Freddy is just casually setting up the Christmas Tree, when Nightmare Bonnie reveals himself to never have celebrated Christmas. This leads the other animatronics to try and teach Nightmare Bonnie what Christmas really is.
One mishap with christmas cookies, and believing Santa to be an enslaver later, Nightmare Bonnie meets up with Freddy and Bonnie, who suggest christmas shopping, Nightmare Bonnie, however, isn't a fan of the idea, as he has a feeling he'll scare everybody. After Freddy keeps attempting to encourage him, Nightmare Bonnie yells at Freddy, but then he finally admits Christmas is an absolute bust for him.
- Nightmare Bonnie: I tried to find it, but it wasn't there.
The next day, on Christmas morning, BB gives Nightmare Bonnie a gift, which is revealed to be a plush toy of himself. Nightmare Bonnie, realizing the meaning of christmas, heads off to meet with his pals. They reconcile, and it's then Nightmare Bonnie learns about snowball fights, and proceeds to dominate Chica and BB.
Tropes:
- Christmas Episode: Nightmare Unwrapped is a christmas episode, nuff' said.
- Continuity Nod: One of Nightmare Bonnie's reasons for not being around during Christmas time is because of the experience the group had with RXQ, which caused him to take a vacation..
- A Day In The Lime Light: Unlike the other holiday specials, which featured the main four animatronics, this one focuses on an unexpected character.... Nightmare Bonnie, with the episode quickly revealing itself to be the final episode of Nightmare Bonnie's Redemption Story Arc, with him losing his mindset of the shame of his past.
- Bittersweet Ending: More sweet than bitter, but it can be seen as bittersweet as Nightmare Bonnie has finally forgiven himself for his past and allowed himself to move on.
- Snowball Fight: Nightmare Bonnie finds out what snowballs are, and along with Bonnie, absolutely destroys Chica and Balloon Boy, as well as later pelting Freddy in the face with a snowball.
- I Am a Monster: Nightmare Bonnie doesn't want to go shopping as he knows what he looks like and that he'll scare everybody, but once Freddy keeps persisting, Nightmare Bonnie quickly yells at the bear, causing Freddy to back down, then Nightmare Bonnie admits, now devastated, that he tried to find the meaning of Christmas for beings like him, but he failed.
