Needs Help: Swiss Army Appendage

The image for Swiss-Army Appendage was changed without discussion back in July from the former to the latter. I actually prefer the Treasure Planet pic, but it's way too dark...thoughts?

edited 23rd Oct '12 10:59:03 AM by Willbyr

Hmm... dark or low quality. Tough choice.

Definitely prefer the second pic, even if it stays dark. Made some adjustments: how's this◊?

The Treasure Island pic is better, and 3 is good with me.

That's much better.

The one from 3 is much more clear.

Cleaned-up TP FTW.

Treasure Planet is better when it's visible.

I think the TP arm is a better example, but the hand makes up such a small portion of the picture that it's hard to see. The nice thing about the IG one is that the hand takes up a large amount of the screen.

In addition to making it less dark, like everyone's said, is there any other scene in that movie where the hand is more prominently displayed?

The arm is still centralised and the focus of attention.

Bump; any other thoughts?

I guess I'm in the minority, because I like Inspector Gadget better.

edited 29th Oct '12 10:26:15 AM by redhed311

Looks like 5 for TP, 1 for IG and one neutral...a couple more votes for the TP pic and we can roll with it, or we can crowner this.

3 is fine.

I actually think I like Inspector Gadget better, too.

Crowner's hooked. I found a better version of the Gadget pic and included it as well as the original, plus a clever RL take.

Bump for votes.

The votes have held steady for a while, so I think we can call this. The new pic's up and tagged and the others are on the Image Links page. Locking up.