History YMMV / TheSecretIslandOfDrQuandary

* NightmareFuel: The sequence where the player takes the doll only to be sucked into its mouth in a color-shifting vortex was noted to give children and adults both nightmares. Even in modern-day {{Lets Play}}s, the players will frequently warn for the scary scene coming up and include an option to skip it. The UnintentionalUncannyValley look of the dolls and the more realistic characters is also pretty good fuel.
* SurpriseDifficulty / ThatOnePuzzle : An algebra minigame in my kiddie EdutainmentGame? Tax Factor regularly stumps adults doing {{Lets Play}}s or walkthroughs unless played as B. Ginner.

* UndesirablePrize: Losing at Discappear nets the player one of the Beach Dudette's terrible Compact Discs, such as [[Music/TinyTim Tiny Tim]]: The Vegas Years or Ukulele Bob Alone at Last.

* NightmareFuel: The sequence where the player takes the doll only to be sucked into its mouth in a color-shifting vortex was noted to give children and adults both nightmares. Even in modern-day {{Lets Play}}s, the players will frequently warn for the scary scene coming up and include an option to skip it. The UncannyValley look of the dolls and the more realistic characters is also pretty good fuel.

* UncannyValley: If there's one thing players remember about this game, it's this. Possibly deliberate with the dolls, since they're.. well, dolls.

* Undesirable Prize: Losing at Disappear nets the player one of the Beach Dudette's terrible Compact Discs, such as [[Music/TinyTim Tiny Tim]]: The Vegas Years or Ukulele Bob Alone at Last.

* UncannyValley: If there's one thing players remember about this game, it's this. Possibly deliberate with the dolls, since they're.. well, dolls.

** There's also Disc Appear, which is sure to be a showstopper for anyone unfamiliar with the underlying mechanics of the GameOfNim. Then D. Feecult gives you an additional middle finger by ''changing the rules'', with your only hint that this has occurred being that a single ingredient of the Fixer Elixir has changed.

* UncannyValley: If there's one thing players remember about this game, it's this. Possibly deliberate with the dolls, since they are... dolls.

* AccidentalNightmareFuel: The sequence where the player takes the doll only to be sucked into its mouth in a color-shifting vortex was noted to give children and adults both nightmares. Even in modern-day {{Lets Play}}s, the players will frequently warn for the scary scene coming up and include an option to skip it. The UncannyValley look of the dolls and the more realistic characters is also pretty good fuel.

* GettingCrapPastTheRadar: At the carnival, clicking the ferris wheel cars, the ticket booth, the crowd, and the fortune-teller's sign will get you comments. One of the comments from the ferris wheel is "[[MakingLoveInAllTheWrongPlaces Harder! HARDER!]]", with the car shaking appropriately.
** The doll O.D. Nary doesn't seem to be wearing pants.

* SurpriseDifficulty: An algebra minigame in my kiddie EdutainmentGame? Tax Factor regularly stumps adults doing {{Lets Play}}s or walkthroughs unless played as B. Ginner.