Back to Reviews

Reviews Comments: The Yin of Earthsong Earthsong whole series review by Pink Ranger V

Earthsong is, at the time of writing, unfinished. However, its most unique quality shines through from the first page: Someone has written a comic for girls and about girls. Of course, there are predecessors (Meridian springs to mind), but Earthsong is the best I have read so far, for many reasons.

The first is that elusive quality of writing, energy. When one takes the symbols, settings, backstory, politics, laws of physics, and other differences, one finds the energy of a work. For Eragon, this is high, masculine fantasy; for Meridian, a teen girl's fantasy adventure; for Earthsong, a feminine fairytale. The story is set in a world that is lush, verdant, and filled with subtle colors and stone worlds. Its colors are mainly dark green, dark red, and dark purple. Its characters are not only female, they range from capable superheroes to shy, timid teenagers, with everything inbetween. The few masculine characters and symbols it does carry are sensitive, inventive ones, such as a demon bookworm or cowardly vampire.

The universe itself, as seen apart from the characters, is also a very feminine one. Sentient worlds that nurture and provide; shades of gray that are not always seen by every character; moral complexity and the sheer laziness of even planets. Subtle understanding of human nature is a feminine characteristic; it shines through here, in vivid detail.

The characters are the most obvious female trait, of course. At first glance, an average comic-reading male would assume shy, timid Willow is the main character; girls are either dumb babes or warrior babes in his world. However, it slowly becomes apparent that Willow is, in fact, a secondary character; this story belongs to Nanashi and the guard she leads. The women here are prominently featured, but have many different types of personality, anywhere from hyperactivity to strength to shyness. All find a place on the team, and all have a role in protecting their world and the people who have soulstones. The few male characters, even the main villain, are complex, thoughtful, and thought-provoking, instead of bash-and-smash 'heroes'.

Earthsong is, overall, a very unique work, and one of the best comics for girls out there. In many ways, it is the Eve of a genre, and I can't wait to see what else it'll come up with.


  • TomWithNoNumbers
  • 6th Feb 13
I agree it's brilliant, but (apart from the recent fashion obssession =D), I don't feel it's that particularly girl focused, at least it's just as fun for guys to read too, I wouldn't have picked up on much of any gender overtones really, except for the largely female cast.

And there are quite a lot of excellent webcomics out there by female authors, I wouldn't be surprised if it was close to a 50/50 split. In fantasy some of the notable webcomics are Juathuur by Katie Sweet *, Unsounded by Ashley Cope, Gaia (although only the artist is female there), Inverloch by Sarah Ellerton, Darken by Kate Ashwin.

...actually that's most of my favourites. Hmmm
  • Aroree
  • 9th Jun 14
This was a compelling review, but I just have to say, Willow IS the main character; she always was. Just because the webcomic focused on Nanashi sometimes did not make the comic focus on her. Especially after Willow's true identity is revealed. This was a nice, fish-out-of-water story, and Willow grew and matured, and discovered powers she never knew she had. She also saves the day. Nanashi is a secondary protagonist, I'll give her that.

Also, there are a lot of female authored webcomics. Such as, 'DMFA' by Amber, 'Miamaska' and 'Trial of the Sun' by Jeinu, 'Blindsprings' by Kadi Fedoruk, 'Candi' by Starline Hodge, 'Cucumber Quest' by Gigi Digi, 'Fragile' by Shouri, and so many more.

In order to post comments, you need to

Get Known