You're entitled to one if you manage to collect all of the pages.
Here's a Meta-Example: Slender was favorably reviewed on Toonami, making it one of the first independent games to recieve that honor. It also Broke The Rating Scale.
Another meta example would be that the game freaked out Troy Wagner. It scared the headphones off of the guy responsible for much of the inspiration behind the mythos and especially for the game itself!
The official remake Slender: The Arrival is being written by the Marble Hornets crew.