#2: Jun 2nd 2018 at 1:56:24 AM
Sorry, but we need a lot more evidence than this to justify a thread. Declining.
"For a successful technology, reality must take precedence over public relations, for Nature cannot be fooled." - Richard Feynman
Total posts: 2
Alright, so this is a thing that has been boiling up in me for a very long time.
I have never been a fan of how when tropers add Arc Villain, they remove the Big Bad trope already there. While Arc Villain theoretically seems to be a subtrope of Big Bad, it is not listed as such. Because of that, I do not think that tropers should remove a Big Bad entry for an Arc Villain entry, especially without an edit reason. I have had trouble with that on Characters.Fairy Tail, and even though I posted in discussion, no one ever responded to me (keep in mind, the character whom the editors insist is the "true" Big Bad barely has any involvement until the final arc).
I think that has to do with the discription of Arc Villain:
This is a bit ambiguous as to the relationship with Big Bad, and that confuses me, and probably lots of others.
However, now I see this on Characters.The Spectacular Spider Man
That entry admits that the villain (Tombstone) is a major villain throughout the whole series, which should techically deny the trope as Arc Villain. What's worse is on the same sheet:
That makes no sense. Arc Villain means that the villain disappears after their arc is done, but Tombstone and all other villains in the series stick around.
Also, though the description says that there is no The Man Behind the Man with Arc Villain, Zhao from Avatar: The Last Airbender is listed though he works for another villain. That is also confusing.
I don't know, it feels that there are a lot of entries of villains that recur, which judging by the description for Arc Villain shouldn't even apply. It's rather annoying that there seems to be multiple interpretations.