I just need to pick up some spices. Amino dexterous and amino sinister, if you have it. Turian shopkeeper:
You don't mix your spice chirality! What cooking school did you say you went to?
Most of the molecules required for life have the property known as chirality
or "handedness". That is, they are not the same as their mirror image, like a left shoe which will not fit properly on your right foot no matter how you rotate it. That wouldn't have been that much of a problem, if not for the one insignificant fact that most of the stuff our bodies are made of, mainly the amino acids, which are the building blocks for the proteins we consist of, are chiral. And all
multicell organisms on Earth are made of L-(or levo-)amino acids.note
Dextro-amino acids (except cysteine) are exceedingly rare in Earth organisms and are used only by some bacteria and in a few very specialized cases by larger creatures. Referencing this fact is a fairly common way for science-fiction writers to Show Their Work
. It generally comes up in one of two situations:
- Aliens can have their entire biochemistry built on molecules with the opposite chirality from that used on Earth, making it simultaneously identical to Earth chemistry (and therefore clearly possible) and incompatible with it.
- Some piece of Applied Phlebotinum may be capable of mirror-reversing people or objects.
In either case, this usually manifests itself as an inability to eat the same food in the same way. Either food tastes different depending on your handedness, or wrong-handed food has no nutritional value or is actively dangerous. Expect some mention of the fact that ethanol is one of the few biologically interesting molecules that doesn't have this property — so, regardless of chirality, everyone can always get drunk together, and you can make moonshine from organic stuff that's otherwise useless for you because it's of the wrong chirality (assuming you have the right microbes).
This is often a form of Artistic License - Chemistry
, especially when authors try to extrapolate to what happens with molecules that are too complex to be synthesized chemically. Contrast No Biochemical Barriers
open/close all folders
- In Through the Looking Glass, Alice speculates that looking-glass milk might not be good to drink. This is probably the Ur Example; in fact, it predates the coining of the word "chirality" by several years. In The Annotated Alice, Martin Gardner discusses the chemical reasons why this would be true, before moving on to point out that looking-glass milk would likely be made of antimatter, making it really bad to drink.
- Referenced darkly in Alan Moore's League of Extraordinary Gentlemen; in a text feature in Vol. 2, it is revealed that Alice emerged from the Looking Glass world with her entire body mirror-reversed. As a result, she was unable to eat normal food, and ultimately starved to death.
- Doorways in the Sand by Roger Zelazny has an "n-axial inversion device", which mirror-reverses anyone or anything that passes through it. The protagonist goes through it about halfway through the book. It turns out that quite a few things taste better when you're mirror-reversed. Especially bourbon. This is because although alcohol is symmetric, the various flavorings are not.
- Of course, one has to be careful when using the device. One unfortunate individual accidentally goes through the wrong way and gets turned inside out!
- In There and Back Again by Pat Murphy, anyone who passes through a wormhole gets mirror-reversed. Any gathering of people who have done a lot of wormhole travel needs two cooks: one for the travelers who are currently "right-handed" (having passed through an odd number of wormholes) and one for the ones who are "left-handed" (having passed through an even number).
- In The Boy Who Reversed Himself by William Sleator, the protagonists gain the ability to enter the fourth dimension and therefore end up reversed. They learn that mirror-ketchup is an extremely addictive drug.
- One of the stories in Callahans Crosstime Saloon has a "Mirror Earth" with right-handed proteins in the place of our left-handed ones. A con artist discovers a means to travel between the two, but finds that there's little he can do with it; Equivalent Exchange is in effect - if he does anything that benefits one world at the expense of the other, the gate will fail, possibly trapping him in a world where he can't digest the food. He finally hits on ethanol; it's not a chiral molecule as said above, but the esters (which determine taste and texture) are. Result: one world's really bad moonshine whiskey is the other's Wonderbooze.
- Destiny's Road by Larry Niven is set on a planet whose indigenous life uses right-handed proteins. This is initially problematic as they need to entirely sterilize an area of the planet so as to have somewhere to grow edible food, but it proves to have some advantages; it means they're immune to native diseases, and they discover that the planet's sea life is the perfect diet food as their bodies are incapable of metabolizing it into fat.
