Follow TV Tropes

Following

History YMMV / TheFirstMenInTheMoon

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** It's pretty clear that he's only with working with Cavor to share in the profit of Cavorite and sells a rented cottage to Cavor for thousands of pounds, whilst tricking Kate into signing the deed over instead of him, so she will take the fall in his place. When he finally sets foot on the Moon he cautiously greets the natives, [[WeVomeInPeaceShootToKill by throwing a dozen of them off a cliff]]. [[PoorCommunicationKills And later assumes that their understandable and relatively benign apprehension towards earthlings is instead a declaration of war.]]

to:

** It's pretty clear that he's only with working with Cavor to share in the profit of Cavorite and sells a rented cottage to Cavor for thousands of pounds, whilst tricking Kate into signing the deed over instead of him, so she will take the fall in his place. When he finally sets foot on the Moon he cautiously greets the natives, [[WeVomeInPeaceShootToKill [[WeComeInPeaceShootToKill by throwing a dozen of them off a cliff]]. [[PoorCommunicationKills And later assumes that their understandable and relatively benign apprehension towards earthlings is instead a declaration of war.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** It's pretty clear that he's only with Cavor to share in the profit of Cavorite and sells a rented cottage to Cavor for thousands of pounds, whilst tricking Kate into signing the deed over instead of him, so she will take the fall in his place. When he finally sets foot on the Moon he cautiously greets the natives, by throwing a dozen of them off a cliff. [[PoorCommunicationKills And later assumes that their understandable and relatively benign apprehension towards earthlings is instead a declaration of war.]]
** Hell, he even sadistically grins and chuckles when he realises that Cavor's HeroicSacrifice accidentally spread a disease to wipe out all of the unsuspecting aliens.

to:

** It's pretty clear that he's only with working with Cavor to share in the profit of Cavorite and sells a rented cottage to Cavor for thousands of pounds, whilst tricking Kate into signing the deed over instead of him, so she will take the fall in his place. When he finally sets foot on the Moon he cautiously greets the natives, [[WeVomeInPeaceShootToKill by throwing a dozen of them off a cliff.cliff]]. [[PoorCommunicationKills And later assumes that their understandable and relatively benign apprehension towards earthlings is instead a declaration of war.]]
** Hell, he even sadistically grins and chuckles when he realises realizes that Cavor's HeroicSacrifice accidentally spread a disease to wipe out all of the unsuspecting aliens.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Corrected "there" to "their".


** It's pretty clear that he's only with Cavor to share in the profit of Cavorite and sells a rented cottage to Cavor for thousands of pounds, whilst tricking Kate into signing the deed over instead of him, so she will take the fall in his place. When he finally sets foot on the Moon he cautiously greets the natives, by throwing a dozen of them off a cliff. [[PoorCommunicationKills And later assumes that there understandable and relatively benign apprehension towards earthlings is instead a declaration of war.]]

to:

** It's pretty clear that he's only with Cavor to share in the profit of Cavorite and sells a rented cottage to Cavor for thousands of pounds, whilst tricking Kate into signing the deed over instead of him, so she will take the fall in his place. When he finally sets foot on the Moon he cautiously greets the natives, by throwing a dozen of them off a cliff. [[PoorCommunicationKills And later assumes that there their understandable and relatively benign apprehension towards earthlings is instead a declaration of war.]]

Added: 659

Changed: 22

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** It's pretty clear that he's only with Cavor to share in the profit of Cavorite and sells a rented cottage to Cavor for thousands of pounds, whilst tricking Kate into signing the deed over instead of him, so she will take the fall in his place. When he finally sets foot on the Moon he cautiously greets the natives, by throwing a dozen of them off a cliff. [[PoorCommunicationKills And later assumes that there understandable and relatively benign disinterest in earthlings is instead a declaration of war.]]

to:

** It's pretty clear that he's only with Cavor to share in the profit of Cavorite and sells a rented cottage to Cavor for thousands of pounds, whilst tricking Kate into signing the deed over instead of him, so she will take the fall in his place. When he finally sets foot on the Moon he cautiously greets the natives, by throwing a dozen of them off a cliff. [[PoorCommunicationKills And later assumes that there understandable and relatively benign disinterest in apprehension towards earthlings is instead a declaration of war.]]



** It's worse in the 1964 film when [[spoiler: Cavor did so ''accidentally''. All while trying to maintain peaceful relations with the aliens.]]

to:

** It's worse in the 1964 film when [[spoiler: Cavor did so ''accidentally''. All while trying to maintain peaceful relations with the aliens.]]]]
* TearJerker:
** From the 1964 film, Cavor and the Grand Lunar's discussion in regards to the concept of war. The Selenite leader comes across as being genuinely confused, and later frightened of the very concept.
--> '''Grand Lunar''': Men enjoy to make war?
--> '''Cavor''': No. No, they detest it!
--> '''Grand Lunar''': Then if they make war, they are defective.
--> '''Cavor''': Well... well, we're not perfect. Well, mankind is still developing. We're not, we're not perfect. There are men of peace.
--> '''Grand Lunar''': My concern is with the men of violence, the men who kill. Soon others will be coming from Earth. Our galleries will be strewn with dead.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** It's worse in the 1964 film when [[spoiler: Cavor did so ''accidentally'' while trying to maintain peaceful relations with the aliens.]]

to:

** It's worse in the 1964 film when [[spoiler: Cavor did so ''accidentally'' ''accidentally''. All while trying to maintain peaceful relations with the aliens.]] ]]

Added: 834

Changed: 832

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DesignatedHero: Bedford in the 1964 film. It's pretty clear that he's only with Cavor to share in the profit of Cavorite and sells a rented cottage to Cavor for thousands of pounds, whilst tricking Kate into signing the deed over instead of him, so she will take the fall in his place. When he finally sets foot on the Moon he cautiously greets the natives, by throwing a dozen of them off a cliff. [[PoorCommunicationKills And later assumes that there understandable and relatively benign disinterest in earthlings is instead a declaration of war.]]

to:

* DesignatedHero: Bedford in the 1964 film. film.
**
It's pretty clear that he's only with Cavor to share in the profit of Cavorite and sells a rented cottage to Cavor for thousands of pounds, whilst tricking Kate into signing the deed over instead of him, so she will take the fall in his place. When he finally sets foot on the Moon he cautiously greets the natives, by throwing a dozen of them off a cliff. [[PoorCommunicationKills And later assumes that there understandable and relatively benign disinterest in earthlings is instead a declaration of war.]]



