The Place for Purging Porn and Pedo-Pandering (AKA P5 flag evaluations)

I've seen people call things "Softcore Porn" that are anything from works that are entirely sex with genitals not in focus, to works that have a lot of fanservice, to works that focus entirely on romance and have maybe one sex scene, to anything with nudity, to works that have women in bikinis. I'm not sure which definition any given person is using.

The work is My Uncle Oswald. Never read it (which is why I have no real idea where it falls relative to the rules); I came across it when doing rename wick moves. Both this wiki and The Other Wiki describe it as "soft porn", hence the question.

I've flagged it.

edited 28th May '12 5:33:54 PM by Nocturna

Bliss stage: Love is your weapon only has implicit sex? Perhaps we should get someone who hasn't played it before to dumpster dive, just to be sure?

Edit:Ohh. It wasn't released.

Ehh. The not reading back enough to understand what was sa.... Umm. Why do we have a trope page for a work which was never released?

edited 28th May '12 8:32:04 PM by Roraborialis

well we had a page on mass effect 3 before its release But with this one I think it has more to do with the fact that the dev-team is mostly tropers.

Nanas Everyday Life. Didn't know of this webcomic but I saw Elfen Lied years ago. I rapidly read all the 77 strips (it takes really little time). The poor protagonist, while she appears naked in some strips, is drawn in an incredibly simple style and not sexualized (despite the early Pedobear cameo), even more after that, when the tone shifts and it becomes incredibly depressing. The most I'd recommend is some cleaning, also to remove the "not to be confused" reference to the now-dead Mai-Chan's Daily Life (it's rethorical to ask that is a permanent redlink now, right?). As usual, however, I want at least another user give his/her opinion beside mine.

O_O It seems to have dirty humor that shocked me. I wouldn't read that at work. Nana here is like what? 11? Like this one. and this Am I just being a prude and reading things into this that are wrong?

Although no one could fap to that. I'm just easily horrified.

You didn't read after those first strips, did you?

BTW, if something is NSFW it doesn't mean it's an auto-cut.

edited 28th May '12 8:54:07 PM by GendoIkari

I agree with Gendo Ikari's suggestion.

As for the comic its self I have seen it posted on 4chan with everyone finding it depressing more the any thing.

So if they are not "faping" to it its probably not peado pandering.

It keeps getting worse if I remember.

Its probably just a misunderstanding,

I at least know you don't want to cut everything nsfw.

edited 28th May '12 9:00:33 PM by Shadis

No, I'm delicate, you know. Does it become War And Peace after that?

I didn't say they should cut all NSFW stuff, I was just warning folks that if they click those links, they'll get fired. And prudes have feelings too. (sniff)

edited 28th May '12 8:55:57 PM by animeg3282

The wiki page itself advises that it's NSFW. If someone is not intelligent enough to not click that at work...

Resume reading from strip 12.

edited 28th May '12 9:00:00 PM by GendoIkari

Strip 14 is even worse. My delicate soul hurts!

I read it a long time ago, but IIRC it was just depressing rather than sexualized.

/a/ thinks the same way and they can find almost anything sexy.

I think the comic is some kind of self aware trap it looks funny it acts funny but its really really depressing.

well after that it still kinda "thinks" its funny.

watch some gurren lagann or some flcl that should fix you right up.

edited 28th May '12 9:12:53 PM by Shadis

There's still some black comedy until strips 25, with the Gunslinger Girl cameos. After that... It's fun fun fun! ^_^

I think this broke my soul. You have to read Sakura Gari for causing me to read that! It's BRUTAL.

Nana's Everyday Life... hm. I know it isn't pornography, and there isn't any paedo-pandering material, so I guess it's safe to keep.

Read it over a year ago; never gonna read it again...

Why?

Did you get super sad oh no!

Aye, I did. It's pretty darn depressing stuff...

While it doesn't sound like it warrants a cut, it sounds like something I don't want to read. I've seen enough Nightmare Fuel / Tear Jerker worthy stuff for my lifetime.

edited 28th May '12 9:36:26 PM by KrazyKopter

Nanas Everyday Life is just heartbreaking...anyone that could find it titillating has no soul.

Doesn't seem cutworthy on the porno grounds. That being said;

I think It pretends to be.

Well it certainly looked like a comedy setup... Except for the contents.