Three years after the war with Dagur, Hiccup
- Chaotic Good: By serving "Loki," the god of mischief, the twins are this, pulling many pranks on Berk.
- Desperately Seeking A Purpose In Life: Now that most of the dragons in the Archipelago have been found, Hiccup is a bit lost, especially when Astrid says she no longer wants to join him on searches for new dragons.
- Dumbass Has a Point: Hiccup likes the twins' plan to steal from the ships in the graveyard before Dagur can. The problem then lies in everyone distracted when Dagur comes.
- Idiot Ball:
- Hiccup going into the booby-trapped ship
- MAcGuffin: The "treasure" on the Reaper
- Names to Run Away from Really Fast: A ship called The Reaper.
- The Bus Came Back:
- Somehow Dagur found Savage, his old Yes-Man, and brought him back.