WMG regarding the character of Prussia goes here.
- Actually, Brandenburg still exists as a federal state of Germany. This just brings the mental image of Prussia and Brandenburg hanging out in Germany's basement. The marriage aspect still works, however.
- Unlikely. Official government sources from both Cuba and Germany have shown that the island was never transferred to East Germany, merely renamed Ernst Thalmann's honor.
- They exist in name only.
- This may have been helped along by Word of God, which stated that Prussia feels more like an enclave rather than a nation these days, and that he was stuck doing dead-end jobs. Maybe he was split between Kaliningrad and East Germany? Since there's still a feeling of "East-German-ness" in those parts of Germany, maybe that's how he was living on into 2009? He was living with Germany anyway since the days of the German Empire, so it could work...
- Recently, I read an article about how a significant portion of Germans (from both sides) actually want Germany to redivide for economic reasons. So.....
- Just a bit of explanation for people who don't understand the whole "want to divide" thing. The Russians ran East Germany into the ground (a long occupation, isolation, and a healthy dose of communism tends to do that...), and the economy was essentially completely destroyed because of it. It was bolstered back up after the Berlin Wall came down, but East Germany is still lagging well behind its Western half and requires a great deal of aid. Germany is an economic superpower, but nowhere near what it could be considering it's carrying around the crutch that is its recently-liberated section. This is on top of the fact that, due to the roughly 40 years apart, the two populations are different in basically everything (political beliefs, lifestyle, etc.), and it's a common thing to speak about them as separate entities. It really wouldn't be that much of a shock for them to indeed split. TL;DR version: Communism sucks in practice, and it's completely plausible that Prussia will get yet another name change.
- So essentially, Germany wants to kick Prussia out of his basement?
- More evidence for this theory in the new game in Himayura's page:
Prussia: I'm done cleaning the library!Germany: You really needn't have bothered, nii-san. I can do that much by myself. Since the unification until now I've done everything by myself. This kind of thing is no problem for me. - Recently, I read an article about how a significant portion of Germans (from both sides) actually want Germany to redivide for economic reasons. So.....
- I found a pretty good headcanon somewhere (will post the source when I find it) which theorized that Prussia was sentenced to die after dissolution, but when Germany learned about this, he felt compelled to save his bro (and probably also felt indebted to him since Prussia shaped a lot of German history) and make an agreement to split his land up into two: West and East, with Prussia taking the East, so that he'd still somehow live. Probably not historically accurate, but it seems plausible.
East and West Germany are still quite distinct, despite not being seperate states. Prussia has at least as much of a separate existence as South Italy.
- Poor Canada...Oi oi, North!
- That's the reason why he likes maple syrup.
- Conversely, he lives on as a Carribean Island. His association with Canada is through their mutual buddy, Cuba.
- Maybe the Reichtangle is Prussia's true form?
- Except that he's been an albino-esque character since his childhood, when Prussia was very much going strong. Even later, he has the red-white color scheme during the brief depiction of the Austrian Succession, which was again while Prussia would have been very much alive.
- I would quote if I could find it, but the Word of God is that in the modern era he spends his time running around Europe and bumming off Germany and Austria (basically in a nod to how the region that was once West Germany is still having to work hard and support what used to be East Germany). Germany and Prussia do in fact interact, and with others in the room who would point out if Germany was speaking to himself (Prussia's drama CD). But, beyond that, Prussia is a pretty isolated character if only because of his own stubbornness. It's not out of character for him not to be interacting much (honestly, if he'd been someplace like the Meeting of the World, I would have put that more in the O.o.C. category. He's not really the diplomatic type; and if he did go I'm sure he probably would have gotten bored and left quickly).
- And, beyond that, Prussia in the modern era is shown interacting with England, France, Austria, and Italy (among others). All four of them are very well acquainted with both Germany and Prussia, all four of them are not known for holding their tongues to spare another's feelings, and at least one most certainly would have said something were this Germany rather than Prussia.
- Prussia and his later incarnation (presumably) East Germany ceased to exist years ago, so how does he still exist in the modern day? Simple: what has Prussia always has, and still does, claim to be?
- Prussia's claims to be awesome and invincible are mostly about him convincing himself of it, though. Especially in the more-modern eras, as he loses his power and place in the world, he's just trying to keep himself from breaking down completely by assuring himself of his own worth and that his old principles are still valid (note any time he talks about 'tears welling up'). If Prussia truly represents awesome, does that mean that being awesome is nothing but a series of delusions to protect self-esteem?
- That explains how he survived. Since Berlin was the capital of Prussia, it would make sense if Gilbert becomes a German state along with Saxony and Bavaria.
- Problem with that, though... The states don't really get personified in the canon (it's exclusively a fan-thing, I believe, to show something like that). So, if Prussia is simply a state, why would he still be displayed within the main cast? Wouldn't he fall into the same spot as Brandenburg, Saxony, and Bavaria (to simply list German examples, though we could say this for places like the US, China, UK, etc., as well), who are not shown? It's a better bet to say that he's East Germany, as the division between the two is noticeable enough for people to identify themselves as something different.
