Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Characters / AndThenThereWereNone

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


!!!'''Portrayed By:''' Roland Young (1945), Stanley Holloway (1965), Gert Froebe (1974), Aleksei Zharkov (1987), Warren Berlinger (1989), Creator/BurnGorman (2015)

to:

!!!'''Portrayed By:''' Roland Young (1945), Stanley Holloway Creator/StanleyHolloway (1965), Gert Froebe (1974), Aleksei Zharkov (1987), Warren Berlinger (1989), Creator/BurnGorman (2015)

Added: 388

Changed: 295

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AntiVillain: Wargrave is, by his own admission, a complete and utter maniac, but he is also a deeply moral man who chooses to use his final days ending the lives of criminals.

to:

* AntiVillain: Wargrave is, by his own admission, a complete and utter maniac, but he is also a deeply moral man who chooses to use his final days ending the lives of criminals. What's particularly effective about him is that he doesn't exempt ''himself'' from his extremely rigid moral code: he knows that by committing murders, he will have become just as guilty as the people he killed, and that means he too has to die, a fate which he calmly accepts without question.


Added DiffLines:

* BetterToDieThanBeKilled: Wargrave starts his scheme in earnest when he receives a terminal diagnosis from his doctor. He realizes that he has a choice: wait for the disease to finish him slowly and painfully, or commit the crime he's always dreamed of and either kill himself after succeeding or get hanged as a murderer. He opts for the latter and pulls the whole thing off perfectly.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added example(s)

Added DiffLines:

* AdaptationalHeroism: In the 2005 game someone else is responsible for the murders on the island and Wargrave's plot to fake his own death comes into play to actually catch Owen and prevent more harm to the others.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


!!!'''Portrayed By:''' Richard Haydn and Queenie Leonard (1945), Mario Adorf and Marianne Hoppe (1965, as Josef and Elsa Grohmann), Alberto De Mendoza and Maria Rohm (1974, as Otto and Elsa Martino), Aleksei Zolotnitsky and Irina Tereshchenko (1987), Paul L. Smith and Moira Lister (1989, as Elmo and Edna Mae Rodgers), Creator/NoahTaylor and Anna Maxwell Martin (2015)

to:

!!!'''Portrayed By:''' Richard Haydn Creator/RichardHaydn and Queenie Leonard (1945), Mario Adorf and Marianne Hoppe (1965, as Josef and Elsa Grohmann), Alberto De Mendoza and Maria Rohm (1974, as Otto and Elsa Martino), Aleksei Zolotnitsky and Irina Tereshchenko (1987), Paul L. Smith and Moira Lister (1989, as Elmo and Edna Mae Rodgers), Creator/NoahTaylor and Anna Maxwell Martin (2015)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ReasonableAuthorityFigure: Legge and Maine do a diligent job of being fair-minded as they discuss the ten guests. They don't leap to judgments about whether Owen's claims are all true and are also willing to acknowledge and consider the misdeeds of public servants like Wargrave and Blore - and in Blore's case, are heavily critical of him and don't hold back on him because he was a police officer like both of them. Most notably, they seem to appreciate how improper Justice Wargrave's summation of the Sefton trial seemed, even though it later transpired that Sefton was guilty.

to:

* ReasonableAuthorityFigure: Legge and Maine do a diligent job of being fair-minded as they discuss the ten guests. They don't leap to judgments about whether Owen's claims are all true and are also willing to acknowledge and consider the misdeeds of public servants like Wargrave and Blore - and in Blore's case, are heavily critical of him and don't hold back on him because he was a police officer like both of them. Most notably, they seem to appreciate how improper Justice Wargrave's summation of the Sefton Seton trial seemed, even though it later transpired that Sefton Seton was guilty.

Added: 583

Changed: 602

Removed: 1233

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AndIMustScream: Wargrave explains that he suffered this trope due to his two biggest personality traits. On the one hand, he was ''obsessed'' with committing a murder and having power over life and death, but on the other, his impossibly strong moral code and belief that only the guilty should be punished left him unable to act on that obsession. He remarks that the whole reason he became a judge was to get relief by sentencing criminals to hang, but it wasn't enough--he was agonizingly trapped between two impulses and couldn't do anything about it until he hit upon his scheme.



