Follow TV Tropes

Following

History YMMV / SonicAdventure2

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CantUnhearIt: It's a bit difficult nowadays to watch Eggman's destruction of the moon and not think of WebVideo/RealTimeFandub's memetic interpretation of Eggman pissing on the moon.

to:

* CantUnhearIt: CantUnHearIt: It's a bit difficult nowadays to watch Eggman's destruction of the moon and not think of WebVideo/RealTimeFandub's memetic interpretation of Eggman pissing on the moon.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Knuckles never once grabs the {{Idiot|Ball}} or ConflictBall (at worst, he understandaby panics when the Master Emerald shards are sent flying into space), the lyrics of his stage music lend him a rarely seen introspective side, and Scott Dreier's low-key performance makes him sound [[TranquilFury rightly exasperated with Rouge's exasperating behavior]]. Later portrayals of Knuckles being gullible, not to say stupid, are TruerToTheText of Sega of Japan's original concept of Knuckles but make him come across as if he TookALevelInDumbass.

to:

*** Knuckles never once grabs the {{Idiot|Ball}} or ConflictBall (at worst, he understandaby understandably panics when the Master Emerald shards are sent flying into space), the lyrics of his stage music lend him a rarely seen introspective side, and Scott Dreier's low-key performance makes him sound [[TranquilFury rightly exasperated with Rouge's exasperating behavior]]. Later portrayals of Knuckles being gullible, not to say stupid, are TruerToTheText of Sega of Japan's original concept of Knuckles but make him come across as if he TookALevelInDumbass.

Added: 2370

Changed: 475

Removed: 1917

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AudienceColoringAdaptation: This game set an unusually high water-mark for certain characters that follow-ups would fail to live up to. Thanks to this game being [[NewbieBoom so widely known]], these portrayals tend to be much better-regarded and more popular than later appearances.
** Knuckles never once grabs the {{Idiot|Ball}} or ConflictBall (at worst, he understandaby panics when the Master Emerald shards are sent flying into space), the lyrics of his stage music lend him a rarely seen introspective side, and Scott Dreier's low-key performance makes him sound [[TranquilFury rightly exasperated with Rouge's exasperating behavior]]. Later portrayals of Knuckles being gullible, not to say stupid, are TruerToTheText of Sega of Japan's original concept of Knuckles but make him come across as if he TookALevelInDumbass.
** Tails is unambiguously a peer and ally of Sonic's rather than his KidSidekick--he orchestrates rescues and counter-Eggman strategies, makes the jump from the CaptainCrash he was in ''Adventure'' to piloting a fully-functional TransformingMecha (which he built himself), creates an EffectiveKnockoff Chaos Emerald, and even goes toe-to-toe with Eggman--now Tails' rival--all by himself. Later games would notably reinstall the SidekickGlassCeiling and [[DemotedToExtra position him as a distinct second-fiddle next to Sonic]].
** Amy also makes a better showing here than she does in later games, despite not being playable. She's competent enough to get to Prison Island all on her own, bust Sonic out of his cell by herself, and plays a key role in Shadow's HeelFaceTurn. She does try to leverage Sonic into a much-desired relationship, but relents the instant he makes it obvious he isn't game--a far more endearing portrayal than the [[{{Flanderization}} increasingly]] deranged MadLove she shows in ''VideoGame/SonicHeroes'', ''VideoGame/SonicBattle'', and ''VideoGame/SonicRush''.



* ToughActToFollow: Despite some of its faults, ''Sonic Adventure 2'' is one of the most beloved stories of the entire series, especially to those who grew up with it. The later entries have trouble topping it, [[VideoGame/ShadowTheHedgehog either trying]] [[VideoGame/SonicTheHedgehog2006 to capture the magic]] and [[VideoGame/SonicForces failing]] or [[VideoGame/SonicColors going for]] [[VideoGame/SonicGenerations a lot more]] [[VideoGame/SonicLostWorld of a comedic, light-hearted bent.]]

to:

* ToughActToFollow: ToughActToFollow:
**
Despite some of its faults, ''Sonic Adventure 2'' is one of the most beloved stories of the entire series, especially to those who grew up with it. The later entries have trouble topping it, [[VideoGame/ShadowTheHedgehog either trying]] [[VideoGame/SonicTheHedgehog2006 to capture the magic]] and [[VideoGame/SonicForces failing]] or [[VideoGame/SonicColors going for]] [[VideoGame/SonicGenerations a lot more]] [[VideoGame/SonicLostWorld of a comedic, light-hearted bent.]]]]
** This game set an unusually high water-mark for certain characters that follow-ups would fail to live up to. Thanks to this game being [[NewbieBoom so widely known]], these portrayals tend to be much better-regarded and more popular than later appearances.
*** Knuckles never once grabs the {{Idiot|Ball}} or ConflictBall (at worst, he understandaby panics when the Master Emerald shards are sent flying into space), the lyrics of his stage music lend him a rarely seen introspective side, and Scott Dreier's low-key performance makes him sound [[TranquilFury rightly exasperated with Rouge's exasperating behavior]]. Later portrayals of Knuckles being gullible, not to say stupid, are TruerToTheText of Sega of Japan's original concept of Knuckles but make him come across as if he TookALevelInDumbass.
*** Tails is unambiguously a peer and ally of Sonic's rather than his KidSidekick--he orchestrates rescues and counter-Eggman strategies, makes the jump from the CaptainCrash he was in ''Adventure'' to piloting a fully-functional TransformingMecha (which he built himself), creates an EffectiveKnockoff Chaos Emerald, and even goes toe-to-toe with Eggman--now Tails' rival--all by himself. Later games would notably reinstall the SidekickGlassCeiling and [[DemotedToExtra position him as a distinct second-fiddle next to Sonic]].
*** Amy also makes a better showing here than she does in later games, despite not being playable. She's competent enough to get to Prison Island all on her own, bust Sonic out of his cell by herself, and plays a key role in Shadow's HeelFaceTurn. She does try to leverage Sonic into a much-desired relationship, but relents the instant he makes it obvious he isn't game--a far more endearing portrayal than the [[{{Flanderization}} increasingly]] deranged MadLove she shows in ''VideoGame/SonicHeroes'', ''VideoGame/SonicBattle'', and ''VideoGame/SonicRush''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Tails is unambiguously a peer and ally of Sonic's rather than his KidSidekick--he orchestrates rescues and counter-Eggman strategies, makes the jump from the CaptainCrash he was in ''Adventure'' to piloting a fully-functional TransformingMecha (which he built himself), creates an EffectiveKnockoff Chaos Emerald, and even goes toe-to-toe with Eggman--now Tails' rival--all by himself. Later games would notably reinstall the SidekickGlassCeiling and position him as a distinct second-fiddle next to Sonic.

to:

** Tails is unambiguously a peer and ally of Sonic's rather than his KidSidekick--he orchestrates rescues and counter-Eggman strategies, makes the jump from the CaptainCrash he was in ''Adventure'' to piloting a fully-functional TransformingMecha (which he built himself), creates an EffectiveKnockoff Chaos Emerald, and even goes toe-to-toe with Eggman--now Tails' rival--all by himself. Later games would notably reinstall the SidekickGlassCeiling and [[DemotedToExtra position him as a distinct second-fiddle next to Sonic.Sonic]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AudienceColoringAdaptation: This game set an unusually high water-mark for certain characters that follow-ups would fail to live up to. Thanks to this game being [[NewbieBoom so widely known]], these portrayals tend to be much better-regarded and more popular than later appearances.
** Knuckles never once grabs the {{Idiot|Ball}} or ConflictBall (at worst, he understandaby panics when the Master Emerald shards are sent flying into space), the lyrics of his stage music lend him a rarely seen introspective side, and Scott Dreier's low-key performance makes him sound [[TranquilFury rightly exasperated with Rouge's exasperating behavior]]. Later portrayals of Knuckles being gullible, not to say stupid, are TruerToTheText of Sega of Japan's original concept of Knuckles but make him come across as if he TookALevelInDumbass.
** Tails is unambiguously a peer and ally of Sonic's rather than his KidSidekick--he orchestrates rescues and counter-Eggman strategies, makes the jump from the CaptainCrash he was in ''Adventure'' to piloting a fully-functional TransformingMecha (which he built himself), creates an EffectiveKnockoff Chaos Emerald, and even goes toe-to-toe with Eggman--now Tails' rival--all by himself. Later games would notably reinstall the SidekickGlassCeiling and position him as a distinct second-fiddle next to Sonic.
** Amy also makes a better showing here than she does in later games, despite not being playable. She's competent enough to get to Prison Island all on her own, bust Sonic out of his cell by herself, and plays a key role in Shadow's HeelFaceTurn. She does try to leverage Sonic into a much-desired relationship, but relents the instant he makes it obvious he isn't game--a far more endearing portrayal than the [[{{Flanderization}} increasingly]] deranged MadLove she shows in ''VideoGame/SonicHeroes'', ''VideoGame/SonicBattle'', and ''VideoGame/SonicRush''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Rewriting to account for the fact that some of the examples are intentional, not accidental.