- Spock Must Die has a mirror-reversed copy of Spock created in a transporter accident. He's unable to eat anything, and so he finds himself slowly starving while he works with a chemistry set in order to create mirrored food he can eat and survive.
- Tour of the Merrimack: The crew aren't worried about picking up any diseases in the Myriad because life on those worlds uses opposite-handed proteins, which are are incompatible with human biology. It's likened to attempting to attach a four-post wheel to a five-post axle with opposite-thread bolts. It is also mentioned that the Hive is unique among all known species in that it is able to digest proteins of either chirality.
- The Isaac Asimov short story "Left to Right" has a scientist create a device that will apply some sort of directional interchange on whatever passes through; the scientist intends to use himself as a test subject. There is a discussion about potential issues if he ends up with his heart on the wrong side or unable to eat because of wrong-handed proteins, but he plans on reversing himself again before that becomes an issue. It turns out not to matter; the device actually just changes the scientist's name from Robert L. Forward to Robert L. Backward.
- An important plot point in David J. Lake's The Right Hand of Dextra and The Wildlings of Westron. Dextran food tastes vile and has no food value for humans; the same applies to Dextran natives and terrestrial produce. Of course, the Dextran Mothers can alter a creature's biochemistry. (Which has the side-effect of creating a connection to the planetary over-consciousness.)
- An important plot point in Marti Steussy's Dreams of Dawn. Juvenile (and not yet sapient) Kargan natives like the taste of terrestrial food, but it can cause their metamorphosis process to go fatally awry thanks to some meddling by Abusive Precursors. The side effects of Kargan food on terrestrial species likewise range from indigestion to fatalities. Solved at the end by altering the colonists' biochemistry to match that of the native species, after much trial and error.
- In The Pentagon War, Centaurian metabolism is based around levulorotary glucose (instead of the dextrorotary glucose we Earth people use). Centaurian food has no nutritional value to humans, and can sometimes be downright poisonous to them — and vice-versa.
- In the Arthur C. Clarke short story "Technical Error", an experimental superconducting power station accidentally inverts Richard Nelson so that all his body chemistry is opposite-handed. He needs to have special "left-handed" food synthesized for him, and since no one is sure if we've missed any essential micronutrients that would also need to be inverted for him, he figures his best option for long-term survival is to repeat the accident and try to re-invert himself.
- In the Star Carrier series, Osiris, a planet orbiting 70 Ophiuchi, is a rare garden world where humans can survive unprotected. However they have to grow their own food crops since the native life has the opposite chirality from Earth life and is therefore inedible.
- However, the planet Vulcan orbiting Epsilon Eridani A is even rarer since the local life has the exact same chirality as terrestrial life. Unfortunately, the same is true for the new aliens discovered in the fifth book, and these aliens are looking for some new prey to hunt and eat.
Live Action TV
- An episode of Black Hole High was actually called "Chirality," and introduced the concept in a chemistry class — then used it as a justification for a Personality Swap episode.
- In GURPS Time Travel, this is one of the entries on the "something went wrong with our dimension-traveling device" chart.
- Many colony worlds in the 2300 AD universe have dextro-based life. To get around this, human colonists sterilize large patches of ground and use "pay dirt" from Earth to set up a localized biosphere suitable for growing crops. On the other hand, many native creatures from dextro-worlds (most infamously Aurore) will take a bite out of humans or their livestock without worrying whether it will make them sick.
- In Mass Effect, the turians and quarians have roughly humanoid biochemistry, but with opposite-chirality proteins, while several other species have the same chirality of protein as humans do. Eating food intended for an opposite-chirality species will at best pass through one's system without providing any nutrients and at worst lead to dangerous allergic reactions. Discussed several times, particularly in Mass Effect 2:
- The page quote comes from an overheard interaction where a turian grocery store operator has to deal with a not-too-bright human customer.
- In a "deleted scene", a turian is amazed by human alcohol.
- In her bar on Ilium, Matriarch Aethyta warns Shepard against eating the beer nuts in the red bowls because they're for turians and quarians. She also speaks of a Noodle Incident where a krogan drank liquefied turian on a dare. Krogans are infamous for Super Toughness to the point where it's a Running Gag, but according to Aethyta "nobody came out of that one looking pretty."
- If a female Shepard romances her turian teammate Garrus, Dr. Mordin Solus warns her against swallowing turian semen.
