Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Heartwarming / StarTrekDiscovery

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* When Tilly is in danger, Burnham doesn't really hesitate to break the Prime Directive, in part for the sake of the mission but mostly clearly out of concern for Tilly's life.
* Having broken the Prime Directive and revealed to the local head priest the truth, Burnham comforts him that the knowledge of technology and alien life doesn't invalidate his religion but adds to and that he should let his people know the truth and let their beliefs grow and evolve to cope with it.

to:

* When Tilly is in danger, Burnham doesn't really hesitate to break the Prime Directive, in part for the sake of the mission but mostly clearly out of concern for Tilly's life.
* Having broken the Prime Directive and revealed to the local head priest the truth, Burnham comforts him that the knowledge of technology and alien life doesn't invalidate his religion but adds to it, and that he should let his people know the truth and let their beliefs grow and evolve to cope with it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:


[[AC:Whistlespeak]]
* Burnham geeking out about the society of the week's language and culture is very touching, she's an explorer at heart.
* Culber's having a spiritual awakening since the Zhian'tara ritual and consults a hologram of his grandma, Stamets and Book in turn.
* When Tilly is in danger, Burnham doesn't really hesitate to break the Prime Directive, in part for the sake of the mission but mostly clearly out of concern for Tilly's life.
* Having broken the Prime Directive and revealed to the local head priest the truth, Burnham comforts him that the knowledge of technology and alien life doesn't invalidate his religion but adds to and that he should let his people know the truth and let their beliefs grow and evolve to cope with it.


Added DiffLines:


Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The biggest triumph of the episode is the resurrection of the original ''Enterprise'' herself. Yes, it's the Mirror Universe version, and the Prime iteration has long been blown to smithereens, but after decades is a version of the old girl back to where she belongs. Detmer and Owosekun are given the honor of bringing her back to HQ, where Starfleet no doubt plans to restore her, and add her to the lineup at the Fleet Museum. Now, the original 1701 will ''finally'' be granted posterity alongside the ''Defiant'', the ''NX-01'', the ''Voyager'', the ''Enterprise''-A, the ''Excelsior'', and the similarly resurrected ''Enterprise''-D as the legends of the pre-Kurtzman ''Trek'' era will now all get to be under one roof. As Kirk would have said, "My friends, we've come home."

to:

* The biggest triumph of the episode is the resurrection of the original ''Enterprise'' herself. Yes, it's the Mirror Universe version, and the Prime iteration has long been blown to smithereens, but after decades is a version of the old girl back to where she belongs. Detmer and Owosekun are given the honor of bringing her back to HQ, where Starfleet no doubt plans to restore her, and add her to the lineup at the Fleet Museum. Now, the original 1701 will ''finally'' be granted posterity alongside the ''Defiant'', the ''NX-01'', the ''Voyager'', the ''Enterprise''-A, the ''Excelsior'', and the similarly resurrected ''Enterprise''-D as the legends of the pre-Kurtzman ''Trek'' era will now all get to be under one roof. As Kirk would have said, "My friends, we've come home."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The ''Discovery'' crew discovers that one of the crews lies on a Terran Ship. To their surprise, it's the ''I.S.S. Enterprise'', revealing her fate after nearly 60 years since she was last seen. It turns out, when Spock's reforms failed, denizens who knew of the Prime Reality hijacked the old girl and fled from the hellish Mirror Universe to seek out a better life, and most of them succeeded in doing so. The person who led them? Saru! And though Burnham and Book don't learn about Spock's reform efforts, the former does take a solemn moment to reminisce about her brother when Book explores his old science station.

to:

* The ''Discovery'' crew discovers that one of the crews clues lies on a Terran Ship. To their surprise, it's the ''I.S.S. Enterprise'', revealing her fate after nearly 60 years since she was last seen. It turns out, when Spock's reforms failed, denizens who knew of the Prime Reality hijacked the old girl and fled from the hellish Mirror Universe to seek out a better life, and most of them succeeded in doing so. The person who led them? Saru! And though Burnham and Book don't learn about Spock's reform efforts, the former does take a solemn moment to reminisce about her brother when Book explores his old science station.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:


