YMMV / New Mutants

YMMVs for the first series:

  • Alas, Poor Scrappy: When Cypher was killed off, people felt real bad.
  • Canon Discontinuity: Several
    • Young X-Men is considered this, both by fans and Marvel, given how Marc Guggenheim didn't give a fuck and pissed off Kyle and Yost and fans of New X-Men/New Mutants with the stories he wrote.
    • Boom Boom/Cannonball's relationship falls into this with the Wells/Carey/Abnett and Lanning run.
    • Pretty much X-Force falls into this for hardcore New Mutant fans, which led to the Well New Mutants series getting hated on, by those who were pissed off that certain members (Boom Boom and Rictor) were not allowed near the book and generally ignored.
  • Complete Monster: Two in the forms of Empath and Donald Pierce. For Pierce, see his entry under X-Men.
    • A bio by Xavier flat-out states that Manuel may be the definition of pure evil. In addition, he has no empathy and toys with others' emotions for his enjoyment.
  • Crowning Moment of Awesome: The Devil Bear Saga, for both Danielle Moonstar and the creative team themselves.
    • The Magus is probably among the most powerful foes any X-team has ever faced, and the New Mutants squad, the Professor, and a cosmically-powered Carol Danvers ended up stopping him. And Doug Ramsey was the guy who won the battle.
  • Ensemble Darkhorse: Rahne has been a member of more X-Men spinoff teams than any other character.
  • Hollywood Homely: Skids was considered "ugly" by the morlocks. This, of course, is because the Morlocks are all hideous and consider her a freak among freaks.
  • Ho Yay: Arguably Warlock towards Cypher before the latter's killing-off.
    • Still present after Cypher came back. "I love you and you are breaking my heart." Well...
    • Between Shatterstar and Rictor as well
  • Les Yay: Danielle and Rahne, due to their psychic-link when Rahne's in wolf-form.
    • -and a good deal of obvious subtext, calling each other 'soul-mate', a revealing event in the Inferno-alternate Manhattan, and Dani saying as much as 'I love y-' on a cliff in Scotland.
    • Sometimes, Illyana towards Kitty, too.
  • Moral Event Horizon: Pierce crosses this several times in the New Mutants origin story alone. Examples are ordering the death of Dani's grandfather and having his men trying to kill each of the New Mutants who were, at the time, teenagers who had only just discovered their powers.
    • The Ani-Mator also crossed this by killing Cypher.
  • My Real Daddy: Warlock was introduced when Bill Sienkiewicz was on the book, and due to his unusual art style he has never looked right when drawn by other people (most artists just copied his style for that particular character, which caused Warlock to jar with their surroundings).
  • Nightmare Fuel: The Demon Bear Saga.
    • Empath, given the stunts he pulls in New Mutants and later on, in New Warriors and Uncanny X-Men
  • Scapegoat Creator: Louis Simonson for Cypher's death. Artist Brett Blevin was the driving force for killing Doug off, manipulating Louis to think no one liked the polarizing character and that fans would cheer his death.
    • Rob Liefeld gets this for Warlock. The character was killed as the transition to X-Force started, but it was Bob Harras who actually gave the kill order due to him never liking Warlock and wanting him dead.
  • The Scrappy: Where to start? Warlock. Gossamyr. Cable.
    • Bird Boy is probably the most extreme, being an imbecilic half-animal who derailed the book into whacky antics and over-eating. He's actually one of the most-accurate in-continuity versions of the Jackovasaurs from South Park. At least he was rapidly Put on a Bus.
    • An entire team of Scrappies was folded in following the Inferno event with the X-Terminators: Boom Boom, Rusty, Skids, Arty, Leech, Rictor, Whiz Kid. Luckily the bulk of the characters were quickly put on various buses, leaving Rictor and Boom Boom to become beloved members of the group, unless you were a shipper who was NOT happy with Wolfsbane and Cannonball ending up romantically involved with Rictor and Boom Boom respectively.
    • Cypher too, but his death was an Alas, Poor Scrappy moment and since his return, he's been Rescued from the Scrappy Heap
  • They Changed It, Now It Sucks: The transition from New Mutants to X-Force. And later the de-Simonson/Liefeldization of the franchise under Zeb Wells
  • They Wasted a Perfectly Good Plot: Cypher was a polarizing character amongst fans of the title in the 1980s, in part because he had sensible everyday mutant powers in the form of the ability to understand any form of language, which sadly also made him utterly useless in fight scenes unless he merged with the alien Warlock. So when Chris Claremont left the book and Louise Simonson took over, artist Brett Blevins conspired to manipulate Simonson into killing off Cypher since he didn't want to draw a mutant "who had to hide behind trees during fights" by tricking her into thinking fans hated him. Sadly, when she killed him off, fans revolted against the death.
    • It's a real shame that Doug was killed before the internet became near-universal or he could have been the world's greatest hacker.
    • Cable versus Apocalypse/The Twelve, which was the replacement for the Highlord Ascension storyline when it was dropped, was haphazardly aborted for a lame-ass month-long event called "Ages of Apocalypse" involving the X-Men in different time periods play-acting various scenarios.
  • Tear Jerker: The issue that dealt with Ilyana's death - or, rather, Jubilee's reaction to it. Even the knowledge of Comic Book Death and the likelihood of Ilyana's eventual return wasn't enough to dampen the emotional weight of a tale about a little girl slowly dying as the adults around her slowly come to the realization that there's nothing they can do to help. Although "I won't allow her to be placed into a living death!" isn't a good argument when it might have allowed them time to find a healer and it certainly would have allowed time for her brother to get home before she died.
  • The Woobie: Rahne. A couple of her old teammates have had worse backstories, but few radiate please hug me as much as she when they are down over it.
    • If there's one constant with Karma it's that life seems to find a way of crapping all over her and her specifically.