** Considering that "jewels" and "emeralds" can be slang for testicles and the BelligerentSexualTension between the two, many of Knuckles' and Rouge's interactions are full of this. The lyrics for many of their stages' BGM have this as well, such as Wild Canyon's lines "They wanna play with my emeralds?...", and "Yeah, Rouge, she's sexy and smooth/A double cross spy thief that's out for my jewels, uh!/I'm feelin' her in mysterious ways".

to:

** Considering that All of Knuckles and Rouge's talk about "jewels" and "emeralds" can easily be slang taken for testicles and the BelligerentSexualTension between the two, many of Knuckles' and Rouge's interactions are full of this. The lyrics for many of their stages' BGM have sexual jokes; this as well, such as isn't helped by the fact that "Kick the Rock!", the BGM for Knuckles's Wild Canyon's lines "They Canyon stage, contains intentional IntercourseWithYou[[note]]"They wanna play with my emeralds?...", " and "Yeah, Rouge, she's sexy and smooth/A double cross spy thief that's out for my jewels, uh!/I'm feelin' her in mysterious ways".ways"[[/note]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Pumpkin Hill is unanimously agreed to be the most enjoyable and well-designed treasure hunting level in the game, as it has plenty of areas for Knuckles to explore without being overwhelming like his other stages, and its memorable BigBoosHaunt Halloween setting. And of course, it has one of the best and most memorable music tracks in the entire game.


Added DiffLines:

** White Jungle is a relatively short level with nothing too difficult, which is a huge relief coming off of Weapons Bed with its hard-hitting enemies and difficult platforming, and Security Hall with its strict 5-minute time limit.


Added DiffLines:

** The Dark Story has one with Weapons Bed and Security Hall, with the former being filled with hard-hitting enemies that appear out of nowhere and difficult platforming sections, and the latter having a five-minute time limit, which pretty much requires knowing the level layout by memory to stand a chance.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
redirect to correct trope


* NeverLiveItDown: Sonic only calls Shadow a "faker" once as an insult, but due to the [[NarmCharm memorability]] of said exchange, fanfiction involving them usually makes it an InsultOfEndearment that the two have no problem calling each other by. AscendedFanBoy Creator/IanFlynn also had a hand in the insult becoming a nickname in the ''Archie'' comic book series.

to:

* NeverLiveItDown: Sonic only calls Shadow a "faker" once as an insult, but due to the [[NarmCharm memorability]] of said exchange, fanfiction involving them usually makes it an InsultOfEndearment that the two have no problem calling each other by. AscendedFanBoy PromotedFanboy Creator/IanFlynn also had a hand in the insult becoming a nickname in the ''Archie'' comic book series.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Tails apparently got all of his intel on a top secret military prison from a public news broadcast. The area is meant to be a highly [[BlackSite restricted area]].

to:

** Due to how the English dub reads, Tails apparently got all of his intel on a top secret military prison from a public news broadcast. The area is meant to be a highly [[BlackSite restricted area]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The game never explores how Eggman feels about his cousin and grandfather being killed by the government; in fact he doesn't seem to care ''at all'' despite allegedly having a great amount of respect for his grandfather. The whole plot is just about Shadow and his feelings. It's a shame, as it could have worked as a great FreudianExcuse for Eggman's behaviour throughout the series. ''Of course'' he wants to take over the world; the world is run by a cruel military that destroyed his family!

to:

** The game never explores how Eggman feels about his cousin and grandfather being killed by the government; in fact he doesn't seem to care ''at all'' despite allegedly having a great amount of respect for his grandfather. The whole plot is just about Shadow and his feelings. It's a shame, as it could have worked as a great FreudianExcuse for Eggman's behaviour throughout the series. ''Of course'' he wants to take over the world; the world is run by a cruel military that destroyed his family!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The game never explores how Eggman feels about his family being murdered by a corrupt government; in fact he doesn't seem to care ''at all'' despite allegedly having a great amount of respect for his grandfather. The whole plot is just about Shadow and his feelings. It's a shame, as it could have worked as a great FreudianExcuse for Eggman's behaviour throughout the series. ''Of course'' he wants to take over the world; the world is run by a cruel military that destroyed his family!

