Follow TV Tropes

Following

History YMMV / TheDevilWearsPrada

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Moving YMMV trope example from the main work page.

Added DiffLines:

* BrokenAesop: Andy is presented as being "too good" for the fashion designer assistant job she applies for, and she derisively says she will only tough it out for a year to gain the experience and connections needed to get the job she wants. When she finally learns to take her job seriously and do it well she's presented as "selling her soul," while her abruptly quitting is presented as "holding true to her morals." However, when she applies for the serious journalism job that she only took the fashion designer assistant job to get, they almost don't hire her due to her abrupt departure ("holding true to her morals"), and only hire her due to Miranda giving her a glowing recommendation... which Miranda only gave her due to Andy learning to do her job well ("selling her soul") in the first place.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AccidentalAesop: Despite some [[BrokenAesop moral ambiguity]] in the film at large, one could definitely take a main Aesop of the film as being to learn as much as you can from every professional experience. While Andy had talent in her desired field of writing from the start, it's clear that working as Miranda's assistant, while nothing to do with that field, taught her many things she didn't consider, including how far she could push herself and the importance of details and presentation.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


*** Admittedly it is kind of a jerk move to promise to be on a birthday-party when you’ve a mandatory workthing. Andy could’ve mentioned that she probably wouldn’t make it because she could get fired for leaving too soon or something. That would’ve been understandable. Instead, Nate is left to just wait...hoping every time someone entered that it would be Andy, waiting until deep in the night with no message from her whatsoever. Seriously, couldn’t she just send a quick text and agree to celebrate another time or something?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Admittedly it is kind of a jerk move to promise to be on a birthday-party when you’ve a mandatory workthing. Andy could’ve mentioned that she probably wouldn’t make it because she could get fired for leaving too soon or something. That would’ve been understandable. Instead, Nate is left to just wait...hoping every time someone entered that it would be Andy, waiting until deep in the night with no message from her whatsoever. Seriously, couldn’t she just send a quick text and agree to celebrate another time or something?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
No linger a trope.


* EvilIsSexy: Despite being an abusive boss, Miranda has a large group of fans who find her drop dead gorgeous. It helps that she is always well dressed and played by the very attractive Creator/MerylStreep, who commands the screen and attention whenever she appears.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* HarsherInHindsight: Nigel's initial ill-treatment of Andy is a little hard to look at after Hathaway alleged that Tucci harassed her by elbowing and commenting on her breasts.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DracoInLeatherPants: Miranda Priestly is presented in a far better light by the fanbase than the film, mainly due to the commanding presence of Creator/MerylStreep. Fans seem to ignore her abusive behavior towards her employees and instead portray her as a tough but fair boss. Fans also like to ignore the fact that she robbed her friend, Nigel, of his dream job to save her own. This also comes from the fact that a lot of fans like to ship her with the lead Andy, so these fans often say the fact that she gave Andy a recommendation at the end is her supporting Andy's career, but this ignores the fact that much of the film is Miranda trying to mold Andy into being ruthless like herself.

to:

* DracoInLeatherPants: Miranda Priestly is presented in a far better light by the fanbase than the film, mainly due to the commanding presence of Creator/MerylStreep. Fans seem to ignore her abusive behavior towards her employees and instead portray her as a tough but fair boss.or even outright BenevolentBoss. Fans also like to ignore the fact that she robbed her friend, Nigel, of his dream job to save her own. This also comes from the fact that a lot of fans like to ship her with the lead Andy, so these fans often say the fact that she gave Andy a recommendation at the end is her supporting Andy's career, but this ignores the fact that much of the film is Miranda trying to mold Andy into being ruthless like herself.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* NeverLiveItDown: Andy's friends really can't live down the scene of them playing with her phone while she's trying to answer it in the restaurant. Among shippers, it's practically their MoralEventHorizon.

to:

* NeverLiveItDown: Andy's friends really can't live down the scene of them playing with her phone while she's trying to answer it in the restaurant. Among Though it only lasts for about 10 seconds, among shippers, it's practically their MoralEventHorizon.

