Follow TV Tropes

Following

History YMMV / TimMinchin

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** "The Pope Song" chooses to call out the Pope with the opening line "fuck the motherfucker".
* DudeNotFunny: Some more conservative Catholic groups were not amused by "The Pope Song". Given how they didn't get the point, it's not surprising.

Added: 996

Changed: 672

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AcceptableTargets: Child molesting priests in ''[[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fHRDfut2Vx0 The Pope Song]]''.

to:

* AcceptableTargets: AcceptableTargets:
**
Child molesting priests in ''[[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fHRDfut2Vx0 The Pope Song]]''.



* CrossesTheLineTwice: ''Some People Have It Worse Than I'' "I could be a thalidomide child with something in my eye, something in my eye!"

to:

* CrossesTheLineTwice: CrossesTheLineTwice:
**
''Some People Have It Worse Than I'' "I could be a thalidomide child with something in my eye, something in my eye!"



* SomeAnvilsNeedToBeDropped: "The Pope Song". The message isn't 'fuck the Pope' but 'if you're more offended by a song in which I say a few nasty words about the Pope than you are about the Pope knowingly sheltering pedophiles that is a really screwed up system of morality you have there'. This may sound like a message anyone should get, but there are countless defenders of this sort of stuff even in 2014, so the anvil ''really'' needs to be dropped.

to:

* SomeAnvilsNeedToBeDropped: SomeAnvilsNeedToBeDropped:
**
"The Pope Song". The message isn't 'fuck the Pope' but 'if you're more offended by a song in which I say a few nasty words about the Pope than you are about the Pope knowingly sheltering pedophiles that is a really screwed up system of morality you have there'. This may sound like a message anyone should get, but there are countless defenders of this sort of stuff even in 2014, so the anvil ''really'' needs to be dropped.dropped.
** "The Fence". The message is that the world is not as [[AlwaysChaoticEvil black]] and [[AlwaysLawfulGood white]] as some make it out to be. He gives the example of the default "military all good, paedophiles all bad" by pointing out that some soldiers may well be paedophiles, while some paedophiles may have guns.



* TearJerker: ''White Wine in the Sun'' for many.

to:

* TearJerker: TearJerker:
**
''White Wine in the Sun'' for many.

Added: 492

Changed: 100

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* PainfulRhyme: From ''Five Poofs and Two Pianos'':

to:

* PainfulRhyme: He has quite a few, though mercifully they're rather funny to make up for it in most cases.
**
From ''Five Poofs and Two Pianos'':


Added DiffLines:

* SomeAnvilsNeedToBeDropped: "The Pope Song". The message isn't 'fuck the Pope' but 'if you're more offended by a song in which I say a few nasty words about the Pope than you are about the Pope knowingly sheltering pedophiles that is a really screwed up system of morality you have there'. This may sound like a message anyone should get, but there are countless defenders of this sort of stuff even in 2014, so the anvil ''really'' needs to be dropped.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** On the bumper sticker "Magic happens": "I have to resist the urge to take my permanent marker and sneak over and write under it, 'So does cot death'."

Added: 391

Changed: 399

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Fridge Brilliance}}:
** When you first listen to The Pope Song, it's tempting to assume it's just an example of VulgarHumor and nothing but an {{Author Tract}} against the Pope filled with {{Cluster F Bomb}}s. When you listen to it again and think about it, though, you realize that the fact that it's offensive is the whole point - the song isn't criticizing the Pope so much as it is people who look the other way when he does something morally grey (or black) but don't hesitate to jump on anyone for questioning him, other religious leaders, or religion in general. The message isn't 'fuck the Pope' but 'if you're more offended by a song in which I say a few nasty words about the Pope than you are about the Pope knowingly sheltering pedophiles that is a really screwed up system of morality you have there'.

to:

* {{Fridge Brilliance}}:
FridgeBrilliance:
** When you first listen to The Pope Song, it's tempting to assume it's just an example of VulgarHumor and nothing but an {{Author Tract}} AuthorTract against the Pope filled with {{Cluster F Bomb}}s. When you listen to it again and think about it, though, you realize that the fact that it's offensive is the whole point - the song isn't criticizing the Pope so much as it is people who look the other way when he does something morally grey (or black) but don't hesitate to jump on anyone for questioning him, other religious leaders, or religion in general. The message isn't 'fuck the Pope' but 'if you're more offended by a song in which I say a few nasty words about the Pope than you are about the Pope knowingly sheltering pedophiles that is a really screwed up system of morality you have there'.



