Follow TV Tropes

Following

History YMMV / TheKeyToASuccessfulInterview

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** WordOfGod insists he's not writing a CrackFic, nor is it supposed to be a joke.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Ryoga managing to find happiness [[spoiler:with [[Manga/AzumangaDaioh Osaka]].

to:

** Ryoga managing to find happiness [[spoiler:with [[Manga/AzumangaDaioh Osaka]].]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* CrowningMomentOfHeartwarming:
** After Akane's [[spoiler:pregnancy scare]], Ranma admits that part of him would have been happy to be a father.
** Ryoga managing to find happiness [[spoiler:with [[Manga/AzumangaDaioh Osaka]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** [[spoiler: Kasumi whupping Shampoo's ass in Chapter 16. This is even more awesome by the fact that in the previous chapter, Akane, Ryoga, Mousse, and Kuno teamed up had tried and ''failed'' to best Shampoo.]]

to:

** [[spoiler: Kasumi whupping Shampoo's ass in Chapter 16. This is even more awesome by the fact that in the previous chapter, Akane, Ryoga, Kodachi, Mousse, and Kuno teamed up had tried and ''failed'' to best Shampoo.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


----



* VillainSue: Shampoo, but she gets better.

to:

* VillainSue: Shampoo, but she gets better.better.

----

Removed: 282

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
I rembered coming across this page recently. This doesn\'t seem like an appropriate use of the trope (it just seems like complaining). Jerk Sue can\'t be a trope used to definie every character in a work- its supposed to be used for a specific character that stands out. The fact its being applied to everyone makes me think it doesn\'t fit anyone.


* JerkSue: The main problem with an othervise rather well-written romp. Many of the characters are played as unsympathetic ruthless, callous, crude, sadistic, bullying, and manipulative sociopathic overpowered JerkAss types, complete with {{butt monkey}}s, and are applauded for it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* JerkSue: The main problem with an othervise rather well-written romp. Many of the characters are played as unsympathetic ruthless, callous, crude, sadistic, bullying, and manipulative sociopathic overpowered JerkAss types, complete with {{butt monkey}}s, and are applauded for it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
This isn\'t YMMV. Moving.


* OnlySaneMan: ''Nabiki'' appears to be the only one left, now. She's the only one who actually breaks down and cries in the face of overwhelming stupidity and/or insanity, complete with a ThousandYardStare.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Chapter 14 [[spoiler: TrainingMontage with Donny Osmond, complete with musical numbers, PLURAL. And one of them is the famous montage song from SouthPark!]]

to:

** Chapter 14 [[spoiler: TrainingMontage with Donny Osmond, complete with musical numbers, PLURAL. And one of them is the famous montage song from SouthPark!]]WesternAnimation/SouthPark!]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Namespace


** Akane gets one when she beats Kodachi... with a [[JoJosBizarreAdventure ZA WARUDO]] impression. OUCH.

to:

** Akane gets one when she beats Kodachi... with a [[JoJosBizarreAdventure [[Manga/JoJosBizarreAdventure ZA WARUDO]] impression. OUCH.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Chapter 14 [[spoiler: GonnaFlyNowMontage with Donny Osmond, complete with musical numbers, PLURAL. And one of them is the famous montage song from SouthPark!]]

to:

** Chapter 14 [[spoiler: GonnaFlyNowMontage TrainingMontage with Donny Osmond, complete with musical numbers, PLURAL. And one of them is the famous montage song from SouthPark!]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* VillainSue: Shampoo, but she gets better and becomes a regular MarySue.

to:

* VillainSue: Shampoo, but she gets better and becomes a regular MarySue.better.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** [[spoiler: "I'm the [[AuthorAvatar Ero-Sennin]] and this is a Fuck You."]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TrollFic: The entire point of the story for some people. On how many levels (if any at all) depends on how highly you think of the author, but various options are listed in the talk page.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* VillainSue: Shampoo, [[HeelFaceTurn but she gets better.]]

to:

* VillainSue: Shampoo, [[HeelFaceTurn but she gets better.]]better and becomes a regular MarySue.

Changed: 1744

Removed: 1148

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Your mileage may vary, yes, but the commentary on the tropes is better suited for the review page.


