Follow TV Tropes

Following

History YMMV / Ultravox

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SeasonalRot: BrokenBase aside, fans of the John Foxx era, fans of the Midge Ure era, and fans of both eras all agree that the band's output suffered a severe drop in quality with ''U-Vox'', [[CreatorKiller from which they never seemed to recover]]. The band split up two years after releasing ''U-Vox'', only to reform in TheNineties with a totally new lineup, save for the inclusion of Billie Currie. This, combined with the band's abandonment of Ultravox's signature NewWaveMusic sound in favor of pop-rock and the poor critical and fan reception of their musical output led this incarnation to unsurprisingly be regarded as Ultravox InNameOnly. Currie then replaced the entire lineup again in 1994, but this didn't help matters either, forcing Ultravox to disband a second time in 1996. The Ure-era lineup managed to reunite in 2008 to much acclaim, but their 2012 album ''Brill!ant'' was highly polarizing, not helped by the fact that it ended up truly being Ultravox's last.

to:

* SeasonalRot: BrokenBase aside, fans of the John Foxx era, fans of the Midge Ure era, and fans of both eras all agree that the band's output suffered a severe drop in quality with ''U-Vox'', [[CreatorKiller from which they never seemed to recover]]. The band split up two years after releasing ''U-Vox'', only to reform in TheNineties with a totally new lineup, save for the inclusion of Billie Billy Currie. This, combined with the band's abandonment of Ultravox's signature NewWaveMusic sound in favor of pop-rock and the poor critical and fan reception of their musical output led this incarnation to unsurprisingly be regarded as Ultravox InNameOnly. Currie then replaced the entire lineup again in 1994, but this didn't help matters either, forcing Ultravox to disband a second time in 1996. The Ure-era lineup managed to reunite in 2008 to much acclaim, but their 2012 album ''Brill!ant'' was highly polarizing, not helped by the fact that it ended up truly being Ultravox's last.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Debates still rage about whether the original John Foxx-led records or the Midge Ure-led records are better. While the former gets praised the most artistically, and was a major influence electronic musicians like Music/GaryNuman, the latter was significantly more successful.

to:

** Debates still rage about whether the original John Foxx-led records or the Midge Ure-led records are better. While the former gets praised the most artistically, and was a major influence on electronic musicians like Music/GaryNuman, the latter was significantly more successful.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Debates still rage about whether the original John Foxx-led records or the Midge Ure-led records are better. While the former gets praised the most artistically, the latter was significantly more successful.

to:

** Debates still rage about whether the original John Foxx-led records or the Midge Ure-led records are better. While the former gets praised the most artistically, and was a major influence electronic musicians like Music/GaryNuman, the latter was significantly more successful.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Were Still Relevant Dammit is not a trope anymore


* WereStillRelevantDammit: The second 90's incarnation of the band featured an image very much lifted from the {{grunge}} scene at the time, with long hair and casual clothing emblematic of pro-Generation X fashion. As a result, [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Tn2d0Dk-5Cs live performances]] of this incarnation are very jarring to look at, with what looks like a bunch of Music/{{Nirvana}} wannabes playing 90's pop rock; Billie Currie in particular looks woefully out of place with his keyboard and violin.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Up To Eleven is being dewicked.


** "The Voice" has some rather silly lyrics ("the look and the sound of the...''[[MundaneMadeAwesome voice?]]''") and the "oohh-oohhh" backing vocals in the chorus are [[UpToEleven a bit much]], even those used to the band's overblown style.

to:

** "The Voice" has some rather silly lyrics ("the look and the sound of the...''[[MundaneMadeAwesome voice?]]''") and the "oohh-oohhh" backing vocals in the chorus are [[UpToEleven a bit much]], much, even those used to the band's overblown style.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Midge's singing voice in general is either wonderfully textured although high-pitched, or whiny, hammy, and over-the-top that makes each track hilarious.

to:

** Midge's singing voice in general is either wonderfully textured although high-pitched, or whiny, hammy, and over-the-top that makes over-the-top, making each track hilarious.

