Follow TV Tropes

Following

History YMMV / YuGiOhTheThousandYearDoor

Go To

OR

Removed: 1209

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* CriticalResearchFailure: Despite his interest in playing the game and his knowledge about it, the author has made a number of research fails. These are just a few of them:
** In the duel between Andy and Vladimir, Vladimir has Steelswarm Roach on the field. Vladimir says Roach can negate any of Andy's level 5 or higher special summons. However, Andy relies mostly on fusion summon, which almost always requires a card's activation that starts a chain to pull off. A card or effect cannot activate while another card or effect is resolving and summon negation must happen exactly when the summon happens. By the time Roach could activate its effect, the monster is already on the field and thus could not be negated.
** The card "Queen's Machine" is used by Poison against Andy. One of its effects prevents Andy's machines from attacking his. In the story proper, Andy's monsters were able to attack Poison directly. Unless a card that prevents your monsters from specifically being attacked says otherwise or allows for direct attacks, in this situation Andy would be unable to attack period since Poison still has monsters on the field which his card dictates cannot be attacked by the opponent's monsters.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
trimming


** In the duel between Andy and Vladimir, Vladimir has Steelswarm Roach on the field. Vladimir says Roach can negate ''any'' of Andy's level 5 or higher special summons. The problem is, Andy relies mostly on fusion summon, which almost always requires a card's activation that starts a chain to pull off. A card or effect cannot activate while another card or effect is resolving and summon negation ''MUST'' happen exactly ''when'' the summon happens. By the time Roach could possibly activate its effect, the monster is already on the field and the last thing that happened was the card or effect responsible for said it ending. This means that Roach cannot negate any of Andy's high level special summons simply because the effect cannot be activated when the summon happens. The author seems to have a tenuous grasp on which special summons can be negated...
** The card "Queen's Machine" used by Poison against Andy. One of it's effects prevents machines from attacking yours. However, in the story proper, Andy's monsters were able to attack directly, even though nothing of the sort is even said on "Queen's Machine". Unless a card that prevents your monsters from specifically being attacked says otherwise or allows for direct attacks, your opponent's monsters cannot attack at all if the only monsters you control are ones that can't be targeted for attacks. This is despite what the author insists, which makes it particularly grating since the first chapter establishes that he was going to follow official rules.

to:

** In the duel between Andy and Vladimir, Vladimir has Steelswarm Roach on the field. Vladimir says Roach can negate ''any'' any of Andy's level 5 or higher special summons. The problem is, However, Andy relies mostly on fusion summon, which almost always requires a card's activation that starts a chain to pull off. A card or effect cannot activate while another card or effect is resolving and summon negation ''MUST'' must happen exactly ''when'' when the summon happens. By the time Roach could possibly activate its effect, the monster is already on the field and the last thing that happened was the card or effect responsible for said it ending. This means that Roach cannot negate any of Andy's high level special summons simply because the effect cannot thus could not be activated when the summon happens. The author seems to have a tenuous grasp on which special summons can be negated...
negated.
** The card "Queen's Machine" is used by Poison against Andy. One of it's its effects prevents Andy's machines from attacking yours. However, in his. In the story proper, Andy's monsters were able to attack directly, even though nothing of the sort is even said on "Queen's Machine". Poison directly. Unless a card that prevents your monsters from specifically being attacked says otherwise or allows for direct attacks, your in this situation Andy would be unable to attack period since Poison still has monsters on the field which his card dictates cannot be attacked by the opponent's monsters cannot attack at all if the only monsters you control are ones that can't be targeted for attacks. This is despite what the author insists, which makes it particularly grating since the first chapter establishes that he was going to follow official rules.monsters.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Fixing a typo.