* CanonDefilement: YourMileageMayVary, but some readers think that most of the characters were much kinder or had largely different personalities originally, to the point that several of them on-off read like similar callous voices that simply borrow the names. When [[TheMessiah Kas]][[FriendToAllLivingThings umi]] starts to seriously threaten to murder her father things have definitely gone far beyond "creative liberties". The overall thematics, interpretations, and power-scalings othervise also diverge wildly from canon, and the narrative has a far more sadistic amoral edge than the original work, with genuinely malevolent characters, such as Shampoo or Nabiki, presented as greatly favoured over ones that are ultimately simply crazy, damaged, and obnoxious, but comparatively harmless, such as principal Kuno.
* CentralTheme: The presented general running thread is: "{{JerkAss}}es and [[TheSociopath Sociopaths]] [[BlueAndOrangeMorality versus]] {{CloudCuckooLander}}s and AcceptableHardLuckTargets". Major BaseBreaker whether the tendency goes well with the reader or not.

to:

* CanonDefilement: YourMileageMayVary, but some readers think that most of the characters were much kinder or had largely different personalities originally, to the point that several of them on-off read like similar callous voices that simply borrow the names. When [[TheMessiah Kas]][[FriendToAllLivingThings umi]] starts to seriously threaten to murder her father things have definitely gone far beyond "creative liberties". The overall thematics, interpretations, Done so gleefully and power-scalings othervise also diverge wildly from canon, and the narrative has without hesitation in a far more sadistic amoral edge than the original work, with genuinely malevolent characters, such as Shampoo or Nabiki, presented as greatly favoured deliberately over ones that are ultimately simply crazy, damaged, and obnoxious, but comparatively harmless, such as principal Kuno.
* CentralTheme: The presented general running thread is: "{{JerkAss}}es and [[TheSociopath Sociopaths]] [[BlueAndOrangeMorality versus]] {{CloudCuckooLander}}s and AcceptableHardLuckTargets". Major BaseBreaker whether
the tendency goes well with the reader or not.top fashion.



* JerkSue: Ranma and Akane are arguably much greater callous savage intolerant JerkAss types than in canon, and given highly preferential treatment because of these qualities. Nabiki is either this or a VillainSue.
* OnlySaneMan: BaseBreaker. The narrative apparently attempts to portray Ranma, Akane, and to an extent Nabiki and eventually Shampoo as this, but it depends on the reader whether it works or not. One part views it as ComedicSociopathy RuleOfFunny RuleOfCool CrossingTheLineTwice ShoutOut creative liberties, and working relative to the more irrational rest of the cast. Another gets a very strong impression that the manner the favoured characters think, talk, and behave recurrently extremely closely intersects with the typical pattern of real-world style in-control, ideologically sadistic, calculating, ruthless, completely compassion-deprived, callously condemning, textbook [[TheSociopath sociopaths]]; [[BlueAndOrangeMorality and with extremely contradictory, inconsistent, disproportionate, and othervise odd sense of scale between different transgressions and punishments]].

to:

* JerkSue: Ranma and Akane are arguably much greater callous savage intolerant JerkAss types than in canon, and given highly preferential treatment because of these qualities. Nabiki is either this or a VillainSue.
* OnlySaneMan: BaseBreaker. The narrative apparently attempts ''Nabiki'' appears to portray Ranma, Akane, be the only one left, now. She's the only one who actually breaks down and to an extent Nabiki and eventually Shampoo as this, but it depends on cries in the reader whether it works or not. One part views it as ComedicSociopathy RuleOfFunny RuleOfCool CrossingTheLineTwice ShoutOut creative liberties, and working relative to the more irrational rest face of the cast. Another gets a very strong impression that the manner the favoured characters think, talk, and behave recurrently extremely closely intersects overwhelming stupidity and/or insanity, complete with the typical pattern of real-world style in-control, ideologically sadistic, calculating, ruthless, completely compassion-deprived, callously condemning, textbook [[TheSociopath sociopaths]]; [[BlueAndOrangeMorality and with extremely contradictory, inconsistent, disproportionate, and othervise odd sense of scale between different transgressions and punishments]].a ThousandYardStare.