Added: 156

Changed: 5

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** "Vienna" is very melodramatic, what with Midge's hammy vocals & the pretentious instrumentation. It's unsurprising some consider it either one of the 80s worst songs or it's best.

to:

** "Vienna" is very melodramatic, what with Midge's hammy vocals & the pretentious instrumentation. It's unsurprising some consider it either one of the 80s 80's worst songs singles or it's best.


Added DiffLines:

** Midge's singing voice in general is either wonderfully textured although high-pitched, or whiny, hammy, and over-the-top that makes each track hilarious.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Narm{{: The Ure-led period is littered with examples:

to:

* {{Narm{{: {{Narm}}: The Ure-led period is littered with examples:



** "The Voice" has some rather silly lyrics ("the look and the sound of the...''[[MundaneMadeAwesome voice?]]''") and the "oooh-ooohs" backing in the chorus are [[UpToEleven a bit much]], even those used to the band's overblown style.

to:

** "The Voice" has some rather silly lyrics ("the look and the sound of the...''[[MundaneMadeAwesome voice?]]''") and the "oooh-ooohs" "oohh-oohhh" backing vocals in the chorus are [[UpToEleven a bit much]], even those used to the band's overblown style.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Narm: The Ure-led period is littered with examples:
** "Vienna" is very melodramatic, what with Midge's hammy vocals & the pretentoius instrumentation. It's unsuprsingig some consider it either one of the 80s worst songs or it's best.
** "The Voice" has some rather silly lyrics ("the look and the sound of the...[[MundaneMadeAwesome voice?]]") and the "oooh-ooohs" backing in the chorus are a bit much, even those used to the band's overblown style.
** "Dancing With Tears In Eyes", despite being about a nuclear meltdown, is often mocked due to it's title alone, as well as Midge becoming a huge slab of pork during the chorus.

to:

* Narm: {{Narm{{: The Ure-led period is littered with examples:
** "Vienna" is very melodramatic, what with Midge's hammy vocals & the pretentoius pretentious instrumentation. It's unsuprsingig unsurprising some consider it either one of the 80s worst songs or it's best.
** "The Voice" has some rather silly lyrics ("the look and the sound of the...[[MundaneMadeAwesome voice?]]") ''[[MundaneMadeAwesome voice?]]''") and the "oooh-ooohs" backing in the chorus are [[UpToEleven a bit much, much]], even those used to the band's overblown style.
** "Dancing With Tears In Eyes", despite being about a nuclear meltdown, is often mocked due to it's title alone, as well as Midge becoming [[LargeHam a huge slab of pork pork]] during the chorus.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Narm: The Ure-led period is littered with examples:
** "Vienna" is very melodramatic, what with Midge's hammy vocals & the pretentoius instrumentation. It's unsuprsingig some consider it either one of the 80s worst songs or it's best.
** "The Voice" has some rather silly lyrics ("the look and the sound of the...[[MundaneMadeAwesome voice?]]") and the "oooh-ooohs" backing in the chorus are a bit much, even those used to the band's overblown style.
** "Dancing With Tears In Eyes", despite being about a nuclear meltdown, is often mocked due to it's title alone, as well as Midge becoming a huge slab of pork during the chorus.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* WereStillRelevantDammit: The second 90's incarnation of the band featured an image very much lifted from the {{grunge}} scene at the time, with long hair and casual clothing emblematic of pro-Generation X fashion. As a result, [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Tn2d0Dk-5Cs live performances]] of this incarnation are very jarring to look at, with what looks like a bunch of Music/{{Nirvana}} wannabes playing 90's pop rock; Billie Currie in particular looks woefully out of place with his keyboard and violin.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SeasonalRot: BrokenBase aside, fans of the John Foxx era, fans of the Midge Ure era, and fans of both eras all agree that the band's output suffered a severe drop in quality with ''U-Vox'', from which they never seemed to recover. The band split up two years after releasing ''U-Vox'', only to reform in TheNineties with a totally new lineup, save for the inclusion of Billie Currie. This, combined with the band's abandonment of Ultravox's signature NewWaveMusic sound in favor of pop-rock and the poor critical and fan reception of their musical output led this incarnation to unsurprisingly be regarded as Ultravox InNameOnly. Currie then replaced the entire lineup again in 1994, but this didn't help matters either, forcing Ultravox to disband a second time in 1996. The Ure-era lineup managed to reunite in 2008 to much acclaim, but their 2012 album ''Brill!ant'' was highly polarizing, not helped by the fact that it ended up truly being Ultravox's last.

