Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Characters / AndThenThereWereNone

Go To

OR

Added: 1818

Changed: 701

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AdaptationalVillainy: In the game, [[spoiler: she is the murderer -- Gabrielle Steele, who killed the real Emily Brent.]]

to:

* AdaptationalVillainy: AdaptationalVillainy:
** In the 1945 adaptation, she is coldly indifferent about her crime, which is changed to sending her own nephew to a reformatory where he eventually hanged himself, while all other versions of her character show at least some degree of guilt, even if repressed.
**
In the game, [[spoiler: she is the murderer -- Gabrielle Steele, who killed the real Emily Brent.]]]]
* AmbiguousDisorder: It progressively becomes clear that there's something more to her behaviour than religious zeal, but not even Armstrong gets to an particular diagnosis. Brent's repressed guilt expresses itself through hallucinations and dissociative episodes, during which she believes Beatrice to be the murderer on the island.
* BeneathTheMask: The other guests may not see it because of her unyielding front, but she's being unconsciously consumed by repressed guilt.



* MyGodWhatHaveIDone: She eventually comes to realize the gravity of what she has done, although by that point it's too late.



* HairOfGoldHeartOfGold: She's blonde in all but the first Alan Towers adaptations, and she's innocent of the crime she's accused of.



* KarmicDeath: [[spoiler: In the original book and adaptations where she is a murderer, she asphyxiates just like the little boy she allowed to drown. It's more so in the 2015 BBC series, where as she gave Cyril false hope he could make it to the rock, Wargrave gives her false hope that he'll spare her]].

to:

* KarmicDeath: [[spoiler: In the original book and adaptations where she is a murderer, she asphyxiates just like the little boy she allowed to drown.drown, on the same date (August 11th). It's more so in the 2015 BBC series, where as she gave Cyril false hope he could make it to the rock, Wargrave gives her false hope that he'll spare her]].



* ProperLady: ''Mercilessly'' deconstructed.

to:

* ProperLady: ''Mercilessly'' deconstructed. At first, Vera seems to be the typical girl that we'd expect to see married after the resolution of the mystery: she's helpful and considerate, even if a past tragedy still weighs on her and has taken her fiance Hugo away from her. As the story goes on, the veneer starts to crack and we see that her politeness is hiding something really dark. [[spoiler: In the end, she kills Lombard, who in another setting could have been her second LoveInterest, and turns out to be guilty of one of the worst crimes among the guests, the real reason why Hugo broke up with her.]]


Added DiffLines:

* AdaptationalAttractiveness: In the book he's described as having a slumped posture and harsh features, such as a mouth similar to a turtle beak due to him using dentures. The adaptations omit these traits, giving him a much more dignified appearance.


Added DiffLines:

* VagueAge: While this is true to most of the characters in the book (only Emily Brent's age is stated explicitly), Wargrave is implied to be the oldest guest along with General Macarthur. The adaptations differ greatly on his age: in the looser ones, he's generally younger and possibly not retired yet (Attenborough is the most extreme example, as he was only 51 at the time), while in the more faithful ones he's portrayed by older actors (Zeldin at 72, Dance at 69).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** If you are a murderer, but you show honest remorse for your crimes, you will get a quick and painless death. Mrs. Rogers is allowed to die in her sleep, and MacArthur gets a simple bludgeon to the brain.

to:

** If you are a murderer, but you show honest remorse for your crimes, you will get a quick and painless death. Mrs. Rogers is allowed to die in her sleep, and MacArthur [=MacArthur=] gets a simple bludgeon to the brain.



** He gives Mrs. Rogers and General Macarthur quick, painless deaths on the grounds that they suffered enough for their crimes.

to:

** He gives Mrs. Rogers and General Macarthur [=Macarthur=] quick, painless deaths on the grounds that they suffered enough for their crimes.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* NotSoDifferent: In the BBC version, the killer seems to recognize this about Vera. [[spoiler: Wargrave realizes she's just as sociopathic as he is, but whereas he is guided by MoralSociopathy to punish the guilty, Vera is a calculating {{Yandere}} who only truly values herself.]]

to:

* NotSoDifferent: NotSoDifferentRemark: In the BBC version, the killer seems to recognize this about Vera. [[spoiler: Wargrave realizes she's just as sociopathic as he is, but whereas he is guided by MoralSociopathy to punish the guilty, Vera is a calculating {{Yandere}} who only truly values herself.]]



