Main Uncanny Valley Discussion

Collapse/Expand Topics

04:44:35 PM Oct 9th 2015
There's just something about the Sparkle Fairy's obviously CG wings that I find off-putting...
08:30:53 AM Dec 8th 2014
Lots of clean up needed. People seem to think this trope means "something I find creepy". Too many examples are of things aren't meant to be realistic at all or things that just plain don't make sense.
08:25:51 AM Aug 31st 2014
Rewrote the gaming paragraph because it ran off on a tangent about Eastern and Western gaming and generation gaps without actually coming back around to how this trope actually applies. I refocused it specifically on unique issues to the gaming medium when attempting to create more realistic graphics without actually passing judgement on the quality of the games themselves.
11:03:46 PM Oct 26th 2015
Yeah the generation gap was the REASON for the uncanny valley, so I don't know why you had to change that to something that amounts to a rambling that makes zero points. There were hotlinks to examples that are common in fandoms as well. So yeah, good going.
08:25:55 PM Mar 19th 2013
Tried looking up Uncanny valley on google images. Not too bad. No really.
10:52:39 AM May 29th 2013
Merely googling that doesn't give many good examples, really.
08:27:27 PM Oct 24th 2012
I've been thinking about this trope, and I'm not putting this forward as a trope but an observation in human nature: I wonder if sometimes an argument or a viewpoint can be in the uncanny valley.

So often in the world you get two groups arguing over something which to an outside observer seems like almost exactly the same argument, but it turns out that the other group's argument is in uncanny valley area - "it's so much like the way we view things but it's NOT."

Just an observation.
08:04:38 AM Nov 10th 2012
edited by Vano
Obviously, the fear reaction to "very close but NOT" is instinctive, and this instinct is justified by the fact that, in nature, mimicry is invariably used for deception.

There are two types of mimicry. Plants and animals either disguise themselves as dangerous things to protect themselves or as friendly things to backstab unsuspecting victims. And since the perpetrator blows its cover by the stab, the attack has to be as fast, cruel and deadly as possible. This second case is what is reflected by the Valley.

As for the first case, it feeds our skepticism regarding things that tend to look overly dangerous hinting they are likely to hide severe weaknesses by this.
01:00:47 PM Nov 10th 2012
I wonder if this is why we are typically repulsed from thinking sexually about family members, such as siblings. They are so much like the kind of person you would be attracted to (After all, your parents fell for each other that way), but it's just freakish to even think about it.
05:50:53 PM Dec 23rd 2012
And personality disorders for example?
05:28:30 PM Sep 11th 2012
I'm not sure why this was listed as an index only, so I changed it back to a trope. I don't really even see index to be listed.
03:58:05 PM Jul 15th 2012
I find the use of "moving corpse" on the graphic interesting, as UNMOVING corpses (such as what you see in the US during visitations or even in old Victorian-era "death pictures") also freak a lot of people out, for much the same reasons.
08:24:51 PM Mar 31st 2012
edited by NaphthaTurisas
Not sure if I understand this correctly, but can this trope work from both sides? That is, if someone started with a photo of a real person and made some tweaks to it in Photoshopó just enough to make the subject look creepy to someone looking at the end resultó that's the same trope, isn't it?

I'm asking because we have examples like the cover to Requiem For The Indifferent, the latest Epica album. Bar code under the shoulder, tree branches growing out of the fingers, extreme pallor and rusty bolts in a bald, metallic-looking head... I think that counts as an invocation of the "less than human" type rather than the "not human enough" type that CGI failures and the like fall into.
06:20:47 PM Apr 16th 2012
Why is there an "Other" page that's identical to "Real Life"?
11:12:43 PM Nov 22nd 2011
Is it even possible for cell animation to fall into the category. Rotoscope animation makes scene, but anime is intentionally stylized & the look is too commonplace to be unsettling.
06:58:06 PM Oct 24th 2011
I found an article addressing this concept while scanning the news for stories relating to psychology. I think it's worth checking out.
04:31:27 PM Oct 10th 2011
This trope applies to non-humans as well, correct, other than the robots and zombies mentioned? Like, say, a humanoid demon with just enough skeletal differences so as to unnerve people (like longer hands and fingers, a longer spine, a slightly differently-shaped skull [deeper jaw and longer tooth sockets to accomodate fangs], and elongated foot and anklebones)? Would this trope apply to something like that?
12:42:18 PM Jul 17th 2011
Is it YMMV if it's explicitly stated in-universe?
11:51:09 AM Aug 14th 2010
Kinda the same princible as with the Bishonen Line...
07:33:58 PM Feb 23rd 2011
No, not at all.
06:02:44 PM Apr 1st 2010
I changed some in the anime group due to the fact that One Piece is a really popular series to make porn of due to how attractive Nami, Robin, and Boa Hancock are and Rei is not Your Mileage May Vary as she was an important character in making the current otaku market with her sex appeal, and Gainax taking advantage of that by making thousands of different variations of her.
Collapse/Expand Topics