The new game "First Date" as a whole. Drew scores a jackpot of a different sort with the first couple that takes part, who have been together for 35 years. And they take jabs at each other on stage to boot.
Something between this and CMoF happens when an even older couple comes up in one "Song for a Lady", the lady in this case, Jeannie, turning out to be a Dirty Old Woman - and Jeff and Jonathan just go with it when the song starts.
Jeff: "Jeannie, you're on the list, and I shudder to think of how you injured your wrist!"
Also CMoH/F-worthy is the time Heather Anne picked an audience member just because it was her birthday, leading to Drew, Ryan, Jeff, Chip and Jonathan breaking into an impromptu chorus:
"Thiiiiiis iiiiiis yooooour birthday song, it isn't very long-" (all cutoff at the same point)