[[AC: Mirrors]]
* The ''Discovery'' crew discovers that one of the crews lies on a Terran Ship. To their surprise, it's the ''I.S.S. Enterprise'', revealing her fate after nearly 60 years since she was last seen. It turns out, when Spock's reforms failed, denizens who knew of the Prime Reality hijacked the old girl and fled from the hellish Mirror Universe to seek out a better life, and most of them succeeded in doing so. The person who led them? Saru! And though Burnham and Book don't learn about Spock's reform efforts, the former does take a solemn moment to reminisce about her brother when Book explores his old science station.
* Moll and L'ak's relationship is built on a genuine love for one another, as they seek to flee to the Gamma Quadrant and live out a peaceful life. And unlike Mirror Lorca, Control, or Osyrra, all of whom had genuinely unsympathetic motives that none of ''Discovery'' or her crew agreed with, Burnham and Book recognize that the two just want to remove the bounty on their heads by selling the Progenitor's tech so they can live out their days in peace. Both of them try to reach out to the outlaws, recognizing their own efforts to redeem themselves. L'ak is even willing to consider a surrender if Moll shares in his sentence. It doesn't get through to them, but it's sweet to see Starfleet can see the humanity in the two.
* Commander Rayner is implied to have his doubts about assuming the chair again, but Burnham has absolute faith in his abilities. True enough, he collaborates with the crew and manages to pull off a successful rescue of the ''Enterprise'' and bring her and everyone onboard out of the pocket dimension. And he never sits in the chair either, patiently waiting to ensure Burnham is the one to take it back when she's brought home safe.
* The biggest triumph of the episode is the resurrection of the original ''Enterprise'' herself. Yes, it's the Mirror Universe version, and the Prime iteration has long been blown to smithereens, but after decades is a version of the old girl back to where she belongs. Detmer and Owosekun are given the honor of bringing her back to HQ, where Starfleet no doubt plans to restore her, and add her to the lineup at the Fleet Museum. Now, the original 1701 will ''finally'' be granted posterity alongside the ''Defiant'', the ''NX-01'', the ''Voyager'', the ''Enterprise''-A, the ''Excelsior'', and the similarly resurrected ''Enterprise''-D as the legends of the pre-Kurtzman ''Trek'' era will now all get to be under one roof. As Kirk would have said, "My friends, we've come home."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Despite not agreeing or getting along with Captain Rayner, Michael is extremely reluctant to speak badly of him to Tribunal out of respect to him as a fellow officer.

to:

* Despite not agreeing or getting along with Captain Rayner, Michael is extremely reluctant to speak badly of him to Tribunal out of respect to him as a fellow officer. Vance even acknowledges the "unwritten code of conduct" between officers as he forces her to answer truthfully, and Rayner doesn't begrudge her having to do so.





Added: 179

Changed: 51

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added example




to:

\n[[folder: Season Five]]
[[AC: Under The Twin Moons]]
* Despite not agreeing or getting along with Captain Rayner, Michael is extremely reluctant to speak badly of him to Tribunal out of respect to him as a fellow officer.
[[/folder]]


Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The fact that the two species that live on Kaminar are living harmoniously side by side is also a nice touch. And Saru has clearly accepted this, moving beyond the fear of the Ba'ul that the Kelpiens used to have.

to:

** The fact that the two species that live on Kaminar are living harmoniously side by side is also a nice touch. And Saru has clearly accepted this, moving beyond the fear of the Ba'ul that the Kelpiens used to have.
have. (Even though he later admits that he still feels lingering resentment towards the Ba'ul, he refuses to indulge this because the alliance between their species is more important.)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

%%
%% Image selected per Image Pickin thread: https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/posts.php?discussion=16986392170.53508800
%% Please don't change or remove without starting a new thread.
%%
[[quoteright:350:https://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/r_2023_10_29t230414427.jpg]]
%%

Changed: 699

Removed: 241

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
No meta moment, see this query.


