Self Demonstrating THEJOKER Discussion

Collapse/Expand Topics
 

maxwellsilver
Topic
04:12:04 AM Dec 27th 2015
Why is the Comic Book page a redirect? I think it would work better if it were a separate page.
Larkmarn
06:48:25 AM Dec 28th 2015
It would. But unless someone actually makes the page, it's better to have the redirect rather than nothing.
maxwellsilver
06:21:14 PM Jan 15th 2016
Page is made.
DrNoPuma
Topic
03:19:31 PM May 4th 2015
edited by DrNoPuma
I have a question. When I last edited the page, I added a section under Evil Laugh that goes like this: "If you're itching for more (you know you are), then try watching this. Or this." Each "this" contained a link to a Youtube video of Mr. J laughing.

Now, here's the question. I was originally going to add a third "Or this" that links to Rick Astley's "Never Gonna Give You Up". I thought it would be funny, and it seemed like something the Joker would do, but I was worried that if I did it, people would think I was being a troll. What do you think? Should we add that last "Or this", or just leave it out?
n00b4liciou5
Topic
08:23:20 PM Oct 12th 2014
Which Joker voice should this article be read in? I prefer Mark Hamill's...
jboone93
08:48:12 PM Oct 12th 2014
I would agree with Hamill. Personally think the order is Hamill, Nicholson, Ledger.
Eiliyan
Topic
07:48:57 AM Apr 25th 2013
This page doesn't read like the Joker to me. It comes off as really...well, amateurish for lack of a better word. Someone who had heard of the Joker but never actually read anything about him, imitating a wild cheese monkey violence style. Eh.
lego_joker
10:21:07 AM Jun 22nd 2013
Confession: I wrote this page (well, half of the description - the other half, and almost all of the tropes, were added by various other Tropers) back in my early days of fandom. Back then, I was already a huge fan of the J-man, but my fanfic skills, to put it lightly, sucked donkey balls.

Later on, I tried writing a more restrained version of this article, while keeping the same Self-Demonstrating spirit, but was overwhelmingly outvoted by my fellow Tropers.
Kadavro
10:54:09 AM Feb 4th 2014
To keep this? you mean? I do think we should have a second article so that we can learn the little factoids we couldn't otherwise. I for one do not think I would ever add anything here if I thought I had to cackle all the way through.
maxwellsilver
04:46:02 PM Jan 16th 2016
Done. The Comic Book page is now up.

The subpages need to be cleaned up considerably, though. The first person is supposed to stay on the self demonstrating page.
captainmarkle
Topic
10:40:38 AM Oct 8th 2012
WHY OH WHY DID THIS GET CHANGED TO SELF DEMONSTRATING?

The entire YMMV page has been wiped, with all CMOA, CMOH and CMOF pages wiped. What the hell.
ryanasaurus0077
11:36:53 AM Oct 8th 2012
edited by ryanasaurus0077
They weren't wiped. The tabs just weren't compatible with the new namespace.
captainmarkle
02:27:28 PM Dec 22nd 2012
edited by captainmarkle
  • comment removed by OP owing to stupidity. Apologies to all*
Tropethorn
Topic
06:35:06 AM Aug 8th 2012
I personally think this first person POV format impedes the information relay aspect of the page.
Eagal
07:02:22 PM Sep 6th 2012
I concur but aint nothing that can be done about it.
MarkLungo
02:29:07 PM Dec 27th 2012
You could always start an objective, factual page on the Joker.
maxwellsilver
04:46:34 PM Jan 16th 2016
Done. See The Joker.
Collapse/Expand Topics
http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/remarks.php?trope=SelfDemonstrating.THEJOKER