Added: 1156

Changed: 485

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BaseBreakingCharacter: Fans' opinions of Christian seem to be split down the middle, with most either loving or hating him. Some love him due to Creator/SimonBaker's natural charm, his actually supporting Andy's efforts at Runway, and finding him more likable than Andy's actual love interest Nate. However, some fans dislike him just as much as Nate due to his pursuit of Andy despite knowing she has a boyfriend, feeling he comes off as creepy rather than charming, and him trying to cost Miranda her job.

to:

* BaseBreakingCharacter: BaseBreakingCharacter:
** Nate used to be a straight up [[TheScrappy scrappy]] when the film first released, due to many finding him dull, along with him being in a relationship with Andy getting [[DieForOurShip popular ships]] but in more recent years he has developed a lot of vocal defenders. The main sticking point that causes flame wars is his treatment of Andy's job. His detracters point out that he constantly insults her job and her boss, encouraging her to quit when this is the only way to get her dream job, but his supporters will often point out that Andy clearly hates the job, he is absolutely right that Miranda is a horrible boss, and that the job is indeed changing Andy.
**
Fans' opinions of Christian seem to be split down the middle, with most either loving or hating him. Some love him due to Creator/SimonBaker's natural charm, his actually supporting Andy's efforts at Runway, and finding him more likable than Andy's actual love interest Nate. However, some fans dislike him just as much as Nate due to his pursuit of Andy despite knowing she has a boyfriend, feeling he comes off as creepy rather than charming, and him trying to cost Miranda her job.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DiagnosedByTheAudience: The way Miranda is -- hyperfocused, brilliant, seemingly obliviously obnoxious, with no real friends despite her love for her family appearing to be genuine -- leads to many fans claiming that she is autistic.

to:

* DiagnosedByTheAudience: The way Miranda is -- hyperfocused, brilliant, seemingly obliviously obnoxious, with no real friends despite her love for her family appearing to be genuine genuine, and eating the exact same thing every day -- leads to many fans claiming that she is autistic.

Added: 768

Changed: 562

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FandomSpecificPlot: Most fanfiction based on the film will have Andy and Miranda meet up soon after Miranda's recommendation and reconnect on a more personal level. It's usually thanks to some meddling on the part of Nigel or the twins. The exact kind of relationship they form depends on the writer, though most will have the two get together romantically, either by finding out they have feelings for each other or by having them admit already existing ones. Some will have the two form a more Mother-Daughter bond, with Miranda encouraging Andy's feelings for another character.

to:

* FandomSpecificPlot: FandomSpecificPlot:
**
Most fanfiction based on the film will have Andy and Miranda meet up soon after Miranda's recommendation and reconnect on a more personal level. It's usually thanks to some meddling on the part of Nigel or the twins. The exact kind of relationship they form depends on the writer, though most will have the two get together romantically, either by finding out they have feelings for each other or by having them admit already existing ones. Some will have the two form a more Mother-Daughter bond, with Miranda encouraging Andy's feelings for another character.character.
** Despite the film ending with her quitting, Andy returning to Runway to finish out the rest of the year is very popular in fanfiction, mainly as a way to keep the Runway characters in contact with Andy.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* EvilIsSexy: Despite being an abusive boss, Miranda has a large group of fans (particularly lesbian or bisexual female fans) who find her drop dead gorgeous. It helps that she is always well dressed and played by the very attractive Creator/MerylStreep, who commands the screen and attention whenever she appears.

to:

* EvilIsSexy: Despite being an abusive boss, Miranda has a large group of fans (particularly lesbian or bisexual female fans) who find her drop dead gorgeous. It helps that she is always well dressed and played by the very attractive Creator/MerylStreep, who commands the screen and attention whenever she appears.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* EvilIsSexy: Despite being an abusive boss, Miranda has a large group of fans (particularly lesbian or bisexual females) who find her drop dead gorgeous. It helps that she is always well dressed and played by the very attractive Creator/MerylStreep, who commands the screen and attention whenever she appears.

to:

* EvilIsSexy: Despite being an abusive boss, Miranda has a large group of fans (particularly lesbian or bisexual females) female fans) who find her drop dead gorgeous. It helps that she is always well dressed and played by the very attractive Creator/MerylStreep, who commands the screen and attention whenever she appears.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* EvilIsSexy: Despite being an abusive boss, Miranda has a large group of fans (particularly lesbian or bisexual females) who find her drop dead gorgeous. It helps that she is always well dressed and played by the very attractive Creator/MerylStreep, who commands the screen and attention whenever she appears.


