Inglourious Basterds back to reviews
Comments
Not glorious at all
So from the start, I had a feeling it would be some kind of western — the music in the beginning reminded me of Ennio Morricone — and I had also read about it being Tarantino's big epic Spaghetti Western — but I had forgotten up until I was reminded by the score. As i watched the opening scene, I was constantly thinking "This is a lot like Sergio Leone's films". The almost casual dialogue (Tarantino at his best) between Landa and the french farmer helped to build the tension in the scene. Like any good Spaghetti Western, there is a lot of scene setting. There are long stretches of film where nothing (in the action sense) happens punctuated by short bursts of horrific violence. And the violence was horrific. Characters are introduced only to be shortly killed thereafter. A memorable scene that stands out for me is when a few of the Basterds are in a bar where several Germans are having a drink and there is a short mexican standoff that ends with everyone (except for a movie star) getting gunned down.

I'm not sure what Tarantino was trying to do with this movie. It definitely wasn't an antiwar movie; I don't think it's supposed to really be about anything. It's just a story that he wanted to tell. You can't root for the Americans. In my opinion, they are just as bad as the Nazis they're scalping — i would go so far as to say that there are two villains in the movie: Aldo and Landa. The scene that really got to me was the forest scalping where the German troop leader didn't want to expose his men to the horrors of the Basterds and chose to die by bat.

I'm not sure how I feel about the movie. What did surprise me was the ending. I had no idea it was an alternate history story. That was pretty cool. I like it when the heroes go out in an explosion.

I recommend it, but I don't think I'll be watching it again.
"the music in the beginning reminded me of Ennio Morricone"

That's because it was Ennio Morricone.
JCaesar 22nd Aug 09
oh yea i looked it up after writing the review. i guess it turns out a few of the songs were by ennio morricone excellent composer. my favorite of his is still "Man with the Harmonica"
guan 22nd Aug 09 (edited by: guan)
"You can't root for the Americans. In my opinion, they are just as bad as the Nazis they're scalping — i would go so far as to say that there are two villains in the movie: Aldo and Landa."

What did you expect? The protagonists of the movie are the inglourious basterds, not some clean glorious or magnificent heros.
Grand Prince Paul II. 24th Aug 09 (edited by: Grand Prince Paul II.)
No, you can root for the Americans. Because the people they are scalping are Nazis. If they were scalping JEWS I would agree.
67.124.88.79 1st Sep 09
The title of your review made me think you didn't like the movie, but after reading it, I understood why. I couldn't find myself rooting for the Americans either, but I don't thnk that's a bad thing, I mean, this is Tarantino, I'm not used to root for his main characters even when they are killing notable bad guys like the Nazis. Anyway, I agree with most of the stuff you said but I would watch this movie again.
Radlum 19th Oct 09
This movie is so immature. When you're first learn of the Holocaust, and you're say, 12, and you're a Jew, Romani or a Slav, you wish that you could have superpowers, torture the Germans and kill Hitler.

The movie is about two hours of blatant wish-fulfillment.
Erpegis 2nd Nov 09
Epergis: Your point being? Movies are all about wish fulfillment. That's what they do.
Dracomicron 4th Nov 09
back to reviews
Add a comment