I personally would more enjoy a new story, possibly a continuation story, simply because I would rather not have yet another version of the Dark Kingdom story unless it somehow includes the Outers and Chibi-Usa. I don't have anything against the first season/Dark Kingdom story, but I was disappointed that the live-action didn't include the other Senshi at least in some way, although I did like Sailor Luna. I would personally prefer it if the new anime at least included the Outers and Chibi-Usa eventually, to have the full set of Senshi, but that's just me.
Ironically, I'm not as fond of the Outers, particularly Pluto and Saturn, but I think that's partially the fault of them not having enough screentime to establish them as having human flaws like the others do (and actually have them make mistakes, especially Saturn who just has bad things happen to her but nothing that is really her fault, and the little we see of her in Stars, she's not weak and shy anymore so she's even more annoyingly perfect to me). That is one more area in which I think the manga does better, in giving Hotaru more focus outside of just being a pitiful host to Mistress 9, she is able to have more character flaws like being a bit of a smart-aleck in the Chibi-Usa diary story about the Hammer Price Shop (from the Stars manga). Or at least showing the hobbies and things that were mentioned in Naoko's official notes, like having Saturn enjoy reading and World History (said to be her favorite subject) or having Pluto be scared of cockroaches and show her love of clothing design, something that she could bond with Michiru over since it could also be considered an art form using clothing (like with Rarity from My Little Pony: Friendship Is Magic
And as long as I'm talking about things I'd like to see, even if they're not likely, I would like to have Chibi-Usa meet the Starlights, simply to have her and Taiki get at least a scene together because they're my two favorite Senshi. They do get to meet in at least one of the musicals, though.
edited 12th Oct '12 7:12:55 PM by Rainbow