...except for the boy who led the song. The storks bring him a dead baby brother.]]
** "In the Duck Yard". An injured songbird is resting in a duck yard, where a proud and haughty Portuguese duck resides. The songbird makes the mistake of comparing the Portuguese to a cat, so [[spoiler: the duck decapitates the songbird.]]

to:

** "The Storks". A young boy leads several other boys into singing a song that taunts a family of storks. As revenge, [[spoiler: the [[spoiler:the storks refuse to bring any of the boys baby brothers or sisters...except for the boy who led the song. The storks bring him a dead baby brother.]]
** "In the Duck Yard". An injured songbird is resting in a duck yard, where a proud and haughty Portuguese duck resides. The songbird makes the mistake of comparing the Portuguese to a cat, so [[spoiler: the [[spoiler:the duck decapitates the songbird.]]



* NatureIsNotNice: "A Drop of Water" is about a scientist who looks at a drop of water in a magnifying glass and is horrified to find it full of tiny EldritchAbomination like creatures tearing each other apart.

to:

* NatureIsNotNice: "A Drop of Water" is about a scientist who looks at a drop of water in a magnifying glass and is horrified to find it full of tiny EldritchAbomination like EldritchAbomination-like creatures tearing each other apart.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

He passed away in August 1875, and never married or had children.

Added: 386

Removed: 239

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CrazyEnoughToWork: The very premise of "Blockhead Hans". Taking [[NoodleImplements a dead crow, an old shoe, and a pocketful of mud]] to woo a princess makes him certifiably crazy. The "awesome" part is that he ''actually pulls it off''.


Added DiffLines:

* SuccessThroughInsanity: The very premise of "Blockhead Hans". Taking [[NoodleImplements a dead crow, an old shoe, and a pocketful of mud]] to woo a princess makes him certifiably crazy... but while his more educated brothers fall at the first hurdle after meeting the princess, Hans ''actually pulls it off'' by virtue of his eccentricity letting him keep up with her verbal sparring.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* * DisproportionateRetribution:

to:

* * DisproportionateRetribution:
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* CrazyEnoughToWork: The very premise of "Blockhead Hans". Taking [[NoodleImplements a dead crow, an old shoe, and a pocketful of mud]] to woo a princess makes him certifiably crazy. The "awesome" part is that he ''actually pulls it off''.

Added: 125

Changed: 91

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Disneyfication}}: A lot of his works has been adapted into animated features for kids, most of them naturally being done by Disney. ''WesternAnimation/{{Thumbelina|1994}}'' also fell into this, [[FollowTheLeader despite being done]] by Creator/DonBluth. ''WesternAnimation/Frozen2013'' went even further, it outright ignored what Anderson wrote.

to:

* {{Disneyfication}}: A lot of his works has been adapted into animated features for kids, most of them naturally being done by Disney. ''WesternAnimation/{{Thumbelina|1994}}'' also fell into this, [[FollowTheLeader despite being done]] by Creator/DonBluth. ''WesternAnimation/Frozen2013''
**''WesternAnimation/Frozen2013''
went even further, it outright ignored what Anderson wrote.wrote.
* * DisproportionateRetribution:
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Disneyfication}}: A lot of his works has been adapted into animated features for kids, most of them naturally being done by Disney. ''WesternAnimation/{{Thumbelina|1994}}'' also fell into this, [[FollowTheLeader despite being done]] by Creator/DonBluth. ''WesternAnimation/Frozen2013'' went even further, it utright ignored what Anderson wrote.

to:

* {{Disneyfication}}: A lot of his works has been adapted into animated features for kids, most of them naturally being done by Disney. ''WesternAnimation/{{Thumbelina|1994}}'' also fell into this, [[FollowTheLeader despite being done]] by Creator/DonBluth. ''WesternAnimation/Frozen2013'' went even further, it utright outright ignored what Anderson wrote.

