* BaseBreaker: Due to Mike's sense of humour, he's either one of the funniest reviewers on TGWTG, or is deeply unfunny or offensive.
* CriticalResearchFailure: If the comments on some of his Youtube videos have anything to go by, he has the tendency to use the items featured on Infomercialism incorrectly or not really getting the main point of the product (Though he creates videos that uses the comments from the original videos and try to debunk the accusations, and some of the suggestions are pretty tame). The most blatant example, however, was the Perfect Slicer review, on which he lambasted it for being such a poor product... while being blissfully ignorant that he was using a cheap plastic knock-off that doesn't even remotely look similar.
** In his 50 Shades of Grey review he seems shocked at the idea of a Dom and sub having a contract, asking "Is that even legal?" It's not legally enforcable, but having a contract to define the terms of the relationship is extremely common in BDSM. In fact, it's one of the few things the movie got more-or-less right.
* CrowningMomentOfHeartwarming:
** When reviewing the Website/ThatGuyWithTheGlasses anniversary specials, he would make a heart with his fingers once [[WebVideo/YouCanPlayThis JewWario]] makes his first appearance.
** When he subjects his cat to the Cat's Meow, she starts to run away in fear. Mike's response is to immediately turn off the (particularly noisy) machine and comfort her.
* EarWorm:
** [[http://thatguywiththeglasses.com/videolinks/teamt/mjtv/specials/31270-english-to-american English to American]].
** [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rhDyqbWhD48 Penis penis penis penis penis penis, bumhole!]] Really, all of Mike's Ditty songs qualify.
* EnsembleDarkhorse: Grace, Mike's wife, has gotten quite popular, especially in the Infomercialism videos.
** Marie, his cat, appeared in only one video. Instantly, she gained everyone's love for being quite vocal and sassy.
* FridgeLogic[=/=]FridgeBrilliance[=/=]FridgeHorror: "Hang On A Second" is dedicated to looking at examples of fridge trope moments in (good) films.
* HeartwarmingInHindsight: Mike was a serious [[TheWoobie woobie]] during his testing of the "Lose a Stone in a Week" diet, having very small portions of very basic food and pretty much starving the whole time. At the end of the last video, he revealed that Grace (who he was engaged to at the time) did the diet with him. At least his fiance was willing to suffer with him.
* HilariousInHindsight:
** He mentions in his TheWickerMan review that it would be better as a comedy, [[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v_mW8mBzmHo&feature=related then somebody posts a recut trailer of the film as if it were a comedy]].
** In his review of ''[[Film/StarWarsEwokAdventures Ewoks: Caravan of Courage]]'', he makes a joke about the Ewoks' dead, unblinking eyes. Five months later, the [[LimitedSpecialCollectorsUltimateEdition Blu-ray edition]] of ''ReturnOfTheJedi'' added CGI blinking for the Ewoks.
** In the review for ''Film/SonOfTheMask'', Mike is shocked to discover that the WebVideo/NostalgiaCritic has reviewed Film/Jaws3D, a movie he has already reviewed. Now the Nostalgia Critic has reviewed ''Film/SonOfTheMask'' as well.
* MemeticMutation: If you look in the comments of any Infomercialism video, you'll most likely find a few people noticing the products and asking Mike to "put your willy in it," including items such as [[{{Squick}} The Ultimate]] [[GroinAttack Chopper.]]
** It's also tradition to point out that Mike is using the product incorrectly (sometimes seriously, but more often than not jokingly), sometimes claiming the need for ridiculous instructions in order for the product to work properly.
** Another similar tradition is to ask Mike if the product works with [[TrademarkFavoriteFood cheese]].
* MostWonderfulSound: "Hello, I'm a British person!"
* NightmareFuel: When he puts on the Rejuvenique.
* SoBadItsGood: His series "Asylum Seeker" is aimed at finding this kind of value in the films of TheAsylum.
** An [[InUniverse Out-of-Universe]] example. The crash scene from ''Our Lips Are Sealed'' is so bad, it's actually kind of funny. [=MikeJ=] rightfully calls it the worst crash scene ever.
* {{Squick}}: In ''Film/{{Piranha}} 3DD'', there's an attractive woman covered in blood and a decapitated head lands in between her boobs. [[AndThatsTerrible It's pretty disturbing]]. What makes it even more disturbing is that it looks like the writers intended it as {{Fanservice}}.
* TheWoobie: Mike during his testing of the "Lose a Stone in a Week", "Baby Food", "Ration Pack", and "Juicing" diets. He spends pretty much the entirety of them looking miserable and pathetic, and you just want to give him a hug.