Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Comicbook / BeforeWatchmen

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DeliberateValuesDissonance: The comics avert PoliticallyCorrectHistory, with slurs being commonly used while several characters are examples of PoliticallyIncorrectHero.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Inversions of Adaptational Attractiveness are covered under their own page.


* AdaptationalAttractiveness: Inverted; While Edgar had been depicted as plain-looking, his ''Before Watchmen'' comic shows him as a borderline {{Gonk}}.

to:

* AdaptationalAttractiveness: Inverted; AdaptationalUgliness: While Edgar had been depicted as plain-looking, his ''Before Watchmen'' comic shows him as a borderline {{Gonk}}.

Added: 656

Removed: 438

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* EngineeredHeroics:
** Spectre starts her career by thwarting staged shop robberies. The stores usually go along with it for the free publicity.
** After the fact variant. The Minutemen succeed in stopping a criminal act, but rather than being Italian fascist saboteurs smuggling bombs, they blow up a warehouse full of smuggled fireworks. Nelly even holds up one of his armored car's own shells as proof the criminals were arms smugglers.


Added DiffLines:

* FakeDangerGambit:
** Silk Spectre's pre-Minutemen superhero career consisted almost entirely of staged heroics by thwarting staged shop robberies using hired actors, which the stores usually go along with it for the free publicity, to raise her profile. Naturally, she resented teammate Silhouette, whose pre-Minutemen career consisted of hunting down pedophiles and rescuing children.
** The Minutemen succeed in stopping a criminal act, but rather than being Italian fascist saboteurs smuggling bombs, they blow up a warehouse full of smuggled fireworks. Nelly even holds up one of his armored car's own shells as proof the criminals were arms smugglers.

Added: 143

Changed: 211

Removed: 102

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ForegoneConclusion: Anyone who's alive in ''Watchmen'' is obviously not going to die or get permanently injured, no matter what it might look like.
** Likewise, you know that some of the Minutemen won't make it all the way through in their own comic.

to:

* ForegoneConclusion: Anyone DoomedByCanon: It's obvious to anyone who's alive in read the original ''Watchmen'' is obviously not going to die or get permanently injured, no matter what it might look like.
** Likewise, you know
that some of the Minutemen won't make it all the way through in their own comic.


Added DiffLines:

* SavedByCanon: Anyone who's alive in ''Watchmen'' is obviously not going to die or get permanently injured, no matter what it might look like.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AdaptationalHeroism: The Comedian.

to:

* AdaptationalHeroism: AdaptationalNiceGuy: The Comedian.Comedian is portrayed more sympathetically and altruistically than he was in the original comic.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* UrineTrouble: Bubastis pees on Adrian at one point.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* InsultBackfire: The Twilight Lady responds to Rorschach calling her a whore by remarking that he says it like it's a bad thing.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AlliterativeTitle
* DeliberatelyMonochrome

to:

* AlliterativeTitle
AlliterativeTitle: Every main word of the title starts with C.
* DeliberatelyMonochromeDeliberatelyMonochrome: The comic is in black-and-white.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Prequel}}: As the title would suggest.

to:

* {{Prequel}}: As the title would suggest.suggest, the comics take place before the original ''Watchmen'' maxiseries.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* ILoveNuclearPower: Averted to tragic effect. In his efforts to prevent the Statue of Liberty from exploding and killing all of New York, Scout manages to prevent the bomb from going off at the cost of being blasted with a high dosage of uranium radiation unprotected. While he looks fine at first, by the time he dies his whole body is deformed beyond recognition.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Nice Hat is now a disambiguation page.


* DeadHatShot: A non-drowning example in Issue #6 [[spoiler: we see a flashback of Ursula's death with her NiceHat turned upside down, and her bed in the back.]]

to:

* DeadHatShot: A non-drowning example in Issue #6 [[spoiler: we see a flashback of Ursula's death with her NiceHat hat turned upside down, and her bed in the back.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DeadHandShot: [[spoiler: How we see Ursula's death, via bloody slashed hand. The Liquidator's death is shown this way as well, seeing only his hand from the bathtub.]]

to:

* DeadHandShot: [[spoiler: How [[spoiler:How we see Ursula's death, via bloody slashed hand. The Liquidator's death is shown this way as well, seeing only his hand from the bathtub.]]



