Follow TV Tropes

Following

History ArtisticLicenseHistory / LiveActionFilms

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* * ''Film/{{Austerlitz}}'': In real life, UsefulNotes/NapoleonBonaparte didn't face a defeated and lone Kutuzov (without capturing him) once he won the battle, Kutuzov was coordinating the retreat of his troops instead.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''ArtisticLicenseHistory/Napoleon2023''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The Apollo 1 disaster is portrayed as having killed the pilots within seconds by a fire followed by a large explosion. In real life, most of the burns on the astronauts occurred in postmortem, with the cause of death being asphyxiation and smoke inhalation.[[note]]The fire quickly consumed all the oxygen in the cabin, but not before melting the astronauts' suits and oxygen tubes, exposing them to the toxic cabin air.[[/note]] Furthermore, the spark caused by faulty wiring is portrayed as occurring within Ed White's line of sight, whereas in real life it originated from under Grissom's seat.

to:

** The Apollo 1 disaster is portrayed as having killed the pilots within seconds by a fire followed by a large explosion. In real life, most of the burns on the astronauts occurred in postmortem, with the cause of death being asphyxiation and smoke inhalation.[[note]]The fire quickly consumed all the oxygen in the cabin, but not before melting the astronauts' suits and oxygen tubes, exposing them to the toxic cabin air.[[/note]] The 'explosion' was actually the hull of the Command Module rupturing from the buildup of heat and pressure inside. Furthermore, the spark caused by faulty wiring is portrayed as occurring within Ed White's line of sight, whereas in real life it originated from under Grissom's seat.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* InUniverse in ''Film/DoctorInDistress1963''; Dr. Sparrow complains about ''The Sorrows of Salome'' as Salome never made it to Rome in real life, but Delia doesn't care so long as she gets a role in the film.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Film/DadsArmy1971'':
** UsefulNotes/AdolfHitler never planned to invade Britain after France, and in reality, would've been preparing for Operation Barbarossa.
** Wilson's newspaper dated the 3rd of May 1940 has the headline of the newspaper printed on the 31st of May in real life.
** Mr. Mainwaring, Wilson, and Pike hear Anthony Eden's announcement of the forming of the Local Defense Volunteers in the middle of the day, despite the fact that his broadcast actually happened in the evening.
** At the meeting in the church hall, Godfrey gives Mr. Mainwaring a message from his wife to bring home a pound of Brussels sprouts. However, the meeting started at 6 pm, the time shops would've closed in TheForties.
** Four modern (by '70s standards) cars can be spotted at the roadblock.

Added: 2304

Removed: 238

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
One of the examples was out of alphabetical order, so I relocated it. Also crosswicked an example


* ''Film/GreenBook'': Don Shirley is depicted as being culturally distant from both his family and also other black people generally, though his living family insists that he was good friends with them and other prominent black musicians.


Added DiffLines:

