YMMV / Spider-Woman

The comic book

  • Author's Saving Throw: The first issue of Spider-Woman took care of the Unfortunate Implications of her possibly crimefighting while pregnant: while she does TRY to, she does so only with special tech Carol gave her to protect the baby, and is talked out of that for her and the child's saftey early into a pregnancy.
  • Broken Base:
    • As noted bellow, there's a notable split between people's thoughts on her new costume; its either a welcomed change that perfectly fits the new direction her character is going in, or a dull, unsexy and pointless change that doesn't fit her character at all.
    • Similarly, and in contrast, her old suit has a similar split on views; either its an ugly and dull outfit that was in need of an update and the frequent body paint-looking design would lead to Fetish Retardant whenever a bad artist got ahold of her (which has happened frequently), or its a classic, simple outfit that could perfectly balance sexiness and creepiness when needed, and just didn't need changing.
    • Jess' pregnancy. A single mother superhero is a fun and interesting idea, but the cover art implies that she'll still be superheroing while heavily pregnant and many feel they could have just brought back Julia, who is already a single mother with spider powers, for the idea. There's also others who feel it's fairly generic to take a superheroine and give her a baby, and some even find it a bit backwards.
  • Foe Yay:
    • Archenemy Morgan le Fay consistently attempts to possess Jessica's body. She claims said body is a battery of Elder God Chthon's magical energies. Morgan also later goes after Scarlet Witch for the same reason. No particular interest yet in Quicksilver who is also infected with said magics but is male. Though these days, Morgan seems to have a thing for Doctor Doom.
    • The relationship between Jessica and Gypsy Moth, a lady villain, is also a bit peculiar. In Spider-Woman vol. 1 #10, 48, 50, Jessica always tries to befriend the mutant because of their perceived similarities. On the other hand, the Moth's main power is to psychokinetically manipulate fibers. Her favorite moves are either stripping opponents of their clothing or binding them in it. Guess how this looks in battles against Jessica. Worth noting that Gypsy Moth is confirmed as being bisexual by Word of God. That would seem to say a lot about the Foe Yay between her and Spider-Woman.
      • There was also Nekra Sinclair, who wanted to kill Jessica because she stirred up funny feelings...
  • Les Yay: Jessica herself has a lot of this with her partner Lindsay. However, she later saved Carol Danvers/Ms. Marvel after being drained by Rogue, which was the beginning of their "friendship", later culminating in Carol hugging the real Jessica in relief after the latter got out of the Skrull ship.
  • They Changed It, So It Sucks: There's a segment of fans who hate the new costume and accuse it of this; complaints include it looking too much like either Batgirl's new costume, Mockingbird, or Kate Bishop rather than Jess, and the weird narmy mask!glasses. There's also fans that just think the old costume was a classic and shouldn't have been messed with. See Broken Base, above.
  • Older Than They Think: Most of the people who complain about changing her suit tend to cite the fact she's only ever had one costume and so it makes no sense to change it. This is true...in that its her only superhero outfit; as she spent time as a non-costumed crime fighter, in fact almost half her existence of her character's existence was as one (with exception of one single return, she spent 17 years in Real Life without a costume, starting 11 years into her existence, and only returned to a costume in 2005 (and even there, technically it was a Skrull in her place for the first four years)). Similar to the criticism that Carol Danvers shouldn't use the codename Captain Marvel because she was Ms. Marvel for decadesnote , these complaints might be from fans who only know of their original and recent adventures, and not the stuff in between.
  • Unintentionally Unsympathetic: After Clint cheated on Jessica, some people lost sympathy for her when she slapped him twice and tried for a third. It doesn't help that he clearly had no idea they were serious or exclusive (given she's referred to as his 'friend-girl' rather than girlfriend) or that she has super strength while he's not, meaning those slaps would have been like being hit by a truck.
  • The Woobie: Jessica was captured and impersonated by the Skrull Queen for two years, and when she's rescued, she's hated. And that's not even after getting into her Dark and Troubled Past. Poor woman.
    Skrull: The reason we knew you could be switched for one of us... is that of all the people in the world... we discovered that no one on this entire planet cares enough about you to notice you at all. And of all the things that went wrong with our invasion... that was the one thing we were absolutely right about.
    • Arana as well, if only because of her father dying.
  • Win Back the Crowd: When first unvailed, Jess's current ongoing earned a lot of criticism due to the creative team attached (Dennis Hopeless, known mostly for Avengers Arena and its sequel, and Greg Land, known mostly for tracing porn) and a variant cover for the first issue drawn by Milo Manara that many felt was so over-sexualized it crossed into misogyny and Fan Disservice, resulting in a number of fans, particularly female and/or feminist fans, to complain. Than preview for issue 5 came out, revealing Jess would get a new, better artist and a new, practical costume, and that Greg Land and the first four issues were just a tie-in to Spider-Verse that the creators had to get out of the way. Suffice to say, many who'd complained now praise what happened with the book, even if they still think the launch was handled terribly.
  • WTH, Costuming Department?: Some say this in regards to the old suit, saying it looks ridiculous while others say this about the new costume, saying it doesn't fit a superhero.

The animated series