** The card "Queen's Machine" used by Poison against Andy. One of it's effects prevents machines from attacking yours. however, in the story proper, Andy's monsters were able to attack directly, even though nothing of the sort is even said on "Queen's Machine". Unless a card that prevents your monsters from specifically being attacked says otherwise or allows for direct attacks, your opponent's monsters cannot attack at all if the only monsters you control are ones that can't be targeted for attacks. This is despite what the author insists, which makes it particularly grating since the first chapter establishes that he was going to follow official rules.

to:

** The card "Queen's Machine" used by Poison against Andy. One of it's effects prevents machines from attacking yours. however, However, in the story proper, Andy's monsters were able to attack directly, even though nothing of the sort is even said on "Queen's Machine". Unless a card that prevents your monsters from specifically being attacked says otherwise or allows for direct attacks, your opponent's monsters cannot attack at all if the only monsters you control are ones that can't be targeted for attacks. This is despite what the author insists, which makes it particularly grating since the first chapter establishes that he was going to follow official rules.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Adding a pair of entries.

Added DiffLines:

* CriticalResearchFailure: Despite his interest in playing the game and his knowledge about it, the author has made a number of research fails. These are just a few of them:
** In the duel between Andy and Vladimir, Vladimir has Steelswarm Roach on the field. Vladimir says Roach can negate ''any'' of Andy's level 5 or higher special summons. The problem is, Andy relies mostly on fusion summon, which almost always requires a card's activation that starts a chain to pull off. A card or effect cannot activate while another card or effect is resolving and summon negation ''MUST'' happen exactly ''when'' the summon happens. By the time Roach could possibly activate its effect, the monster is already on the field and the last thing that happened was the card or effect responsible for said it ending. This means that Roach cannot negate any of Andy's high level special summons simply because the effect cannot be activated when the summon happens. The author seems to have a tenuous grasp on which special summons can be negated...
** The card "Queen's Machine" used by Poison against Andy. One of it's effects prevents machines from attacking yours. however, in the story proper, Andy's monsters were able to attack directly, even though nothing of the sort is even said on "Queen's Machine". Unless a card that prevents your monsters from specifically being attacked says otherwise or allows for direct attacks, your opponent's monsters cannot attack at all if the only monsters you control are ones that can't be targeted for attacks. This is despite what the author insists, which makes it particularly grating since the first chapter establishes that he was going to follow official rules.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Edit made by a serial ban evader. Removing on principle. Additionally, Lady Jane Grey is actually maedar, a.k.a. the author and therefore cannot add YMMV items to this page.


* HarsherInHindsight: Stan mentioned that turning against one's father is fairly common theme and that turning against the mother is practically unheard of, ''[[Anime/KillLaKill well...]]''
* HilariousInHindsight: In one chapter, Hyde (acting as {{narrator}} in a pre-chapter synopsis) ponders the fate of Duel Spirits whose cards have been placed on the Forbidden List, mentioning how some fans envision a prison somewhere they'd like to see TierInducedScrappy cards dragged away too, and how players have actually signed petitions to "pardon" the ones they desire off the list. Many cards since then with humorous art suggest there is ''indeed'' such a place; inmates include [[http://yugioh.wikia.com/wiki/Mistaken_Arrest Sangan, Graceful Charity]], [[http://yugioh.wikia.com/wiki/Mistaken_Accusation Witch of the Black Forest]], [[http://yugioh.wikia.com/wiki/Summon_Gate Goyo Guardian, Performage Plushfire, Elder Entity Norden, and Number 16: Shock Master,]] and until recently, Thousand Eyes Restrict, who is shown being released in the third card, having been taken off the List in October 2016.

to:

