Ask The Tropers

open

Possible editing with an agenda? Videogame

So I'm a bit worried about this entry, since the issue it's discussing is only around 7 months old, and I don't want to come across as if I'm taking sides.

The troper Chrononaut70 appears to have made a few edits on the YMMV pages for Mafia III and Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas, both of which seem to have some sort of agenda in regards to BLM.

On December 11th 2020, he edited a (now deleted) entry for Harsher in Hindsight, changing it from:

• "The re-release of Mafia III as the Definitive Edition in 2020 comes during a time of Civil Rights protests, protests against Police Brutality, and intense backlash against white nationalism (particularly Neo-Confederate)."

To, with the reason "Since there is a lot of rioting, looting and vandalism in addition to protests, I think it's appropriate to bring these things up":

• The re-release of Mafia III as the Definitive Edition in 2020 comes during a time of riots, protests, unrest, and intense backlash against racism (perceived or not).

He also changed this sentence on the same day, changing "black men" to "men of all races":

• Police Brutality is a thing that black men deal with every day. Lincoln is frequently harassed and sometimes even attacked for just being in the "wrong" neighborhood.

On the GTA:SA page, five days after the Mafia III edits, he edited this paragraph on a Harsher in Hindsight entry:

• Then came the George Floyd protests in 2020, where a fatal choking by law enforcement and several other factors lead to protests that had a tendency of turning violent and spreading to cities outside of Minnesota, one of which was Los Angeles. It also didn't help that the line "Take it off, please, I can't breathe, please!" said by CJ as he was inside Tenpenny's police cruiser sounds disturbingly similar to the one George Floyd said when he was pleading for his life.

Changing it to this entry that, in my opinion, leans on Victim Blaming:

• Then came the George Floyd unrest in 2020, where a fatal accident due to the subject's awful health, drug overdose, and several other factors lead to protests that had a tendency of turning violent and spreading to cities outside of Minneapolis, one of which was Los Angeles. It also didn't help that the line "Take it off, please, I can't breathe, please!" said by CJ as he was inside Tenpenny's police cruiser sounds disturbingly similar to the one George Floyd said when he was pleading for his life while acting very erratically and resisting arrest.

I have edited the aforementioned entry back to be a bit more neutral. I'm not the most educated when it comes to BLM, but from his entries, I get the sense that he's trying to brush out discussions about racism against African-Americans, which I find strange because the pages he's edited on are for games with African-American protagonists. I just thought I'd get others' opinions about it first because I'm not sure if this is a recurring issue or not.