* GeniusBonus: the whole routine about [[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DX_K1wb-S9s singing in F-sharp]], aside from showcasing HollywoodToneDeaf in the most wonderful way, is extra funny if you're a vocalist and know that F-major is, for some reason, impossible to sing in. Without instruments to herd them, 90% of singers starting out in that key will have drifted into another by the end of the song.

to:

* GeniusBonus: the GeniusBonus:
** The
whole routine about [[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DX_K1wb-S9s singing in F-sharp]], aside from showcasing HollywoodToneDeaf in the most wonderful way, is extra funny if you're a vocalist and know that F-major is, for some reason, impossible to sing in. Without instruments to herd them, 90% of singers starting out in that key will have drifted into another by the end of the song.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Refuge In Vulgarity is being renamed to Vulgar Humor. Zero Context Examples and bad examples are being cut.


** When you first listen to The Pope Song, it's tempting to assume it's just an example of {{Refuge In Vulgarity}} and nothing but an {{Author Tract}} against the Pope filled with {{Cluster F Bomb}}s. When you listen to it again and think about it, though, you realize that the fact that it's offensive is the whole point - the song isn't criticizing the Pope so much as it is people who look the other way when he does something morally grey (or black) but don't hesitate to jump on anyone for questioning him, other religious leaders, or religion in general. The message isn't 'fuck the Pope' but 'if you're more offended by a song in which I say a few nasty words about the Pope than you are about the Pope knowingly sheltering pedophiles that is a really screwed up system of morality you have there'.

to:

** When you first listen to The Pope Song, it's tempting to assume it's just an example of {{Refuge In Vulgarity}} VulgarHumor and nothing but an {{Author Tract}} against the Pope filled with {{Cluster F Bomb}}s. When you listen to it again and think about it, though, you realize that the fact that it's offensive is the whole point - the song isn't criticizing the Pope so much as it is people who look the other way when he does something morally grey (or black) but don't hesitate to jump on anyone for questioning him, other religious leaders, or religion in general. The message isn't 'fuck the Pope' but 'if you're more offended by a song in which I say a few nasty words about the Pope than you are about the Pope knowingly sheltering pedophiles that is a really screwed up system of morality you have there'.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Refuge In Vulgarity is being renamed to Vulgar Humor. Zero Context Examples and bad examples are being cut.


* SophomoreSlump: ''So Rock'' has some good numbers, but veers much further than ''Dark Side'' into RefugeInVulgarity. Fortunately, this is dialled back on ''Ready For This?'' in favour of [[DeadpanSnarker Deadpan Snarking]], {{Take That}}s and {{Anti Love Song}}s.

to:

* SophomoreSlump: ''So Rock'' has some good numbers, but veers much further than ''Dark Side'' into RefugeInVulgarity.VulgarHumor. Fortunately, this is dialled back on ''Ready For This?'' in favour of [[DeadpanSnarker Deadpan Snarking]], {{Take That}}s and {{Anti Love Song}}s.

Added: 128

Changed: 1765

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Fridge Brilliance}}: When you first listen to The Pope Song, it's tempting to assume it's just an example of {{Refuge In Vulgarity}} and nothing but an {{Author Tract}} against the Pope filled with {{Cluster F Bomb}}s. When you listen to it again and think about it, though, you realize that the fact that it's offensive is the whole point - the song isn't criticizing the Pope so much as it is people who look the other way when he does something morally grey (or black) but don't hesitate to jump on anyone for questioning him, other religious leaders, or religion in general. The message isn't 'fuck the Pope' but 'if you're more offended by a song in which I say a few nasty words about the Pope than you are about the Pope knowingly sheltering pedophiles that is a really screwed up system of morality you have there'.
** For Prejudice, there's some Fridge Brilliance when you realise that Tim can say the infamous word.
*** ''Wossy Can I Bang Your Wife'' was a show of solidarity, crossing the line that had previously got the show he performed it on cancelled.

to:

* {{Fridge Brilliance}}: Brilliance}}:
**
When you first listen to The Pope Song, it's tempting to assume it's just an example of {{Refuge In Vulgarity}} and nothing but an {{Author Tract}} against the Pope filled with {{Cluster F Bomb}}s. When you listen to it again and think about it, though, you realize that the fact that it's offensive is the whole point - the song isn't criticizing the Pope so much as it is people who look the other way when he does something morally grey (or black) but don't hesitate to jump on anyone for questioning him, other religious leaders, or religion in general. The message isn't 'fuck the Pope' but 'if you're more offended by a song in which I say a few nasty words about the Pope than you are about the Pope knowingly sheltering pedophiles that is a really screwed up system of morality you have there'.
** For Prejudice, ''Prejudice'', there's some Fridge Brilliance when you realise that Tim can say the infamous word.
*** ''Wossy Can I Bang Your Wife'' ** ''Song for Wossy'' was a show of solidarity, crossing the line that had previously got the show he performed it on cancelled.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** ''Drowned,'' about the duality of love.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** ''You Grew On Me''. The lyrics are hilarious, but the melody and emotion he brings to it are astounding.