* FridgeHorror: [[spoiler: Cavor destroys an entire sentient race to prevent them fighting a war with humanity. While, yes, a huge war would have been awful, most wars tend to end, and usually with diplomacy and peace (or at least a cessation of conflict for some time). There's no reason there couldn't have been peace in the future.]]

to:

* FridgeHorror: FridgeHorror
**
[[spoiler: Cavor destroys an entire sentient race to prevent them fighting a war with humanity. While, yes, a huge war would have been awful, most wars tend to end, and usually with diplomacy and peace (or at least a cessation of conflict for some time). There's no reason there couldn't have been peace in the future.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DesignatedHero: Bedford in the 1964 film. It's pretty clear that he's only with Cavor to share in the profit of Cavorite and sells a rented cottage to Cavor for thousands of pounds, whilst tricking Kate into signing the deed over instead of him, so she will take the fall in his place. When he finally sets foot on the Moon he cautiously greets the natives, by throwing a dozen of them off a cliff. [[PoorCommunicationKills Later assumes that there understandable and relatively benign disinterest in earthlings is instead a declaration of war.]]

to:

* DesignatedHero: Bedford in the 1964 film. It's pretty clear that he's only with Cavor to share in the profit of Cavorite and sells a rented cottage to Cavor for thousands of pounds, whilst tricking Kate into signing the deed over instead of him, so she will take the fall in his place. When he finally sets foot on the Moon he cautiously greets the natives, by throwing a dozen of them off a cliff. [[PoorCommunicationKills Later And later assumes that there understandable and relatively benign disinterest in earthlings is instead a declaration of war.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DesignatedHero: Bedford in the 1964 version. It's pretty clear that he's only with Cavor to share in the profit of Cavorite and sells a rented cottage to Cavor for thousands of pounds, whilst tricking Kate into signing the deed over instead of him, so she will take the fall in his place.
** Hell, he even sadistically grins when he realises that Cavor's HeroicSacrifice accidentally spread a disease to wipe out all of the unsuspecting aliens.

to:

* DesignatedHero: Bedford in the 1964 version. film. It's pretty clear that he's only with Cavor to share in the profit of Cavorite and sells a rented cottage to Cavor for thousands of pounds, whilst tricking Kate into signing the deed over instead of him, so she will take the fall in his place.
place. When he finally sets foot on the Moon he cautiously greets the natives, by throwing a dozen of them off a cliff. [[PoorCommunicationKills Later assumes that there understandable and relatively benign disinterest in earthlings is instead a declaration of war.]]
** Hell, he even sadistically grins and chuckles when he realises that Cavor's HeroicSacrifice accidentally spread a disease to wipe out all of the unsuspecting aliens.

Added: 141

Changed: 13

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Hell, he even sadistically grins when he realises that Cavor's HeroicSacrifice spread a disease to wipe out all of the unsuspecting aliens.

to:

** Hell, he even sadistically grins when he realises that Cavor's HeroicSacrifice accidentally spread a disease to wipe out all of the unsuspecting aliens.


Added DiffLines:

** It's worse in the 1964 film when [[spoiler: Cavor did so ''accidentally'' while trying to maintain peaceful relations with the aliens.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Hell, he even sadistically grins when he realises that Cavor's HeroicSacrifice was so he could spread disease to wipe them all out.

to:

** Hell, he even sadistically grins when he realises that Cavor's HeroicSacrifice was so he could spread a disease to wipe them out all out.of the unsuspecting aliens.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DesignatedHero: Bedford in the 1964 version. I'ts pretty clear that he's only with Cavor to share in the profit of Cavorite and sells a rented cottage to Cavor for thousands of pounds, whilst tricking Kate into signing the deed over instead of him, so she will take the fall in his place.

to:

* DesignatedHero: Bedford in the 1964 version. I'ts It's pretty clear that he's only with Cavor to share in the profit of Cavorite and sells a rented cottage to Cavor for thousands of pounds, whilst tricking Kate into signing the deed over instead of him, so she will take the fall in his place.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* FridgeBrilliance: [[spoiler: Gatiss' conceit that Cavor used a sheet of Cavorite to flush the moon's atmosphere into space, rendering the moon the airless dead world Aldrin and Armstrong discover. An extremely elegant solution to the problem that ScienceMarchesOn.]]
* FridgeHorror: [[spoiler: Cavor destroys an entire sentient race to prevent them fighting a war with humanity. While, yes, a huge war would have been awful, most wars tend to end, and usually with diplomacy and peace (or at least a cessation of conflict for some time). There's no reason there couldn't have been peace in the future.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DesignatedHero: Bedford in the 1964 version. I'ts pretty clear that he's only with Cavor to share in the profit of Cavorite and sells a rented cottage to Cavor for thousands of pounds, whilst tricking Kate into signing the deed over instead of him, so she will take the fall in his place.
** Hell, he even sadistically grins when he realises that Cavor's HeroicSacrifice was so he could spread disease to wipe them all out.

Top