YMMVs for the second series/New X-Men:

  • Alternative Character Interpretation: After all that happened to him in this series and later, many fans belive Julian is suffering from post traumatic stress disorder.
  • Angst? What Angst?: No matter how many bad things happens to Pixie, she is angsty about it only when somebody directly pushes the issue.
    • While Rockslide has his greatest failure with the deaths of the students on the bus, he's still possibly the best-adjusted member of the cast, and absolutely loves being a mutant and an X-Man. The fact he's not exactly bright tends to help the angst roll off him.
  • Complete Monster:
  • Crowning Moment of Awesome: Laura playing The Cavalry during Stryker's attack on the school in New X-Men. The adults present are quickly rendered ineffective, and except for Dust, the kids are only able to put up a token defense at best. Then Laura arrives and utterly destroys the Purifiers attacking the school. Single-handed.
    • She takes part in yet another during Messiah Complex: Laura is a part of the X-Force team who arrive to take on Lady Deathstrike and the Reavers after they previously ambushed Cable. Laura is very angry, and makes very short work of Deathstrike for nearly killing Hellion.
  • Crowning Moment of Funny:
    • Dani gets her friend - a congnitive therapist - to try to work around the personal issues of her teammates and Nate Grey. She has to explain to him the Summers Family Tree.
    • After Julian mouths off about her always playing Wolverine in simulations, X-23 very clearly makes her irritation known by walking up to him and extending her claws just short of his groin.
      Julian: Down, girl.
      (SNIKT)
      Rockslide: Ouch.
      Julian: Didn't they clone you a sense of humor?
  • Crowning Moment of Heartwarming:
    • X-23's Odd Friendship with Dust, which leads to the former going to considerable lengths to save the latter from Stryker and his Purifiers.
      • Although Hellion was a bit of a dick to her when they first met (though it's often exaggerated), he becomes one of the first people to actively try to help her learn that she's better than what the Facility made her. Logan may have talked a big game, but it was Julian who made the first real steps in her later development.
    • Nate Grey is getting those in the new series, first with Cyclops assuring him he is finally home and second with Hope Summers taking him under her wings, despite all the issues she must have with his pressence.
  • Cult Classic: The DeFilippis/Weir run. The later Kyle/Yost run has a more traditional sort of fanbase.
  • Ensemble Darkhorse: The Hellions, to the point that not only they got their own mini, but under Kyle & Yost series basically became "Surge and Hellions", before the cast expanded.
    • Pixie and Rockslide under Kyle & Yost - since cancellation of New X-men they are two members of the cast most used. Megan even got her own limited series and Santo had huge supporting role in Wolverne & Jubilee miniseries.
  • Fan-Preferred Couple: Elixir/Wither, for both the obvious and the fact that their powers cancel each other. But mostly the obvious. Wither is also more commonly paired with Mercury than his canon crush, Wallflower.
  • Flanderization: Combined closely with Demoted to Extra - a common complaint by fans of the characters is that since New X-Men ended, Julian and Noriko only show up whenever writers needs somebody to act like a jerk to main characters, Victor has been reduced to token gay character and Santo exists solely to say something funny from time to time.