to:

** The game never explores how Eggman feels about his family cousin and grandfather being murdered killed by a corrupt the government; in fact he doesn't seem to care ''at all'' despite allegedly having a great amount of respect for his grandfather. The whole plot is just about Shadow and his feelings. It's a shame, as it could have worked as a great FreudianExcuse for Eggman's behaviour throughout the series. ''Of course'' he wants to take over the world; the world is run by a cruel military that destroyed his family!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
I noticed a version of this text was removed because the editor didn't agree with it a few years ago... but like, that's what we have YMMV for, right? So I've cleaned it up and brought it back.


** The game introduced several iconic elements to the series, which have been commonplace since, so their inclusion here might come across as somewhat formulaic. These include Shadow and Rouge, the space colony ARK, Eggman's extended family, the presence of a worldwide military force named GUN, and many other smaller elements that would gain precedence during the next few games.

to:

** The game Sonic Adventure 2 made a spectacular impact in its heyday, kickstarted a NewbieBoom for the Sonic fanbase, and introduced several iconic elements to elements. But the series, which have game has also been commonplace since, so their inclusion here might come across as somewhat formulaic. These include Shadow divisive, and Rouge, seen various waves of HypeBacklash. Its detractors cite it as the space colony ARK, Eggman's extended family, the presence of a worldwide military force named GUN, and origin point for many other smaller elements of the [[FranchiseOriginalSin flaws that would gain precedence during plague its successors]]: A narrower focus on executing quick actions through more linear level design, the next few games.sound balancing flaws, and the glaring plotholes in the story. [=SA2=] remains a love-it-or-hate-it game: To some, it's a legendary and influential Sonic game that still holds up. To others, it's a clunky relic of the 2000s that hasn't aged well.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The scene where Eggman watches a news broadcast and discovers Shadow's theft of the chaos emerald and his subsequent framing of Sonic. It's supposed to be a major plot point explaining why the military was after Sonic at the beginning of the Hero Story, but any seriousness of the scene is immediately taken away by the ''very'' exaggerated and obviously fake British accent of the news reporter, along with the camera zooming in ''right'' onto Shadow's face, yet everyone still thinks it's Sonic.
*** Eggman also ''scratches his ass'' while watching the scene unfold, which makes things even harder to take seriously.

Added: 196

Changed: 74

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* LikeYouWouldReallyDoIt: You didn't ''really'' think Sonic died in that exploding capsule, did you?

to:

* LikeYouWouldReallyDoIt: You LikeYouWouldReallyDoIt:
**You
didn't ''really'' think Sonic died in that exploding capsule, did you?you?
**Even before it became well known due to ItWasHisSled, did you really think that Eggman would get to destroy the Earth?

Changed: 244

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Eggamn and Tails have their upgrades regardless of whether you collected them or not.


** The second Tails vs Eggman battle. The level has no rings, meaning no regaining health, and your enemy will pull out special attacks that do massive damage are extremely hard to dodge with the slow character you use. The version when fighting as Eggman becomes a BreatherBoss if you got the Protective Armor upgrade in Cosmic Wall, but doing so makes the version when fighting as Tails even ''harder'' since unlike every other boss in the game (including the fight before Metal Harbor), Eggman will keep the effects of the Protective Armor upgrade and thus take even less damage.

to:

** The second Tails vs Eggman battle. The level has no rings, meaning no regaining health, and your enemy will pull out special attacks that do massive damage are extremely hard to dodge with the slow character you use. The version when fighting as Eggman becomes a BreatherBoss if you got the Protective Armor upgrade in Cosmic Wall, but doing so makes the version when fighting as Tails even is ''harder'' since unlike every other boss in the game (including the fight before Metal Harbor), Eggman will keep has the effects of the Protective Armor upgrade and thus take even less damage.damage where as Tails as a boss just uses the missile upgrade which won't have any real noticeable advantages against you.

