Follow TV Tropes

Following

History AlternativeCharacterInterpretation / Videogames

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Rather unlikely actually, as evidence points to Tromell and the other Guado actually WANTING to be annihilated by the Ronso. Especially if you actually let it happen, the Guado are strangely are peace...even if they have suffered Genocide and there are no Fiends made from them as they actually willingly go to the Farplane. They must of REALLY wanted to Atone for the horrible stuff they did in FFX to go "that" way.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** One of the reasons Orgrim is up to so may interpretations is the number of retcons relating to him; originally he decieved and ambushed Lothar(greatest human hero ever); later this was retconned into killing him in an honorable, on on one fight-- something a lot of people didn't like. Also, he was known among the orcs as "The Backstabber" for usurping the posistion of warchief from Blackhand. A lot of people took this to mean he literally stabbed Blackhand in the back in a cowardly assassination attempt; it was never clearly stated in the original lore and was someone in line with his behavior, like ambushing Lothar. It was later explained that he killed Blackhand in a fair fight-- he was called the backstabber because Blackhand was [[VillianWithGoodPublicity popular]]. From there, Orgrim was mainly doing what was best for the orcs even if it meant wiping out the humans.

to:

*** One of the reasons Orgrim is up to so may interpretations is the number of retcons relating to him; originally he decieved and ambushed Lothar(greatest human hero ever); later this was retconned into killing him in an honorable, on on one fight-- something a lot of people didn't like. Also, he was known among the orcs as "The Backstabber" for usurping the posistion of warchief from Blackhand. A lot of people took this to mean he literally stabbed Blackhand in the back in a cowardly assassination attempt; it was never clearly stated in the original lore and was someone in line with his behavior, like ambushing Lothar. It was later explained that he killed Blackhand in a fair fight-- he was called the backstabber because Blackhand was [[VillianWithGoodPublicity [[VillainWithGoodPublicity popular]]. From there, Orgrim was mainly doing what was best for the orcs even if it meant wiping out the humans.

Added: 1360

Changed: 1173

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
lessening the wall of text effect and adding ACI for Rhyme


* ''TheWorldEndsWithYou'' (or It's A Wonderful World) has many of the characters being easily able to be Alternatively Characterized, and in fact has an extra chapter where it does basically just that, expanding on many of the traits already visible in the main story, such as Joshua's ambiguously gayness having the ambiguous part taken out. This can even be further alternatively characterized as him simply messing with Neku, and in fact being straight. Shiki is either cheerful and positive because she's pretending to be more like Eri, or because that's how she is, but she's too shy and unconfident to show it. Neku either genuinely hates people, or can't bear to be close to them, afraid he'll get hurt. The second seems more likely though given what the top of Pork Tower reveals. He could also be afraid that he'll hurt them, indirectly. Does Neku have a romantic interest in Shiki, or is it simply the first person he's opened up to that she becomes [[spoiler: his fee for the second week]]? Is Beat so stupid he doesn't notice what's going on, or is he so driven by his goals he doesn't notice? Kariya is either too lazy to get promoted, or he enjoys Uzuki's company so much he doesn't want to leave their partnership. Is Joshua a SmugSnake, MagnificentBastard who [[spoiler: enjoys forcing people to play games and in fact knew he wouldn't destroy Shibuya from the first day, or was he inspired by Neku's refusal to shoot him?]]

to:

* ''TheWorldEndsWithYou'' (or It's A Wonderful World) has many of the characters being easily able to be Alternatively Characterized, and in fact has an extra chapter where it does basically just that, expanding on many of the traits already visible in the main story, such as story.
**
Joshua's ambiguously gayness {{ambiguously gay}}ness, having the ambiguous part taken out. This can even be further alternatively characterized as him simply messing with Neku, and in fact being straight. straight.
*** In the end, was Joshua a SmugSnake, MagnificentBastard who [[spoiler:enjoyed forcing people to play games and in fact knew he wouldn't destroy Shibuya from the first day]], or was he [[spoiler:inspired by Neku's refusal to shoot him]]?
**
Shiki is either cheerful and positive because she's pretending to be more like Eri, or because that's how she is, but she's too shy and unconfident to show it. it.
**
Neku either genuinely hates people, or can't bear to be close to them, afraid he'll get hurt. The hurt (the second seems more likely though likely, though, given what the top of Pork Tower reveals. City reveals). He could also be afraid that he'll hurt them, indirectly. indirectly.
***
Does Neku have a romantic interest in Shiki, or is it simply the first person he's opened up to that she becomes [[spoiler: his [[spoiler:his fee for the second week]]? week]]?
**
Is Beat so stupid he doesn't notice what's going on, or is he so driven by his goals he doesn't notice? notice?
**
Kariya is either too lazy to get promoted, or he enjoys Uzuki's company so much he doesn't want to leave their partnership. partnership.
** Another Day does a number on Rhyme.
Is Joshua she a SmugSnake, MagnificentBastard who [[spoiler: enjoys forcing people genuinely pure, wise little girl, or is that just a façade to play games and in fact knew he wouldn't destroy Shibuya from the first day, or was he inspired by Neku's refusal to shoot him?]] obscure her cruel, manipulative nature?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Is everybody forgetting the Blot? In several continuities he's just a crook who aspires world domination ([[VillainDecay or has daddy issues and]] [[{{Discontinuity}} tried to become the Phantom Rainbow]]), in Epic Mickey, he's an EldritchAbomination made of Ink and Thinner, with the possible goal of erasing everything.