** On the meta level, this is Star Trek's first on screen use of the f-word. And what is it in reference to? Excitement regarding science. It's not a pointed instance to tell the audience that things are really drastic, it's these characters being excited that they are going to do science, and spare the pain and suffering of an innocent creature.

to:

** On the meta level, this is Star Trek's first on screen use of the f-word. And what is it in reference to? Excitement regarding science. It's not a pointed instance to tell the audience that things are really drastic, it's these characters being excited that they are going to do science, and spare the pain and suffering of an innocent creature.



* Stamets bonding with Adira over loving people who are / were dead but still present. It's a sweet moment between two not-very-social geniuses, which Adira follows up by offering to get rid of his arm implants. There's meta heartwarming too: one older openly LGBTQ actor bonding with the younger generation, and promising to unconditionally believe and support them.

to:

* Stamets bonding with Adira over loving people who are / were dead but still present. It's a sweet moment between two not-very-social geniuses, which Adira follows up by offering to get rid of his arm implants. There's meta heartwarming too: one older openly LGBTQ actor bonding with the younger generation, and promising to unconditionally believe and support them.






* A Meta moment for the ''Series/StarTrekVoyager'' fans: ''Voyager'' is ordered to take point on the fight against the ''Veridian'', and continues to press the pursuit all the way until Burnham orders the Federation/Ni'Var fleet to back off.



* A meta example: The crew, in preparing for the mission and finding solutions to their problems, make references to similar situations that the TOS, TNG, and Voyager crews found themselves in.

to:

* A meta example: The crew, in preparing for the mission and finding solutions to their problems, make references to similar situations that the TOS, TNG, and Voyager crews found themselves in.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** That scene is the key to the whole episode! Burnham is at an impasse because, for the first time in her life, she wants to initiate a romantic relationship but has no idea how—-because absolutely nothing in her upbringing, education, or life experience has prepared her for it. Stamets’ fond, exasperated “would you let me lead, please?!" gives her one absolutely crucial clue: she needs to be able to trust and let go rather than forcing things to happen. Stamets’ story of honesty and trusting in love even if it isn’t logical gets her the rest of the way there.

to:

** That scene is the key to the whole episode! Time loop stories are always about someone who is emotionally stuck and unable to progress, and they break the loop by outgrowing it. Burnham is at an impasse because, for the first time in her life, she wants to initiate a romantic relationship but has no idea how—-because absolutely nothing how--because ''absolutely nothing'' in her upbringing, education, or life experience has prepared her for it. Stamets’ fond, exasperated “would you let me lead, please?!" gives her one absolutely crucial clue: she needs to be able learn to trust and let go and let things develop rather than forcing things to happen. assuming there's a script somewhere. Stamets’ story of honesty showing your partner your real self rather than a carefully constrained facade, and trusting in love even if it isn’t logical logical, gets her the rest of the way there.
there. After that scene, she's able to dance and connect with Tyler for the first time.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** That scene is the key to the whole episode! Burnham is at an impasse because, for the first time in her life, she wants to initiate a romantic relationship but has no idea how—-because absolutely nothing in her upbringing, education, or life experience has prepared her for it. Stamets’ fond, exasperated “would you let me lead, please?!" gives her one absolutely crucial clue: she needs to be able to trust and let go rather than forcing things to happen. Stamets’ story of honesty and trusting in love even if it isn’t logical gets her the rest of the way there.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* After Felix dies at the colony, Burnham returns the lalogi orb that he stole to the daughter of its (deceased) rightful owner. She's grateful to have it back and be able to add herself to the family tree contained therein.

to:

* After Felix dies at the colony, Burnham returns the lalogi orb that he stole to the very pregnant daughter of its (deceased) rightful owner. She's grateful to have it back and be able to add herself (and presumably her soon to be born child) to the family tree contained therein.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Dewicked trope


* Although laden with AdultFear, Ephraim's SternChase with the ''Enterprise'' shows her devotion to her unhatched children, considering that she keeps at it for ''years''.