to:

* SeasonalRot: BrokenBase aside, fans of the John Foxx era, fans of the Midge Ure era, and fans of both eras all agree that the band's output suffered a severe drop in quality with ''U-Vox'', [[CreatorKiller from which they never seemed to recover.recover]]. The band split up two years after releasing ''U-Vox'', only to reform in TheNineties with a totally new lineup, save for the inclusion of Billie Currie. This, combined with the band's abandonment of Ultravox's signature NewWaveMusic sound in favor of pop-rock and the poor critical and fan reception of their musical output led this incarnation to unsurprisingly be regarded as Ultravox InNameOnly. Currie then replaced the entire lineup again in 1994, but this didn't help matters either, forcing Ultravox to disband a second time in 1996. The Ure-era lineup managed to reunite in 2008 to much acclaim, but their 2012 album ''Brill!ant'' was highly polarizing, not helped by the fact that it ended up truly being Ultravox's last.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* HarsherInHindsight: The video for "Dancing with Tears in My Eyes" has a nuclear power plant accident causing an explosion two years before the Chernobyl accident in 1986.

Added: 433

Changed: 208

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BrokenBase: Debates still rage about whether the original John Foxx-led records or the Midge Ure-led records are better. While the former gets praised the most artistically, the latter was significantly more successful.

to:

* BrokenBase: BrokenBase:
**
Debates still rage about whether the original John Foxx-led records or the Midge Ure-led records are better. While the former gets praised the most artistically, the latter was significantly more successful.successful.
** Ure-era fans are decidedly split on the quality of ''Brill!ant''; to some, it's a much-needed return to form after the catastrophic results of the 1986-1994 albums, while others see it as nothing more than ''U-Vox 2.0''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FanonDiscontinuity: The InNameOnly 90's incarnations of Ultravox, thanks to their radically different sound and lineups.

to:

* FanonDiscontinuity: The InNameOnly 90's incarnations of Ultravox, thanks to their radically different sound and lineups.lineups, neither of which are well-received to this day.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FanonDiscontinuity: The InNameOnly 90's incarnation of Ultravox.

to:

* FanonDiscontinuity: The InNameOnly 90's incarnation incarnations of Ultravox.Ultravox, thanks to their radically different sound and lineups.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SuspiciouslySimilarSong: "Mr. X" sounds a ''lot'' like Music/{{Kraftwerk}}.

to:

* SuspiciouslySimilarSong: "Mr. X" sounds a ''lot'' like Music/{{Kraftwerk}}. It also shares its melody with former lead singer John Foxx's solo song "Touch and Go".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SuspiciouslySimilarSong: "Mr. X" sounds a ''lot'' like Music/{{Kraftwerk}}.

to:

* SuspiciouslySimilarSong: "Mr. X" sounds a ''lot'' like Music/{{Kraftwerk}}.Music/{{Kraftwerk}}.
* ToughActToFollow: ''Vienna'' was a huge hit. While promoting the follow-up ''Rage in Eden'', one of the band was asked how well he thought it would do. He replied "It probably won't be as successful, because not many records are."
----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SeasonalRot: BrokenBase aside, fans of the John Foxx era, fans of the Midge Ure era, and fans of both eras all agree that the band's output suffered a severe drop in quality with ''U-Vox'', from which they never seemed to recover. The band split up two years after releasing ''U-Vox'', only to reform in TheNineties with a totally new lineup, save for the inclusion of Billie Currie. This, combined with the band's abandonment of Ultravox's signature NewWaveMusic sound in favor of pop-rock and the poor critical and fan reception of their musical output led this incarnation to unsurprisingly be regarded as Ultravox InNameOnly. Currie then replaced the entire replacement lineup a second time in 1994, but this didn't help matters either, forcing Ultravox to disband a second time in 1996. The Ure-era lineup managed to reunite in 2008 to much acclaim, but their 2012 album ''Brill!ant'' was highly polarizing, not helped by the fact that it ended up truly being Ultravox's last.