* VillainSue: Shampoo. She has a mindset on par with the worst BlackLagoon cast members. Although beyond the extreme power-up Shampoo's personality may be the most in-character in the entire story, simply cranked UpToEleven, and the reason she worked despite this in canon (while keeping the irreverent tone intact) is partially that she was there treated as severely outmatched by any male with the possible exception of Tatewaki, and as the least martially talented member of the cast, considering her lack of prowess despite being trained by Cologne (however, she was also the most devious and multi-talented).

to:

* VillainSue: Shampoo. She has a mindset on par with the worst BlackLagoon cast members. Although beyond the extreme power-up Shampoo's personality may be the most in-character in the entire story, simply cranked UpToEleven, and the reason Shampoo, [[HeelFaceTurn but she worked despite this in canon (while keeping the irreverent tone intact) is partially that she was there treated as severely outmatched by any male with the possible exception of Tatewaki, and as the least martially talented member of the cast, considering her lack of prowess despite being trained by Cologne (however, she was also the most devious and multi-talented).gets better.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* VillainSue: Shampoo. She has a mindset on par with the worst BlackLagoon cast members, and among other things [[MoralEventHorizon planned to brainwash Akane into forgetting her life and family, to then be sold into sex-slavery]]. Although beyond the extreme power-up Shampoo's personality may be the most in-character in the entire story, simply cranked UpToEleven, and the reason she worked despite this in canon (while keeping the irreverent tone intact) is partially that she was there treated as severely outmatched by any male with the possible exception of Tatewaki, and as the least martially talented member of the cast, considering her lack of prowess despite being trained by Cologne (however, she was also the most devious and multi-talented).

to:

* VillainSue: Shampoo. She has a mindset on par with the worst BlackLagoon cast members, and among other things [[MoralEventHorizon planned to brainwash Akane into forgetting her life and family, to then be sold into sex-slavery]].members. Although beyond the extreme power-up Shampoo's personality may be the most in-character in the entire story, simply cranked UpToEleven, and the reason she worked despite this in canon (while keeping the irreverent tone intact) is partially that she was there treated as severely outmatched by any male with the possible exception of Tatewaki, and as the least martially talented member of the cast, considering her lack of prowess despite being trained by Cologne (however, she was also the most devious and multi-talented).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** [[spoiler: Kasumi whupping Shampoo's ass in Chapter 19. This is even more awesome by the fact that in the previous chapter, Akane, Ryoga, Mousse, and Kuno teamed up had tried and ''failed'' to best Shampoo.]]

to:

** [[spoiler: Kasumi whupping Shampoo's ass in Chapter 19.16. This is even more awesome by the fact that in the previous chapter, Akane, Ryoga, Mousse, and Kuno teamed up had tried and ''failed'' to best Shampoo.]]



** Chapter 17 [[spoiler: GonnaFlyNowMontage with Donny Osmond, complete with musical numbers, PLURAL. And one of them is the famous montage song from SouthPark!]]
** Chapter 24 is a crowning CHAPTER of funny!

to:

** Chapter 17 14 [[spoiler: GonnaFlyNowMontage with Donny Osmond, complete with musical numbers, PLURAL. And one of them is the famous montage song from SouthPark!]]
** Chapter 24 21 is a crowning CHAPTER of funny!



* TearJerker: The results of [[WhamEpisode Chapter 15]] are literally this for Akane, bordering on DespairEventHorizon.

to:

* TearJerker: The results of [[WhamEpisode Chapter 15]] 12]] are literally this for Akane, bordering on DespairEventHorizon.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CanonDefilement: YourMileageMayVary, but some readers think that most of the characters were much kinder or had largely different personalities originally, to the point that several of them read like PossessionSue spokespieces that simply borrow the names. When [[TheMessiah Kas]][[FriendToAllLivingThings umi]] starts to seriously threaten to murder her father things have definitely gone far beyond "creative liberties". The overall thematics, interpretations, and power-scalings othervise also diverge wildly from canon, and the narrative has a far more sadistic amoral edge than the original work, with genuinely malevolent characters, such as Shampoo or Nabiki, presented as greatly favoured over ones that are ultimately simply crazy, damaged, and obnoxious, but comparatively harmless, such as principal Kuno.

to:

* CanonDefilement: YourMileageMayVary, but some readers think that most of the characters were much kinder or had largely different personalities originally, to the point that several of them on-off read like PossessionSue spokespieces similar callous voices that simply borrow the names. When [[TheMessiah Kas]][[FriendToAllLivingThings umi]] starts to seriously threaten to murder her father things have definitely gone far beyond "creative liberties". The overall thematics, interpretations, and power-scalings othervise also diverge wildly from canon, and the narrative has a far more sadistic amoral edge than the original work, with genuinely malevolent characters, such as Shampoo or Nabiki, presented as greatly favoured over ones that are ultimately simply crazy, damaged, and obnoxious, but comparatively harmless, such as principal Kuno.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CanonDefilement: YourMileageMayVary, but some readers think that most of the characters were much kinder or had largely different personalities originally, to the point that several of them read like PossessionSue spokespieces that simply borrow the names. When [[TheMessiah Kas]][[FriendToAllLivingThings umi]] starts to seriously threaten to murder her father things have definitely gone far beyond "creative liberties". The overall thematics, interpretations, and power-scalings othervise also diverge wildly from canon, and the narrative has a far more sadistic amoral edge than the original work, with genuinely malevolent characters (Shampoo among other things [[MoralEventHorizon planned to brainwash Akane into forgetting her life and family, to then be sold into sex-slavery]]) easily favoured over ones that are ultimately simply crazy, damaged, and obnoxious, but comparatively harmless, such as principal Kuno.