Changed: 91

Removed: 30

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Disneyfication}}: A lot of his works has been adapted into animated features for kids, most of them naturally being done by Disney. ''WesternAnimation/{{Thumbelina|1994}}'' also fell into this, [[FollowTheLeader despite being done]] by Creator/DonBluth.
* DisproportionateRetribution:

to:

* {{Disneyfication}}: A lot of his works has been adapted into animated features for kids, most of them naturally being done by Disney. ''WesternAnimation/{{Thumbelina|1994}}'' also fell into this, [[FollowTheLeader despite being done]] by Creator/DonBluth.
* DisproportionateRetribution:
Creator/DonBluth. ''WesternAnimation/Frozen2013'' went even further, it utright ignored what Anderson wrote.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DontFearTheReaper: In "[[https://andersen.sdu.dk/vaerk/hersholt/OleLukoie_e.html Ole Lukoie/Lukoje]]", Death is a handsome, awe-inspiring horseman.
--> "There," he said, "you can see my brother, the other Ole Lukoie. He is also called Death. You can see that he doesn't look nearly as bad as they make him out to be in the picture books, where he is only bones and knuckles. No, his coat is embroidered with silver. It is the magnificent uniform of a hussar, and a cloak of black velvet floats behind him and billows over his horse. See how he gallops along."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
redundant


** A JustifiedTrope in "The Marsh-King's Daughter" (1858) by Creator/HansChristianAndersen: A stork watches a princess being dragged into a bog lake by the Marsh King (a swamp creature similar to a nix). The stork keeps visiting the lake and eventually notices a water lily growing up from the lake; on the lily there forms a large bud which finally opens to reveal a human baby. Realizing that the baby is the daughter of the abducted princess and the Marsh King, the stork takes up the baby and delivers it to a childless family living nearby, by reaching through a window and laying it on the wife's chest while she is sleeping; the couple is happy to adopt the baby. The stork [[LampshadeHanging hangs a lampshade]] by musing that since people say he is bringing the babies, he might as well for once do it for real.

to:

** A JustifiedTrope in "The Marsh-King's Daughter" (1858) by Creator/HansChristianAndersen: (1858): A stork watches a princess being dragged into a bog lake by the Marsh King (a swamp creature similar to a nix). The stork keeps visiting the lake and eventually notices a water lily growing up from the lake; on the lily there forms a large bud which finally opens to reveal a human baby. Realizing that the baby is the daughter of the abducted princess and the Marsh King, the stork takes up the baby and delivers it to a childless family living nearby, by reaching through a window and laying it on the wife's chest while she is sleeping; the couple is happy to adopt the baby. The stork [[LampshadeHanging hangs a lampshade]] by musing that since people say he is bringing the babies, he might as well for once do it for real.

Added: 1488

Changed: 817

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DeliveryStork: A JustifiedTrope in "The Marsh-King's Daughter" (1858) by Creator/HansChristianAndersen: A stork watches a princess being dragged into a bog lake by the Marsh King (a swamp creature similar to a nix). The stork keeps visiting the lake and eventually notices a water lily growing up from the lake; on the lily there forms a large bud which finally opens to reveal a human baby. Realizing that the baby is the daughter of the abducted princess and the Marsh King, the stork takes up the baby and delivers it to a childless family living nearby, by reaching through a window and laying it on the wife's chest while she is sleeping; the couple is happy to adopt the baby. The stork [[LampshadeHanging hangs a lampshade]] by musing that since people say he is bringing the babies, he might as well for once do it for real.

to:

* DeliveryStork: DeliveryStork:
** In "The Storks" (1839), a family of storks raising their young on a farmhouse roof are repeatedly taunted by a group of children with a mean-spirited mocking song about storks. When the young storks are finally grown, they take revenge on the children by flying to "the pond where all the little human babies lie until the storks come to take them to their parents", and picking up a little baby sibling for every child who did not mock the storks, but none for the children who mocked them. The boy who told the other children to stop taunting the storks gets both a brother ''and'' a sister, and the boy who always started the song gets a dead baby for a brother.
**
A JustifiedTrope in "The Marsh-King's Daughter" (1858) by Creator/HansChristianAndersen: A stork watches a princess being dragged into a bog lake by the Marsh King (a swamp creature similar to a nix). The stork keeps visiting the lake and eventually notices a water lily growing up from the lake; on the lily there forms a large bud which finally opens to reveal a human baby. Realizing that the baby is the daughter of the abducted princess and the Marsh King, the stork takes up the baby and delivers it to a childless family living nearby, by reaching through a window and laying it on the wife's chest while she is sleeping; the couple is happy to adopt the baby. The stork [[LampshadeHanging hangs a lampshade]] by musing that since people say he is bringing the babies, he might as well for once do it for real.

Top