Added DiffLines:

* RootingForTheEmpire: A lot of fans rooted for the abusive boss Miranda rather than any of the heroic characters, thanks to Creator/MerylStreep's charismatic performance.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


%%* DiagnosedByTheAudience: The way Miranda is -- hyperfocused, brilliant, seemingly obliviously obnoxious, with no real friends despite her love for her family appearing to be genuine -- certainly comes off as autistic. (Partial context: Doesn't mention a large group of fans diagnosing Miranda as this)

to:

%%* * DiagnosedByTheAudience: The way Miranda is -- hyperfocused, brilliant, seemingly obliviously obnoxious, with no real friends despite her love for her family appearing to be genuine -- certainly comes off as leads to many fans claiming that she is autistic. (Partial context: Doesn't mention a large group of fans diagnosing Miranda as this)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Trivia and requires Word Of God


* AuthorsSavingThrow: Given the flak that Lily received in the first book for refusing to handle her alcoholism, the second ensured that Lily would have to work to earn her friendship back with Andy. Namely that Emily becomes Andy's new best friend after they [[spoiler:start a magazine together, and Lily is utterly sympathetic when she hears that Max and Emily went behind Andy's back to sign the deal with Miranda. It's the only time in the series that Lily isn't judgmental about Andy's career or choices in men and offers comfort]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DiagnosedByTheAudience: The way Miranda is -- hyperfocused, brilliant, seemingly obliviously obnoxious, with no real friends despite her love for her family appearing to be genuine -- certainly comes off as autistic.

to:

* %%* DiagnosedByTheAudience: The way Miranda is -- hyperfocused, brilliant, seemingly obliviously obnoxious, with no real friends despite her love for her family appearing to be genuine -- certainly comes off as autistic.autistic. (Partial context: Doesn't mention a large group of fans diagnosing Miranda as this)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DiagnosedByTheAudience: The way Miranda is -- hyperfocused, brilliant, seemingly obliviously obnoxious, with no real friends despite her love for her family appearing to be genuine -- certainly comes off as autistic.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AngelDevilShipping: Easily the biggest ship in the fandom is the sweet and kind Andy with her abusive and often rude boss Miranda (who is the titular Devil). This is mainly because of the chemistry between the two and the fact that many fans don't like Andy's canon relationship with Nate, as well as the fact that Miranda is a frequent target of the DracoInLeatherPants treatment.

to:

* AngelDevilShipping: Easily the biggest ship in the fandom is the sweet and kind Andy with her abusive and often rude boss Miranda (who is the titular Devil). This is mainly because of the chemistry between the two and the fact that many fans don't like Andy's canon relationship with Nate, as well as the fact that Miranda is a frequent target of the DracoInLeatherPants treatment.treatment and, even without that, being a major LoveToHate character.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Values Resonance has a twenty year waiting period.


* ValuesResonance: Regarding Andy's friends' attitude regarding how runway has changed, with the movie of course ending with even Andy herself realizing it, but as times have gone by it has become increasingly easy to see it. By TheNewTwenties with several issues bringing remote work to the forefront, an increase in the importance of work/life balance, a renewed condemnation of toxic bosses and workplaces (which Miranda and Runway are in spades), and trends like the "silent quitting", it gets to the point that many first time viewers is a shock that Andy doesn't agree with them to start with.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ValuesResonance: Regarding Andy's friends' attitude regarding how runway has changed, with the movie of course ending with even Andy herself realizing it, but as times have gone by it has become increasingly easy to see it. By TheNewTwenties with several issues bringing remote work to the forefront, an increase in the importance of work/life balance, a renewed condemnation of toxic bosses and workplaces (which Miranda and Runway are in spades), and trends like the "silent quitting", it gets to the point that some first time viewers is a shock that Andy doesn't agree with them to start with.

to:

* ValuesResonance: Regarding Andy's friends' attitude regarding how runway has changed, with the movie of course ending with even Andy herself realizing it, but as times have gone by it has become increasingly easy to see it. By TheNewTwenties with several issues bringing remote work to the forefront, an increase in the importance of work/life balance, a renewed condemnation of toxic bosses and workplaces (which Miranda and Runway are in spades), and trends like the "silent quitting", it gets to the point that some many first time viewers is a shock that Andy doesn't agree with them to start with.

Top