* AlternativeCharacterInterpretation: Some think that C'ren is a sociopath, and at least one person thinks Plankton is the OnlySaneMan in the story.
* AssPull: At least one person thought that "Monica" just pulled everything that happened in this fanfic out of "her" ass.
* BigLippedAlligatorMoment: A truck crashed and Patrick started opening gag-cans labeled Seanut Brittle like he did in "Pranks a Lot". This never gets mentioned again.
* CrackPairing: [[spoiler: C'ren and Plankton. The author supposedly wrote a snippet of a threesome between C'ren, Plankton, and Doubloon Swallowin' Misty, an OriginalCharacter from his other fanfic FanFic/PlanktonsEyeView in a Website/DeviantArt journal entry. However, since the journal entry resembles a CrackFic generator, this may or may not be true.]]
* CriticalResearchFailure: Bikini Bottom and Atlantis are two separate places.
* DracoInLeatherPants: Plankton is treated in the fanfic as a protagonist. C'ren is implied to have romantic feelings for him.
* [[TookTheBadFilmSeriously Took the Bad Fic Seriously]]: The fanfic got flames from many angry, offended readers, not realizing that the story is not actually meant to be taken seriously. But James put on a good enough show that it [[PoesLaw looked like it was all in earnest]].