- "Seven o'Clock News/Silent Night". There's just something in the juxtaposition of the calm and peaceful melody and all the violence in the news report.
- Just stop and really pay attention the next time you hear "The Sound of Silence".
- Even better is the original version.
- "Bridge over Troubled Water" can absolutely kill some people (not literally), as do the beautiful cover versions by Eva Cassidy and Roberta Flack.
- "Scarborough Fair/Canticle" becomes really depressing when you listen to the lyrics and realize what it actually says. Sarah Brightman's version is particularly haunting.
- "Old Friends/Bookends" can bring a tear to many a person's eye — and, as time goes on and he keeps getting older, it just gets sadder and sadder.
Preserve your memories,
They're all that's left you.
- "He Was My Brother", made worse by the fact that it's based on a true story.
- "The Boxer".
- "For Emily, Whenever I May Find Her", especially the version found in their 1972 Greatest Hits album.
- "The Sun Is Burning".
- "Sparrow." My God, "Sparrow."
- "April Come She Will"
- "My Little Town"
- Their version of Daniel Robles "El Condor Pasa".
- "The Only Living Boy in New York," another autobiographical song.
- Their cover of Jackson C. Frank's "Blues Run the Game" manages to out-sad the original, which is no mean feat.
- Not to mention Garfunkel's solo tune "Bright Eyes", from the Watership Down soundtrack.
- The last verse of "A Most Peculiar Man":
He died last SaturdayWith the windows closed, so he'd never wake upto a silent world in his tiny roomAnd Mrs Riordon says he has a brother somewhere, who should be notified soonAnd all the people said"What a shame that he's dead, butWasn't he a most peculiar man?
- "I am a Rock"
Don't talk of loveWell, I've heard the word beforeIt's sleeping in my memoryI won't disturb the slumber of the feelings that have diedIf I'd never loved I never would have criedI am a rockI am an island.
"Kathy, I'm lost," I said,
Though I knew she was sleeping.
I'm empty and aching and I don't know why.
- "Richard Cory," where the narrator still desperately wants to be the rich titular character even after Richard Cory kills himself.
He freely gave to charity, he had the common touch,And they were grateful for his patronage and thanked him very much,So my mind was filled with wonder when the evening headlines read:"Richard Cory went home last night and put a bullet through his head."But I work in his factoryAnd I curse the life I'm livingAnd I curse my povertyAnd I wish that I could be,Oh, I wish that I could be,Oh, I wish that I could beRichard Cory.
Tear Jerker / Simon & Garfunkel
The music (and harmony vocals) of Simon & Garfunkel is often considered to be so hauntingly beautiful, much of their output can really move one to tears.