to:

** ''You Grew On Me''. The lyrics are hilarious, but the melody and emotion he brings to it are astounding. During performances, you can hear people laughing along with the first verse, and then listening to it in awed silence when he repeats it at the end of the song.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** ''Not Perfect''. In particular, this part tends to bring people with body issues to tears.

to:

** During some live tapings of ''Not Perfect''.Perfect'', you can actually see audience members crying. In particular, this part tends to bring people with body issues to tears.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Editing for style


It's not perfect, but it's mine

to:

It's not perfect, but ''but it's minemine.''



it’s not perfect, ''but it’s mine.''\\

to:

it’s It’s not perfect, ''but it’s mine.''\\
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** ''Not Perfect'' also has the tendency to upset those people with mental health issues; after singing about how his brain made of love and bad lyrics, but can also hide his fucked up thoughts, he closes:
-->It’s where I spend the vast majority of my time.\\
it’s not perfect, ''but it’s mine.''\\
It’s not perfect, I’m not quite sure I’ve worked out how to work it.\\
It’s not perfect, ''but it’s mine.''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Moved True Art Is Angsty over.

Added DiffLines:

* TrueArtIsAngsty: Discussed in ''Rock And Roll Nerd'' and satirised in ''Dark Side''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Also, the sceptic Minchin often has a go at irrational belief; such as in "Storm", "If I Didn't Have You", "White Wine In The Sun", "I Love Jesus", "Take My Wife" and "Ten Foot Cock And A Few Hundred Virgins".

to:

** Also, the sceptic Minchin often has a go at irrational belief; such as in "Storm", "If I Didn't Have You", "White Wine In The Sun", "I Love Jesus", "Take My Wife" Wife", "Thank You God" and "Ten Foot Cock And A Few Hundred Virgins".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


''I took you round to watch the f-uitable.''

to:

''I took you round to watch the f-uitable.foot-able.''

Added: 137

Changed: 32

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** From ''Inflatable You'' (a song that consists of these):

to:

** From ''Inflatable You'' (a song that consists of these):You'':


Added DiffLines:

** In the ''Three Minute Song'':
-->''But the problem with my particular oeuvre''\\
''Is that half my songs are five minutes and oeu-ver''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** From ''Inflatable You'' (a song that consists of these):
-->''My mates all reckon you are suitable''\\
''I took you round to watch the f-uitable.''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
ARRGH


It's not perfect, but it's mine\\

to:

It's not perfect, but it's mine\\mine

Added: 114

Changed: 2

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Decided it would be better to quote the chorus as well


But it never says a bad word about me

to:

But it never says a bad word about meme\\
This is my body, and it's fine\\
It's where I spend the vast majority of my time\\
It's not perfect, but it's mine\\

Added: 35

Changed: 90

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** ''You Grew On Me''. Also, ''Rock And Roll Nerd'' for some.

to:

** ''You Grew On Me''. Also, The lyrics are hilarious, but the melody and emotion he brings to it are astounding.
**
''Rock And Roll Nerd'' for some.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Horse shit.


--> I spend so much time hating it\\
--> But it never says a bad word about me\\

to:

--> I spend so much time hating it\\
--> But it never says a bad word about me\\me

Added: 119

Changed: 74

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** ''Not Perfect''.

to:

** ''Not Perfect''. In particular, this part tends to bring people with body issues to tears.
--> And the weirdest thing about it is\\
--> I spend so much time hating it\\
--> But it never says a bad word about me\\
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* CrossesTheLineTwice: ''Some People Have It Worse Than I'' "I could be a thalidomide child with something in my eye, something in my eye!"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
game, not a trope.


* BetterThanItSounds: ''Mitsubishi Colt'' and ''Storm'' are 9-minute AuthorTract beat poems about, respectively, a drunken yuppie and a GranolaGirl. ''Storm'' in particular is considered among his best work.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** ''Wossy Can I Bang Your Wife'' was a show of solidarity, crossing the line that had previously got the show he performed it on cancelled.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* EarWorm: Most of his songs but especially ''Thank You God''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** For Prejudice, there's some Fridge Brilliance when you realise that Tim can say the infamous word.