- Also, if a male Shepard romances his quarian teammate Tali, Dr. Mordin Solus says; "Oral contact with tissue dangerous. Take precautions." This could be a warning against swallowing quarian vaginal fluids, advice to not let Tali swallow human semen, or both.
- One of the "Cerberus Daily News" briefs mentions a new treatment that temporarily allows dextro- or levo-based species to safely eat the other type of food. Despite the fact that the eater gets no nutritional benefit from the mirror food and they have to "purge" within 24 hours, it becomes a fad among gourmands.
- Freefall. In the 'garden-world' of Pfouts, life developed with opposite chirality as compared to humans, making it more inhospitable to human colonization than a bare ball of rock could ever be. Thus, some clever humans are speculating about uplifting a local species to sentience, thus gaining a colony-by-extension for humanity. One of the main characters is an uplifted wolf, made as a proof-of-concept for that endeavour.
- From the files of the SCP Foundation comes SCP-739, a small closet with mirrored interiors. Closing a person in the booth once will flip all their amino-chains. Closing them in twice will switch them back, but repeating the experiment too many times with the same subject leads to something else emerging. As a fun side benefit, locking sugar packets in the closet will flip them as well. The scientist specifically notes that they would make excellent diet sweeteners.
- In the massively crossover fanfic Bring Me the Head of Harry Potter, it's revealed that Voldemort used a spell that turned people inside out. Examining a battlefield long after the fact, Willow Rosenberg feels the earth's pain from wrong-chirality organic molecule poisoning.
- One Stargate SG-1 fanfic mentions a right-handed world being used as a prison planet. Plenty of oxygen, but if you escape the prison camp there's absolutely nothing to eat. Unless you dismember the guards.
- A recurring research project carried out by organic chemists has been to develop a sugar with at least part of the molecule having a reversed chirality: the goal is to have a sugar that will trigger the taste buds for sweetness the same but be unable to be taken up by the body (and as a bonus, the bacteria that cause tooth decay), thus being calorie-free.
- Possibly this effort is doomed to failure, as a brain that doesn't receive an actual (right-handed) glucose rush in the wake of eating a sweet-tasting flavoring is likely to start registering that flavor as non-sweet after several exposures. (As this argument applies to all low-calorie sweeteners, it is probably flawed.)
- Another probelm is that if the sugars can't be absorbed in the gut, there could be mild laxative effects from osmosis. This one seems actually likely, since "sugar alcohols" used as "non-caloric" sweeteners (such as sorbitol) really are laxatives in large doses.
- Receptors for proteins, hormones, and other organic chemical compounds are made to fit certain molecular structures of a certain chirality. If a molecule does not have the correct chirality, it doesn't fit in the receptor, or worse, can actively harm the organism. As if that's not enough, the human body can sometimes metabolize a useful structure into its harmful mirror image. This was what happened with Thalidomide - a certain chiral structure (also called an enantiomer) of the compound was useful for the effects of morning sickness in pregnant women, but the other enantiomer of it caused terrible birth defects. The early testing of the compound was performed on just the desired enatiomer, but the mass-production synthesis method produced a racemic form. This is also the case with the cancer-fighting drug Platinol, which only causes sickness because scientists can't separate the helpful enantiomer of the drug from the toxic one, so it's sold as a mixture of the two (any mixture of both enantiomers of a compound is called a racemic mixture).
- Also played Genre Savvy by big pharmaceutical companies. A company will frequently develop and market a medication consisting of some compound in a racemic mixture, sell that until its patent exclusivity expires, and then release a "new" medication consisting of only the biologically active enantiomer of the original compound, so as to gain a whole new patent life for essentially the same compound. A good clue to this tactic is a generic drug name that looks like the original with a S or D added. Examples include Prilosec (omeprazole) vs. Nexium (esomeprazole), Celexa (citalopram) vs. Lexapro (escitalopram), Claritin (loratadine) vs. Clarinex (desloratadine), and so on.
- The artificial sweetener Aspartame (which you might see under trade names Nutra Sweet (tm) or Equal (tm).) One enantiomer tastes sweet (sweeter than sugar, in fact), and the other tastes bitter. (This is why diet sodas can taste "off" to some people.) Also worth noting that citric acid reverses the bitter enantiomer into the sweet one.