* NotSoDifferent: Two instances in the 2015 BBC miniseries:

to:

* NotSoDifferent: NotSoDifferentRemark: Two instances in the 2015 BBC miniseries:
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BlueAndOrangeMorality: Being a mentally deranged man, he does not operate by a normal moral code. His criteria for murder depends on several variables.
** People who are completely innocent of a crime are spared his viciousness. Even those who could potentially unravel his scheme.
** If you are a murderer, but you show honest remorse for your crimes, you will get a quick and painless death. Mrs. Rogers is allowed to die in her sleep, and MacArthur gets a simple bludgeon to the brain.
** Due to his sociopathy, Marston gets a very quick death from poisoning. Not just because Owen hated him for his crime, but because Marston's lack of conscience meant Owen wouldn't be able to take joy from his suffering.
** Blore and Dr. Armstrong suffer bad fates because they were both men in authority who misused their positions.
** Vera gets the most prolonged period of emotional agony, because Owen considered her the worst person for not saving her charge from drowning.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AmbiguouslyEvil: Despite strong suspicion based on the cicurmstances of Mrs. Brady's death and their reactions to being accused, the Rogers' are never explicitly confirmed as having killed her in the book. Their version of her death happening while Rogers was genuinely trying to get her medicine is plausible, and it does seem odd that they would have risked committing an InheritanceMurder when the inheritance was little enough that they were still working as servants a few years later.

to:

* AmbiguouslyEvil: Despite strong suspicion based on the cicurmstances of Mrs. Brady's death and their reactions to being accused, the Rogers' are never explicitly confirmed as having killed her in the book. Their version of her death happening while Rogers was genuinely trying to get her medicine is plausible, and it does seem odd that they would have risked committing an InheritanceMurder when the inheritance was little enough that they were still working as servants a few years later. Unless the murder was committed because of the assumption that the servants would inherit all her money and only later found out that it wasn’t the case, making this a case of AllForNothing.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* PoliticallyIncorrectVillain: In the 2015 version, his violent homophobia gets him onto the deadly island.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* GenderFlip: In the 2017 Japanese TV adaptation, Dr. Armstrong becomes a female (named Dr. Erika Konami) and is given penchant for fishing. Dr. Armstrong is also sometimes performed by an actress in the play adaption to balance out the female to male ratio somewhat.

to:

* GenderFlip: In the 2017 Japanese TV adaptation, Dr. Armstrong becomes a female (named Dr. Erika Konami) and is given a penchant for fishing. Dr. Armstrong is also sometimes performed by an actress in the play adaption to balance out the female to male ratio somewhat.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AdaptationExpansion: A famous actress named Gabrielle ''Turl'' is mentioned in passing in the novel, where she is just one of many people rumored to have purchased the island after it went up for sale, which turns out to be false. In the game, not only is Gabrielle ''Steele'' one of the house's past owners, it turns out she's ''still'' its owner.

Added: 201

Removed: 92

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DeathFromAbove: [[spoiler:In the original novel, he is killed when a marble clock is dropped on his head.]]



* InSeriesNickname: Lombard calls him "Tubs" in the 2015 version, to his constant annoyance.



* InSeriesNickname: Lombard calls him "Tubs" in the 2015 version, to his constant annoyance.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FakingTheDead: He appears to be the fifth victim, but his first death was faked. He did, however, commit suicide after everything was done, and the police wound up finding 10 dead bodies on the island.

to:

* FakingTheDead: He appears to be the fifth sixth victim, but his first death was faked. He did, however, commit suicide after everything was done, and the police wound up finding 10 dead bodies on the island.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* * NobleDemon: He's an unhinged sadist and killer...but he prefers to direct his cruelties toward those who deserved it. He's even willing to give the genuinely remorseful characters a painless death.

to:

* * NobleDemon: He's an unhinged sadist and killer...but he prefers to direct his cruelties toward those who deserved it. He's even willing to give the genuinely remorseful characters a painless death.