Added: 2473

Changed: 878

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Fridge Brilliance}}: When you first listen to The Pope Song, it's tempting to assume it's just an example of {{Refuge In Vulgarity}} and nothing but an {{Author Tract}} against the Pope filled with {{Cluster F Bomb}}s. When you listen to it again and think about it, though, you realize that the fact that it's offensive is the whole point - the song isn't criticizing the Pope so much as it is people who look the other way when he does something morally grey (or black) but don't hesitate to jump on anyone for questioning him, other religious leaders, or religion in general. The message isn't 'fuck the Pope' but 'if you're more offended by a song in which I say a few nasty words about the Pope than you are about the Pope knowingly sheltering pedophiles that is a really screwed up system of morality you have there'.

to:

* AcceptableTargets: Child molesting priests in ''[[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fHRDfut2Vx0 The Pope Song]]''.
** Also, the sceptic Minchin often has a go at irrational belief; such as in "Storm", "If I Didn't Have You", "White Wine In The Sun", "I Love Jesus", "Take My Wife" and "Ten Foot Cock And A Few Hundred Virgins".
* BetterThanItSounds: ''Mitsubishi Colt'' and ''Storm'' are 9-minute AuthorTract beat poems about, respectively, a drunken yuppie and a GranolaGirl. ''Storm'' in particular is considered among his best work.
* {{Fridge Brilliance}}: When you first listen to The Pope Song, it's tempting to assume it's just an example of {{Refuge In Vulgarity}} and nothing but an {{Author Tract}} against the Pope filled with {{Cluster F Bomb}}s. When you listen to it again and think about it, though, you realize that the fact that it's offensive is the whole point - the song isn't criticizing the Pope so much as it is people who look the other way when he does something morally grey (or black) but don't hesitate to jump on anyone for questioning him, other religious leaders, or religion in general. The message isn't 'fuck the Pope' but 'if you're more offended by a song in which I say a few nasty words about the Pope than you are about the Pope knowingly sheltering pedophiles that is a really screwed up system of morality you have there'.there'.
* GeniusBonus: the whole routine about [[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DX_K1wb-S9s singing in F-sharp]], aside from showcasing HollywoodToneDeaf in the most wonderful way, is extra funny if you're a vocalist and know that F-major is, for some reason, impossible to sing in. Without instruments to herd them, 90% of singers starting out in that key will have drifted into another by the end of the song.
** In ''If I Didn't Have You'', Tim conjectures an alternate universe in which he is married to a small blonde Portuguese skier with neck-down [[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alopecia alopecia]].
* PainfulRhyme: From ''Five Poofs and Two Pianos'':
-->''Five poofs, and two pianos''\\
''Yeah! It's a revolution''\\
''And probably the best solution''\\
''To the problem you're inveitably having with an even number of homosexuals...''
* SophomoreSlump: ''So Rock'' has some good numbers, but veers much further than ''Dark Side'' into RefugeInVulgarity. Fortunately, this is dialled back on ''Ready For This?'' in favour of [[DeadpanSnarker Deadpan Snarking]], {{Take That}}s and {{Anti Love Song}}s.
* TearJerker: ''White Wine in the Sun'' for many.
** ''Not Perfect''.
** ''You Grew On Me''. Also, ''Rock And Roll Nerd'' for some.
----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Fridge Brilliance}}: When you first listen to The Pope Song, it's tempting to assume it's just an example of {{RefugeInVulgarity}} and nothing but an {{AuthorTract}} against the Pope filled with {{ClusterFBomb}}s. When you listen to it again and think about it, though, you realize that the fact that it's offensive is the whole point - the song isn't criticizing the Pope so much as it is people who look the other way when he does something morally grey (or black) but don't hesitate to jump on anyone for questioning him, other religious leaders, or religion in general. The message isn't 'fuck the Pope' but 'if you're more offended by a song in which I say a few nasty words about the Pope than you are about the Pope knowingly sheltering pedophiles that is a really screwed up system of morality you have there'.

to:

* {{Fridge Brilliance}}: When you first listen to The Pope Song, it's tempting to assume it's just an example of {{RefugeInVulgarity}} {{Refuge In Vulgarity}} and nothing but an {{AuthorTract}} {{Author Tract}} against the Pope filled with {{ClusterFBomb}}s.{{Cluster F Bomb}}s. When you listen to it again and think about it, though, you realize that the fact that it's offensive is the whole point - the song isn't criticizing the Pope so much as it is people who look the other way when he does something morally grey (or black) but don't hesitate to jump on anyone for questioning him, other religious leaders, or religion in general. The message isn't 'fuck the Pope' but 'if you're more offended by a song in which I say a few nasty words about the Pope than you are about the Pope knowingly sheltering pedophiles that is a really screwed up system of morality you have there'.

Top