* BornLucky: In the book. Once you know the full extent of [[GambitRoulette his plans]] and the circumstances around them, you realize that he was very lucky that the things turned out the way they did. One of the biggest instances would be the fact that the bad weather prevented Narracott from coming back before it was too late. He did use the excuse that it was a social "experiment" to dissuade the villagers from coming. But we later learn that Fred Narracott wanted to bypass these orders as soon as he saw the first distress calls, but couldn't because of the storm. Had he been able to sail, most of the murders could have been prevented.



* GambitRoulette: Works ''ridiculously'' well in the book, but fails in the Hollywood adaptations.

to:

* GambitRoulette: Works ''ridiculously'' well in Once you know the book, full extent of his plans and the circumstances around them, you realize that he was very lucky that the things turned out the way they did. One of the biggest instances would be the fact that the bad weather prevented Narracott from coming back before it was too late. He did use the excuse that it was a social "experiment" to dissuade the villagers from coming. But we later learn that Fred Narracott wanted to bypass these orders as soon as he saw the first distress calls, but fails in couldn't because of the Hollywood adaptations.storm. Had he been able to sail, most of the murders could have been prevented.


Added DiffLines:

* MortonsFork: Wargrave explains that he suffered this trope due to his two biggest personality traits. On the one hand, he was ''obsessed'' with committing a murder and having power over life and death, but on the other, his impossibly strong moral code and belief that only the guilty should be punished left him unable to act on that obsession. He remarks that the whole reason he became a judge was to get relief by sentencing criminals to hang, but it wasn't enough--he was agonizingly trapped between two impulses and couldn't do anything about it until he hit upon his scheme.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AntiVillain: Wargrave is, by his own admission, a complete and utter maniac, but he is also a deeply moral man who chooses to use his final days ending the lives of criminals.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MeaningfulName: A surname composed of "war" and "grave" really suits a HangingJudge. It still applies with the AdaptationNameChange, since the surname is changed to Cannon (or Quinncannon), which is very similar to "canon" (or "Queen's canon"). His first. And is Lawrence. Appropriate, given that he is a judge operating by the law for justice.

to:

* MeaningfulName: A surname composed of "war" and "grave" really suits a HangingJudge. It still applies with the AdaptationNameChange, since the surname is changed to Cannon (or Quinncannon), which is very similar to "canon" (or "Queen's canon"). His first. And first name is Lawrence. Appropriate, given that he is a judge operating by the law for justice.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MeaningfulName: A surname composed of "war" and "grave" really suits a HangingJudge. It still applies with the AdaptationNameChange, since the surname is changed to Cannon (or Quinncannon), which is very similar to "canon" (or "Queen's canon").

to:

* MeaningfulName: A surname composed of "war" and "grave" really suits a HangingJudge. It still applies with the AdaptationNameChange, since the surname is changed to Cannon (or Quinncannon), which is very similar to "canon" (or "Queen's canon"). His first. And is Lawrence. Appropriate, given that he is a judge operating by the law for justice.

Added: 583

Changed: 565

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* WhenItAllBegan: In the epliogue, the killer states that they were first inspired following a discussion with the GP (family doctor) of the employer of Mr & Mrs Rodgers. The GP stated that he was certain that the Rodgerses had deliberately killed their employer by witholding medication, but knew that there was no way of proving this, and wondered to the killer about how many other similar cases existed, where people had committed murders in ways that could never be proven.

to:

* WhenItAllBegan: In the epliogue, epilogue, the killer states that they were first inspired following a discussion with the GP (family doctor) of the employer of Mr & Mrs Rodgers. The GP stated that he was certain that the Rodgerses had deliberately killed their employer by witholding medication, but knew that there was no way of proving this, and wondered to the killer about how many other similar cases existed, where people had committed murders in ways that could never be proven.



* ReasonableAuthorityFigure: Legge and Maine do a diligent job of being fair-minded as they discuss the ten guests. They don't leap to judgments about whether Owen's claims are all true and are also willing to acknowledge and consider the misdeeds of public servants like Wargrave and Blore. Most notably, they seem to appreciate how improper Justice Wargrave's summation of the Sefton trial seemed, even though it later transpired that Sefton was guilty.

to:

