Archived Discussion

This is discussion archived from a time before the current discussion method was installed.

Working Title: Superlative Dubbing: From YKTTW

Voodoo Master: As a sub-lover, it's not like I'm going to make fun of a dub for being a dub. I just prefer to watch subtitled works, for the most part. Calling me a Japanophile maniac who can't accept that people have different opinions seems to be... a bit immature.

It's not that I dislike this page; everyone putting dubs here seems decent. Whoever wrote the introduction, however, needs to calm down. Would you like it if I made a Superlative Subbing page and then inundated the beginning with "Those foreign bastards, too stupid and closed-minded to read text on a screen! Changing our beloved Japanese voice actors! This subtitling job'll show them just how wrong they are!"? No. It would be dickish.

Charred Knight: Unless your the type of person who hasn't watched a dub in 5 years and still claims that no dub can match the Japanese version the page isn't making fun of you. The problem is that I have seen a lot of people whose only experience with Dubs are by those by 4kids who take the awful dub quality of their work and thinks that all dubs are like that.
http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/archived_discussion.php?s_t=SugarWiki.SuperlativeDubbing