* ''Film/GreenBook'': Don Shirley is depicted as being culturally distant from both his family and also other black people generally, though his living family insists that he was good friends with them and other prominent black musicians.
* ''Film/GuyanaCrimeOfTheCentury'': While the movie attempts to follow to the letter the recounting of the events that led to the real-life Jonestown massacre, several liberties were taken (this doesn't count the changed names of the involved people, which was done due to RomanAClef):
** Many of the commune's inhabitants are portrayed as white people. In RealLife, the majority of Peoples Temple followers were of color.
** The speech O'Brien gives in front of the commune's inhabitants to say that he's told that living in it has been the greatest thing ever for its inhabitants takes place during the day. In RealLife, Leo Ryan's gave that speech during night.
** The reverend's portrayal as a preacher against the corruption of society leans towards showing him as a {{Jerkass}} since the beginning. In RealLife, while Jim Jones was already a very controversial person before moving to Jonestown, he was known for using his charisma and sense of assurance to win over his followers, and only showed publicly his troublesome attitude after moving to Guyana. Relatedly, other than a few dialogue lines, the movie surprisingly underplays Johnson's socialist motivations regarding his church as well as its multiracial embrace, despite the real-life Jim Jones having those two concepts as the driving forces for his religious movement.
** After O'Brien dodges a knife attack from a Temple follower and leaves alongside the defectors who side with him, Johnson says in front of the remaining people that O'Brien's plane must be brought down (an euphemism referring to his eventual murder). In RealLife, nobody at Jonestown outside Jones and his inner circle even knew what happened in Port Kaituma until Jones himself informed everybody about Leo Ryan's death during the evening when the murder-suicide took place.
** Susan Ames (the fictionalized version of Sharon Agnes) is shown being murdered alongside her children. In RealLife, following the orders of Jim Jones, Sharon killed her youngest children and then asked the eldest one to kill her and then commit suicide.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Film/Tetris2023'': While roughly based on an account of real-life events, some events were either embellished or introduced to make for a more compelling story:
** While Henk really was the one that suggested ''Tetris'' to be bundled with the Game Boy, in reality it was already out in Japan without any bundled games at the time Henk went to Russia to negotiate the handheld rights.
** Belikov's BatmanGambit in reality only involved him roasting [[CorruptBureaucrat Robert Stein]] over not paying his due royalties and imposing increased rates and penalties (which he was actually prepared to lower if Stein complained) in order to prevent him from [[ReadTheFinePrint reading the fine print]]. The ''Tetris'' arcade rights were not actually involved the negotiations.
** While Henk Rogers, Robert Stein and Kevin Maxwell really were in Russia at the same time for the ''Tetris'' rights, they never became aware of each other's presence while they were there. [[spoiler:Henk Rogers and Robert Stein]] never actually met as Belikov was in fact ''very careful'' in keeping all parties separate and arranging his meetings with them in such a way so that they '''wouldn't''' accidentally bump into each other. The ChanceMeetingBetweenAntagonists was just added to the movie to create tension.
** The ending car chase was invented purely to give the film an exciting climax. However, the idea didn't come out of nowhere: while it's true that Robert Maxwell attempted to sic the KGB on Henk and co. in retaliation for obtaining the rights to ''Tetris'', in reality the KGB told him that there was nothing they could do since their hands were tied trying to deal with their collapsing government and to [[KnowWhenToFoldEm just give up.]]
** Henk was not blackmailed to abandon his pursuit for the rights to ''Tetris'', nor did he miss his daughter's recital to secure the rights.
** The Russian government never threatened Henk's wife.
** Apparently, Robert Maxwell wasn't as bad in real life as the film made him out to be. In real life, he was ''even worse''. In fact, while the [[WhiteCollarCrime fraudulent contract]] he offered Nintendo didn't actually happen, Robert Maxwell ''built his empire with these sort of deals''.
** Valentin Trifonov is an original character made specifically for the film, based on all of corrupt officials in the USSR's ranks.
** A minor factual error presented in the ending: Alexey and his family are shown immigrating to San Francisco. They actually immigrated to Seattle.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Film/{{Emily}}'':
** Historians indeed speculate about a romantic connection between William Weightman and one of the Brontë sisters — but with Creator/{{Anne|Bronte}}, not Creator/{{Emily|Bronte}}, as this film portrays.
** The film implies that Creator/CharlotteBronte did not begin writing in earnest until ''Literature/WutheringHeights'' became a hit and Emily died. In reality, ''Literature/JaneEyre'' was published a couple of months before ''Wuthering Heights'' to acclaim.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Truman'', a {{Biopic}} about UsefulNotes/HarrySTruman based off the novel by David [=McCullough=] and starring Creator/GarySinise as the titular president, has a number of notable inaccuracies:

to:

* ''Truman'', ''Film/{{Truman}}'', a {{Biopic}} about UsefulNotes/HarrySTruman based off the novel by David [=McCullough=] and starring Creator/GarySinise as the titular president, has a number of notable inaccuracies:

Added: 56

Changed: 360

Removed: 258

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The Duke of Burgundy is portrayed as stating he doesn't believe in God or the Devil to Joan in front of witnesses. Not only is there no evidence of this (which would be very unlikely in that era) but no one would ever say this ''publicly'' (because anyone who did ran the risk of being convicted of blasphemy).

to:

** The Duke of Burgundy is portrayed as stating he doesn't believe in God or the Devil to Joan in front of witnesses. Not only is there no evidence of this (which would be very unlikely in that era) but no one would ever say this ''publicly'' (because anyone who did ran the risk of being convicted of blasphemy).'
** Joan was described with black hair rather than blond.



* WebVideo/ConfusedMatthew went to great lengths to explain how ''Film/{{Titanic 1997}}'' went beyond Artistic License and outright falsified what happened on the Titanic to make the upperclassmen on the ship as unsympathetic as possible and thus try and make the main characters more sympathetic. His two biggest beefs seem to be: falsely portraying First Officer (third in command of the ship, Chief Officer is 2nd in command) William Murdock as a corrupt individual who took bribes and shot people to ensure certain people spots on the lifeboats, and making up the idea that the ship's crew tried to keep the lower class men down in third class to let them all die.

to:

* WebVideo/ConfusedMatthew went to great lengths to explain how ''Film/{{Titanic 1997}}'' went beyond Artistic License and outright falsified what happened on the Titanic to make the upperclassmen on the ship as unsympathetic as possible and thus try and make the main characters more sympathetic. His two biggest beefs seem to be: falsely portraying 1997}}'': The film inaccurately portrays First Officer (third in command of the ship, Chief Officer is 2nd in command) William Murdock as a corrupt individual who took bribes and shot people to ensure certain people spots on the lifeboats, and making up the idea that lifeboats. Also, the ship's crew tried did not try to keep the lower class men lowerclassmen down in third class to let them all die.