to:

* SeasonalRot: BrokenBase aside, fans of the John Foxx era, fans of the Midge Ure era, and fans of both eras all agree that the band's output suffered a severe drop in quality with ''U-Vox'', from which they never seemed to recover. The band split up two years after releasing ''U-Vox'', only to reform in TheNineties with a totally new lineup, save for the inclusion of Billie Currie. This, combined with the band's abandonment of Ultravox's signature NewWaveMusic sound in favor of pop-rock and the poor critical and fan reception of their musical output led this incarnation to unsurprisingly be regarded as Ultravox InNameOnly. Currie then replaced the entire replacement lineup a second time again in 1994, but this didn't help matters either, forcing Ultravox to disband a second time in 1996. The Ure-era lineup managed to reunite in 2008 to much acclaim, but their 2012 album ''Brill!ant'' was highly polarizing, not helped by the fact that it ended up truly being Ultravox's last.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SeasonalRot: BrokenBase aside, John Foxx-era fans and Midge Ure-era ones both agree that the band's output suffered a severe drop in quality with ''U-Vox'', from which they never seemed to recover. The band split up two years after releasing ''U-Vox'', only to reform in TheNineties with a totally new lineup, save for the inclusion of Billie Currie. This, combined with the band's abandonment of Ultravox's signature NewWaveMusic sound in favor of pop-rock and the poor critical and fan reception of their musical output led this incarnation to unsurprisingly be regarded as Ultravox InNameOnly. Currie then replaced the entire replacement lineup a second time in 1994, but this didn't help matters either, forcing Ultravox to disband a second time in 1996. The Ure-era lineup managed to reunite in 2008 to much acclaim, but their 2012 album ''Brill!ant'' was highly polarizing, not helped by the fact that it ended up truly being Ultravox's last.

to:

* SeasonalRot: BrokenBase aside, fans of the John Foxx-era Foxx era, fans and of the Midge Ure-era ones Ure era, and fans of both eras all agree that the band's output suffered a severe drop in quality with ''U-Vox'', from which they never seemed to recover. The band split up two years after releasing ''U-Vox'', only to reform in TheNineties with a totally new lineup, save for the inclusion of Billie Currie. This, combined with the band's abandonment of Ultravox's signature NewWaveMusic sound in favor of pop-rock and the poor critical and fan reception of their musical output led this incarnation to unsurprisingly be regarded as Ultravox InNameOnly. Currie then replaced the entire replacement lineup a second time in 1994, but this didn't help matters either, forcing Ultravox to disband a second time in 1996. The Ure-era lineup managed to reunite in 2008 to much acclaim, but their 2012 album ''Brill!ant'' was highly polarizing, not helped by the fact that it ended up truly being Ultravox's last.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SeasonalRot: BrokenBase aside, John Foxx-era fans and Midge Ure-era ones both agree that the band's output suffered a severe drop in quality with ''U-Vox'', from which they never seemed to recover. The band split up two years after releasing ''U-Vox'', only to reform in TheNineties with a totally new lineup, save for the inclusion of Billie Currie. The completely different lineup and poorly-received musical output (consisting of just ''two'' albums between 1992 and 1996) led this incarnation to unsurprisingly be regarded as Ultravox InNameOnly. The Ure-era lineup managed to reunite in 2008 to much acclaim, but their 2012 album ''Brill!ant'' was highly polarizing, not helped by the fact that it ended up being Ultravox's last.

to:

