Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Recap / StarTrekDeepSpaceNineS01E15Progress

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
trope was cut/disambiguated due to cleanup


*** Hydroelectric power doesn't always require [[JustForPun damn big dams]] on a river. Alternatives can best be described as "windmills under water," whether that water is a river or the ocean. Speaking of windmills...

to:

*** Hydroelectric power doesn't always require [[JustForPun damn big dams]] dams on a river. Alternatives can best be described as "windmills under water," whether that water is a river or the ocean. Speaking of windmills...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* SciFiWritersHaveNoSenseOfScale:
** [[TheNewTwenties Nowadays]], powering a few hundred thousand homes wouldn't require tapping the core of the planet, there are several alternatives offered by late 20[[superscript:th]]/early 21[[superscript:st]] century technology. Imagine how much the technology would improve between now and 2370.
*** Geothermal power plants would work just fine without causing any ecological desolation. Iceland[[note]]pop. 325,000+[[/note]] already gets most of its power this way. There's also the added bonus of essentially free heat for many homes, as well.
*** Solar power can be used for heating[[labelnote:really!]]Don't believe it? Fill a black container with water and leave it out in the sun for a while, then see what happens if you try to drink it[[/labelnote]] ''and'' power. In 300 years there would probably be the technology to put huge solar satellites in orbit that would transmit the power to the surface.
*** Hydroelectric power doesn't always require [[JustForPun damn big dams]] on a river. Alternatives can best be described as "windmills under water," whether that water is a river or the ocean. Speaking of windmills...
*** Wind power. If there's an atmosphere, there's wind.
*** Ocean Thermal Energy Conversion. Familiar to players of [[VideoGame/SidMeiersAlphaCentauri Sid Meier's Alien Crossfire]] as the Thermocline Transducer, these devices abuse the sharp temperature differential in water on either sides of a layer called the thermocline. Combine that with the [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thermoelectric_effect thermoelectric effect]] and you've got instant power anywhere the ocean is deep enough.
*** Not to mention fusion energy which is firmly established as being in Bajor and the Federation's tech[[note]]They say present-day Earth is still about 15 years away from fusion power, [[ModernStasis and has been since the Seventies]].[[/note]] and is clean as well.
** On another note, the notion that an habitable, albeit inhospitable, moon orbiting a heavily-populated, warp-capable planet would only have fifty people living on it is pretty difficult to swallow. If UsefulNotes/TheMoon had a biosphere and Earth-like gravity, we'd probably have colonized it [[UsefulNotes/TheSpaceRace back in the sixties]]. Even if you assume that the Cardassians drove most of the population away, one has to wonder why the Cardassians didn't colonize it themselves.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



* BrokenAesop: Subverted. At first it seems the [[AnAesop Aesop]] of the story is that Mullibok's rebellion against the Bajoran government is just as valid as Kira's rebellion against the Cardassian occupation was, even though she was fighting against genocidal tyrants, while he is fighting against something that will benefit hundreds of thousands of Bajorans. However, in the end the real Aesop is that Kira has to learn, against her instincts as a former freedom fighter, that sometimes the right thing to do is to side with the authority against the rebel.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SherlockCanRead: At first, it seems that O'Brien knows about self-sealing stembolts. But then O'Brien admits that he has never heard of them, and the only reason he even knew what the the cargo was is because he read it on a manifest pad.

to:

* SherlockCanRead: At first, it seems that O'Brien knows about self-sealing stembolts. But then O'Brien admits that he has never heard of them, and the only reason he even knew what the the cargo was is because he read it on a manifest pad.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
added Sherlock Can Read

Added DiffLines:

* SherlockCanRead: At first, it seems that O'Brien knows about self-sealing stembolts. But then O'Brien admits that he has never heard of them, and the only reason he even knew what the the cargo was is because he read it on a manifest pad.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Moved "Spiritual Successor" to YMMV tab


* SpiritualSuccessor: The episode is essentially a rehash of "[[Recap/StarTrekTheNextGenerationS3E2TheEnsignsOfCommand The Ensigns of Command]]." In both episodes, settlers have had the rights to their home taken away from them without their say to benefit the greater good. A main character must try to convince them to leave, but they insist on staying even though remaining would be a death sentence. Ultimately, the main character destroys a prized construction to force the settlers' hand.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* EarlyInstallmentWeirdness: Why is ''Jake'' the one having to convince ''Nog'' to work through a ChainOfDeals to make a profit when Nog is disgruntled at not being able to get Latinum upfront? Later episodes (particularly [[Recap/StarTrekDeepSpaceNineS07E06TreacheryFaithAndTheGreatRiver "Treachery, Faith, and the Great River"]]) would establish Ferengi (including Nog) as expert ''traders,'' not just aliens with a MoneyFetish.

