TV Tropes Org
site search
GI Joe The Riseof Cobra back to reviews
Comments
G.I Joe, how does it compare to Transformers?
Its better!

Im not a Joe fan, not one bit, yet Rise of Cobra is simply better. The plot, while silly, is more coherent. The action is interresting, unlike Transformers, where the robots looked like gray blurrs half the time. Fortunately they corrected that in the sequel.

The main difference between these films is that Rise of Cobra doesnt take itself very seriously. Its cheesy, hammy and its aware of it. Transformers had mood whiplash and could never quite decide if it wanted to be a kick-ass action film or a retarded immature comedy. It was dumb and obnoxious. I mean, seriously...masturbation jokes? Robo-testicles?

Another weak spot of transformers where the characters. Shia sucked, Megan was wooden and the robots barely talked (except Optimus, who was top-notch). I know giant CGI robots aren't exactly actors, but could they atleast have some dialogue. The average Decepticon line was "AAAHHRRRRRRRGGLLLLGGLLL!" Destro, Doctor, Baroness, Storm Shadow, Zartan where much more memorable because they where given some spotlight. Overall, GI Joe used the villains much more effectively.

I can't say for sure if Rise of Cobra is closer to its source material, but im going to take a guess and say it felt like a GI Joe movie. One last thing: Is it me or was this movie LESS patriotic than Transformers? Ironic for a toyline with the "Real American Hero" tagline.

I say watch GI Joe, bring some pop-corn and enjoy the cheese!
This review would be better if it didn't spend more than half the time bitching about another movie.
comment #5049 Zaptech 5th Nov 10
I found the movie to be fun. They didn't shoot the action in the awful manner of the Bay movies or with shaky cam and they filled it with cool and interesting weaponry. I've never liked Joseph Godron-Levitt and in this movie he plays a real ridiculous villain, who didn't deserve to be the mastermind when matched up to the awesome Christopher Eccleston. The actress playing Scarlett was a bit annoying, as was the Wayan brother. Tatum is all muscle and nothing else. The good villain lineup and Snake Eyes make the movie worth a watch though.
comment #6828 shinfernape 15th Mar 11
You mean the FANTASTIC Christopher Eccleston.
comment #6834 callsignecho 15th Mar 11
I'm not familiar with the source material. This type of movie isn't usually my thing, but I found it a reasonably entertaining (if rather light-weight) use of the viewing time.
comment #8266 Seanette 24th Jun 11
In order to post comments, you need to Get Known
TV Tropes by TV Tropes Foundation, LLC is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported License.
Permissions beyond the scope of this license may be available from thestaff@tvtropes.org.
Privacy Policy