half great, the other half, not so.
The first half of this movie, a mockumentary with big dollops of social satire on the side, is excellent. I also liked the body horror elements, which worked extremely well. My hope was that our protagonist would slowly realise the suffering of the "prawn" who hurt just as much as humans, but would be ultimately powerless to stop the banality of evil. Instead, the film becomes reliant on stock devices and overused action tropes. The most appalling was the absurd
General Ripper Colonel, a character who was such a two dimensional asshole, it was numbingly obviously that he was going to end up with a spectacular karmic death. That's why I didn't really care when he did. The film did its action extremely well, and even with a comparatively tiny budget, this film somehow managed to make mecha fighting that far surpasses that of
Transformers. But saying that, the action just seemed out of place in the context of the movie.
The problem was that the movie proposed a simple solution to save all the aliens in one go, which jarred with the anti-apartheid theme. There was no easy escape from real life apartheid, so I found this ending bittersweet. Ultimately, I wanted there to be a downer ending which more accurately reflected the hopelessness of it all, like in the apartheid in novel
A dry White Season, and not some "happy" ending with heroes rising for freedom and slaughtering all the evil baddies like
Braveheart.
i thought the ending was pretty sad... only two of the aliens manage to run away, with only the promise of coming back 3 years later to save the rest (we never see if they do), and the protagonist ends up completing the transformation to an alien... and the aliens are still locked up
comment #979
kuroyume
13th Sep 09
Seriously. The movie had a downer ending. Did you walk out right at the end of the climactic battle or something? There's a spark of hope, sure, but... it isn't as you say it is.
comment #990
Dracomicron
14th Sep 09
comment #1009
Dick Richardson
17th Sep 09
comment #1012
maninahat
17th Sep 09
I try not to judge a movie by its as-of-yet-unmade theoretical potential sequel.
comment #1013
Dracomicron
17th Sep 09
Neither do I. My point was that the "glimmer of hope" might as well be the brilliant beacon of likelyhood, and that we haven't seen a genuinely sad ending to the plot unless a sequel is made in which the whole "glimmer of hope" (a potential cosmic get-out-of-jail-free-card for the aliens) is completely shot down.
comment #1014
maninahat
17th Sep 09
I'm just saying that, in classic space opera terms, they skipped A New Hope and went straight to Empire Strikes Back. I don't consider this to be a bad thing.
comment #1015
Dracomicron
17th Sep 09
Now, if you had seen it before tvtropes ruined your life, would you have liked it better?
comment #1398
alcatrazz
29th Nov 09
Is it a spark of hope or a downer ending if the aliens come back and bomb the hell out of earth?
comment #1408
174.21.37.104
1st Dec 09
Ohh gawd, the action, was so well choreographed, blah blah budget. I can NOT wait for the aliens to come back and bomb the hell out of earth. Downer ending? maybe, greatest alien invasion story ever? YES
comment #1410
59.154.24.147
2nd Dec 09
Why does it even have to have a sad ending to be good? Is true art really angsty?
comment #1623
76.184.250.63
7th Jan 10
comment #1786
Skaterpen
1st Feb 10
comment #12537
maninahat
27th Jan 12
(edited by: maninahat)
I'm sorry, I can't stop laughing.
comment #12540
VeryMelon
27th Jan 12
comment #15490
OrKuunArQenByundis
23rd Jul 12
We see these sorts of movies done quite a lot: Braveheart and Avatar are also action movies based around real world events. But they get away with having implausible, ludicrous, exciting action because they pick less familiar events from far in the past, and they make the subject generic enough to not grate with the historical reality. District 9 makes the dual mistake of being based on a fairly recent event, and being a little too on the nose in its setting. If you make a film that way, you tend to need more sober, sensitive introspection, and fewer big launching robots.
comment #15493
maninahat
23rd Jul 12
comment #19446
Ryuhza
20th May 13
The spark of hope thing is that "some time someone might be able to come back," not "the magic macguffin survived." The one person who could save the prawns is a liar who will do whatever it takes to get home (remember how he promised to cure Wikus only to leave him behind). This is a very iffy thing. It would be wrong to ignore the possibility that something might get better. As for the actionized finale, yeah it looks all action-y but we see by the end, the whistleblowers are in jail, and the aliens are still stuck in a slum. To be blunt, all the fighting against the bad guys was for a big colossal "maybe" that has not done much in the following years.
comment #19451
fenrisulfur
20th May 13
In order to post comments, you need to
Get Known