to:

** Is everybody forgetting the Blot? In several continuities he's just a crook who aspires world domination ([[VillainDecay or has daddy issues and]] [[{{Discontinuity}} tried to become the Phantom Rainbow]]), domination, but in Epic Mickey, he's an EldritchAbomination made of Ink and Thinner, with the possible goal of erasing everything.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Though that would involve [[spoiler:the creater of the world, Li-Grim, lying to you when she admits that the dream world is "an illusion".]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Because after final fantasy this troper has seen Cloud go from awesome to whiny emo bitch. Also What rivalry between Aerith and Tifa? From what this troper recalls they hit it off just fine and there was no malice.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

***[[FantasticRacism Elves don't count]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** They didn't. At all. Not even one of them.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

**** Picky, who's fairly nice to Ness in the ending and actually tries to fight, could indicate that there's something more to Pokey besides his home life that resulted in him turning out the way he did, or perhaps something happened to Pokey that turned him into a jerk. As for Lardna, she appears to have another man in her life in the ending, with no mention as to where Aloysius went, so it could indicate that either she's unfaithful or that she was never happy with the marriage.


Added DiffLines:

*** Interestingly enough, Rufus states that his father chose to control the world with money, giving people jobs and the protection of the Shinra army, but that he prefers to do it by fear.


Added DiffLines:

** In the sequel, does Tromell really regret what Seymour did in the Guado's name and what he himself allowed to happen by preventing Yuna from sending him and destroying the evidence that he killed his father, or is he mainly taking on his [[TheAtoner Atoner]] stance out of fear that the Ronso will annihilate the Guado?


Added DiffLines:

*** During the mission where [[spoiler:Marche's clan fights Ritz's clan]], Ritz admits that games have to end at some point, but she isn't ready to end it yet. Perhaps if Marche had waited until after Ritz came to terms with he issues since it only takes [[spoiler:Shara telling her that white hair is special and that her mother was sad only because she was sad]] for her to do so, she might have stood aside without a fight or helped him.


Added DiffLines:

*** She also becomes increasingly ruthless in Cataclysm, [[spoiler:raising undead for the Horde and using the same New Plague that was used at the Wrathgate]]. One interpretation is that having accomplished her goal of revenge against the Lich King, she has lost sight of all other goals she once had. Another is that the incident and the Horde bailing her out solidified her loyalty to the Horde and that she's trying to help them against the Alliance while refusing to accept that they don't like the assistance that they're getting.


Added DiffLines:

*** Interestingly enough, if you finish the All Stars version of Super Mario Brothers while small Mario, you will receive a Super Mushroom and grow to Super Mario. Whether that means that Mario was always supposed to be at Princess Peach's height or was given it so he could grow to her size is less clear, though, although this would suggest the former.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Geez video game bosses, if you cared so much about your troops, [[MoralMyopia why'd you send them to invade another country for conquest, or to kidnap a princess, or slaughter space liners passengers to steal their stuff, or to try an take over the world...]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Claude of ''GrandTheftAutoIII'' has this, due to his HeroicMime status. Is he motivated by revenge against Catalina? Against anyone who betrays him? Is he merely a PunchClockVillian who takes all these jobs for money? Power? [[BloodKnight Blood lust?]] On a smaller scale: Did Claude actually [[spoiler: shoot Maria]] or did he merely [[spoiler: fire into the air to shut her up?]]
** CJ from ''GrandTheftAutoSanAndreas'' is a divisive chararacter, due to his more {{anti hero}}ic attributes. Some view him as an ultimately good person who has to do bad things to help the people he loves. Others view him as just as much a monster as every other GTA protagonist.