* Many films about Joan of Arc had Joan depicted with different hair color, in the 1999 film, She is depicted as a blonde and has a pixie cut, while other films depict her as a red-head or have brown hair. In reality, Her hair is black and wears it in a bob.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** There's no indication Dick or Lynne encouraged Liz to make a public stand against same-sex marriage which served to alienate her from Mary. Instead, they attempted to reconcile them (Liz later recanted her views on the issue after her very public spat with Mary in 2021, plainly admitting that she had been wrong on the issue).

to:

** There's no indication Dick or Lynne encouraged Liz to make a public stand against same-sex marriage which served to alienate her from Mary. Instead, they attempted to reconcile them (Liz later recanted her views on the issue after her very public spat with Mary in 2021, plainly admitting that she had been wrong on the issue).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** There's no indication Dick or Lynne encouraged Liz to make a public stand against same-sex marriage which served to alienate her from Mary. Instead, they attempted to reconcile them (Liz later recanted her views on the issue after her very public spat with Mary in 2021).

to:

** There's no indication Dick or Lynne encouraged Liz to make a public stand against same-sex marriage which served to alienate her from Mary. Instead, they attempted to reconcile them (Liz later recanted her views on the issue after her very public spat with Mary in 2021).2021, plainly admitting that she had been wrong on the issue).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The opening narration for ''Film/ABridgeTooFar'' goes thusly: "In 1944, the Second World War was in its fifth year and still going Hitler's way. German troops controlled most of Europe. D-Day changed all that." By 1944, the war was quite definitely ''not'' going Hitler's way anymore. A constant barrage of defeats on the Eastern Front and Anglo-American air raids over German cities meant that, by the time D-Day happened, Hitler's defeat was only a matter of time. It was launched to help accelerate the end of the war in Europe. And by this point German troops did not control "most of Europe" (outside of its Axis allies) anymore.

to:

* The opening narration for ''Film/ABridgeTooFar'' goes thusly: "In 1944, the Second World War was in its fifth year and still going Hitler's way. German troops controlled most of Europe. D-Day changed all that." By 1944, the war was quite definitely ''not'' going Hitler's way anymore. A constant barrage of defeats on the Eastern Front and Anglo-American air raids over German cities meant that, by the time D-Day happened, Hitler's defeat was only a matter of time. It was launched to help accelerate the end of the war in Europe. And by this point German troops did not control "most of Europe" (outside of its Axis allies) anymore.anymore, having lost almost all of their territorial gains in the Soviet Union.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Film/AnastasiaOnceUponATime'': Fantasy stuff aside, Tsar UsefulNotes/NicholasII (Creator/BrandonRouth) has no facial hair at all somehow, whereas he had plenty of it in RealLife (a mustache above a beard, no less).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The film implies that Cheney played a significant role in the veto of Congress's attempt to re-instate the Fairness Doctrine, a law from 1949 that forced broadcast radio and TV outlets to present both sides of an issue equally, and it eventually led to the rise of opinion news networks like Creator/FoxNews. In reality, there's no record of Cheney convincing the House to abstain from interfering with the veto, especially given that Cheney wasn't the GOP Whip until 1989. Additionally, the Fairness Doctrine only applied to broadcast television stations and had no authority over cable stations, so Fox News wouldn't have to abide by the doctrine even if it were still a law today.

to:

** The film implies that Cheney played a significant role in the veto of Congress's attempt to re-instate the Fairness Doctrine, a law from 1949 that forced broadcast radio and TV outlets to present both sides of an issue equally, and it eventually led to the rise of opinion news networks like Creator/FoxNews.Fox News. In reality, there's no record of Cheney convincing the House to abstain from interfering with the veto, especially given that Cheney wasn't the GOP Whip until 1989. Additionally, the Fairness Doctrine only applied to broadcast television stations and had no authority over cable stations, so Fox News wouldn't have to abide by the doctrine even if it were still a law today.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Film/{{Transformers}}'' claims that many of the advancements in technology in the 20th century were a result of reverse-engineering [[spoiler:Megatron]], who had been hidden under the Hoover Dam by the US government. The filmmakers include cars in this list of technologies. In reality, [[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Karl_Benz Karl Benz]] (as in Mercedes-Benz) patented the first internal combustion-powered car in ''1895'', thirty years before the Hoover Dam was even thought of.