* PoliceAreUseless: Both AC Legge and Inspector Maine are meticulous in analysing the case and trying to work out who the killer was. Maine refuses to use any shortcuts and probes every possible explanation for the deaths, even when this means accepting none of their theories. However, they cannot crack the case.
* ReasonableAuthorityFigure: Legge and Maine do a diligent job of being fair-minded as they discuss the ten guests. They don't leap to judgments about whether Owen's claims are all true and are also willing to acknowledge and consider the misdeeds of public servants like Wargrave and Blore.Blore - and in Blore's case, are heavily critical of him and don't hold back on him because he was a police officer like both of them. Most notably, they seem to appreciate how improper Justice Wargrave's summation of the Sefton trial seemed, even though it later transpired that Sefton was guilty.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* WhenItAllBegan: In the epliogue, the killer states that they were first inspired following a discussion with the GP (family doctor) of the employer of Mr & Mrs Rodgers. The GP stated that he was certain that the Rodgerses had deliberately killed their employer by witholding medication, but knew that there was no way of proving this, and wondered to the killer about how many other similar cases existed, where people had committed murders in ways that could never be proven.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Yandere}}: In the book, [[spoiler:turns out that she did cause Cyril Hamilton's death so his uncle Hugo, who was her lover, could inherit the child's estate]]. Downplayed in the Russian film adaptation, where a single flashback shows her [[spoiler:coldly watching Cyril runs into the sea to his death after Hugo explains why he can't marry her.]]

to:

* {{Yandere}}: In the book, [[spoiler:turns out that she did cause Cyril Hamilton's death so his uncle Hugo, who was her lover, could inherit the child's estate]]. Downplayed in the Russian film adaptation, where a single flashback shows her [[spoiler:coldly watching Cyril runs run into the sea to his death after Hugo explains why he can't marry her.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CuteAndPsycho: A gentle, sweet, naive girl who [[spoiler:caused the death of her lover's nephew, who was her charge, by letting him drown in the sea so her lover could inherit the family state and marry her. She only gets crazier as the story goes on.]]

to:

* CuteAndPsycho: A gentle, sweet, naive girl who [[spoiler:caused the death of her lover's nephew, who was her charge, by letting him drown in the sea so her lover could inherit the family state estate and marry her. She only gets crazier as the story goes on.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
spelling correction


* TheScapegoat: Downplayed, as Lomabrd is guilty (something he himself freely admits), but he mentions in passing that there were two other men with him who also stole the food and abandoned the Africans (with it being unclear if they were just as culpable as Lombard, less culpable or even guiltier than he was), who avoid U.N. Owen's radar, unlike Lombard himself.

to:

* TheScapegoat: Downplayed, as Lomabrd Lombard is guilty (something he himself freely admits), but he mentions in passing that there were two other men with him who also stole the food and abandoned the Africans (with it being unclear if they were just as culpable as Lombard, less culpable or even guiltier than he was), who avoid U.N. Owen's radar, unlike Lombard himself.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BadassBystander: Fred's the only one to smell a rat in the story Mr Owen gives the people of Sticklehaven to cut off contact with Soldier Island. When he hears that an SOS signal's been spotted coming from the island, he decides to ignore the orders and gathers a group to sail to the island as soon as the sea is calm enough.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ThanatosGambit: His very last victim...is himself, since he's fatally ill and wants to leave the world of the living right after the last victim dies.

to:

* ThanatosGambit: His very last victim...victim is himself, since he's fatally ill and wants to leave the world of the living right after the last victim dies.

Added: 987

Changed: 334

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The butler and maid who accomodate the other guests. They are accused of causing the death of their former employer, a rich spinster named Jennifer Brady, by withholding a vital drug so that she would die and they could inherit her money.

to:

The butler and maid who accomodate accommodate the other guests. They are accused of causing the death of their former employer, a rich spinster named Jennifer Brady, by withholding a vital drug so that she would die and they could inherit her money.



* AnimalMotifs: He's frequently compared to a turtle, with his wrinkled face, sunken lips, heavily-lidded eyes, and generally slow, calm demeanor mentioned as shared traits.



* AndIMustScream: Wargrave explains that he suffered this trope due to his two biggest personality traits. On the one hand, he was ''obsessed'' with committing a murder and having power over life and death, but on the other, his impossibly strong moral code and belief that only the guilty should be punished left him unable to act on that obsession. He remarks that the whole reason he became a judge was to get relief by sentencing criminals to hang, but it wasn't enough--he was agonizingly trapped between two impulses and couldn't do anything about it until he hit upon his scheme.