* TerribleIntervieweesMontage:The auditions for the Minutemen. The hopefuls range from amusingly ineffectual (Liberty Lassy, a cheerful Statue of Liberty-themed triple threat who can cook a mean brisket) to strange (Iron Lid, a crimefighter in a welder's mask and metal armor who wants to burn crooks with fire, and The Slut, a perfectly ordinary-looking woman who likes to take her clothes off and do...stuff) to just sad (Hank, an overweight man in a dirty sweatshirt with a bucket on his head who's "just Hank").

to:

* TerribleIntervieweesMontage:The TerribleIntervieweesMontage: The auditions for the Minutemen. The hopefuls range from amusingly ineffectual (Liberty Lassy, a cheerful Statue of Liberty-themed triple threat who can cook a mean brisket) to strange (Iron Lid, a crimefighter in a welder's mask and metal armor who wants to burn crooks with fire, and The Slut, a perfectly ordinary-looking woman who likes to take her clothes off and do...stuff) to just sad (Hank, an overweight man in a dirty sweatshirt with a bucket on his head who's "just Hank").



* KickTheSonOfABitch: [[spoiler:Rorshach kills Taylor Stone with his siganture "The End Is Nigh" sign.]]

to:

* KickTheSonOfABitch: [[spoiler:Rorshach kills Taylor Stone with his siganture signature "The End Is Nigh" sign.]]



* GeniusBruiser

to:

* GeniusBruiserGeniusBruiser:
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* RedHerring: The child killer's identity was implied to be the man from Ursula's past. [[spoiler: Hooded Justice was the prime suspect; he wore a hood and similar colors. Numerous hints were dropped that he at least had some connection to the case. The true culprit being Rolf Mueler (who was the man from her past), with Eddie pointing out the FridgeLogic of him not being Justice, given the age difference.]]

to:

* RedHerring: The child killer's identity was implied to be the man from Ursula's past. [[spoiler: Hooded Justice was the prime suspect; he wore a hood and similar colors. Numerous hints were dropped that he at least had some connection to the case. The true culprit being Rolf Mueler Müller (who was the man from her past), with Eddie pointing out the FridgeLogic of him not being Justice, given the age difference.]]



** In ''Watchmen'' Hooded Justice is suspected of being a German circus strongman named Rolf Müller, [[spoiler:but her it's confirmed that while a serial killer Müller had been a seperate person too old to be Hooded Justice. However Hooded Justice does speak in German at one point and it's implied he was a boy named Jacob who was abused by Müller. Since Müller had a picture of Jacob a likely explantion would be that Hooded Justice is Müller's son.]]

to:

** In ''Watchmen'' Hooded Justice is suspected of being a German circus strongman named Rolf Müller, [[spoiler:but her here it's confirmed that while a serial killer Müller had been a seperate person who was too old to be Hooded Justice. However Hooded Justice does speak in German at one point and it's implied he was a boy named Jacob who was abused by Müller. Since Müller had a picture of Jacob a likely explantion would be that Hooded Justice is Müller's son.]]

Added: 453

Changed: 302

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{RetCon}}:

to:

* {{RetCon}}: {{Retcon}}:



** In ''Watchmen'' Hooded Justice is suspected of being a German circus strongman named Rolf Müller, [[spoiler:but her it's confirmed that while a serial killer Müller had been a seperate person too old to be Hooded Justice. However Hooded Justice does speak in German at one point and it's implied he was a boy named Jacob who was abused by Müller. Since Müller had a picture of Jacob a likely explantion would be that Hooded Justice is Müller's son.]]



* StartOfDarkness

to:

* StartOfDarknessStartOfDarkness: When he was young Edgar had a crush on a girl who seemed to take an interest in him after he does a magic trick with her as his assistant, but later he overhears her discussing plans to embarress him while having sex with her boyfriend. He then murders her boyfriend and puts his corpse in her bed.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Retcon}: Two noticeable examples, though easily explained away by saying that Dan didn't feel like telling Laurie the true details and lied.

to:

* {{Retcon}: {{Retcon}}: Two noticeable examples, though easily explained away by saying that Dan didn't feel like telling Laurie the true details and lied.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* {{Retcon}: Two noticeable examples, though easily explained away by saying that Dan didn't feel like telling Laurie the true details and lied.
** In ''Watchmen'' Dan tells Laurie that he was surprised his father had left him his money after he died, having apparently been disappointed that he didn't go into banking like him. This comic reveals that he was an abusive man who had a heart attack when Dan was seventeen after beating his wife, with her and Dan choosing to wait until he was actually dead before calling an ambulance.
** In ''Watchmen'' Dan described Twilight Lady to Laurie as being a sick woman with an obsession with him and misremembers her name as Dusk Woman, though given he kept her photo it's implied he was leaving out details. This comic explains they had a DatingCatwoman relationship that ended with her breaking up with him.