- There are characters for Saxony and Bavaria that appear briefly as background characters and in footnotes, but it's debatable if they're still kicking around in the series or not after their assimilation into Germany. But if Prussia is still around, perhaps it's not too much of a stretch to assume that they're living in some capacity too. Brandenburg? Beats me.
- They're background characters, yes, but the sketch in question was from a historical period where they were both countries (or, rather, as close to countries as any of them were in those days). There's been no sign of them otherwise.
- It appears that they might (key: might) still be hanging around, if Prussia's words in the recently-released Kuso-game are to be believed. In addition to them, other brothers get referenced.
- Problem with that, though... The states don't really get personified in the canon (it's exclusively a fan-thing, I believe, to show something like that). So, if Prussia is simply a state, why would he still be displayed within the main cast? Wouldn't he fall into the same spot as Brandenburg, Saxony, and Bavaria (to simply list German examples, though we could say this for places like the US, China, UK, etc., as well), who are not shown? It's a better bet to say that he's East Germany, as the division between the two is noticeable enough for people to identify themselves as something different.
- He's stated that he doesn't have a body in his character CD. While this can be interpreted as him simply not having a country to attach himself to, it's also likely that he literally doesn't have a biological body. It could have dissolved (so to speak) after the German reunification, although it probably started fading in and out of existence starting with the dissolution of Prussia after World War II. He's not dead, though, and he still retains consciousness; he just can't interact with the physical place like he used to.
- The "no body" statement was actually in a fan-made version of Maru Kaite Chikyuu, it doesn't appear in any official song. However, the idea of poltergeist Prussia is too amusing, or rather a Prussia that only THINKS he's a ghost and tries (and fails since he's not quite dead) to haunt others "awesomely".
- That is too epic not to exist, someone has to write it.
- Well, here's a fanart of ghost!Prussia.
- The "no body" statement was actually in a fan-made version of Maru Kaite Chikyuu, it doesn't appear in any official song. However, the idea of poltergeist Prussia is too amusing, or rather a Prussia that only THINKS he's a ghost and tries (and fails since he's not quite dead) to haunt others "awesomely".
- Prussia grew out of the Margraviate of Brandenburg, and Potsdam was its base of power even though Berlin had been its capital. While this would prevent a challenge for the times when the two were separate, it is possible that there was originally a separate Brandenburg-tan as well. They might have faded after the union of Brandenburg-Prussia, or they faded with being dissolved after WWII as well. Nowadays, it is Gilbo who is Brandenburg as some consider it to be the remnant of Prussia.
- Appears to be Jossed now; Kuso-game refers to Brandenburg and Prussia as separate elder brothers of Germany.
- If this is actually the case, then said ego is at least partly justified. You have to admit, surviving on willpower alone is pretty awesome.
- Or perhaps he's become the personification of everything AWESOME.
- It's quite possible that Gilbert is both the German Empire and Prussia, the same way Arthur is both the United Kingdom and England or how Sadik is both the Ottoman Empire and Turkey.
- History itself would back this. The kingdom of Prussia made of two thirds of the German Empire, and the Emperor of Germany was also the King of Prussia per the constitution.
- As a modification of that idea, Prussia and Germany are like two halves of a single German whole. Prussia is the militaristic Blood Knight half, rooted in his origins from the Teutonic Knights. Germany is the peaceful cultured half, only fighting because he has to. The current mindset of the German nation determines which one is the leader. Assuming that Ludwig is indeed descended from the Holy Roman Empire he probably started out weak as the German Confederation, under the joint custody of Prussia and Austria. After the Revolutions of 1848 ignited pan-German nationalism he became the ideal of a united Germany, growing older and more robust. Eventually Prussia and Austria got sick of sharing so they went to war over their little brother in 1867. Prussia emerged victorious and began plotting a way to make Ludwig even more awesome. France, determined to stop this from happening, tried to beat the brothers up but failed miserably. The resulting foundation of the German Empire made Ludwig into the nation-tan we see today although Gilbert was still the older brother in the relationship, based on Prussia's historical domination of the Empire. The reason Ludwig was on the Italian front during WWI was because Prussia was fighting the main battle against England and France in the west. After WWI Ludwig became the senior brother as Prussia's influence declined under the non-militaristic Weimar Republic. When the Nazis took over later Prussia (in the form of the Junkers generals), eager to start fighting again, convinced his brother that it was a good idea to take over Europe and once more took the lead, explaining why Ludwig is so hesitant to talk about WWII, as he was basically led by the nose into committing atrocities. After their second defeat the two brothers were split into the Federal Republic of Germany and the German Democratic Republic, monitored by the West and Russia respectively. Once the two were reunified Ludwig took over again as the lead brother. However, one day, should crisis again befall Germany, Prussia in all of his awesome glory may again return to the forefront.