Added: 202

Removed: 213

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* NobleDemon: [[spoiler: He's an unhinged sadist and killer...but he prefers to direct his cruelties toward those who deserved it. He's even willing to give the genuinely remorseful characters a painless death]].


Added DiffLines:

* * NobleDemon: He's an unhinged sadist and killer...but he prefers to direct his cruelties toward those who deserved it. He's even willing to give the genuinely remorseful characters a painless death.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* NobleDemon: [[spoiler: He's an unhinged sadist and killer...but he prefers to direct his cruelties toward those who deserved it. He's even willing to give the genuinely remorseful characters a painless death]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DefiledForever: Brent strongly believes this, and threw her own maid out over it.


Added DiffLines:

* LackOfEmpathy: If you're someone who doesn't meet her high standards, [[NoSympathy you're damned in her eyes]], no ifs, ands, or buts. [[DownplayedTrope Then again]], she chews Lombard out for leaving his men to die for being natives, so she is certainy capable of empathy.


Added DiffLines:

* PureIsNotGood: She's a staunchly religious person, but her moral inflexibility makes her incredibly cold-hearted.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* YourDaysAreNumbered: [[spoiler:He has to commit suicide as part of his plan, but this isn't a problem for him since he has a fatal disease and only a short time left to live anyway.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* KillItWithFire: If Patrick takes too long, a fire rigged by Gabrielle to explode is what kills Charles Morely.

to:

* KillItWithFire: If Patrick takes too long, a fire Ship Rock's bonfire is rigged by Gabrielle to explode is what explode, and that kills Charles Morely.Morely if Patrick takes too long.



* ThemeSerialKiller: She makes sure that the deaths will happen just like in the rhyme "Ten Little Sailor Boys."

to:

* ThemeSerialKiller: She makes sure that the deaths will happen just like in the rhyme "Ten Little Sailor Boys."

Added: 221

Changed: 110

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* KillItWithFire: If Patrick takes too long, a fire is what ends up killing Charles Morely.
* NeverHurtAnInnocent: In her own words...

to:

* KillItWithFire: If Patrick takes too long, a fire rigged by Gabrielle to explode is what ends up killing kills Charles Morely.
* NeverHurtAnInnocent: In This is what Gabrielle claims regarding her own words...victims.



* SuicidalSadisticChoice: After voicing her intention to shoot Patrick dead and commit suicide with poison, Gabrielle tries to convince Vera to hang herself unless she wants to be executed for supposedly being the killer.



* YouHaveOutlivedYourUsefulness: Once Archibald Morris was finished assisting her in finding information about her then-future victims, she murdered him.

to:

* YouHaveOutlivedYourUsefulness: Once Archibald Morris was finished assisting her in finding information about her then-future victims, she murdered him.
him with poison.

Added: 587

Changed: 187

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AdaptationalHeroism: In the game, where he's NOT the murderer and really did want Armstrong to help him catch the killer. (See Gabrielle below)

to:

* AdaptationalHeroism: In the game, where he's NOT the murderer and really did want Armstrong to help him catch the killer. (See Gabrielle below)



Near the end of the 2005 game ''Agatha Christie: And Then There Were None'', Patrick stumbles across Vera being held at gunpoint by Emily Brent... who was actually murdered two weeks prior. The woman posing as Emily is actually a former actress named Gabrielle Steele who harbored a serious grudge against Justice Wargrave after her boyfriend Edward Seton killed himself while he was imprisoned.

* AxCrazy: TheReveal firmly esbtalishes just how much of a crazed mastermind Gabrielle truly is.

to:

Near the end of the 2005 game ''Agatha Christie: And Then There Were None'', Patrick stumbles across Vera being held at gunpoint by Emily Brent... who was actually murdered two weeks prior. The woman posing as Emily is actually a former actress named Gabrielle Steele who harbored a serious grudge against Justice Wargrave after her boyfriend Edward Seton killed himself while he was imprisoned.