to:

* Claude of ''GrandTheftAutoIII'' has this, due to his HeroicMime status. Is he motivated by revenge against Catalina? Against anyone who betrays him? Is he merely a PunchClockVillian PunchClockVillain who takes all these jobs for money? Power? [[BloodKnight Blood lust?]] Some combination of the above? On a smaller scale: Did Claude actually [[spoiler: shoot Maria]] or did he merely [[spoiler: fire into the air to shut her up?]]
** CJ from ''GrandTheftAutoSanAndreas'' is a divisive chararacter, character, due to his more {{anti hero}}ic attributes. Some view him as an ultimately good person who has to do bad things to help the people he loves. Others view him as just as much a monster as every other GTA protagonist.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Third interpretation: a completely normal person with DeadpanSnarker tendencies, put through trauma and under stress, which brings out the more negative aspects of his personality. [[TruthInTelevision Likelier thank you'd believe.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** As I said, how can blond hair and blue eyes be considered Mary Sue traits?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** You could say that Tidus and Yuna are equally important. Without Tidus,the spiral of death would have continued without interruption, but he would have no motive to find an alternate method of defeating Sin without his love for Yuna.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Nova she maybe one of Mengsk loyal assasins, or just someone who was brainwashed into serving the Dominion. [[spoiler: With the ghost programing which includes Mindwipe as part of its training, she may not know who exactly she's working for.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Orgrim was one of the notable few who [[spoiler: didn't drink from the chalice which turned most of the orcs into demon-like brutes]]. He's also the PlayerCharacter SoYeah. HumansAreBastards or HumansAreSpecial.

to:

*** Orgrim was one of the notable few who [[spoiler: didn't drink from the chalice which turned most of the orcs into demon-like brutes]]. He's also the PlayerCharacter SoYeah.PlayerCharacter. HumansAreBastards or HumansAreSpecial.



*** Also, she's not really displacing creatures. It's not as if she ended up bringing the Sheegoth from Phendrana Drifts to Aether, they just moved into different rooms that are exactly the same as the rooms they were previously in with no help from Samus. Hell, the Chozo Ghosts are friggin ghosts, they can walk through walls (plus, most of the rooms on the 1st floor of the ruins don't have roofs, SoYeah).

to:

*** Also, she's not really displacing creatures. It's not as if she ended up bringing the Sheegoth from Phendrana Drifts to Aether, they just moved into different rooms that are exactly the same as the rooms they were previously in with no help from Samus. Hell, the Chozo Ghosts are friggin ghosts, they can walk through walls (plus, most of the rooms on the 1st floor of the ruins don't have roofs, SoYeah).roofs).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Aryan profile, the ChosenOne, adored by all, friend to all living things, of divine parentage? She's about as close as you can get to a Purity Sue during the intro as you can get.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Oops, did the markup wrong. Fixed the entry above too.


* "[[Portal And when you're dead I will be still alive]]". Threat of a future murder attempt, or lamentation of immortality?
* [[Marathon]]: Considering that the Marathon trilogy has far more {{Fanon}} than actual {{Canon}}, there's plenty of room for interpretation. Is [[MissionControl Durandal]] a self-centered psychopathic [[AIIsACrapshoot computer]] saving the colony ship and universe just because he's in it, or {{The Atoner}} trying to make up for what he did under Strauss's control (and possibly even before he was known as Durandal)?

to:

* "[[Portal And {{Portal}} "And when you're dead I will be still alive]]".alive". Threat of a future murder attempt, or lamentation of immortality?
* [[Marathon]]: {{Marathon}}: Considering that the Marathon trilogy has far more {{Fanon}} than actual {{Canon}}, there's plenty of room for interpretation. Is [[MissionControl Durandal]] a self-centered psychopathic [[AIIsACrapshoot computer]] saving the colony ship and universe just because he's in it, or {{The Atoner}} trying to make up for what he did under Strauss's control (and possibly even before he was known as Durandal)?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added Marathon



to:

*[[Marathon]]: Considering that the Marathon trilogy has far more {{Fanon}} than actual {{Canon}}, there's plenty of room for interpretation. Is [[MissionControl Durandal]] a self-centered psychopathic [[AIIsACrapshoot computer]] saving the colony ship and universe just because he's in it, or {{The Atoner}} trying to make up for what he did under Strauss's control (and possibly even before he was known as Durandal)?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
I'm rewriting this part.


