Follow TV Tropes

Following

Discussion History YMMV / Bleach

Go To

[004] Wyldchyld Current Version
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
to:
AssPull entry under debate on YMMV page between two tropers. I pulled it here so they could sort it out and noticed this thread, which I\'d forgotten about. Since it\'s the same entry and the same issue, I don\'t see the point starting a new thread, although if it\'s too confusing, go ahead and start one.

It looks like this entry was added back to the YMMV page on the 2nd February without an edit reason and without continuing/completing the discussion page conversation. It was then removed by a different troper and readded yet again. The two conflicting edit reasons are as follows:

11th April 2016: Removed, edit reason given.
[[quoteblock]]This was not an \"Asspull\" no matter how much the fandumb claims it it, we\'ve know for a while now that Ichigo could go hollow, heck \"white\" Zangetsu himself said that he would come back, plus whenever Ichigo put on his hollow mask an extra stripe would appear which is obviously supposed to be taken as a subtle countdown.[[/quoteblock]]

14th April 2016: Readded, edit reason given:
[[quoteblock]]1: Ichigo\'s hollow form has already been seen. Spoiler alert, it looks nothing like this one, because 2: as mentioned the new form is explicitly not a result of his inner hollow emerging , but an entirely separate being whose existence was not explained until several dozen chapters later. 3: Even in the unlikely event that the addition of stripes on Ichigo\'s hollow mask can somehow be construed as a countdown, that is not sufficient to justify Ulquiorra\'s defeat because 4: refer back to the fact that the transformation is a result on a theretofore non-existent entity. A countdown to a deus ex machina doesn\'t make it not a deus ex machina.[[/quoteblock]]
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
to:
AssPull entry under debate on YMMV page between two tropers. I pulled it here so they could sort it out and noticed this thread, which I\'d forgotten about. Since it\'s the same entry and the same issue, I don\'t see the point starting a new thread, although if it\'s too confusing, go ahead and start one.

It looks like this entry was added back to the YMMV page on the 2nd February without an edit reason and without continuing/completing the discussion page conversation. It was then removed by a different troper and readded yet again. The two conflicting edit reasons are as follows:

11th April 2016: Removed, edit reason given.
[[quoteblock]]This was not an \"Asspull\" no matter how much the fandumb claims it it, we\'ve know for a while now that Ichigo could go hollow, heck \"white\" Zangetsu himself said that he would come back, plus whenever Ichigo put on his hollow mask an extra stripe would appear which is obviously supposed to be taken as a subtle countdown.[[/quoteblock]]

14th April 2016: Removed, edit reason given:
[[quoteblock]]1: Ichigo\'s hollow form has already been seen. Spoiler alert, it looks nothing like this one, because 2: as mentioned the new form is explicitly not a result of his inner hollow emerging , but an entirely separate being whose existence was not explained until several dozen chapters later. 3: Even in the unlikely event that the addition of stripes on Ichigo\'s hollow mask can somehow be construed as a countdown, that is not sufficient to justify Ulquiorra\'s defeat because 4: refer back to the fact that the transformation is a result on a theretofore non-existent entity. A countdown to a deus ex machina doesn\'t make it not a deus ex machina.[[/quoteblock]]
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
to:
AssPull entry under debate on YMMV page between two tropers. I pulled it here so they could sort it out and noticed this thread, which I\'d forgotten about. Since it\'s the same entry and the same issue, I don\'t see the point starting a new thread.

It looks like this entry was added back to the YMMV page on the 2nd February without an edit reason and without continuing/completing the discussion page conversation. It was then removed by a different troper and readded yet again. The two conflicting edit reasons are as follows:

11th April 2016: Removed, edit reason given.
[[quoteblock]]This was not an \"Asspull\" no matter how much the fandumb claims it it, we\'ve know for a while now that Ichigo could go hollow, heck \"white\" Zangetsu himself said that he would come back, plus whenever Ichigo put on his hollow mask an extra stripe would appear which is obviously supposed to be taken as a subtle countdown.[[/quoteblock]]

14th April 2016: Removed, edit reason given:
[[quoteblock]]1: Ichigo\'s hollow form has already been seen. Spoiler alert, it looks nothing like this one, because 2: as mentioned the new form is explicitly not a result of his inner hollow emerging , but an entirely separate being whose existence was not explained until several dozen chapters later. 3: Even in the unlikely event that the addition of stripes on Ichigo\'s hollow mask can somehow be construed as a countdown, that is not sufficient to justify Ulquiorra\'s defeat because 4: refer back to the fact that the transformation is a result on a theretofore non-existent entity. A countdown to a deus ex machina doesn\'t make it not a deus ex machina.[[/quoteblock]]
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
to:
Entry under debate on YMMV page between two tropers. I pulled it here so they could sort it out and noticed this thread, which I\'d forgotten about. Since it\'s the same entry and the same issue, I don\'t see the point starting a new thread.

It looks like this entry was added back to the YMMV page on the 2nd February without an edit reason and without continuing/completing the discussion page conversation. It was then removed by a different troper and readded yet again. The two conflicting edit reasons are as follows:

11th April 2016: Removed, edit reason given.
[[quoteblock]]This was not an \"Asspull\" no matter how much the fandumb claims it it, we\'ve know for a while now that Ichigo could go hollow, heck \"white\" Zangetsu himself said that he would come back, plus whenever Ichigo put on his hollow mask an extra stripe would appear which is obviously supposed to be taken as a subtle countdown.[[/quoteblock]]

14th April 2016: Removed, edit reason given:
[[quoteblock]]1: Ichigo\'s hollow form has already been seen. Spoiler alert, it looks nothing like this one, because 2: as mentioned the new form is explicitly not a result of his inner hollow emerging , but an entirely separate being whose existence was not explained until several dozen chapters later. 3: Even in the unlikely event that the addition of stripes on Ichigo\'s hollow mask can somehow be construed as a countdown, that is not sufficient to justify Ulquiorra\'s defeat because 4: refer back to the fact that the transformation is a result on a theretofore non-existent entity. A countdown to a deus ex machina doesn\'t make it not a deus ex machina.[[/quoteblock]]
Top