to:

* Although laden with AdultFear, Ephraim's SternChase with the ''Enterprise'' shows her devotion to her unhatched children, considering that she keeps at it for ''years''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Earth is ready to rejoin the Federation, with Andoria likely to follow. It's also revealed that Tellar Prime never left, meaning that the four founding members will be together again.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The truly heartwarming detail is that the ''Mitchell'' is named for Kenneth Mitchell, who has played a number of different ''Discovery'' cast and is suffering the effects of ALS. We also hear reports from the USS ''[[Creator/AntonYelchin Yelchin]]'' and the USS ''[[Series/StarTrekDeepSpaceNine Nog]]'', referencing two previous ''Trek'' cast members who passed away in recent years.

to:

** The truly heartwarming detail is that the ''Mitchell'' is named for Kenneth Mitchell, who has played a number of different ''Discovery'' cast characters and is suffering the effects of ALS. We also hear reports from the USS ''[[Creator/AntonYelchin Yelchin]]'' and the USS ''[[Series/StarTrekDeepSpaceNine Nog]]'', referencing two previous ''Trek'' cast members who passed away in recent years.

Changed: 22

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[/folder]]

to:

[[/folder]]




to:

[[/folder]]


Added: 1205

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[AC: Coming Home]]
* Tilly addresses a gaggle of cadets as Starfleet Headquarters arrives at Earth to begin the HomeworldEvacuation. She tells them that the evacuees will terrified, and looking to the Federation for leadership and support, and that the cadets [[DareToBeBadass are ready for the challenge that awaits them.]]
* During the evacuation of Earth, Cadets Gorev and Harral are worried that they won't be able to evacuate all of the Earthers in time, showing they have come a long way since their original training mission where they were distrustful of cadets from other worlds.
* A shuttle trying to escape Earth is about to be run down by a large chunk of debris, much like what happened to Adira and Gray's ship in the previous season. Instead the starship ''Mitchell'' warps in and blasts it just in time.
** The truly heartwarming detail is that the ''Mitchell'' is named for Kenneth Mitchell, who has played a number of different ''Discovery'' cast and is suffering the effects of ALS. We also hear reports from the USS ''[[Creator/AntonYelchin Yelchin]]'' and the USS ''[[Series/StarTrekDeepSpaceNine Nog]]'', referencing two previous ''Trek'' cast members who passed away in recent years.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:


[[AC: The Galactic Barrier]]
* When it looks like ''Discovery'' might be destroyed trying to traverse the Barrier, the bridge officers begin talking about their plans for when they get home after succeeding at their mission. Detmer and Owo decide to go on a trip together.
* After the crew and delegation are informed that the DMA has changed course and is now set to destroy Earth, Titan, and Ni'Var, Saru asks T'Rina if she'd like him to join her for a meal. She accepts, saying that his presence would be a comfort.
* We get some backstory on Tarka, and learn about the time he spent with Oros in an Emerald Chain work camp. Oros is not interested in making friends, and we soon learn that he was traumatized watching his old cellmate die during an escape attempt. [[TraumaButton When the camp alarms later go off]], Oros freaks out and Tarka runs over to comfort him, showing that he wasn't always the abrasive JerkAss we know in the present day.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:


[[AC: ...But To Connect]]
* While Earth has yet to return to the Federation, Burnham and ''Discovery''[='s=] actions last year have made great strides in improving relations. In particular, the now-General Ndoye tells Burnham that United Earth's government now includes Titan and is more inclusive.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* T'Rina has some Kaminar-style tea brought to Saru, leading to Burnham to note the Vulcan president seems to fancy him after their previous meeting.
* Tilly reassuring Adira that [[YouAreBetterThanYouThinkYouAre They Are Better Than They Think They Are]]

to:

* T'Rina has some Kaminar-style tea brought to Saru, leading to Burnham to playfully note the Vulcan president seems to fancy him after their previous meeting.
* Tilly reassuring Adira that [[YouAreBetterThanYouThinkYouAre They Are Better Than They Think They Are]]Are]].

