In General
- Whenever the team actually solve a mystery with no one dying (or at least no one deserving of it).
Season One
The End- Mike taking down the Chupacabra with one punch.
Ultimate Judgment Day
- Pigeon figuring out that Bobby Fischer's brain is inside the IBM supercomputer and tricks Mike into freeing his brain from the machine.
Kidnapped!
- Mike's speech to the graduating students that also moved Yung's kidnapper into letting her go.
Ty-Stunned
- Mike and the gang arriving to save Mrs. Ensler from Chainsaw Charlie and Mike takes him down with his stun gun.
Season Two
What's that Gnoise?- With the auto repair closed and fed up with the noise, Mike take things to his own hand by ripping apart Meg' minivan to find the source of the noise.
She's A Bayniac
- Mike arriving just in time to save Marquess from Courtney, who is revealed to be an alien. He got in several punches on her but she escaped when Mike slipped on semen.
Tent Revival
- Mike arrives in time to save Yung from Satanists performing a summoning ritual and one shot punches none other than Satan himself!
- Mike punching out the two co-workers who were pranking Carol with fake love letters. For the first time, Mike's violent response was MORE than appropriate and satisfying.