* SeasonalRot: BrokenBase aside, John Foxx-era fans and Midge Ure-era ones both agree that the band's output suffered a severe drop in quality with ''U-Vox'', from which they never seemed to recover. The band split up two years after releasing ''U-Vox'', only to reform in TheNineties with a totally new lineup, save for the inclusion of Billie Currie. The completely different lineup This, combined with the band's abandonment of Ultravox's signature NewWaveMusic sound in favor of pop-rock and poorly-received the poor critical and fan reception of their musical output (consisting of just ''two'' albums between 1992 and 1996) led this incarnation to unsurprisingly be regarded as Ultravox InNameOnly. Currie then replaced the entire replacement lineup a second time in 1994, but this didn't help matters either, forcing Ultravox to disband a second time in 1996. The Ure-era lineup managed to reunite in 2008 to much acclaim, but their 2012 album ''Brill!ant'' was highly polarizing, not helped by the fact that it ended up truly being Ultravox's last.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* FanonDiscontinuity: The InNameOnly 90's incarnation of Ultravox.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SeasonalRot: BrokenBase aside, John Foxx-era fans and Midge Ure-era ones both agree that the band's output suffered a severe drop in quality with ''U-VOX'', from which they never seemed to recover. The band split up two years after releasing ''U-VOX'', only to reform in TheNineties with a totally new lineup, save for the inclusion of Billie Currie. The completely different lineup and poorly-received musical output (consisting of just ''two'' albums between 1992 and 1996) led this incarnation to unsurprisingly be regarded as Ultravox InNameOnly. The Ure-era lineup managed to reunite in 2008 to much acclaim, but their 2012 album ''Brilliant'' was highly polarizing, not helped by the fact that it ended up being Ultravox's last.

to:

* SeasonalRot: BrokenBase aside, John Foxx-era fans and Midge Ure-era ones both agree that the band's output suffered a severe drop in quality with ''U-VOX'', ''U-Vox'', from which they never seemed to recover. The band split up two years after releasing ''U-VOX'', ''U-Vox'', only to reform in TheNineties with a totally new lineup, save for the inclusion of Billie Currie. The completely different lineup and poorly-received musical output (consisting of just ''two'' albums between 1992 and 1996) led this incarnation to unsurprisingly be regarded as Ultravox InNameOnly. The Ure-era lineup managed to reunite in 2008 to much acclaim, but their 2012 album ''Brilliant'' ''Brill!ant'' was highly polarizing, not helped by the fact that it ended up being Ultravox's last.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* SeasonalRot: BrokenBase aside, John Foxx-era fans and Midge Ure-era ones both agree that the band's output suffered a severe drop in quality with ''U-VOX'', from which they never seemed to recover. The band split up two years after releasing ''U-VOX'', only to reform in TheNineties with a totally new lineup, save for the inclusion of Billie Currie. The completely different lineup and poorly-received musical output (consisting of just ''two'' albums between 1992 and 1996) led this incarnation to unsurprisingly be regarded as Ultravox InNameOnly. The Ure-era lineup managed to reunite in 2008 to much acclaim, but their 2012 album ''Brilliant'' was highly polarizing, not helped by the fact that it ended up being Ultravox's last.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Suspiciously similar song (Mr. X, which sounds like Kraftwerk)


* SignatureSong: Depending on how you know them, "Vienna" or "Dancing with Tears in My Eyes".

to:

* SignatureSong: Depending on how you know them, "Vienna" or "Dancing with Tears in My Eyes".Eyes".
* SuspiciouslySimilarSong: "Mr. X" sounds a ''lot'' like Music/{{Kraftwerk}}.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Not YMMV


* ThePeteBest: Foxx, in a rare case of this happening with a band that had already been signed and released several albums (to modest success and critical acclaim, to be fair). After he left, the band had its first-ever hit singles with Midge Ure at the mike, and remained fixtures of the UK pop charts for several years. Foxx's solo career brought him some minor hits, and he withdrew from music for a time after 1985.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
The Pete Best

Added DiffLines:

* ThePeteBest: Foxx, in a rare case of this happening with a band that had already been signed and released several albums (to modest success and critical acclaim, to be fair). After he left, the band had its first-ever hit singles with Midge Ure at the mike, and remained fixtures of the UK pop charts for several years. Foxx's solo career brought him some minor hits, and he withdrew from music for a time after 1985.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* MagnumOpus: ''Vienna'' has the most chart and critical success of the band's career.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BrokenBase: Debates still rage about whether the original John Foxx-led records or the Midge Ure-led records are better. While the former gets praised the most artistically, the latter was significantly more successful.
* MagnumOpus: ''Vienna'' has the most chart and critical success of the band's career.
* SignatureSong: Depending on how you know them, "Vienna" or "Dancing with Tears in My Eyes".

Top