  • Friendly Fandoms: There is big overlap between fans of New X-Men, Avengers Academy, Runaways and Young Avengers, so these four fandoms are likely to stick together.
  • Harsher in Hindsight: The Elixir/Wither/Wallflower love triangle; now that all of them are dead in the Marvel continuity. Poor Elixir died twice, once in the Wolverines mini-series before being resurrected by Brian Michael Bendis for All-New X-Men. And then he was killed again for Uncanny X-Men in favor of Triage.
  • Internet Backdraft: Whoo boy, DeFilippis/Weir vs. Kyle/Yost. DeFilippis has been known to defend Kyle and Yost from angry fans, for what it's worth.
  • The Scrappy: Icarus. You'd think this would be because of acting like a moron and inadvertently getting himself and half his friends killed in the first Kyle/Yost arc... except nobody much liked him under DeFilippis and Weir, either. Perhaps he still had the stench of the infamous Chuck Austen Uncanny run (the first run to prominently feature him, though he'd been a background Guthrie child in older comics) about him?
  • Strawman Has a Point: Kevin Ford (AKA Wither) is hiding out in a junkyard after accidentally killing his dad with his disintegration abilities. While trying to lay low, he ends up killing the dog belonging to the junkyard's owner. A confrontation ensues, and at the last second, Dani Moonstar rescues Kevin and beats up his attackers. While we're supposed to root for Dani and not the bigoted junkyard owner, it's hard not to sympathize with him given that a mutant just trespassed on his property and killed his innocent pet. And then when Wither decides he doesn't want to stay at the school, after having no on-panel counselling or training to control his powers, and after having to be stopped from deliberately killing someone, Xavier just lets him go on his way. You're supposed to be on Xavier's side for letting a kid choose his own life, but when the kid has already killed someone and his mutant power is dissolving any organic matter he touches, you kind of feel like getting the cops involved might be a good idea, and maybe the pro-registration crowd have a point.
  • Tear Jerker: The funeral issue. Both of them. Heck, the yearbook issue, too, if you know what's coming.
  • The Woobie: Oh boy, does it have several. At the end of Kyle and Yost run you can say all of students are this, having been put through so much their definition of good day is "nobody has been killed or maimed today".
    • Iron Woobie: Pixie, hands down. What she went through with Kyle and Yost was only the start of hell other writers subjecter her to, yet she never loses her smile.
    • Jerkass Woobie: Hellion is a bit of a jerk, even if with heart of gold, but not only DeFilippis and Weir had his parents effectively disinherit him, under Kyle and Yost his life has been turned into endless series of kicks in the face. And then they kicked him even more in X-Force. Surge and Prodigy could also qualify, considering some questionable choices they make in last arcs, that are directly caused by what they've been through before.

YMMVs for Young X-Men:

  • The Scrappy: Ink was hated by many fans. The fact that the writer went to extreme lengths (like, you know, giving him the power of Phoenix) to make him seem important did not go over well with fans, and he also had the stigma of being a human rather than a mutant. Being a Jerk Ass and bizarrely ending up with Emma Frost in a Bad Future also didn't help.
http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/YMMV/NewMutants