to:

* ''Film/{{Transformers}}'' ''Film/{{Transformers|2007}}'' claims that many of the advancements in technology in the 20th century were a result of reverse-engineering [[spoiler:Megatron]], who had been hidden under the Hoover Dam by the US government. The filmmakers include cars in this list of technologies. In reality, [[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Karl_Benz Karl Benz]] (as in Mercedes-Benz) patented the first internal combustion-powered car in ''1895'', thirty years before the Hoover Dam was even thought of.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Film/{{The Three Musketeers|2023}}'': The name of D'Artagnan's father is mentioned as being Achille. The RealLife one was named Bertrand de Batz (the real Charles D'Artagnan took his mother's name when he went to Paris).

to:

* ''Film/{{The Three Musketeers|2023}}'': Musketeers|2023}}'' (2023): The name of D'Artagnan's father is mentioned as being Achille. The RealLife one was named Bertrand de Batz (the real Charles D'Artagnan took his mother's name when he went to Paris).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** On the matter of the Nazi book burnings, those all took place around May 10, 1933, not in 1938. Neither UsefulNotes/AdolfHitler nor Heinrich Himmler attended them, they involved the SA and not the SS (nor the military), and the crowds of people burning books were German students and not random citizens of various ages.

to:

** On the matter of the Nazi book burnings, those all took place around May 10, 1933, not in 1938. Neither UsefulNotes/AdolfHitler nor Heinrich Himmler UsefulNotes/HeinrichHimmler attended them, they involved the SA and not the SS (nor the military), and the crowds of people burning books were German students and not random citizens of various ages.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Film/TheManWithTheIronHeart'':
** Heinrich Mueller is presented as a Nazi Party member who joined Heydrich's intelligence agency under Hitler's direct orders. Mueller didn't actually join the party until 1939 and was [[MyCountryRightOrWrong blindly obedient to the state]] instead, suppressing communist movements while also urging the Bavarian government to retaliate against the Nazis before they seized power. Heydrich mainly recruited Mueller because the latter's actions had made him politically vulnerable (and thus, dependent on Heydrich's patronage) and because he saw an advantage to keeping the SS independent of the party.
** While the climaxes of ''Atentát'' (1964), ''Film/OperationDaybreak'' (1975) and ''Film/{{Anthropoid}}'' (2016) were filmed at the [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ss._Cyril_and_Methodius_Cathedral Orthodox church]] where the LastStand of Jozef Gabčík and Jan Kubiš happened, the climax of ''The Man with the Iron Heart'' has been filmed at a different church, and a Catholic one in [[invoked]][[CaliforniaDoubling Budapest]] at that.
** German soldiers being killed during the LastStand at the church, with automatic weapons. The commando had only pistols when the assault happened, and the German force sent to catch/kill them only suffered five lightly wounded.
** The village of Lidice wasn't just burned down by the Germans as reprisals for the death of Heydrich like it is in the film. That village was ''razed to the ground'', erased from existence. Roads leading to it were diverted, the ground was levelled and the cemetery was emptied of its dead and looted.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Sheryl Yoast, daughter of T.C. assistant coach Bill Yoast, was depicted as an only child. She was really the third of Bill's four daughters.

to:

** Sheryl Yoast, daughter of T.C. assistant coach Bill Yoast, was depicted as an only child. She was really the third of Bill's four daughters. Her surviving sisters (Sheryl had died a couple of years before production started) had no problem with this bit of artistic license.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Adam references Sweet Child O' Mine. Appetite For Destruction didn't come out until 1987, and the song itself wasn't released as a single until 1988.

to:

** Adam references Sweet "Sweet Child O' Mine. Appetite For Destruction Mine". ''Appetite for Destruction'' didn't come out until 1987, and the song itself wasn't released as a single until 1988.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In the movie, T.C.'s coach says "We are not like all the other schools in this conference, they're all white. They don't have to worry about race. We do." In reality, every single school T.C. faced had been integrated for several years.

to:

** In the movie, film, T.C.'s head coach Herman Boone says "We are not like all the other schools in this conference, they're all white. They don't have to worry about race. We do." In reality, every single school T.C. faced had been integrated for several years.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Sheryl Yoast, daughter of T.C. head coach Bill Yoast, was depicted as an only child. She was really the third of Bill's four daughters.

to:

** Sheryl Yoast, daughter of T.C. head assistant coach Bill Yoast, was depicted as an only child. She was really the third of Bill's four daughters.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Correction.