* AttackOnTheHeart: One of the game's possible outcomes is Gabrielle fatally shooting Vera in her heart.
*
AxCrazy: TheReveal firmly esbtalishes establishes just how much of a crazed mastermind Gabrielle truly is.



* JerkWithAHeartOfJerk: Gabrielle's "Emily Brent" act lays out just how insensitive she was about her role in Beatrice Taylor's suicide. When she lets her identity out of the bag, however, she proves to be even ''worse'' than Emily was.



* KillItWithFire: If Patrick takes too long, a fire is what ends up killing Charles Morely.
* NeverHurtAnInnocent: In her own words...
-->'''Gabrielle''': Madmen kill for no reason! No sense of justice at ''all!'' I only killed those who ''deserve'' to die!



* WhamShot: Right before the WhamLine, Patrick runs into Vera's bedroom... only to stumble upon "Emily Brent" holding her at gunpoint.

to:

* WhamShot: Right before the WhamLine, WhamLine is delivered, Patrick runs into opens the door to Vera's bedroom... only to stumble upon "Emily Brent" holding her Vera at gunpoint.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[folder:[[spoiler:Gabrielle Steele]]]]

to:

[[folder:[[spoiler:Gabrielle Steele]]]][[folder:Gabrielle Steele]]



* EvilGloating: Gabrielle relishes in killing Patrick before Vera either hangs herself or is sentenced to DeathByHanging under the mistaken belief that she masterminded the Shipwreck Island murders.

to:

* EvilGloating: Gabrielle relishes details everything in killing detail to Vera in the game's climax, with Patrick before Vera either hangs herself or is sentenced to DeathByHanging under the mistaken belief that she masterminded the Shipwreck Island murders.witnessing it from Vera's doorway.



* OneTrueLove: Gabrielle certainly felt this way about Edward, which is why his death causes her to

to:

* OneTrueLove: Gabrielle certainly felt this way about Edward, which is why his death causes her to absolutely [[AxCrazy lose]] [[SerialKillingsSpecificTarget it]].



* SmugSnake: After TheReveal, it's clear she's convinced that all will go according to plan, especially in regards to Vera committing suicide.

to:

* SmugSnake: After TheReveal, it's clear she's convinced that all will go according to plan, especially in regards to Vera committing suicide.plan.



-->'''Gabrielle''':

to:

-->'''Gabrielle''': I wanted to extend Wargrave's torture for three excruciating days. What better way than to make him watch others die, crimes committed under his very nose, deaths he was helpless to prevent? How his ego must have been scraped ''raw!''



* TwoAliasesOneCharacter: Ulrick Norman Owen and Una Nancy Owen? Yeah. That's all Gabrielle.

to:

* TwoAliasesOneCharacter: Ulrick Norman Owen and Una Nancy Owen? Yeah. That's all ''all'' Gabrielle.

Added: 1265

Changed: 123

Removed: 836

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DrivenToSuicide: At the end, he commits suicide in such a way as to match the details of his 'murder'.

to:

* DrivenToSuicide: At the end, he commits suicide in such a way as to match the details of his 'murder'."murder."



* ChekhovsGunman: She even points out to Vera that the house's screening room featured posters of her.

to:

* ChekhovsGunman: She even points out to reminds Vera that the house's screening room featured features posters of her.



