YMMV / Incredible Crew

• Broken Base: Being a live-action show on Cartoon Network gave it one practically by default. That said, general consensus from those that did watch it admitted that it was actually pretty funny but would've been more at home in Nickelodeon's camp (especially considering Nick Cannon was one of the creators).
• Fight Scene Failure: In "Magical Video Game Controller", with a finale of crappy VFX.
• Growing the Beard: Most people who did watch the show stated that it was actually a cut above most kids' sketch shows with some well-written humor (the lack of a laugh track certainly helped), and actually got better as the season went on. However, it got cancelled before it could really reach its full potential.
• Hilarious in Hindsight: One of the sketches in the show is about a boy who gets a new cell phone who somewhat forces him to be its boyfriend. A year after the sketch's debut came the release of the film her, about a guy who falls in love with his computer OS.
• Retroactive Recognition:
  • Shameik Moore ultimately went on to do bigger things in the acting industry, both in animation (as the voice of Miles Morales in Spider-Man: Spider-Verse) and in live-action (as Malcolm Adekanbi in the critical darling Dope).
  • Jeremy Shada, who had been known as the voice of Finn in Adventure Time (which was also on CN at the time) before this, would later go on to voice Lance in Voltron: Legendary Defender as well, among featuring in other smaller roles.
• Special Effect Failure: On more than one occasion. Whether or not it was invoked is up for you to decide.
• Suspiciously Similar Song: The "Reading is Fun" song has the exact same melody as "Dance Away" from Project A-Ko. It goes past the point of being "suspiciously similar" to straight up being the same exact song with different lyrics.

---