to:

* CanonDefilement: YourMileageMayVary, but some readers think that most of the characters were much kinder or had largely different personalities originally, to the point that several of them read like PossessionSue spokespieces that simply borrow the names. When [[TheMessiah Kas]][[FriendToAllLivingThings umi]] starts to seriously threaten to murder her father things have definitely gone far beyond "creative liberties". The overall thematics, interpretations, and power-scalings othervise also diverge wildly from canon, and the narrative has a far more sadistic amoral edge than the original work, with genuinely malevolent characters (Shampoo among other things [[MoralEventHorizon planned to brainwash Akane into forgetting her life and family, to then be sold into sex-slavery]]) easily characters, such as Shampoo or Nabiki, presented as greatly favoured over ones that are ultimately simply crazy, damaged, and obnoxious, but comparatively harmless, such as principal Kuno.



* VillainSue: Shampoo. She has a mindset on par with the worst BlackLagoon cast members. Although beyond the extreme power-up Shampoo's personality may be the most in-character in the entire story, simply cranked UpToEleven, and the reason she worked despite this in canon (while keeping the irreverent tone intact) is partially that she was there treated as severely outmatched by any male with the possible exception of Tatewaki, and as the least martially talented member of the cast, considering her lack of prowess despite being trained by Cologne (however, she was also the most devious and multi-talented).

to:

* VillainSue: Shampoo. She has a mindset on par with the worst BlackLagoon cast members.members, and among other things [[MoralEventHorizon planned to brainwash Akane into forgetting her life and family, to then be sold into sex-slavery]]. Although beyond the extreme power-up Shampoo's personality may be the most in-character in the entire story, simply cranked UpToEleven, and the reason she worked despite this in canon (while keeping the irreverent tone intact) is partially that she was there treated as severely outmatched by any male with the possible exception of Tatewaki, and as the least martially talented member of the cast, considering her lack of prowess despite being trained by Cologne (however, she was also the most devious and multi-talented).

Added: 884

Changed: 823

Removed: 798

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
I can see the point of removing CD due to length, but OSM is fine, twosided, and is just as valid as Crazy Awesome.


* CanonDefilement: YourMileageMayVary, but some readers think that most of the characters were much kinder or had largely different personalities originally, to the point that several of them read like [[PossessionSue similar author spokespieces that simply borrow the names]]. When [[TheMessiah Kas]][[FriendToAllLivingThings umi]] starts to seriously threaten to murder her father things have definitely gone far beyond "creative liberties" and should simply switch to original characters instead.
* The overall thematics, interpretations, and power-scalings othervise also diverge wildly from canon, and the narrative has a far more sadistic malevolent edge than the original work, with genuinely evil characters (Shampoo is on par with the worst BlackLagoon cast members, and among other things [[MoralEventHorizon planned to brainwash Akane into forgetting her life and family, to then be sold into sex-slavery]]) by far favoured over ones that are ultimately simply crazy, damaged, and obnoxious, but comparatively harmless, such as principal Kuno. The Sailor Moon and Harry Potter stories from the same author are much easier to stomach in this regard, as the protagonists are presented as much less nasty, whereas the antagonists are monstrous enough to genuinely deserve their punishments.

to:

* CanonDefilement: YourMileageMayVary, but some readers think that most of the characters were much kinder or had largely different personalities originally, to the point that several of them read like [[PossessionSue similar author PossessionSue spokespieces that simply borrow the names]]. names. When [[TheMessiah Kas]][[FriendToAllLivingThings umi]] starts to seriously threaten to murder her father things have definitely gone far beyond "creative liberties" and should simply switch to original characters instead.
*
liberties". The overall thematics, interpretations, and power-scalings othervise also diverge wildly from canon, and the narrative has a far more sadistic malevolent amoral edge than the original work, with genuinely evil malevolent characters (Shampoo is on par with the worst BlackLagoon cast members, and among other things [[MoralEventHorizon planned to brainwash Akane into forgetting her life and family, to then be sold into sex-slavery]]) by far easily favoured over ones that are ultimately simply crazy, damaged, and obnoxious, but comparatively harmless, such as principal Kuno. The Sailor Moon and Harry Potter stories from the same author are much easier to stomach in this regard, as the protagonists are presented as much less nasty, whereas the antagonists are monstrous enough to genuinely deserve their punishments.Kuno.



