Nightmare Fuel: The Mothman Prophecies

  • Suspecting Cold is watching him during their phone conversation, John rifles through a drawer and picks up an item without looking at it:
    John Klein: What's in my hand?
    Indrid Cold: Chap Stick.
    [John opens his hand...revealing a tube of Chap Stick]
    • "A broken smile beneath her whispered wings..."
  • There was a scene where Connie tells John her dream and she gets very nervous and scared about it. That scene can be incredibly terrifying, specially thanks to how real it actually seems like to someone who was starting to believe in everything that was happening.
  • The original book consists of the purest, Grade-A Nightmare Fuel. Whether you're frightened by Keel's idea that the universe is not just aware but actively screwing with us just for laughs, or at the depths of his paranoia, is up to the individual reader.
  • The sound of Indrid Cold's voice on the phone.
    John Klein: I want to meet you...
    Indrid Cold: You already have, John. I've seen you afraid. You're frightened right now, aren't ya?
  • And this exchange.
    John: What do you look like?
    Indrid Cold: It depends on who's looking.
  • The voice coming out of the motel sink's drain.
  • The beginning when they're driving down the street, and the Mothman crashes into their windshield.
  • The collapse of the Silver Bridge in the film is extremely realistic.