You would not think a musical based on Goosebumps would be such a blast to listen to...you would be wrong... what's more, each song has its own genre!
- The opening theme known as, what else, "Goosebumps"
. A love letter to the books with great references and swinging music, how could it not pump you up for the show? And what's great about "Goosebumps (Reprise)"? Hearing R. L. Stine himself singing! - "A Super Scary Play" introduces us to Brooke and Zeke, with them being just as thrilled and a bit anxious about wether or not they get the leading roles
- "The Legend" has a catchy Latin rhythm as Ms. Walker and Tina explain the lore behind the incident that happened 72 years ago regarding the original play.
- "Watch Your Step" is a jazzy number where Emile (played by Alex Brightman) expresses his concern for Brooke and Zeke in regards to their safety.
- "Babbling Brooke" doubles as funny, with both Brooke and Brian trying to keep themselves together in a lovely duet.
- "The Story of the Phantom". The music is beautiful and the storytelling is just divine. It's inspired by the title song from The Phantom of the Opera and it shows.
- "Understudy Buddy" has a catchy pop song beat to it, even though Tina acts like a mean girl through most parts of the song.
- "Whodunit?" has a mysterious rousing medley with Zeke, Brooke and Brian trying to figure out who's behind the recent acts of sabotage.
- "My Home Sweet Home" is bittersweet, as just like the book, it's revealed that Emile is a homeless man living under the theater.
- "My Story" explains Brian’s backstory, mixing "The Legend" and "Babbling Brooke" into a heartwarming farewell as he ascends into the afterlife with a swan song to the one girl he cares about.