* OnlySaneMan: In the context of the setting, Ranma and Akane are this. Shampoo and Kuno both show signs of approaching this territory. Nabiki tries but ocassionaly falls prey to the madness of the story.

to:

* OnlySaneMan: In the context of the setting, JerkSue: Ranma and Akane are this. arguably much greater callous savage intolerant JerkAss types than in canon, and given highly preferential treatment because of these qualities. Nabiki is either this or a VillainSue.
* OnlySaneMan: BaseBreaker. The narrative apparently attempts to portray Ranma, Akane, and to an extent Nabiki and eventually
Shampoo as this, but it depends on the reader whether it works or not. One part views it as ComedicSociopathy RuleOfFunny RuleOfCool CrossingTheLineTwice ShoutOut creative liberties, and Kuno both show signs of approaching this territory. Nabiki tries but ocassionaly falls prey working relative to the madness more irrational rest of the story.cast. Another gets a very strong impression that the manner the favoured characters think, talk, and behave recurrently extremely closely intersects with the typical pattern of real-world style in-control, ideologically sadistic, calculating, ruthless, completely compassion-deprived, callously condemning, textbook [[TheSociopath sociopaths]]; [[BlueAndOrangeMorality and with extremely contradictory, inconsistent, disproportionate, and othervise odd sense of scale between different transgressions and punishments]].



* VillainSue: Shampoo. Although beyond the extreme power-up Shampoo's personality may be the most in-character in the entire story, simply cranked UpToEleven, and the reason she worked despite this in canon (while keeping the irreverent tone intact) is partially that she was there treated as severely outmatched by any male with the possible exception of Tatewaki, and as the least martially talented member of the cast, considering her lack of prowess despite being trained by Cologne (however, she was also the most devious and multi-talented).

to:

* VillainSue: Shampoo. She has a mindset on par with the worst BlackLagoon cast members. Although beyond the extreme power-up Shampoo's personality may be the most in-character in the entire story, simply cranked UpToEleven, and the reason she worked despite this in canon (while keeping the irreverent tone intact) is partially that she was there treated as severely outmatched by any male with the possible exception of Tatewaki, and as the least martially talented member of the cast, considering her lack of prowess despite being trained by Cologne (however, she was also the most devious and multi-talented).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
See talk

Added DiffLines:

* CanonDefilement: YourMileageMayVary, but some readers think that most of the characters were much kinder or had largely different personalities originally, to the point that several of them read like [[PossessionSue similar author spokespieces that simply borrow the names]]. When [[TheMessiah Kas]][[FriendToAllLivingThings umi]] starts to seriously threaten to murder her father things have definitely gone far beyond "creative liberties" and should simply switch to original characters instead.
* The overall thematics, interpretations, and power-scalings othervise also diverge wildly from canon, and the narrative has a far more sadistic malevolent edge than the original work, with genuinely evil characters (Shampoo is on par with the worst BlackLagoon cast members, and among other things [[MoralEventHorizon planned to brainwash Akane into forgetting her life and family, to then be sold into sex-slavery]]) by far favoured over ones that are ultimately simply crazy, damaged, and obnoxious, but comparatively harmless, such as principal Kuno. The Sailor Moon and Harry Potter stories from the same author are much easier to stomach in this regard, as the protagonists are presented as much less nasty, whereas the antagonists are monstrous enough to genuinely deserve their punishments.
* CentralTheme: The presented general running thread is: "{{JerkAss}}es and [[TheSociopath Sociopaths]] [[BlueAndOrangeMorality versus]] {{CloudCuckooLander}}s and AcceptableHardLuckTargets". Major BaseBreaker whether the tendency goes well with the reader or not.

Changed: 914

Removed: 1526

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Please take your angst up with the author directly and leave this page alone. Your opinion does not belong on any of the pages pertaining to this story.