to:

* EarlyInstallmentWeirdness: Why is ''Jake'' the one having to convince ''Nog'' to work through a ChainOfDeals to make a profit when Nog is disgruntled at not being able to get Latinum upfront? Later episodes (particularly [[Recap/StarTrekDeepSpaceNineS07E06TreacheryFaithAndTheGreatRiver "Treachery, Faith, and the Great River"]]) would establish Ferengi (including (especially Nog) as expert ''traders,'' not just aliens with a MoneyFetish.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The old man tells her four the thousandth time that as long as his home is there, that's where he's staying. In response, Kira phasers the newly-built kiln and torches his house, leaving him nowhere to return. He asks her to kill him too, but she refuses, saying she won't let him. The episode ends with her preparing to beam Mullibok and herself off the moon.

to:

The old man tells her four for the thousandth time that as long as his home is there, that's where he's staying. In response, Kira phasers the newly-built kiln and torches his house, leaving him nowhere to return. He asks her to kill him too, but she refuses, saying she won't let him. The episode ends with her preparing to beam Mullibok and herself off the moon.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SpiritualSuccessor: The episode is essentially a rehash of "[[Recap/StarTrekTheNextGenerationS3E2TheEnsignsOfCommand The Ensigns of Command]]." In both episodes, an officer comes to a remote settlement and must convince the settlers to leave their hard-fought home to make way for interests that are larger than them. Ultimately, both officers destroy a prized construction to force the settlers' hand.

to:

* SpiritualSuccessor: The episode is essentially a rehash of "[[Recap/StarTrekTheNextGenerationS3E2TheEnsignsOfCommand The Ensigns of Command]]." In both episodes, an officer comes settlers have had the rights to a remote settlement and their home taken away from them without their say to benefit the greater good. A main character must try to convince the settlers them to leave their hard-fought home to make way for interests that are larger than them. leave, but they insist on staying even though remaining would be a death sentence. Ultimately, both officers destroy the main character destroys a prized construction to force the settlers' hand.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TrashTheSet: The episode ends with Kira destroying Mullibok's kiln and torching his house.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SpiritualSuccessor: The episode is essentially a rehash of "[[Recap/StarTrekTheNextGenerationS3E2TheEnsignsOfCommand The Ensigns of Command]]." In both episodes, an officer comes to a remote settlement and must convince the settlers to leave their hard-fought home to make way for interests that are larger than them. Ultimately, both officers destroy a prized construction to convince the settlers to leave.

to:

* SpiritualSuccessor: The episode is essentially a rehash of "[[Recap/StarTrekTheNextGenerationS3E2TheEnsignsOfCommand The Ensigns of Command]]." In both episodes, an officer comes to a remote settlement and must convince the settlers to leave their hard-fought home to make way for interests that are larger than them. Ultimately, both officers destroy a prized construction to convince force the settlers to leave.settlers' hand.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* SpiritualSuccessor: The episode is essentially a rehash of "[[Recap/StarTrekTheNextGenerationS3E2TheEnsignsOfCommand The Ensigns of Command]]." In both episodes, an officer comes to a remote settlement and must convince the settlers to leave their hard-fought home to make way for interests that are larger than them. Ultimately, both officers destroy a prized construction to convince the settlers to leave.

Changed: 3099

Removed: 531

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


While playing cards in the corner of Quark's, Nog overhears Quark flipping his lid over being stuck with 5000 wrappages of Yamok sauce; a seasoning only Cardassians can stomach. While Quark is peeved at having to write these off as a loss, Nog spies an opportunity.

to:

While playing cards in the corner of Quark's, Nog overhears Quark flipping his lid over being stuck with 5000 5,000 wrappages of Yamok sauce; a seasoning only Cardassians can stomach. While Quark is peeved at having to write these off as a loss, Nog spies an opportunity.