* EvilGloating: Gabrielle relishes in killing Patrick before Vera either hangs herself or is sentenced to DeathByHanging under the mistaken belief that she masterminded the Shipwreck Island murders.
* EvilRedhead: It's a given since she's the BigBad of the game.
* FakingTheDead: She has herself stung a few times by bees, takes some curare, and applies Bellman's Universal Embrocation in order to make sure it appear she kicked the bucket from a severe allergic reaction to bee stings.
* HalfTheManHeUsedToBe: Thomas Rogers literally gets the axe from Gabrielle, and she uses it to ''cut him into halves''.
* HiddenVillain: Her survival, her true identity, and her murderous personality aren't made known until the game's almost over.
* TheKillerBecomesTheKilled: After getting into a brief physical confrontation with Patrick, he shoves Gabrielle into the noose she prepared for Vera.
* OneTrueLove: Gabrielle certainly felt this way about Edward, which is why his death causes her to
* RoaringRampageOfRevenge: After Edward Seton committed suicide, Gabrielle plotted to make Justice Wargrave ''suffer'' over the course of three days by surrounding him with death before she killed him.
* SerialKillingsSpecificTarget: Justice Wargrave was the true target of her scheme.



-->'''Gabrielle''': I wanted Wargrave to suffer those three days—watching as death approached, and powerless to prevent it.

to:

-->'''Gabrielle''': I wanted Wargrave to suffer those three days—watching as death approached, and powerless to prevent it.



* EvilRedhead: It's a given since she's the BigBad of the game.
* HalfTheManHeUsedToBe: Thomas Rogers literally gets the axe from Gabrielle, and she uses it to ''cut him into halves''.
* HiddenVillain: Her survival, her true identity, and her murderous personality aren't made known until the game's almost over.
* TheKillerBecomesTheKilled: After getting into a brief physical confrontation with Patrick, he shoves Gabrielle into the noose she prepared for Vera.
* OneTrueLove: Gabrielle certainly felt this way about Edward, which is why his death causes her to
* RoaringRampageOfRevenge: After Edward Seton committed suicide, Gabrielle plotted to make Justice Wargrave ''suffer'' over the course of three days by surrounding him with death before she killed him.
* SerialKillingsSpecificTarget: Justice Wargrave was the true target of her

Added: 3082

Changed: 408

Removed: 80

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheDreaded: Everyone is terrified of him, especially not knowing his identity.



* TheDreaded: Everyone is terrified of him, especially not knowing his identity.



[[folder:Gabrielle Steel]]

to:

[[folder:Gabrielle Steel]]
[[folder:[[spoiler:Gabrielle Steele]]]]
Near the end of the 2005 game ''Agatha Christie: And Then There Were None'', Patrick stumbles across Vera being held at gunpoint by Emily Brent... who was actually murdered two weeks prior. The woman posing as Emily is actually a former actress named Gabrielle Steele who harbored a serious grudge against Justice Wargrave after her boyfriend Edward Seton killed himself while he was imprisoned.