Added: 829

Changed: 378

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SeinfeldIsUnfunny: The game introduced several iconic elements to the series, which have been commonplace since, so their inclusion here might come across as somewhat formulaic. These include Shadow and Rouge, the space colony ARK, Eggman's extended family, the presence of a worldwide military force named GUN, and many other smaller elements that would gain precedence during the next few games.

to:

* SeinfeldIsUnfunny: The SeinfeldIsUnfunny:
**The
game introduced several iconic elements to the series, which have been commonplace since, so their inclusion here might come across as somewhat formulaic. These include Shadow and Rouge, the space colony ARK, Eggman's extended family, the presence of a worldwide military force named GUN, and many other smaller elements that would gain precedence during the next few games.games.
**The inclusion of a 3D version of [[NostalgiaLevel Green Hill Zone]] as a reward for getting all 180 emblems in the game. When the game first came out this was quite the treat since it was the first time Green Hill had been seen in an official capacity since the original game and was a nice anniversary gift for the series. Nowadays Green Hill has been used so many times in various games that fans were celebrating whenever it ''didn't'' show up.


* PoisonOakEpilepticTrees: In October 2011, an [[http://www.giantbomb.com/profile/lordxavierbritish/blog/why-sonic-adventure-2-has-the-best-story-in-gaming/87241/ article]] was written that theorized the possibility of the lyrics in Knuckles' stage music metaphorically telling the story of Knuckles being a drug addict who's [[AllJustADream hallucinating]] the ''Sonic'' universe to escape from his grim reality, [[spoiler:interpreting a scrapped final level as his overdose-induced death]]. It's a combination of NightmareFuel and TearJerker.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Crazy Gadget, due to the element of GravityScrew and the maze-like final section where a single wrong move can lose a life. Hard Mode makes it even worse due to the exploding variety of the [[DemonicSpiders artificial chaos enemy]] being ''everywhere''. Also, hard mode requires you to pull off some insane stunts over bottomless pits and go through the maze-like section at the end at least ''twice'' to find a very well-hidden switch that unlocks the goal ring. [[note]]There are several shortcuts that make this section easier and reduce the number of times you have to repeat the maze.[[/note]] On the plus side, even if you die and have to restart from the second checkpoint, it is still possible to A-rank the mission from there if you play through the rest of the level well enough, though that's no easy task.

to:

** Crazy Gadget, due to the element of GravityScrew and the maze-like final section where a single wrong move can lose a life. Hard Mode makes it even worse due to the exploding variety of the [[DemonicSpiders artificial chaos enemy]] Artificial Chaos]] enemy being ''everywhere''. Also, hard mode Hard Mode requires you to pull off some insane stunts over bottomless pits and go through the maze-like section at the end at least ''twice'' to find a very well-hidden switch that unlocks the goal ring. [[note]]There are several shortcuts that make this section easier and reduce the number of times you have to repeat the maze.[[/note]] On the plus side, even if you die and have to restart from the second checkpoint, it is still possible to A-rank the mission from there if you play through the rest of the level well enough, though that's no easy task.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** One of Omochao's DummiedOut lines is "Did you know The Doctor's mustache is fake?". "The Doctor" is often assumed to be Dr. Eggman, but the corresponding line in Japanese reveals he was actually talking about "Doctor Chao", the principal of the Chao Kindergarten.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The Chao garden system in the HD ports introduced a new glitch with rendering on Shiny two-tone Chao, referred as the "[[https://chao-island.com/wiki/Bright_Chao Bright Chao]]" glitch, which causes their bodies to shine incredibly brightly instead of their original color tones with a shinier sheen. Some Shiny Jewel Chao also don't render correct and may appear completely invisible. Other issues with the Chao garden system with the HD ports also includes planted trees rendering miniscule and floating mid-air, and missing content that originally required the connectivity with the VMU on the Dreamcast or Gameboy Advance on the [=GameCube=] versions.

to:

** The Chao garden system in the HD ports introduced a new glitch with rendering on Shiny two-tone Chao, referred as the "[[https://chao-island.com/wiki/Bright_Chao Bright Chao]]" glitch, which causes their bodies to shine incredibly brightly instead of their original color tones with a shinier sheen. Some Shiny Jewel Chao also don't render correct and may appear completely invisible. Other issues with the Chao garden system with the HD ports also includes planted trees rendering miniscule and floating mid-air, and missing content that originally required the connectivity with the VMU on the Dreamcast or Gameboy Advance on the [=GameCube=] versions.mid-air.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
But in all fairness, that would go fine under THIS trope.

