- Accidental Innuendo: Weenie gives Joey some homemade soup, causing the audience to gasp. They then clarify it's just chicken noodle.
- Audience-Alienating Premise: A college musical about anthropomorphic genitalia that ultimately climaxes in a council of flying vaginas? Even some of the most die hard StarKids have difficulty with this one.
- Big-Lipped Alligator Moment: Even in a show about Anthropomorphic Personifications of genitalia, "Flight of the Pussies" is pretty weird.
- Does This Remind You of Anything?: In this
part of MAMD where three dicks are competing to become Joey's, what Weenie says to Joey really makes it sound as if they're all going to gang-rape him. - Ensemble Dark Horse: The Old Snatch and Joey's Heart. In every single scene, his over the top reaction to everything is endearingly side-splitting.
- Esoteric Happy Ending: Not as bad as some examples, but there's still some moments. Mainly, The Old Snatch leaves Tiffany. Tiffany then adopts Weenie, a penis. This is already pretty weird but to top it off Weenie is now hell bent on revenge against Joey and want to kill him and is controlling the Too Dumb to Live Tiffany who might just listen to him.
- Hilarious in Hindsight: This is a musical about characters talking with their anthropomorphized genitalia. Come 2017, Netflix released Big Mouth, a cartoon about pre-teens talking with anthropomorphized genitalia. Granted, that's the only thing they have in common.
- Apparently Harry in A Very Potter Senior Year was right — if Ron wanted to kiss Ginny he really did just have to ask.
- Dick compares his and Joey's relationship to "Batman and Robin". Considering Dick would go on to play Batman in Holy Musical B@man! and develop a relationship with his own Dick/Robin, this is incredibly amusing.
- Hollywood Homely: Sally. Parodied and discussed:Joey: "She's actually really beautiful. She's not that ugly at all. I don't know where we got this idea of her being a salad from."
- Ho Yay: Joey and Dick. "Me and My Dick" is even a love song between the two of them. Crosses over into Heterosexual Life-Partners since they are both, technically, into girls. It's just that everyone's relationship with their own genitals is, by definition, sexual.
- Retroactive Recognition: Newcomers to this musical seeing Devin Lytle of Buzzfeed's Ladylike as an anthropomorphic talking vagina tend to Freak Out even more than seeing her in A Very Potter Musical as Cho Chang.