* AxCrazy: TheReveal firmly esbtalishes just how much of a crazed mastermind Gabrielle truly is.
* BigBad: Of ''Agatha Christie: And Then There Were None''.
* BludgeonedToDeath: She kills three of the victims this way, using an unspecified blunt instrument with General John Mackenzie, doing Justice Lawrence Wargrave in with his own law book, and a bear-shaped marble clock for William Blore.
* ChekhovsGunman: She even points out to Vera that the house's screening room featured posters of her.
* DeadPersonImpersonation: Gabrielle killed Emily Brent two weeks before the game's events, impersonating her from that point on.
* SlainInTheirSleep: Gabrielle overdoses Ethel Rogers with Trional, ensuring that heart failure is what kills her while she's sleeping.
* SmugSnake: After TheReveal, it's clear she's convinced that all will go according to plan, especially in regards to Vera committing suicide.
* SoftSpokenSadist: Gabrielle has a soft voice, and she took pleasure in Wargrave's suffering.
-->'''Gabrielle''': I wanted Wargrave to suffer those three days—watching as death approached, and powerless to prevent it.
* SpeakIllOfTheDead: She calls Lawrence a "venomous old judge" and Emily a "hateful old hag."
* TamperingWithFoodAndDrink: Anthony Marston dies at Gabrielle's hand after she laces some whiskey with potassium cyanide, resulting in him being fatally asphyxiated.
* ThemeSerialKiller: She makes sure that the deaths will happen just like in the rhyme "Ten Little Sailor Boys."
* TwoAliasesOneCharacter: Ulrick Norman Owen and Una Nancy Owen? Yeah. That's all Gabrielle.
* WalkingSpoiler: Nobody suspected that Gabrielle was a murderous seeker of vengeance pretending to be Emily or that the Owens were fictitious people she came up with.
* WhamLine: "I've always had a duplicated set of keys, Miss Claythorne, as a former and actually the ''current'' owner of this house."
* WhamShot: Right before the WhamLine, Patrick runs into Vera's bedroom... only to stumble upon "Emily Brent" holding her at gunpoint.
* EvilRedhead: It's a given since she's the BigBad of the game.
* HalfTheManHeUsedToBe: Thomas Rogers literally gets the axe from Gabrielle, and she uses it to ''cut him into halves''.
* HiddenVillain: Her survival, her true identity, and her murderous personality aren't made known until the game's almost over.
* TheKillerBecomesTheKilled: After getting into a brief physical confrontation with Patrick, he shoves Gabrielle into the noose she prepared for Vera.
* OneTrueLove: Gabrielle certainly felt this way about Edward, which is why his death causes her to
* RoaringRampageOfRevenge: After Edward Seton committed suicide, Gabrielle plotted to make Justice Wargrave ''suffer'' over the course of three days by surrounding him with death before she killed him.
* SerialKillingsSpecificTarget: Justice Wargrave was the true target of her
* YouHaveOutlivedYourUsefulness: Once Archibald Morris was finished assisting her in finding information about her then-future victims, she murdered him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* YouWillBeSpared: In the 2015 adaptation owing to AdaptaionalHeroism, Owen leaves him alive.

to:

* YouWillBeSpared: In the 2015 adaptation owing to AdaptaionalHeroism, Adaptational Heroism, Owen leaves him alive.

Added: 271

Changed: 35

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* PoliticallyIncorrectVillain: Besides his crime of course, it's kind of interesting that while the newer version of the novel replaced the racist earlier title, Lombard's anti-Semitic and racist sentiments are left intact, and while his chivalry is a redeeming quality, he also displays it in a sexist way.

to:

* PoliticallyIncorrectVillain: Besides his crime crime, of course, it's kind of interesting that while the newer version of the novel replaced the racist earlier title, Lombard's anti-Semitic and racist sentiments are left intact, and while his chivalry is a redeeming quality, he also displays it in a sexist way.



A retired World War I general. He is accused of causing the death of Arthur Richmond, his wife Leslie's lover by sending him on a mission that guarantees him dead.

to:

A retired World War I general. He is accused of causing the death of Arthur Richmond, his wife Leslie's lover lover, by sending him on a mission that guarantees him dead.



* NotAfraidToDie: He is so consumed by guilt that he actually welcomes his impending fate. [[spoiler: Owen rewards him with a quick and painless death.]]

to:

* NotAfraidToDie: He is so consumed by guilt that he actually welcomes his impending fate. [[spoiler: Owen [[spoiler:Owen rewards him with a quick and painless death.]]



* AdaptationalHeroism: The fact that Rogers mentally abused his wife is omitted in the Soviet adaptation. [[spoiler:Which makes it the opposite trope for Mrs. Rogers, who is therefore as guilty of murder as him instead of being under duress]].

to:

* AdaptationalHeroism: The fact that Rogers mentally abused his wife is omitted in the Soviet adaptation. [[spoiler:Which makes it [[AdaptationalVillainy the opposite trope trope]] for Mrs. Rogers, who is therefore as guilty of murder as him instead of being under duress]].



* KickTheDog: He's not the only unrepentant one on the island, but one of his viewpoint passages shows him outright ''gleefully'' reminiscing about turning the jury against Seton. [[spoiler: Subverted when it turns out that Seton ''did'' do it, making it a KickTheSonOfABitch]].

to:

* KickTheDog: He's not the only unrepentant one on the island, but one of his viewpoint passages shows him outright ''gleefully'' reminiscing about turning the jury against Seton. [[spoiler: Subverted when it turns out that Seton really ''did'' do it, making it a KickTheSonOfABitch]].