** Sheryl Yoast, daughter of T.C. head coach Bill Yoast, was depicted as an only child. She was really the third of Bill's four daughters. Also, the real Sheryl was 9 years old in 1971, too young to have been played by Creator/HaydenPanettiere.

to:

** Sheryl Yoast, daughter of T.C. head coach Bill Yoast, was depicted as an only child. She was really the third of Bill's four daughters. Also, the real Sheryl was 9 years old in 1971, too young to have been played by Creator/HaydenPanettiere.

Added: 2151

Changed: 8

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Remember the Titans has a few.


** The film gives the impression that the American public opinion was against strongly against the Apollo program. While there was a vocal segment of the population who felt it was a waste of money, the majority of the American public was ''in support'' of the mission.

to:

** The film gives the impression that the American public opinion was against strongly against the Apollo program. While there was a vocal segment of the population who felt it was a waste of money, the majority of the American public was ''in support'' of the mission.


Added DiffLines:

* ''Film/RememberTheTitans'':
** T.C. Williams High School in Alexandria, Virginia, whose 1971 football team is the main subject, was depicted as a school that been racially integrated that very year. Alexandria's real-life schools had been integrated in 1959. What ''actually'' happened in 1971 was that Alexandria's school division[[note]]In Virginia, unlike virtually everywhere else in the U.S., public schools are operated by branches of local governments. "School division" is the proper term for the operator of a Virginia public school.[[/note]] partially merged its three high schools. The three previous schools would serve only freshmen and sophomores, while T.C. Williams opened as a single school for all of the city's juniors and seniors.
** The film showed T.C. as winning multiple close games before finishing unbeaten. The real team was indeed unbeaten (13–0), but most of their wins were blowouts, with 9 being shutouts.
** In the movie, T.C.'s coach says "We are not like all the other schools in this conference, they're all white. They don't have to worry about race. We do." In reality, every single school T.C. faced had been integrated for several years.
** The climax of the film is a Virginia state championship game between T.C. and George C. Marshall High of nearby Falls Church, which T.C. won on a fourth-down come-from-behind play at the very end of the game. The T.C.–Marshall matchup did happen in real life, with the same finish, but it was a midseason game. T.C.'s real state championship game was a 27–0 blowout of Andrew Lewis High[[note]]which has since become a middle school[[/note]] of Salem.
** The film depicts T.C.'s star linebacker Gerry Bertier as having suffered a paralyzing injury in a car crash in the days before the state title game. The real Bertier ''was'' paralyzed in a 1971 car crash, but it took place after a post-championship banquet honoring the team.
** Sheryl Yoast, daughter of T.C. head coach Bill Yoast, was depicted as an only child. She was really the third of Bill's four daughters. Also, the real Sheryl was 9 years old in 1971, too young to have been played by Creator/HaydenPanettiere.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The idea that members of kurgan cultures were AlwaysChaoticEvil people who would throw babies into pits for fun is pure Hollywood invention.

to:

** The idea that members of kurgan cultures were AlwaysChaoticEvil people who would throw babies into pits for fun is pure Hollywood invention. Then again, we're hearing this from the mouth of Ramirez, not the Kurgan himself, who may be going off folklore and hearsay.

Added: 351

Changed: 69

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** They also had a sister who fled to the Soviet Union, with her fate being unknown.

to:

** They also had a sister who fled to was killed by the Soviet Union, with her fate being unknown.Nazis, though she isn't mentioned in the film.
** Solly didn't meet Stalin's son until later when he had been established in the German Army. He translated during his interrogation. In fact, his job was not only as a regular soldier there, but a translator as he'd learned fluent Russian from his time in the Komsomol orphanage. After the war, he worked briefly as a translator for the Soviets too.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Film/DaysOfBetrayal'': Owing to the fact that the film was made in {{Comm|ie Land}}unist [[UsefulNotes/CzechRepublic Czecho]]UsefulNotes/{{slovakia}}, the Communist Party of Czechoslovakia (''Komunistická strana Československa'', KSČ) is presented as pretty much the only faction defending the nation when UsefulNotes/NaziGermany starts occupying it, while this was far from being the truth. Likewise, the Czech bourgeoisie is presented as pretty much LesCollaborateurs.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* For [[ConspiracyTheorist the standards]] of [[Creator/OliverStone its director]], the reconstruction of the first phases of UsefulNotes/TheSalvadoranCivilWar in ''Film/{{Salvador}}'' is remarkably accurate and the film has been even praised by the US Ambassador in the country at the time for having captured well the chaotic situation. However, it still takes some liberties. In particular, its depiction of the assassination of Archbishop Oscar Romero is quite inaccurate.

Top