Changed: 25

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** They need to disable life support to leave enough power for the ship to escape the rift. The solution is to stow the crew in the transporter buffer for the few minutes it will take to reach safety, a risky technique only used occasionally in Starfleet history. Burnham orders that everyone gather in groups to beam up, so nobody is forced to do it on their own. She then dons an EVA suit so she can stay with Zora.

to:

** They need to disable life support to leave enough power for the ship to escape the rift. The solution is to stow the crew in the transporter buffer for the few minutes it will take to reach safety, a risky technique only used occasionally in Starfleet history. Burnham orders that everyone gather in groups to beam up, so nobody is forced to do it on their own. [[NoOneGetsLeftBehind She then dons an EVA suit so she can stay with Zora. Zora.]]

Added: 891

Changed: 68

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Mind-melding with T'Rina and reliving the destruction of Kwejian allows Book to gain some small measure of closure by seeing Leto's face one more time and seeing the love in his face.

to:

* Mind-melding with T'Rina and reliving the destruction of Kwejian allows Book to gain some small measure of closure by seeing Leto's face one more time and seeing the love in his face. The reserved Vulcan goes on to offer her condolences for his loss.
* Book asks T'Rina to teach him how Vulcans repress their emotions. She notes what Sarek failed to in his own time: Vulcan control of their emotions works for Vulcans, but not for everyone else. She believes it would be actively harmful for Book to try, given his people's strong empathic nature.


Added DiffLines:

* President Rillak, who has been critical of Burnham for her leadership style in the past, arranges for Burnham and Saru to be present when the negotiations go south, trusting her to do her typical thing and find her own solution to the problem, free of the baggage of the formal negotiation process.
** It is later revealed that President Rillak was secretly warned of the impending complications by President T'Rina, giving her time to prepare.
* T'Rina has some Kaminar-style tea brought to Saru, leading to Burnham to note the Vulcan president seems to fancy him after their previous meeting.

Added: 1408

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:


[[AC: Stormy Weather]]
* Zora is generally concerned that the crew won't trust her now that she is self-aware and experiencing emotions. The crew, in particular Burnham and Gray, work with her to figure things out.
** Gray, learning that Zora is growing distracted by her inability to sense anything beyond her hull in the subspace rift, offers to help take her mind off of things by playing a game.
** They need to disable life support to leave enough power for the ship to escape the rift. The solution is to stow the crew in the transporter buffer for the few minutes it will take to reach safety, a risky technique only used occasionally in Starfleet history. Burnham orders that everyone gather in groups to beam up, so nobody is forced to do it on their own. She then dons an EVA suit so she can stay with Zora.
* Zora and Burnham comfort each other during the perilous journey, Burnham giving Zora advice on how to endure her current situation (the damage the ship is taking is comparable to painful injuries for Zora due to her being connected to the entire ship), and Zora offers to sing a song for Burnham to help distract her from her own suffering (the entire ship is getting hot enough to start fires).
* A meta example: The crew, in preparing for the mission and finding solutions to their problems, make references to similar situations that the TOS, TNG, and Voyager crews found themselves in.

Added: 244

Changed: 47

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The commencement address to the newest class of Starfleet Academy graduates confirms that the Federation is indeed rebuilding after the defeat of the Emerald Chain, up from 38 member planets last season to 59. Nowhere near its peak of 350, or even the 150 during Picard's time, but it's a start.

to:

* The commencement address to the newest first class of Starfleet Academy graduates cadets in over a century confirms that the Federation is indeed rebuilding after the defeat of the Emerald Chain, up from 38 member planets last season to 59. Nowhere near its peak of 350, or even the 150 during Picard's time, but it's a start.


Added DiffLines:


[[AC: The Examples]]
* After Felix dies at the colony, Burnham returns the lalogi orb that he stole to the daughter of its (deceased) rightful owner. She's grateful to have it back and be able to add herself to the family tree contained therein.

Top