Back on [=DS9=], Nog and Jake attempt to sell their stock of Yamok sauce to an alien freighter captain who deals with Cardassians. He turns down the purchase, but offers an exchange: 14400 self-sealing stem bolts which were set to be purchased by a Bajoran who was short on cash. Nog isn't too thrilled about not getting any latinum, but Jake convinces him to agree. He promptly acquires Quark's allegedly worthless supply of Yamok sauce for the trade, Quark being content that someone else is doing the legwork disposing of it for him.

to:

Back on [=DS9=], Nog and Jake attempt to sell their stock of Yamok sauce to an alien freighter captain who deals with Cardassians. He turns down the purchase, purchase but offers an exchange: 14400 14,400 self-sealing stem bolts which that were set to be purchased by a Bajoran who was short on cash. Nog isn't too thrilled about not getting any latinum, but Jake convinces him to agree. He promptly acquires Quark's allegedly worthless supply of Yamok sauce for the trade, Quark being content that someone else is doing the legwork disposing of it for him.



Mullibok starts telling tall tales about how he came to start farming on Jeraddo. Such as digging with his bare hands, and crushing mineralized dirt with his teeth. Kira decides to share her stories of the resistance in turn. When Mullibok makes light of the occupation, Kira is indignant, explaining that the only reason they weren't wiped out was that they were "hanging on like fanatics." Much to her dismay, she realizes her resistance cell's attitude is much like Mulllibok's; and he's still not moving.

Nog and Jake inspect their supply of self-sealing stem bolts, only to realize they have no idea what they do. Even [[MrFixit O'Brien]] has never heard of these things before. Stuck with a huge crate of mysterious parts, Jake and Nog (Under the alias of the "Noh-Jay Consortium") contact the intended recipient.

He still doesn't have the cash, but offers yet another exchange: seven tessipates of land on Bajor. Nog isn't thrilled about getting dirt and no money, but Jake once again convinces him the land is a worthwhile acquisition.

Returning to [=DS9=], Kira tries convincing the Government to stall or use slower methods, but they're having none of it. Three people aren't worth depriving several hundred thousands of power. Kira is informed that the project is happening, whether or not Mullibok leaves.

Returning to his cottage with security, Kira again tries convincing him to leave. But the situation goes FUBAR when Mullibok's mute associates attack the security team. Mullibok loses it and tries strangling the security member, forcing the other to shoot him.

He survives, but ''still'' won't move. After Bashir treats his injuries, Kira stays behind to look after him and talk him into leaving.

Sisko visits her on Jerrado, and manages to uncover why Kira is so adamant about helping him: She's been in his position before: a much-trampled underdog at the mercy of powerful government forces. He assures her she's on the right side, that Bajor needs her, and leaves her to come up with a solution to the impasse.

While brooding in their usual corner, Jake and Nog overhear their big break: The Bajoran Government is trying to build on a strip of land owned by four different interests. They've been able to close the deal with three of the owners, but the mysterious "Noh-Jay Consortium" is impossible to reach. Nog reveals he and Jake are said consortium, and offers his uncle a very lucrative business opportunity; for a mere 5 bars of gold-pressed latinum, of course.

Returning again to Mullibok, Kira helps him finish a kiln he's been working on... and then says, now that it's done, it's time to leave. She's issuing her ultimatum: Mullibok is coming with her, whether he likes it or not.

The old man tells her that as long as his home is there, that's where he's staying. In response, Kira phasers the newly-built kiln and torches his house, leaving him nowhere to return. He asks her to kill him too, but she refuses; the episode ends with her preparing to beam Mullibok and herself off the moon.

to:

Mullibok starts telling tall tales about how he came to start farming on Jeraddo. Such Jeraddo, such as digging with his bare hands, and crushing mineralized dirt with his teeth. Kira decides to share her stories of the resistance in turn. When Mullibok makes light of the occupation, Kira is indignant, explaining that the only reason they weren't wiped out was that they were "hanging on like fanatics." Much to her dismay, she realizes her resistance cell's attitude is much like Mulllibok's; Mulllibok's, and he's still not moving.

Nog and Jake inspect their supply of self-sealing stem bolts, only to realize they have no idea what they do. Even [[MrFixit O'Brien]] has never heard of these things before. Stuck with a huge crate of mysterious parts, Jake and Nog (Under (under the alias of the "Noh-Jay Consortium") contact the intended recipient.

recipient. He still doesn't have the cash, cash but offers yet another exchange: seven tessipates of land on Bajor. Nog isn't thrilled about getting dirt and no money, but Jake once again convinces him the land is a worthwhile acquisition.

Returning to [=DS9=], Kira tries convincing the Government government to stall or use slower methods, but they're having none of it. Three people aren't worth depriving several hundred thousands of power. Kira is informed that the project is happening, whether or not Mullibok leaves.