* CanonDefilement: Most of the characters were much kinder or had largely different personalities originally, to the point that several of them read like [[PossessionSue similar author spokespieces that simply borrow the names]]. When [[TheMessiah Kas]][[FriendToAllLivingThings umi]] starts to seriously threaten to murder her father things have definitely gone far beyond "creative liberties" and should simply switch to original characters instead.
* The overall thematics, interpretations, and power-scalings othervise also diverge wildly from canon, and has a far more sadistic malevolent edge than the original work, with genuinely evil characters (Shampoo is on par with the worst BlackLagoon cast members, and among other things [[MoralEventHorizon planned to brainwash Akane into forgetting her life and family, to then be sold into sex-slavery]]) by far favoured over ones that are ultimately simply crazy, damaged, and obnoxious, but comparatively harmless, such as principal Kuno. The Sailor Moon and Harry Potter stories from the same author are much easier to stomach in this regard, as the protagonists are presented as much less nasty, whereas the antagonists are monstrous enough to genuinely deserve their punishments.
* CentralTheme: The presented general running thread is: "{{JerkAss}}es and [[TheSociopath Sociopaths]] [[BlueAndOrangeMorality versus]] {{CloudCuckooLander}}s and AcceptableHardLuckTargets". Major BaseBreaker whether the tendency goes well with the reader or not.



* JerkSue: Ranma and Akane



* OnlySaneMan: BaseBreaker. The narrative apparently attempts to portray Ranma, Akane, and to an extent Nabiki and eventually Shampoo as this, but it depends on the reader whether it works or not. One part views it as ComedicSociopathy RuleOfFunny RuleOfCool CrossingTheLineTwice ShoutOut creative liberties, and working relative to the more irrational rest of the cast. Another gets a very strong impression that the manner the favoured characters think, talk, and behave recurrently extremely closely intersects with the typical pattern of real-world style in-control, ideologically sadistic, calculating, ruthless, completely compassion-deprived, callously condemning, textbook [[TheSociopath sociopaths]]; [[BlueAndOrangeMorality and with extremely contradictory, inconsistent, disproportionate, and othervise odd sense of scale between different transgressions and punishments]].

to:

* OnlySaneMan: BaseBreaker. The narrative apparently attempts to portray Ranma, Akane, In the context of the setting, Ranma and to an extent Nabiki and eventually Akane are this. Shampoo as this, and Kuno both show signs of approaching this territory. Nabiki tries but it depends on the reader whether it works or not. One part views it as ComedicSociopathy RuleOfFunny RuleOfCool CrossingTheLineTwice ShoutOut creative liberties, and working relative ocassionaly falls prey to the more irrational rest madness of the cast. Another gets a very strong impression that the manner the favoured characters think, talk, and behave recurrently extremely closely intersects with the typical pattern of real-world style in-control, ideologically sadistic, calculating, ruthless, completely compassion-deprived, callously condemning, textbook [[TheSociopath sociopaths]]; [[BlueAndOrangeMorality and with extremely contradictory, inconsistent, disproportionate, and othervise odd sense of scale between different transgressions and punishments]].story.



* VillainSue: Shampoo, and technically Nabiki. Although beyond the extreme power-up Shampoo's personality may be the most in-character in the entire story, simply cranked UpToEleven, and the reason she worked despite this in canon (while keeping the irreverent tone intact) is partially that she was there treated as severely outmatched by any male with the possible exception of Tatewaki, and as the least martially talented member of the cast, considering her lack of prowess despite being trained by Cologne (however, she was also the most devious and multi-talented).

to:

* VillainSue: Shampoo, and technically Nabiki.Shampoo. Although beyond the extreme power-up Shampoo's personality may be the most in-character in the entire story, simply cranked UpToEleven, and the reason she worked despite this in canon (while keeping the irreverent tone intact) is partially that she was there treated as severely outmatched by any male with the possible exception of Tatewaki, and as the least martially talented member of the cast, considering her lack of prowess despite being trained by Cologne (however, she was also the most devious and multi-talented).

Added: 784

Changed: 874

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CanonDefilement: Most of the characters were much kinder or had largely different personalities originally, to the point that several of them read like [[PossessionSue similar author spokespieces that simply borrow the names]]. The overall thematics, interpretations, and power-scalings othervise diverge wildly from canon, and has a far more sadistic malevolent edge than the original work, with genuinely evil characters (Shampoo is on par with the worst BlackLagoon cast members, and among other things [[MoralEventHorizon planned to brainwash Akane into forgetting her life and family, to then be sold into sex-slavery]]) by far favoured over ones that are ultimately simply crazy, damaged, and obnoxious, but comparatively harmless, such as principal Kuno. The Sailor Moon and Harry Potter stories from the same author are much easier to stomach in this regard, as the protagonists are presented as much less nasty, whereas the antagonists are monstrous enough to genuinely deserve their punishments.

