Main Mono Chrome Casting Discussion

Collapse/Expand Topics

12:41:45 PM Sep 9th 2016
I'm not sure that the trope name clearly expresses the concept. While the word monochrome does indeed mean "shades of a single colour", most people will be familiar with it in the context of "monochrome photography" or "monochrome television", ie. white and black. Combine that with the fact that white and black are both shades of achromatic grey, and the word becomes not only apparently incorrect, but technically incorrect as well.

A better trope name might be something along the lines of "Whitewatching" (It doesn't have to be that, of course, but the trope name should clearly express that it specifically refers to Caucasians).
10:01:02 AM Jan 12th 2014
Black people in Shakespeare's London? Is there a source for this, besides a Dr. Who episode? Certainly at the time, people would have known what a black person was, but Africa and the middle east was quite far away, and tourism was low. A black person is feasible, but probably unusual enough to turn heads.
09:00:10 AM Jul 24th 2013
Would examples that aren't monochromatic, but noticeably lacking in a particular race be counted? Especially if the setting would indicate that that race should appear?

For example, a work set in Mexico that has a white protagonist and a black protagonist, but no Hispanic characters.

07:52:28 PM Jul 15th 2013
Perhaps there should be another trope about how there isn't always monochrome casting because of all the 'averted' examples that don't really belong on this page. Perhaps something along the lines of 'Purposely Diverse Casting'?
05:23:16 PM Jan 16th 2012

  • It's Always Sunny In Philadelphia. Philadelphia has a less than 50% Caucasian rate, yet there are barely ever any non-white people on the show, save for guest spots or small recurring roles (such as when Ryan Howard and Sinbad guest-starred, or the father of Dee's surrogate baby). This becomes the plot-point of an entire episode, with The Gang worrying that not having any black friends (or even black patrons) automatically makes them racist.
    • To the show's credit, while the main cast is extremely white, it actually does a good job of portraying a realistic depiction of diversity around the city. There are tons of non-white extras and one-shot characters (cops, nurses, store employees, and random bystanders) shown whenever the main cast members leave their bar and go somewhere.

This seems somewhat contradictory.
12:51:07 PM Sep 9th 2016
I know this is a three-year-old comment, but...

I'm not so sure it's contradictory. Even in extremely multi-ethnic cities, it's an unfortunate reality that many people's social circles will, in general, be more-or-less racially homogeneous. There are a number of factors that influence this: the tendency for immigrant populations to settle in the same region as their fellow expats (which then often ensures that the local school districts are divided along ethnic lines), racism, ease of communication, religious ties, etc.

Consequently, it seems logical that a show might have a predominantly Caucasian cast while still showing the diversity of its setting through background characters and guest stars. Whether this is good or bad is open to interpretation.
08:17:44 PM Aug 14th 2011
Thinking of adding a video game section. While video games are young enough to have suffered this trope relatively little, there's still a good few examples floating about. Anyone interested in helping me compile a list?

Off to top of my head:

05:53:09 AM Jan 14th 2012
I take issue with the Harry Potter entry. It's in the literature section, but I'm reasonably sure that, outside of the obvious (The Weasleys) most of the named characters weren't given much of a visual description and could pretty much be whatever race you wanted. It'd be fair enough if we moved it to the Film section.
10:30:55 PM Jan 14th 2012
I recall that the Ghostbusters game for the NES only featured 3 white Ghostbusters.
09:32:18 AM Jan 12th 2014
Early video games could easily fall into this, because the repeated use of sprites.
11:54:09 PM Feb 11th 2017
Harry Potter should be removed from this page. For starters, the UK of the 1990s when the books take place was by no means a particularly diverse country, the 1991 census showed as little as 7% were of non-European origins and quite a few characters have names that display their origins (Cho Chang, the Patil sisters) without making it explicit. This is really going full on PC here, which is especially absurd considering that the author herself is a dedicated SJW.
Collapse/Expand Topics