Returning to his cottage with security, Kira again tries convincing him to leave. But the situation goes FUBAR when Mullibok's mute associates attack the security team. Mullibok loses it and tries strangling the security member, forcing the other to shoot him.

him. He survives, but ''still'' won't move. After Bashir treats his injuries, Kira stays behind to look after him and talk him into leaving.

Sisko visits her on Jerrado, Jerrado and manages to uncover why Kira is so adamant about helping him: She's been in his position before: a much-trampled underdog at the mercy of powerful government forces. He assures her she's on the right side, that Bajor needs her, and leaves her to come up with a solution to the impasse.

While brooding in their usual corner, Jake and Nog overhear their big break: The Bajoran Government is trying to build on a strip of land owned by four different interests. They've been able to close the deal with three of the owners, but the mysterious "Noh-Jay Consortium" is impossible to reach. Nog reveals he and Jake are said consortium, that consortium and offers his uncle a very lucrative business opportunity; opportunity, for a mere 5 bars of gold-pressed latinum, of course.

Returning again to Mullibok, Kira helps him finish a kiln he's been working on... on and then says, now that it's done, it's time to leave. She's issuing her ultimatum: bringing this episode to a conclusion whether Mullibok is coming with her, whether he likes it or not.

The old man tells her four the thousandth time that as long as his home is there, that's where he's staying. In response, Kira phasers the newly-built kiln and torches his house, leaving him nowhere to return. He asks her to kill him too, but she refuses; the refuses, saying she won't let him. The episode ends with her preparing to beam Mullibok and herself off the moon.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Recap Pages shouldn't spoil things that happen after the recapped episode.


* {{Foreshadowing}}: This episode would seem to lay the groundwork for Nog's abilities as an expert wartime scrounge once he becomes a member of Starfleet.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


'''Kira''': No, no. I want to hear who won.

to:

'''Kira''': No, no. [[DidYouDie I want to hear who won.won]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TheMunchausen: Mullibok, on occasion. He likes to tell fantastic stories about how he overpowered the entire crew of a Cardassian ship while escaping to Jeraddo (well, there ''were'' only six of them...) and how he plowed the fields of what became his farm using only his fingernails. Of course, Kira doesn't buy a word of it, but she finds it entertaining.
-->'''Mullibok''': So once again starvation and I were staring each other in the face. I'm not boring you?\\
'''Kira''': No, no. I want to hear who won.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
So Proud of You

Added DiffLines:

* SoProudOfYou: [[ImpliedTrope Implied]] with Quark toward Nog when he realizes that his nephew and Jake are the "Noh-Jay Consortium" in possession of a parcel of land wanted by the Bajoran government.

Added: 4

Changed: 29

Removed: 52

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
moving to Development Gag


!!Tropes:

* The47Society: 47 people have already left Jerrado.

to:

!!Tropes:

* The47Society: 47 people have already left Jerrado.
!!"Progress" provides examples of:



* TheVoiceless: Mullibok's two farmer friends. All we know is [[NoodleIncident "The Cardassians saw to that."]]

to:

* TheVoiceless: Mullibok's two farmer friends. All we know is [[NoodleIncident "The Cardassians saw to that."]]"]]
----

Added: 143

Changed: 6

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


While playing cards in the corner of Quarks, Nog overhears Quark flipping his lid over being stuck with 5000 wrappages of Yamok sauce; a seasoning only Cardassians can stomach. While Quark is peeved at having to write these off as a loss, Nog spies an opportunity.

to:

While playing cards in the corner of Quarks, Quark's, Nog overhears Quark flipping his lid over being stuck with 5000 wrappages of Yamok sauce; a seasoning only Cardassians can stomach. While Quark is peeved at having to write these off as a loss, Nog spies an opportunity.



Mullibok starts telling tall tales about how he came to start farming on Jeraddo. Such as digging with his bare hands, and crushing mineralized dirt with his teeth. Kira decides to share her stories of the resistance with in turn. When Mullibok makes light of the occupation, Kira is indignant, explaining that the only reason they weren't wiped out was that they were "hanging on like fanatics." Much to her dismay, she realizes her resistance cell's attitude is much like Mulllibok's; and he's still not moving.

to:

Mullibok starts telling tall tales about how he came to start farming on Jeraddo. Such as digging with his bare hands, and crushing mineralized dirt with his teeth. Kira decides to share her stories of the resistance with in turn. When Mullibok makes light of the occupation, Kira is indignant, explaining that the only reason they weren't wiped out was that they were "hanging on like fanatics." Much to her dismay, she realizes her resistance cell's attitude is much like Mulllibok's; and he's still not moving.