* HarsherInHindsight: Stan mentioned that turning against one's father is fairly common theme and that turning against the mother is practically unheard of, ''[[Anime/KillLaKill well...]]''
* HilariousInHindsight: In one chapter, Hyde (acting as {{narrator}} in a pre-chapter synopsis) ponders the fate of Duel Spirits whose cards have been placed on the Forbidden List, mentioning how some fans envision a prison somewhere they'd like to see TierInducedScrappy cards dragged away too, and how players have actually signed petitions to "pardon" the ones they desire off the list. Many cards since then with humorous art suggest there is ''indeed'' such a place; inmates include [[http://yugioh.wikia.com/wiki/Mistaken_Arrest Sangan, Graceful Charity]], [[http://yugioh.wikia.com/wiki/Mistaken_Accusation Witch of the Black Forest]], [[http://yugioh.wikia.com/wiki/Summon_Gate Goyo Guardian, Performage Plushfire, Elder Entity Norden, and Number 16: Shock Master,]] and until recently, Thousand Eyes Restrict, who is shown being released in the third card, having been taken off the List in October 2016.
]]''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HarsherInHindsight: Stan mentioned that turning against one's father is fairly common theme and that turning against the mother is practically unheard of, ''[[Anime/KillLaKill well...]]''

to:

* HarsherInHindsight: Stan mentioned that turning against one's father is fairly common theme and that turning against the mother is practically unheard of, ''[[Anime/KillLaKill well...]]'']]''
* HilariousInHindsight: In one chapter, Hyde (acting as {{narrator}} in a pre-chapter synopsis) ponders the fate of Duel Spirits whose cards have been placed on the Forbidden List, mentioning how some fans envision a prison somewhere they'd like to see TierInducedScrappy cards dragged away too, and how players have actually signed petitions to "pardon" the ones they desire off the list. Many cards since then with humorous art suggest there is ''indeed'' such a place; inmates include [[http://yugioh.wikia.com/wiki/Mistaken_Arrest Sangan, Graceful Charity]], [[http://yugioh.wikia.com/wiki/Mistaken_Accusation Witch of the Black Forest]], [[http://yugioh.wikia.com/wiki/Summon_Gate Goyo Guardian, Performage Plushfire, Elder Entity Norden, and Number 16: Shock Master,]] and until recently, Thousand Eyes Restrict, who is shown being released in the third card, having been taken off the List in October 2016.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
One trope or item per line.


* [[HilariousInHindsight Hilarious]]/ HarsherInHindsight: Stan mentioned that turning against one's father is fairly common theme and that turning against the mother is practically unheard of, ''[[Anime/KillLaKill well...]]''

to:

* [[HilariousInHindsight Hilarious]]/ HarsherInHindsight: Stan mentioned that turning against one's father is fairly common theme and that turning against the mother is practically unheard of, ''[[Anime/KillLaKill well...]]''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* [[HilariousInHindsight Hilarious]]/ HarsherInHindsight: Stan mentioned that turning against one's father is fairly common theme and that turning against the mother is practically unheard of, ''[/Anime/KillLaKill well...]]''

to:

* [[HilariousInHindsight Hilarious]]/ HarsherInHindsight: Stan mentioned that turning against one's father is fairly common theme and that turning against the mother is practically unheard of, ''[/Anime/KillLaKill ''[[Anime/KillLaKill well...]]''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* [[HilariousInHindsight Hilarious]]/ HarsherInHindsight: Stan mentioned that turning against one's father is fairly common theme and that turning against the mother is practically, ''[[http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Anime/KillLaKill well...]]''

to:

* [[HilariousInHindsight Hilarious]]/ HarsherInHindsight: Stan mentioned that turning against one's father is fairly common theme and that turning against the mother is practically, ''[[http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Anime/KillLaKill practically unheard of, ''[/Anime/KillLaKill well...]]''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* [[HilariousInHindsight Hilarious]]/ HarsherInHindsight: Stan mentioned that turning against one's father is fairly common theme and that turning against the mother is a, ''[[http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Anime/KillLaKill well...]]''

to:

* [[HilariousInHindsight Hilarious]]/ HarsherInHindsight: Stan mentioned that turning against one's father is fairly common theme and that turning against the mother is a, practically, ''[[http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Anime/KillLaKill well...]]''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*[[HilariousInHindsight Hilarious]]/ HarsherInHindsight: Stan mentioned that turning against one's father is fairly common theme and that turning against the mother is a, ''[[http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Anime/KillLaKill well...]]''

Top