*** Yeah, but the first game they were trying to exterminate the humans. The Repliforce incident, not so much... ''but'' their refusal to even so much as negotiate after the Sky Lagoon incident suggests their [[HonorBeforeReason pride]] helped sabotage an already volatile incident. Plus, they're an army and they seemed to have been disobeying orders. Any government would be scared if one of their best armies refused reasonable orders to come in for questioning because they were implicated in a major atrocity, and belong to a population well known for going murderously berserk. Declaring them Maverick wasn't exactly done on a whim.

to:

*** Yeah, but the first game they were trying to exterminate the humans. The Repliforce incident, not so much... ''but'' their refusal to even so much as negotiate after the Sky Lagoon incident suggests their [[HonorBeforeReason pride]] helped sabotage an already volatile incident. Plus, **** Alternatively alternatively, they're an army answerable to the world governments, and therefore they seemed to have been disobeying orders. Any government would be scared if one of their best armies refused reasonable agreed to obey orders unless they were needlessly suicidal or would involve doing the kinds of things they were framed for. Throw in the parts where their troops and their equipment were seen at the scene of an atrocity, and their steadfast refusal to come in for questioning because so they were implicated in could potentially clear themselves came not from the worry that they'll be scapegoated but rather a major atrocity, glorified mechanical pissing contest (which would look really suspicious), and belong to a population well known for going murderously berserk. Declaring them Maverick wasn't exactly done on a whim.it becomes less "overzealous bastards who couldn't stand the thought of robots not obeying orders" and more "panicked but justifiable reaction".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

***[[spoiler: "I will not be stop not by you, by the confederacy, or the protoss or anyone! I will rule this sector or see burn to asses around me!]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** As for Dahlia herself, even though she's usually seen as a plain CompleteMonster, there are a few people who think that she has a FreudianExcuse. In-Universe, her sister is among those people.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* The other main Ace Attorney bone of contention is whether Terry Fawles had special needs\mental issues or not. If he does, then it makes Dahlia even more evil for manipulating him, as he wouldn't have understood that being in love with a 14-year old is squicky. If he doesn't, then many fans would lose sympathy for him completely.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** [[WhamEpisode The Protoss mini-campaign in Wings of Liberty]] gave a huge one to the [[HiveMind Overmind]]. [[spoiler: Apparently it infested Kerrigan so that the Zerg could gain independence and stand a chance against the [[BiggerBad Dark Voice]] and its hybrid armies.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** And from the same game we have [[TheGambler Setzer]]. Happy-go-lucky thrill seeker who JumpedAtTheCall just for the kicks, or world-weary nihilist who, after his DespairEventHorizon, simply [[DeathSeeker didn't care whether he lived or died]]? Your call.
--> '''[[LoveableRogue Locke]]''': I can't believe this [[GlobalAirship clunky old thing]] can fly... You sure it'll stay in the air?\\
'''Setzer''': When things fall, they fall... Life's a game of chance. You play your cards, and Fate plays hers...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Still wrong


*[[Portal "And when you're dead I will be still alive"]]. Threat of a future murder attempt, or lamentation of immortality?

to:

*[[Portal "And *"[[Portal And when you're dead I will be still alive"]].alive]]". Threat of a future murder attempt, or lamentation of immortality?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Third fix. I suck at this.


[[Portal "And when you're dead I will be still alive"]]. Threat of a future murder attempt, or lamentation of immortality?

to:

[[Portal *[[Portal "And when you're dead I will be still alive"]]. Threat of a future murder attempt, or lamentation of immortality?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
More fixing and new example


*** The canonical Manga shows that her parents and home colony was destroyed by the Space Pirates. And the Chozo raised her to be a force for good.

to:

*** The canonical Manga shows that [[FreudianExcuse her parents and home colony was destroyed by the Space Pirates.Pirates]]. And the Chozo raised her to be a force for good.




to:

[[Portal "And when you're dead I will be still alive"]]. Threat of a future murder attempt, or lamentation of immortality?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Mistake correction


*** The canonical Manga shows that [[Freudian excuse her parents and home colony was destroyed by the Space Pirates.]] And the Chozo raised her to be a force for good.

to:

*** The canonical Manga shows that [[Freudian excuse her parents and home colony was destroyed by the Space Pirates.]] Pirates. And the Chozo raised her to be a force for good.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
My own two cents

Added DiffLines:

*** The canonical Manga shows that [[Freudian excuse her parents and home colony was destroyed by the Space Pirates.]] And the Chozo raised her to be a force for good.

Top