Added DiffLines:

* MoralSociopathy: [[spoiler:From a young age, he's had pronounced sadistic tendencies -- but also a strong moral code that causes him to disdain harm towards the innocent.]]
* NamesToRunAwayFromReallyFast: "Wargrave" certainly doesn't sound like a peaceful man's surname.

Added: 283

Removed: 128

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ActuallyIAmHim: In the 2015 version he comes to the island under the alias of Mr. Davis and confesses to being Blore once the accusations are read aloud.



* HoistByHerOwnPetard: [[spoiler:At the end of the game. To explain it would be a bit...[[ArtisticLicensePhysics complex...]] ]]



* HoistByHerOwnPetard: [[spoiler:At the end of the game. To explain it would be a bit...[[ArtisticLicensePhysics complex...]] ]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* MadArtist: [[spoiler: He considers himself this in his confession. He wanted to create ten artistic deaths that no-one could solve, but acknowledges that he's writing the confession to show off the crime as his so that people will see how clever his scheme was.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
can't recall Fred having killed anyone, so it's not like Wargrave should have murdered him in the first place


* YouWillBeSpared: In the book and most adaptations, he leaves Fred Narracott out of the machinations and orders him not to return to the island. This saves Fred's life. He also spares Isaac Morris in the 2015 adaptation, owing to Morris just being an ordinary lawyer.

to:

* YouWillBeSpared: In the book and most adaptations, he leaves Fred Narracott out of the machinations and orders him not to return to the island. This saves Fred's life. He also spares Isaac Morris in the 2015 adaptation, owing to Morris just being an ordinary lawyer.

Added: 973

Changed: 411

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-->Perhaps we're dead already and we just don't realise it. And this is hell. We're in hell, and we're being punished for what we done. Because I did kill him - Landor. I stomped him until he was pulp. His own mother couldn't see him, couldn't say goodbye! I murdered him, alright. He was helpless and I didn't stop. He must've been so frightened. He was just a young lad.

to:

-->Perhaps we're dead already and we just don't realise realize it. And this is hell. We're in hell, and we're being punished for what we done. Because I did kill him - Landor. I stomped him until he was pulp. His own mother couldn't see him, couldn't say goodbye! I murdered him, alright. He was helpless and I didn't stop. He must've been so frightened. He was just a young lad.



* AdaptationalHeroism: In the stage play and some films, [[spoiler:Lombard is innocent. He went to get help and didn’t come back in time. He just made the story up just so he could see everyone’s reaction to his confession.]]



** In the book, he abandons the tribesmen to starve to death while they were lost, but did not directly kill them. In the 2015 version, he actively murdered the 21 Africans and burned their village in pursuit of securing a diamond mine. [[spoiler:Apparently Subverted though. He went to get help and didn’t come back in time. He just made the story up just so he could see everyone’s reaction to his confession.]]

to:

** In the book, he abandons the tribesmen to starve to death while they were lost, but did not directly kill them. In the 2015 version, he actively murdered the 21 Africans and burned their village in pursuit of securing a diamond mine. [[spoiler:Apparently Subverted though. He went to get help and didn’t come back in time. He just made the story up just so he could see everyone’s reaction to his confession.]]



* PetTheDog: In the 2015 series, he realizes that Vera isn't the killer because she has an alibi when Blore is dead. Lombard tries in vain to protect her knowing the other killer is on the island. [[spoiler:Sadly, it doesn't save him when Vera gets ahold of his gun]].



* NeverHurtAnInnocent: In the book and 2015 BBC miniseries, he confirms that he made sure all of the victims on the island were guilty of their crimes. He spares Fred Narracott, who was in innocent, and in fact orders him not to return to the island.

to:

* NeverHurtAnInnocent: In the book and 2015 BBC miniseries, he confirms that he made sure all of the victims on the island were guilty of their crimes. He spares Fred Narracott, who was in innocent, and in fact orders him not to return to the island.