* BadPeopleAbuseAnimals: In his confession letter, he mentions "certain experiments" he performed on animals [[TroublingUnchildlikeBehavior as a little boy]] as one of the early signs of his sociopathy and obsession with death.



* YourDaysAreNumbered: He's terminally ill and decides to leave the world taking some unpunished criminals with him.

to:

* YourDaysAreNumbered: He's terminally ill and decides to leave He mentions in his confession letter that he didn't have the world taking some unpunished criminals guts to go through with him.his plans until he received a fatal (though unspecified) diagnosis from his doctor. Wargrave realized that he didn't have much time left and decided to go out not just murdering murderers, but setting up a grandiose mystery in the process.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
removed unnecessary Self Fulfilling Spoiler


* MouthOfSauron: Morris deals with people on behalf of his client due to Mr. Owen being an InventedIndividual whose creator can't afford to let anyone know who [[spoiler:he]] is.

to:

* MouthOfSauron: Morris deals with people on behalf of his client due to Mr. Owen being an InventedIndividual whose creator can't afford to let anyone know who [[spoiler:he]] is.they are.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Per TRS.


* KickTheDog: He's not the only unrepentant one on the island, but one of his viewpoint passages shows him outright ''gleefully'' reminiscing about turning the jury against Seton. [[spoiler: Subverted when it turns out that Seton really ''did'' do it, making it a KickTheSonOfABitch]].

to:

* KickTheDog: He's not the only unrepentant one on the island, but one of his viewpoint passages shows him outright ''gleefully'' reminiscing about turning the jury against Seton. [[spoiler: Subverted when it turns out that Seton really ''did'' do it, making it a KickTheSonOfABitch]].it]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Tropes related to the killer's identity should be listed under their separate folder so as to avoid spoiling TheReveal.

to:

Tropes related to the killer's identity should be listed under their separate folder separately so as to avoid spoiling TheReveal.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DontDoThisCoolThing: How the Russian film version implies Vera [[spoiler:goaded Cyril into swimming out to sea and drowning. She kept teasing him that the rock he wanted to swim up to is too far away and he won't be able to reach it.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* HappyFlashback: Played with in the Russian film version. [[spoiler:As she is driven mad by guilt and about to hang herself, Vera experiences a brief flashback to a happier time as Cyril's governess where the two of them bond and play joyfully on the beach.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Yandere}}: In the book, [[spoiler:turns out that she did cause Cyril Hamilton's death so his uncle Hugo, who was her lover, could inherit the child's estate]]. Not quite ''as'' much in the Russian film adaptation, but a single flashback showing her [[spoiler:coldly watching Cyril die after Hugo explains why he can't marry her]] is all it takes to seal it.

to:

* {{Yandere}}: In the book, [[spoiler:turns out that she did cause Cyril Hamilton's death so his uncle Hugo, who was her lover, could inherit the child's estate]]. Not quite ''as'' much Downplayed in the Russian film adaptation, but where a single flashback showing shows her [[spoiler:coldly watching Cyril die runs into the sea to his death after Hugo explains why he can't marry her]] is all it takes to seal it.her.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SpottingTheThread: In the BBC adaptation, he states that [[spoiler: he wasn't sure Vera was guilty until he heard her speak at the funeral, professing her guilt over not being able to catch up with Cyril. He then confronts Vera with the knowledge that Cyril was sickly with weak lungs and couldn't have possibly outrun or outswum Vera, who is still in her prime. It's not enough to prove that Vera committed murder, but it's enough for him to break up with her.]]

to:

* SpottingTheThread: In the BBC adaptation, he states that [[spoiler: he wasn't sure Vera was guilty until he heard her speak at the funeral, inquest, professing her guilt over not being able to catch up with Cyril. He then confronts Vera with the knowledge that Cyril was sickly with weak lungs and couldn't have possibly outrun or outswum Vera, who is still in her prime. It's not enough to prove that Vera committed murder, but it's enough for him to break up with her.]]

Added: 107

Changed: 112

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AdaptationalVillainy: In the game, [[spoiler:''he'' murdered Cyril and blamed Vera for it]].

to:

* AdaptationNameChange: A minor one, but in the play his name is changed to Hugh Hamilton.
* AdaptationalVillainy: In the game, game and the play, [[spoiler:''he'' murdered Cyril and blamed Vera for it]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


!!Gabrielle Steelee

to:

!!Gabrielle Steelee
Steele

Top