- Supporting that theory is The Blood and Iron speech. I mean just look at Prussia: The Steel-color hair, Blood-color eyes, and Prussia being the predecessor of the very foundations of Germanic Efficiency. When the German peoples need to take up arms again, they will call on the will of Blood and Iron.
Whatever it is that decides when a nation-tan is going to die seems to know when a country is gone for good and when it's going to return. If they started to die as soon as their nation stopped existing, then we wouldn't still be on the original Poland. So the nation Prussia is going to return somehow.
I realise that this theory depends somewhat on Himaruya being clairvoyent... but why not?
- This might not be so farfetched. After all, it's been said that East Germany still has a different culture from West Germany, due to living under communism, as well as other factors. Maybe they re-separate into two countries, and the East renames itself Prussia? Then, all they have to do is put the Hohenzollern pretender on the throne...
- Actually, it returned as a reconstituted free state of Prussia. So, not a nation, exactly, but given Himaruya's recent micronation spree (Sealand, Seborga, Wy...) it's pretty plausible.
- So, with the wide-embracing of atheism in East Germany, in the modern era he should be racing to lose it.
Before and during WWII, Hitler centralized Germany as much as he could, removing many of the special rights as he could from German states and cities. For example, Austria ("Österreich" meaning "Eastern Realm") became "Östmark" (meaning Eastern March), basically making it a simple area of Germany and attempting to remove any aspects of a separate Austrian identity. Prussia was another one of the hardest hit, and lost pretty much every right he had as the Kingdom of Prussia within Germany, and later the Free State of Prussia with the Weimar Republic. At the end of WWII, the Allies were set to make this de facto status official, and also disassembled Prussia's body, giving much of it to Poland and Russia. Prussia likely would have died, his people and land (the Russian occupation zone) becoming part of Germany...
However, Russia, not wanting to play nice and deciding instead to not completely reunify Germany as a Federal Republic, declared "We Can Rebuild Him!!!" *Slasher Smile*
Thus, the Russian occupied zone was reconstituted as the German Democratic Republic (GDR). This is represented by having Russia perform some seriously disturbing surgery on Prussia, giving his land and people a new country, but also integrating as much Soviet philosophy, government, doctrine, technology, and culture as he possibly could. This, combined with the fact that Russia annexed historical East Prussia (Kaliningrad), resulted in Robo!Prussia. Robo!Prussia remained a loyal Soviet underling for decades before the USSR collapsed. This, of course, allowed Gilbert to reunify with his brother, although his continued robotic existence kept him somewhat separate from his brother (read: Ostalgie). However, Russia still has control of the Kaliningrad region (which acts as a type of remote control). He simply awaits the best moment to... make use of it.
The personification of Kaliningrad, the Soviet ace-in-the-hole? ... GILBIRD
- He still lives with his brother because America didn't feel like putting up with him.
- Or Prussia, IA, or New Prussia, ON... There are a lot of places.
- Considering how vicious the knights were, and how vicious Prussia eventually became, it's likely Prussia killed the older nation and took its name.
- It should actually be noted that, as he did indeed NOT start off as an actual country, he came into being as the Teutonic Order, which still exists to this day. It might be safe to say that is the actual reason he is still alive
- I should also note the Teutonic Order still exists. And even has a website.
- My headcanon is this is one of his deaths... yes I know he doesn't look a thing like him... see the below entry?
- I second this.
- That could also explain why Prussia is always hanging around or 'bothering' Germany. The Holocaust is STILL happening and he's trying to get Germany to remember that the Holocaust IS still happening even though he isn't in the country very often (or tell him, going off on whatever Germany theory you like, like him not knowing he's a nazi yet).
- Going off of this, Prussia is the one who told Himaruya about the nation-tans in the first place. The only reason he took so long to appear is that he knew if he was the star or even just one of the leads, other -tans would suspect and his plan to survive would be ruined. So he made it Italy because if it had to be someone else, at least it's cute little Italy. (II'm pretty sure he thinks Italy's cute in canon, I think it's in one of the Drama CDs?)
- Corollary; Gilbird is his hat.
AH! but why Assassins creed you may ask? Given the plot in assassins creed, (and the fact that creed 3 takes place during the American revolution) it is entirely possible for some one to stumble across a nation tan in the past using the Animus, and then find the still living nation.
Prussia's cleaning game and a comment from the author both confirm that the germanic states that were united to birth Germany were Prussia's older siblings. That would also make Austria Prussia's older sibling. So why is it never commented on and why does he torment Austria at every chance? Because Prussia started out as less than a nation. He was just an order of german knights who clawed and scratched his way into nationhood, first as a recognized military state, then as a dukedom, and finally a kingdom in his own right. But Austria, his big brother, never gave him the recognition or praise he felt he had earned for all of his hard work, so Prussia conquered and unified the rest of the Germanic states and left Austria out of it out of spite, and decided that he'd be a better big brother to Germany than Austria ever was to him.