to:

* CanonDefilement: Most of the characters were much kinder or had largely different personalities originally, to the point that several of them read like [[PossessionSue similar author spokespieces that simply borrow the names]]. When [[TheMessiah Kas]][[FriendToAllLivingThings umi]] starts to seriously threaten to murder her father things have definitely gone far beyond "creative liberties" and should simply switch to original characters instead.
*
The overall thematics, interpretations, and power-scalings othervise also diverge wildly from canon, and has a far more sadistic malevolent edge than the original work, with genuinely evil characters (Shampoo is on par with the worst BlackLagoon cast members, and among other things [[MoralEventHorizon planned to brainwash Akane into forgetting her life and family, to then be sold into sex-slavery]]) by far favoured over ones that are ultimately simply crazy, damaged, and obnoxious, but comparatively harmless, such as principal Kuno. The Sailor Moon and Harry Potter stories from the same author are much easier to stomach in this regard, as the protagonists are presented as much less nasty, whereas the antagonists are monstrous enough to genuinely deserve their punishments.



* JerkSue: Ranma, Akane

to:

* JerkSue: Ranma, Ranma and Akane
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CanonDefilement: Most of the characters were much kinder or had largely different personalities originally, to the point that several of them read like [[PossessionSue similar author spokespieces that simply borrow the names]]. The overall thematics, interpretations, and power-scalings othervise diverge wildly from canon, and has a far more sadistic malevolent edge than the original work, with genuinely evil characters (Shampoo is on par with the worst BlackLagoon cast members, and among other things [[MoralEventHorizon planned to brainwash Akane into forgetting her life and family, to then be sold into sex-slavery]]) by far favoured over ones that are ultimately simply crazy, damaged, and obnoxious, but comparatively very harmless, such as principal Kuno. The Sailor Moon and Harry Potter stories from the same author are much easier to stomach in this regard, as the protagonists are presented as much less nasty, whereas the antagonists are monstrous enough to genuinely deserve their punishments.

to:

* CanonDefilement: Most of the characters were much kinder or had largely different personalities originally, to the point that several of them read like [[PossessionSue similar author spokespieces that simply borrow the names]]. The overall thematics, interpretations, and power-scalings othervise diverge wildly from canon, and has a far more sadistic malevolent edge than the original work, with genuinely evil characters (Shampoo is on par with the worst BlackLagoon cast members, and among other things [[MoralEventHorizon planned to brainwash Akane into forgetting her life and family, to then be sold into sex-slavery]]) by far favoured over ones that are ultimately simply crazy, damaged, and obnoxious, but comparatively very harmless, such as principal Kuno. The Sailor Moon and Harry Potter stories from the same author are much easier to stomach in this regard, as the protagonists are presented as much less nasty, whereas the antagonists are monstrous enough to genuinely deserve their punishments.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CanonDefilement: Most of the characters were much kinder or had largely different personalities originally, to the point that several of them read like [[PossessionSue similar author spokespieces that simply borrow the names]]. The overall thematics, interpretations, and power-scalings othervise diverge wildly from canon, and has a far more sadistic malevolent edge than the original work, with genuinely evil characters (Shampoo is on par with the worst BlackLagoon cast members, and planned to brainwash Akane into forgetting her life and be sold into sex-slavery) by far favoured over ones that are ultimately simply crazy and obnoxious, but comparatively harmless, such as principal Kuno. The Sailor Moon and Harry Potter stories from the same author are much easier to stomach in this regard, as the protagonists are presented as much less nasty, whereas the antagonists are monstrous enough to genuinely deserve their punishments.

to:

