Main Music Video Syndrome Discussion

Collapse/Expand Topics

02:54:11 PM Nov 30th 2012
I really don't understand why there's an entry for Cast Away for not using this trope. Thousands of movies don't use this trope. Suggest cutting.
12:51:42 PM Dec 1st 2012
No objections? Then I strike!
07:42:46 PM Apr 12th 2011
Is it possible to get a slightly more neutral wording in this, or at least a YMMV tag in there sowmewhere? I like this effect, personally.
12:11:47 PM Sep 2nd 2011
I second this.
08:03:19 PM Oct 30th 2011
I third. The entry looks more neutral than when I was last here, but it could still use work. Film scores are used to help tell stories, why can't songs do the same? Best example I can think of is the soundtrack for 500DaysOfSummer, which plays a very active role in the story. Tom's decision to move on from Summer wouldn't feel nearly as triumphant if wasn't set to Vagabond by Wolfmother.
07:19:11 PM Feb 28th 2011
What exactly is the difference between the use of this trope and meta-diagetic music (e.g. musical sequences in films that are closely synchronized to the onscreen action) in general? For example, A Clockwork Orange contains several examples of scenes choreographed to music; would that be an example of this trope? I'm a little unclear on the intended definition.
12:12:03 AM Nov 2nd 2012
That's called a montage. It predates the 80's by quite a bit.

And yeah, this trope REALLY speaks ill of this practice, even though it's not only GOOD under most circumstances, but much more simple and natural than this article claims. It's just simple synchronization: synching the sound and the video. Just like synching sight and sound in a play—we've been doing it for centuries, and it's not some kind of invented concept.
Collapse/Expand Topics