Added: 434

Changed: 165

Removed: 144

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Likewise, you know in ''Minutemen'' that some of these characters won't make it all the way through.

to:

** Likewise, you know in ''Minutemen'' that some of these characters the Minutemen won't make it all the way through.through in their own comic.



* RetCon: [[spoiler:Some implications Adrian made in the original comic such as Hooded Justice's fate and WhoKilledJFK turned out to be false.]]



* {{Retcon}}: [[spoiler:It's revealed that the excerpts from ''Under the Hood'' in ''Watchmen'' weren't completely honest.]]

to:

* {{Retcon}}: [[spoiler:It's revealed {{RetCon}}:
** [[spoiler:It turns out
that the excerpts from Hollis' book ''Under the Hood'' in ''Watchmen'' weren't wasn't completely honest.]]honest in regards to Hooded Justice and left out a few other details.]]
** In the original graphic novel Sally implies that she and the Comedian only had an affair once which resulted in Laurie's conception, but here it reveals that she and Blake reconnected after Silhouette's funeral and had an affair lasting at least until her wedding day with Larry.

Added: 327

Changed: 134

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* RoadTripPlot

to:

* RoadTripPlotRoadTripPlot:



* TheSixties

to:

* TheSixtiesStageMom: Sally is this with flashbacks showing how she prevented Laurie from making any friends and how she tried to control her life.
* TheSixties: The comic takes place in 1966, several months before she become Silk Spectre and attends the Crimebusters meeting.


Added DiffLines:

* TheReasonYouSuckSpeech: Hollis gives one to one of Laurie's hippie friends, saying that he had a responsibility to look after his friends and that he has no right to judge Sally for how she raised.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* [[spoiler:PosthumousNarration]]

to:

* [[spoiler:PosthumousNarration]]PosthumousNarration: [[spoiler:Bill does this after his funeral.]]



** ''Minutemen #4'' is where the ball really drops: [[spoiler: Silhouette is killed, Silk Spectre quits, Mothman's severe alcoholic problems increase, and Hooded Justice is revealed to have some connection to the child murders.]]

to:

** ''Minutemen #4'' is where the ball really drops: [[spoiler: Silhouette [[spoiler:Silhouette is killed, Silk Spectre quits, Mothman's severe alcoholic problems increase, and Hooded Justice is revealed to have some connection to the child murders.]]

Added: 144

Changed: 39

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SurvivorsGuilt: [[spoiler:Byron admits he feels bad Silhouette and Dollar Bill died before him, thinking he should've been the first to die.]]



* ImpracticallyFancyOutfit: Hooded Justice: The Noose looks cool, but it serves as an easy thing to grab onto in a fight. When Comedian left, he used it to flip Justice over and subdue him [[spoiler: and in issue #6 Hollis grabs onto it, breaking his neck.]] Lampshaded

to:

* ImpracticallyFancyOutfit: Hooded Justice: The Noose looks cool, but it serves as an easy thing to grab onto in a fight. When Comedian left, he used it to flip Justice over and subdue him [[spoiler: and in issue #6 Hollis grabs onto it, breaking his neck.]] LampshadedLampshaded.



* WhereItAllBegan

to:

* WhereItAllBeganWhereItAllBegan: This is the story of the Minutemen.

Added: 104

Changed: 12

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* KickTheSonOfABitch: [[spoiler:Rorshach kills Taylor Stone with his siganture "The End Is Nigh" sign.]]



* SinisterMinister: Reverend Taylor Stone.

to:

* SinisterMinister: Reverend [[spoiler:Reverend Taylor Stone.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BackstoryHorror

to:

* BackstoryHorrorBackstoryHorror:



* [[spoiler: BuryYourGays: Ursula and Gretchen were killed by one of her foes, both for being an enemy [[HomophobicHateCrime and for her orientation]].]]

to:

* [[spoiler: BuryYourGays: Ursula [[spoiler:Ursula and Gretchen were killed by one of her foes, both for being an enemy [[HomophobicHateCrime and for her orientation]].]]



