Just a Face and a Caption: Irritation Is The Sincerest Form Of Flattery

The image is too specific in its reference that it can effectively illustrate the trope to everyone.

Nothing against My Little Pony: Friendship Is Magic, but for people who don't know who Rainbow Dash and Scootaloo are, and don't know that Scootaloo normally doesn't look like that (and can therefore conclude that she is impersonating Rainbow), this image will be an utterly incomprehensible inside joke. The caption doesn't help in the slightest, by the way.

Also, since it's a piece of fan art, it might also warrant a source.

Motion to pull, and replace with a better illustration.

edited 16th Jan '14 7:45:03 PM by jeez

Honestly, the expressions and the caption make it work well enough for me to vote Keep Until Better Image Suggested.

edited 16th Jan '14 8:41:26 PM by Willbyr

Keep Until Better Image Suggested for Willbyr's reasons.

You don't need to know what Scootaloo looks like usually to know that's she's imitating Rainbow Dash, the expressions show that and the caption does help so I'm going with the rare KUPKIS vote.

edited 17th Jan '14 2:10:51 AM by treelo

Weak, but doesn't hurt the page.

If you have a motion to pull and replace with a better image, I'd ask, "With what image?"

It can't be much clearer they the rainbow pony is being imitated and the filly is looking for approval. Very strong Keep Until Better Image Suggested.

Yeah, this is definitely Keep Until Better Image Suggested. Even if you've never seen the show, the small pony is obviously imitating the adult, and the expressions capture the trope pretty well; you've got extreme enthusiasm partnered with "WTF are you doing?"

Another keep or Keep Until Better Image Suggested vote and we can move on.

I think it's fine as well.

Done. I'll tag the page in a sec; locking up.