Added DiffLines:

* InsultBackfire:
-->'''Sisko:''' You know, you're causing a lot of trouble.
-->'''Mullibok:''' I can't tell you how delighted I am to hear that.

Added: 269

Removed: 253

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FantasticMeasurementSystem: Jake and Nog at one point acquire seven "tessipates" of land. Even in-universe they have no idea how big a plot that is, but since the buyer is the only person who knows what the stembolts they have to trade even ''are'' they roll with it.



* {{Microts}}: Jake and Nog at one point aquire seven "tessipates" of land. Even in-universe they have no idea how big a plot that is, but since the buyer is the only person who knows what the stembolts they have to trade even ''are'' they roll with it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* {{Microts}}: Jake and Nog at one point aquire seven "tessipates" of land. Even in-universe they have no idea how big a plot that is, but since the buyer is the only person who knows what the stembolts they have to trade even ''are'' they roll with it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* EarlyInstallmentWeirdness: Why is ''Jake'' the one having to convince ''Nog'' to work through a ChainOfDeals to make a profit when Nog is disgruntled at not being able to get Latinum upfront? Later episodes (particularly [[Recap/StarTrekDeepSpaceNineS07E06TreacheryFaithAndTheGreatRiver "Treachery, Faith, and the Great River"]]) would establish Ferengi (including Nog) as expert ''traders,'' not just aliens with a MoneyFetish.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* {{Foreshadowing}}: This episode would seem to lay the groundwork for Nog's abilities as an expert wartime scrounge once he becomes a member of Starfleet.
* JerkWithAHeartOfGold: This episode highlights just how belligerent Quark can be with his brother... and several times shows just how kind he often is to his nephew, at one point calming himself down purely so he can tell Nog "You're a good boy."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ReversePsychology: Mullibok has a habit of driving off people by annoying them with long-winded anecdotes. When Sisko expresses interest in one of Mullibok's stories, however, Mullibok chooses not to bother with it.

Changed: 211

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Returning again to Mullibok, Kira helps him finish a kiln he's been working on... and promptly blasts it with her phaser. Driven by necessity, she's issuing her ultimatum: Mullibok is coming with her, whether he likes it or not.

The old man tells her that as long as his home is there, that's where he's staying. In response, Kira likewise phasers his house, leaving him nowhere to return. Persuaded at last, he has no choice but to agree with her that it's time to move on, and the episode ends with her preparing to beam Mullibok and herself off the moon.

to:

Returning again to Mullibok, Kira helps him finish a kiln he's been working on... and promptly blasts it with her phaser. Driven by necessity, she's then says, now that it's done, it's time to leave. She's issuing her ultimatum: Mullibok is coming with her, whether he likes it or not.

The old man tells her that as long as his home is there, that's where he's staying. In response, Kira likewise phasers the newly-built kiln and torches his house, leaving him nowhere to return. Persuaded at last, he has no choice He asks her to kill him too, but to agree with her that it's time to move on, and she refuses; the episode ends with her preparing to beam Mullibok and herself off the moon.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* KavorkaMan: Dax mentions that Morn tried to ask her out. This is the first mention that he's more than just a permanent fixture at Quark's.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* MadeOfIncendium: Kira barely has to touch Mullibok's house with a lit torch to set it to burning merrily.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* PlotHole[=/=]SciFiWritersHaveNoSenseOfScale: As observed by Website/StarDestroyerDotNet [[http://stardestroyer.net/Empire/Database/Query-ST.php?Series=DS9&Category=Realism&EpName=Progress&Keywords=&Quotes=&Analysis=&Submit=Submit here]]. Hmm, Bajor's got an electrical power shortage calculated at a few hundred thousand households. Should the Federation just build them a fusion reactor? No, let's wreck a life-bearing moon and kick all the inhabitants off. This would be a fine story in a modern-day Earth setting, but not for an entire planet of billions of inhabitants with abundant clean power.
** The Federation would probably consider this an internal matter and plenty of Bajorans distrust them at this point anyway. Furthermore, it's very probable the energy generated by the matter is for more than just the ones which are desperately counting on it now. Bajor is rebuilding and has a need for the power it'll provide many more houses until then.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[quoteright:350:http://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/mullibok_2369.jpg]]
[[caption-width-right:350:Meet the only Bajoran more stubborn than Kira]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* The47Society: 47 people have already left Jerrado.

Top