* [[spoiler:DownerEnding: Rorschach and Nite Owl don't work together anymore, and Dan doesn't get together with the Twilight Lady.]]

to:

* [[spoiler:DownerEnding: Rorschach DownerEnding: [[spoiler:Rorschach and Nite Owl don't work together anymore, and Dan doesn't get together with the Twilight Lady.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* HeroStageShow: Dollar Bill's day job is performing in a heroic stage show to entertain kids and promote a bank. At one point, he convinces Nite-Owl to join him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Stuffed Into The Fridge is now a fanspeak/disambiguation and should not be linked as a trope. If possible, examples are being moved to another of the tropes on the disambiguation


* StuffedIntoTheFridge: Ultimately [[spoiler:subverted by Nancy; she is approached by the Bard while she's waiting for Rorschach, who slashes her throat and carves words into her body, but she survives to identify him and comes out of the story alive, albeit traumatised]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Stuffed Into The Fridge is now a fanspeak/disambiguation and should not be linked as a trope. If possible, examples are being moved to another of the tropes on the disambiguation. ZCE


* StuffedIntoTheFridge: Again, Miranda St. John.
Tabs MOD

Added: 286

Removed: 283

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
dewicking redirect


* ItIsPronouncedTroPAY: In a conversation with Captain Metropolis, Adrian is asked if his name is pronounced Ozy''man''dius or Ozyman''di''us. He explains that while both are acceptable, he's always preferred Ozyman''di''us.
-->'''Ozymandias:''' It sounds more... ''elegant'' somehow.


Added DiffLines:

* PronouncingMyNameForYou: In a conversation with Captain Metropolis, Adrian is asked if his name is pronounced Ozy''man''dius or Ozyman''di''us. He explains that while both are acceptable, he's always preferred Ozyman''di''us.
-->'''Ozymandias:''' It sounds more... ''elegant'' somehow.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* PhysicalGod: Manhattan is able to create and destroy {{Alternate Universe}}s simply by imagining into and out of existence. And after the events of ''ComicBook/{{Watchmen}}'', Manhattan geso on to create new lifeforms on another planet.

to:

* PhysicalGod: Manhattan is able to create and destroy {{Alternate Universe}}s simply by imagining into and out of existence. And after the events of ''ComicBook/{{Watchmen}}'', Manhattan geso goes on to create new lifeforms on another planet.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Disambiguating; deleting and renaming wicks as appropriate. Moved to discussion


* {{GIFT}}: For every character who's not Rorschach, anonymity comes as a curse. When the blackout happens, [[WhatYouAreInTheDark everyone turns to crime]] and [[spoiler:Rawhead, when wearing Rorschach's mask, decides to play at crimefighting, only to be murdered himself.]]

Added: 191

Changed: 213

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ExpendableAlternateUniverse: All the {{Alternate Universe}}s Dr. Manhattan creates end in nuclear war, so he more safely destroys them all [[PhysicalGod by thinking them out of existence]].



* PhysicalGod: Manhattan is able to create {{Alternate Universe}}s just by imagining [[ForWantOfANail alternate scenarios]]. These all end in nuclear war though, so Manhattan destroys them all, once again by simply thinking about it. And after the events of Watchmen, Manhattan does go on to create new lifeforms on another planet.

to:

* PhysicalGod: Manhattan is able to create and destroy {{Alternate Universe}}s just simply by imagining [[ForWantOfANail alternate scenarios]]. These all end in nuclear war though, so Manhattan destroys them all, once again by simply thinking about it. into and out of existence. And after the events of Watchmen, ''ComicBook/{{Watchmen}}'', Manhattan does go geso on to create new lifeforms on another planet.



* DatingCatwoman: Nite Owl has an affair with the Twilight Lady, as opposed to her simply having a crush on him, as he tells Laurie years later.

to:

* DatingCatwoman: Nite Owl has an affair with the Twilight Lady, as opposed to her simply having a crush on him, [[UnreliableExpositor as he tells Laurie years later.later]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
No longer a trope


* BadassGay: Hooded Justice, Captain Metropolis, and the Silhouette. Gretchen has a moment in her flashback.

Top