* PetTheDog: He gives Mrs. Rogers and General Macarthur quick, painless deaths on the grounds that they suffered enough for their crimes.

to:

* PetTheDog: PetTheDog:
**
He gives Mrs. Rogers and General Macarthur quick, painless deaths on the grounds that they suffered enough for their crimes.crimes.
** Owen explicitly tells Fred to ''not'' return to the island, no matter what. Owen doesn't want to hurt an innocent man.



* YouWillBeSpared: In the book and most adaptations, he leaves Fred Narracott out of the machinations and orders him not to return to the island. This saves Fred's life.

to:

* YouWillBeSpared: In the book and most adaptations, he leaves Fred Narracott out of the machinations and orders him not to return to the island. This saves Fred's life. He also spares Isaac Morris in the 2015 adaptation, owing to Morris just being an ordinary lawyer.



* UnableToSupportAWife: He has some old fashioned ideas about this and refuses to marry Vera because of his income level.

to:

* UnableToSupportAWife: He has some old fashioned old-fashioned ideas about this and refuses to marry Vera because of his income level.



* AdaptationalHeroism: The 2015 BBC adaptation has him as an ordinary lawyer and not a drug dealer. For this reason, Mr. Owen spares him.



* DeadAllAlong: It's revealed that he died of a drug overdose the day the others left to the island.

to:

* DeadAllAlong: It's revealed that he died of a drug overdose the day the others left to for the island.


Added DiffLines:

* YouWillBeSpared: In the 2015 adaptation owing to AdaptaionalHeroism, Owen leaves him alive.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DrowningMySorrows: Hugo became an alcoholic [[spoiler:after realizing that Vera killed Cyril because of him.]]

Added: 934

Changed: 508

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In the book, he abandons the tribesmen to starve to death while they were lost, but did not directly kill them. In the 2015 version, he actively murdered the 21 Africans and burned their village in pursuit of securing a diamond mine. [[spoiler:Subverted. He went to get help and didn’t come back in time. He just made the story up just so he could see everyone’s reaction to his confession.]]

to:

** In the book, he abandons the tribesmen to starve to death while they were lost, but did not directly kill them. In the 2015 version, he actively murdered the 21 Africans and burned their village in pursuit of securing a diamond mine. [[spoiler:Subverted.[[spoiler:Apparently Subverted though. He went to get help and didn’t come back in time. He just made the story up just so he could see everyone’s reaction to his confession.]]



* TheSocialDarwinist: He freely admits to having left twenty-one African men to starve to death, and is well-known for participating in quasi-legal activities. His justification is, "self-preservation is a man's first duty." However, [[spoiler:this ultimately becomes his own undoing during the showdown between himself and Vera Claythorne at the end.]]

to:

* TheScapegoat: Downplayed, as Lomabrd is guilty (something he himself freely admits), but he mentions in passing that there were two other men with him who also stole the food and abandoned the Africans (with it being unclear if they were just as culpable as Lombard, less culpable or even more guiltier than he was), who avoid U.N. Owen's radar, unlike Lombard himself.
* TheSocialDarwinist: He freely admits to having left twenty-one African men to starve to death, death (it's unclear whether all of them actually did die, but Lombard seems to think they did), and is well-known for participating in quasi-legal activities. His justification is, "self-preservation is a man's first duty." However, [[spoiler:this ultimately becomes his own undoing during the showdown between himself and Vera Claythorne at the end.]]


Added DiffLines:

* AmbiguouslyEvil: Despite strong suspicion based on the cicurmstances of Mrs. Brady's death and their reactions to being accused, the Rogers' are never explicitly confirmed as having killed her in the book. Their version of her death happening while Rogers was genuinely trying to get her medicine is plausible, and it does seem odd that they would have risked committing an InheritanceMurder when the inheritance was little enough that they were still working as servants a few years later.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AmoralAttorney: A shady lawyer who dealt drugs and would do other suspicious things for money with no questions.


Added DiffLines:

* {{Hypochondria}}: He had many imagined physical ailments and was killed with pills he was assured would solve that problem.

Top