Added DiffLines:

* SpecialEffectFailure:
** The Chao garden system in the HD ports introduced a new glitch with rendering on Shiny two-tone Chao, referred as the "[[https://chao-island.com/wiki/Bright_Chao Bright Chao]]" glitch, which causes their bodies to shine incredibly brightly instead of their original color tones with a shinier sheen. Some Shiny Jewel Chao also don't render correct and may appear completely invisible. Other issues with the Chao garden system with the HD ports also includes planted trees rendering miniscule and floating mid-air, and missing content that originally required the connectivity with the VMU on the Dreamcast or Gameboy Advance on the [=GameCube=] versions.
** A majority of the story cutscenes in ''Sonic Adventure 2 Battle'' and its HD ports suffer from various problems, ranging from missing or poorly re-created visual effects, loss in colors or effects, inconsistently going from widescreen to 4:3 in some scenes that involved video effects in the HD ports, and errors with Amy's character models that include misaligned head or eyes and textures problems. A comparison of these problems can be seen in [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yMauzPcOorQ this video]].
** The later HD ports suffers from object and character model issues that the Dreamcast and [=GameCube=] version didn't have, such as shading problems (e.g. Sonic's and Shadow's character models have a mustache-like shading error around their mouths), rendering issues (e.g. missing details on Tails and Eggman's mechs, Rouge's Treasure Scope), and some lighting effects being completely missing like in Iron Gate and Lost Colony, losing the dark atmosphere those stages had.
** The [=GameCube=] versions had some sound mixing problems, but the HD ports managed to make it even worse with sound effects blurring out so loudly that it drowns out voice-overs or other effects during gameplay or story scenes.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
quote: Please only add examples of games that contain game-breaking bugs or are broken to the point of unplayability, not minor glitches or annoyances." :unquote


* PortingDisaster: Although ''Sonic Adventure 2 Battle'' has been billed as the definitive version of ''Sonic Adventure 2'', the [=GameCube=] version of the game has some issues compared to the original Dreamcast version, some of which have gotten worse with the later HD ports.
** The Chao garden system in the HD ports introduced a new glitch with rendering on Shiny two-tone Chao, referred as the "[[https://chao-island.com/wiki/Bright_Chao Bright Chao]]" glitch, which causes their bodies to shine incredibly brightly instead of their original color tones with a shinier sheen. Some Shiny Jewel Chao also don't render correct and may appear completely invisible. Other issues with the Chao garden system with the HD ports also includes planted trees rendering miniscule and floating mid-air, and missing content that originally required the connectivity with the VMU on the Dreamcast or Gameboy Advance on the [=GameCube=] versions.
** A majority of the story cutscenes in ''Sonic Adventure 2 Battle'' and its HD ports suffer from various problems, ranging from missing or poorly re-created visual effects, loss in colors or effects, inconsistently going from widescreen to 4:3 in some scenes that involved video effects in the HD ports, and errors with Amy's character models that include misaligned head or eyes and textures problems. A comparison of these problems can be seen in [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yMauzPcOorQ this video]].
** The later HD ports suffers from object and character model issues that the Dreamcast and [=GameCube=] version didn't have, such as shading problems (e.g. Sonic's and Shadow's character models have a mustache-like shading error around their mouths), rendering issues (e.g. missing details on Tails and Eggman's mechs, Rouge's Treasure Scope), and some lighting effects being completely missing like in Iron Gate and Lost Colony, losing the dark atmosphere those stages had.
** The [=GameCube=] versions had some sound mixing problems, but the HD ports managed to make it even worse with sound effects blurring out so loudly that it drowns out voice-overs or other effects during gameplay or story scenes.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** At the start of the game, Sonic gets mistaken for his CriminalDoppelganger who has the word "Shadow" in his name. The same would happen to his rival Mario [[VideoGame/SuperMarioSunshine just a year later]].

to:

