"Don't Shoot Me Santa", their take on the Christmas song. Made especially funny by the fact that it's performed in their usual musical style and sounds like something right off Sam's Town, with Flowers pulling out all his vocal stops on lines like, "Don't shoot me Santa Claus, I've been a clean-livin' boy..."
The sequels to "Don't Shoot Me Santa", "I Feel It In My Bones" and "Dirt Sledding", are equally likely to cause involuntary spitting of eggnog.
"Hey Kringle! / You mean to say when you were young you never got wild?"