* CanonDefilement: Most of the characters were much kinder or had largely different personalities originally, to the point that several of them read like [[PossessionSue similar author spokespieces that simply borrow the names]]. The overall thematics, interpretations, and power-scalings othervise diverge wildly from canon, and has a far more sadistic malevolent edge than the original work, with genuinely evil characters (Shampoo is on par with the worst BlackLagoon cast members, and among other things [[MoralEventHorizon planned to brainwash Akane into forgetting her life and family, to then be sold into sex-slavery) sex-slavery]]) by far favoured over ones that are ultimately simply crazy crazy, damaged, and obnoxious, but comparatively very harmless, such as principal Kuno. The Sailor Moon and Harry Potter stories from the same author are much easier to stomach in this regard, as the protagonists are presented as much less nasty, whereas the antagonists are monstrous enough to genuinely deserve their punishments.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CanonDefilement: Most of the characters were much kinder or had largely different personalities originally, to the point that several of them read like [[PossessionSue similar author spokespieces that simply borrow the names]]. The overall thematics, interpretations, and power-scalings othervise diverge wildly from canon, and has a far more sadistic malevolent edge than the original work, with genuinely evil characters (Shampoo is on par with the worst BlackLagoon cast members, and planned to brainwash Akane into forgetting her life and be sold into sex-slavery) by far favoured over ones that are ultimately simply crazy and obnoxious, but comparatively harmless, such as principal Kuno. The Sailor Moon and Harry Potter distortion stories are much easier to stomach in this regard, as the protagonists are presented as much less nasty, whereas the antagonists are monstrous enough to genuinely deserve their punishments.

to:

* CanonDefilement: Most of the characters were much kinder or had largely different personalities originally, to the point that several of them read like [[PossessionSue similar author spokespieces that simply borrow the names]]. The overall thematics, interpretations, and power-scalings othervise diverge wildly from canon, and has a far more sadistic malevolent edge than the original work, with genuinely evil characters (Shampoo is on par with the worst BlackLagoon cast members, and planned to brainwash Akane into forgetting her life and be sold into sex-slavery) by far favoured over ones that are ultimately simply crazy and obnoxious, but comparatively harmless, such as principal Kuno. The Sailor Moon and Harry Potter distortion stories from the same author are much easier to stomach in this regard, as the protagonists are presented as much less nasty, whereas the antagonists are monstrous enough to genuinely deserve their punishments.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* CanonDefilement: Most of the characters were much kinder or had largely different personalities originally, to the point that several of them read like [[PossessionSue similar author spokespieces that simply borrow the names]]. The overall thematics, interpretations, and power-scalings othervise diverge wildly from canon, and has a far more sadistic malevolent edge than the original work, with genuinely evil characters (Shampoo is on par with the worst BlackLagoon cast members, and planned to brainwash Akane into forgetting her life and be sold into sex-slavery) by far favoured over ones that are ultimately simply crazy and obnoxious, but comparatively harmless, such as principal Kuno. The Sailor Moon and Harry Potter distortion stories are much easier to stomach in this regard, as the protagonists are presented as much less nasty, whereas the antagonists are monstrous enough to genuinely deserve their punishments.
* CentralTheme: The presented general running thread is: "{{JerkAss}}es and [[TheSociopath Sociopaths]] [[BlueAndOrangeMorality versus]] {{CloudCuckooLander}}s and AcceptableHardLuckTargets". Major BaseBreaker whether the tendency goes well with the reader or not.


Added DiffLines:

* OnlySaneMan: BaseBreaker. The narrative apparently attempts to portray Ranma, Akane, and to an extent Nabiki and eventually Shampoo as this, but it depends on the reader whether it works or not. One part views it as ComedicSociopathy RuleOfFunny RuleOfCool CrossingTheLineTwice ShoutOut creative liberties, and working relative to the more irrational rest of the cast. Another gets a very strong impression that the manner the favoured characters think, talk, and behave recurrently extremely closely intersects with the typical pattern of real-world style in-control, ideologically sadistic, calculating, ruthless, completely compassion-deprived, callously condemning, textbook [[TheSociopath sociopaths]]; [[BlueAndOrangeMorality and with extremely contradictory, inconsistent, disproportionate, and othervise odd sense of scale between different transgressions and punishments]].

Added: 23

Changed: 216

Removed: 94

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* JerkSue: Ranma, Akane



* VillainSue: Shampoo. Although beyond the extreme power-up her personality may be the most in-character in the entire story, simply cranked UpToEleven, and the reason she worked despite this in canon (while keeping the irreverent tone intact) is partially that she was there treated as severely outmatched by any male with the possible exception of Tatewaki.
** And considering that most characters have taken a level in badass, this could be justified.

to:

* VillainSue: Shampoo. Shampoo, and technically Nabiki. Although beyond the extreme power-up her Shampoo's personality may be the most in-character in the entire story, simply cranked UpToEleven, and the reason she worked despite this in canon (while keeping the irreverent tone intact) is partially that she was there treated as severely outmatched by any male with the possible exception of Tatewaki.
** And
Tatewaki, and as the least martially talented member of the cast, considering that her lack of prowess despite being trained by Cologne (however, she was also the most characters have taken a level in badass, this could be justified.devious and multi-talented).

Top