** At the start of the game, Sonic gets mistaken for his CriminalDoppelganger who has the word "Shadow" in his name. The same would happen to his rival Mario [[VideoGame/SuperMarioSunshine just a year later]]. Both titles also feature said doppelganger framing the protagonist for a crime and getting them thrown in prison (though unintentionally in Shadow's case), forcing them to spend the rest of the game clearing their name.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AssPull: Near the end of the Hero and Dark stories, Eggman manages to trap Sonic in a chamber and has him shot out of an airlock to plummet to Earth to his death. How does he get out of this? He performs Chaos Control with a ''fake'' Chaos Emerald. The fake emerald was made by Tails to mimic a real emerald's power signature, but it doesn't actually have the same output of power. Not only that, but performing Chaos Control with only one ''real'' emerald is an ability only Shadow can perform, Sonic only ever displaying that kind of power as Super Sonic.

to:

* AssPull: Near the end of the Hero and Dark stories, Eggman manages to trap Sonic in a chamber and has him shot out of an airlock to plummet to Earth to his death. How does he get out of this? He performs Chaos Control with a ''fake'' Chaos Emerald. The fake emerald was made by Tails to mimic a real emerald's power signature, but it doesn't actually have the same output of power. Not only that, but performing Sonic only recently discovered what Chaos Control with only one ''real'' emerald even is an ability only when he saw Shadow can perform, perform it, and the latter only performed it ''once'' in front of him. Yet, Sonic only ever displaying that kind of power as Super Sonic. is somehow able to pull it off on his first attempt with no experience or knowledge on how to do it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AngstWhatAngst: Near the end of both the Dark and Hero stories, Dr. Eggman has Amy, a 12 year old girl, at ''gunpoint'' and threatens to ''shoot her in the head'' if Sonic doesn't hand over the final chaos emerald. Despite the seriousness of the situation, when Sonic does arrive, he simply smiles and cracks a joke about Eggman "turning into a big time villain" before confidentially walking into the room. Granted, it's ''possible'' Eggman wasn't actually being serious about harming Amy and Sonic just knows him that well to tell, but he still acts weirdly unfazed to the fact that his friend's life is being threatened right in front of him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The scene of Sonic and Shadow turning into their super forms loses its intended impact when you have the two hedgehogs shaking their fists while the emeralds circle them, making it look like they're trying to see who can jerk off the hardest. Then, when the transformation happens, all their upgrades you've obtained for both of them throughout the game suddenly dissaper, because they never bothered to account for the upgrades for their super forms.

to:

** The scene of Sonic and Shadow turning into their super forms loses its intended impact when you have the two hedgehogs shaking their fists while the emeralds circle them, making it look like they're trying to see who can jerk off the hardest. Then, when the transformation happens, all their upgrades you've obtained for both of them throughout the game suddenly dissaper, disappear, because they never bothered to account for the upgrades for their super forms.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Many people claim that the original Dreamcast version has a bug where, when you play as Eggman near the end of the game, he’ll fall through the floor over and over with no way to stop it. Thing is, this is actually an anti-piracy measure triggered when the game detects that it's not being played on an official disc, and it only became widely known as a “bug” due to how common it was to pirate Dreamcast games. While it is possible for legit copies to trigger this (usually if there are scratches near the center of the disc), it's much less common than people think.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* TrueArtIsAngsty: They took a series previously known more for colourful backgrounds and cutesy creatures and turned it into a tale of revenge, grief for lost loved ones, and [[spoiler:attempted use of a weapon literally capable of wiping out all of humanity.]] ''VideoGame/SonicAdventure 1'' was already this compared to the earlier Sonic games, but ''Sonic Adventure 2'' [[ExaggeratedTrope took it even further...]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Minor spelling mistake.


---> '''Eggman:''' I'm Dr. Eggman, the greatest scientific genius in the world! Hahahahahaha! I finally did it! I've defeated Sonic! That annoying hedgehog is no gone forever! He's nothing but floating chunks in space now! What are you going to do now, Tails? If you are against me, you'll suffer the same fate as your buddy, Sonic.

to:

---> '''Eggman:''' I'm Dr. Eggman, the greatest scientific genius in the world! Hahahahahaha! I finally did it! I've defeated Sonic! That annoying hedgehog is no now gone forever! He's nothing but floating chunks in space now! What are you going to do now, Tails? If you are against me, you'll suffer the same fate as your buddy, Sonic.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** [[ThatOneBoss The Biolizard may be difficult]], but the awesome theme music, "[[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wIYnkOF7V7E Supporting Me]]', makes up for it.

to:

** [[ThatOneBoss The Biolizard may be difficult]], but the awesome theme music, "[[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wIYnkOF7V7E Supporting Me]]', Me]]", makes up for it.

Top